2015-01-15 Zernik, J. "Fraudulent New IT Systems of the Israeli Courts - Unannounced Regime Change?" [online] Human Rights Alert (NGO)

Published on January 2019 | Categories: Documents | Downloads: 5 | Comments: 0 | Views: 266
of 10
Download PDF   Embed   Report

Comments

Content

Digitally signed by Joseph Zernik, PhD Date: 2015.01.16 00:55:47 +02'00'

Fraudulent New IT Systems of the Israeli Courts - Unannounced Regime Change? Joseph Zernik, PhD Human Rights Alert (NGO), Tel-Ai, !srael  "oseph#$ernik%hra-ngo#org Abstract  &ali'it, integrit, an' impats o* the ne+ !T sstems o* the !sraeli ourts, implemente' in the 'ea'e o* the s, are e.amine'# The report is /ase' in part on the Human Rights Alert, NGO, (HRA) su/mission *or the 0niersal Perio'i Reie+ (0PR) o* human rights in !srael / the Human Rights 1ounil (HR1) o* the 0nite' Nations (0N) +hih, *ollo+ing pro*essional HR1 sta** reie+, +as inorporate' into the HR1 0PR report (23) +ith the note4 56ak o* integrit in the eletroni reor' sstems o* the supreme ourt, the 'istrit ourts an' the 'etainees7 'etainees7 ourts in !srael5# !srael5# The urrent urrent report is also /ase' on the *in'ings o* the 8tate Om/u'sman7s Report (2), +hih note' that sstem 'eelopment *aile' to ompl +ith 8tate la+ an' stan'ar's4 stan'ar's4 1ontrats +ere signe' signe' +ith no legal ten'er an' +ith no spei*iatio spei*iations9 ns9 'eelopment 'eelopment +as arrie' arrie' out +ith no ore management / state emploees9 sstems +ere aepte' +ith no in'epen'ent ali'ation / state emploees9 serers +ere remoe' *rom the usto' o* the state ourts into the usto' o* a orporation, an' unkno+n num/er o* people +ere issue' 'ou/le smart !D ar's# 8stem analsis reeals4 Deelopment an' implem implement entatio ation n +ith no la+*ul la+*ul author authorit, it, serer sererss o* uneri uneri*ie *ie' ' i'entit i'entit, , an' inali' inali' implem implement entati ation on o*  eletroni signatures, authentiation proe'ures, authorities an' permissions# Data mining reeals +i'esprea' issuane o* inali' "u'iial# :alsi*ie', simulate', an';or *orge' "u'iial reor's are presente'# 1ase stu'ies *ous on the unla+*ul 'epriation 'epriation o* li/ert, li/ert, perseution o* +histle-/lo+ +histle-/lo+ers, ers, an' *ailing orporate;/anking orporate;/anking regulation# The possi/ilit that suh *un'amental 'e*iienies, +hih sstematiall strippe' "u'iial reor's o*  an sem/lane o* ali'it an' authentiit through a ostl, long-term pro"et, oerseen / ke national  "u'iial *igures, are the outome o* oersight, or human error is remote# The sstems shoul' /e ie+e' as suspension suspension o* the la+ o* the lan', or 'enial o* aess to the iil ourts# As suh, the represent represent a regime hange, or a onstitutional risis in a nation +ith no onstitution# The last ouple o* 'ea'es also inole' unpree'ente' orruption o* goernment, an' soio-eonomi hanges, +hih propelle' !srael to the *irst plae in poert among O<1D nations# The sstems remarka/l resem/le similarl 'e*iient, ol'er sstems o*  the 8tate o* 1ali*ornia an' the 08 *e'eral ourts# The role o* !=> an' <D8, 08-/ase' orporations, in the 'eelopment o* the !sraeli sstems is nota/le, as +ell as similar on'ut / !=> in other nations# Notie the uni?ue relationship /et+een o'e an' la+ in suh sstems, orretie measures are propose', alling *or Pu/li Pu/liit it o* the 6a+ @ transp transparen aren  - an' *or the 8eparat 8eparation ion o* Po+ers Po+ers @ plain plaing g the 'eelopm 'eelopment ent an' implementatio implementation n o* suh sstems sstems un'er aounta/ilit aounta/ilit to the legislature# legislature# Human rights an' internet internet atiists atiists shoul' shoul' /e igilan igilantt in monito monitoring ring suh sstem sstems# s# !T e.perts e.perts shoul' shoul' assume assume more more promin prominent ent 'uties 'uties in the sa*eguar' o* iil soiet in our era# !eywords e-"ustie, human rights, ourts, prisons, /anking regulation, 8tate o* !srael# "# Introduction The ourts +orl'+i'e hae implemente' implemente' in reent reent 'ea'es 'ea'es !T sstems *or e**iient e**iient management management o* ourt ases, eletroni *iling / parties, an' pu/li aess aess to ourt reor's# 0nite' Nations reports on 8trengthening Ju'iial !ntegrit Against 1orruptionB (, 2) enourage the proess# No 'ou/t, suh sstems oul' hae improe' improe' the transparen transparen an' integrit integrit o* the "u'iial "u'iial proesses# proesses# Ho+eer, Ho+eer, the transition to eletroni eletroni a'ministration o* the ourts is not risk *ree# 1ourt proe'ures an' in in partiular, the maintenane an' sa*eguar' o* ali' ourt ourt reor's, hae eole' oer enturies un'er paper a'ministration o* the ourts# The are the ore o* *air hearing, an' ?uintessential to them is the oor'inate' oor'inate' ations o* the t+o arms o* the ourts4 ourts4 The "u'iial arm @ a'"u'iating a'"u'iating an' issuing issuing 'eision reor's, an' the ministerial (lerial) arm @ authentiating, erti*ing, an' maintaining ourt reor's as their la+*ul usto'ians# On the other han', historial historial reie+ *in's that orruption o* the o**ies o* the lerks is orrelate' +ith orruption o* the ourts themseles (>essinger, )# The transition transition to eletroni eletroni a'ministration a'ministration o* the ourts amounts to a sea hange in the operations operations o* the o**ies o* the lerks# Preious stu'ies 'oumente' the 'etrimental e**ets o* the implementation o* inali' !T sstems sstems in the ourts an' prisons in the 0nite' 8tates, in the 8tate o* 1ali*ornia, an' in the 8tate o* !srael (Human Rights Alert 2, 23, 2C, Zernik, 2, 2a, 2/, 2C)# The urrent report is /ase' in part on the Human Rights Alert, NGO, (HRA) su/mission to the 0nite' Nations Human Rights 1ounil (HRA, 23), +hih +as inorporate' into the Pro*essional 8ta** Report (23) o* the 1ounil7s Perio'i Reie+ +ith the note4 lak o* integrit o* the eletroni reor's o* the 8upreme 1ourt, the 'istri 'istritt ourts ourts an' the 'etain 'etainees ees ourts in !srael !srael#B #B Gien Gien spae spae limit, limit, instan instantt report report proi' proi'es4 es4 a) Online Online

Appen'i. ! - an e.pan'e' ersion o* the urrent report +ith links to online re*erenes an' reor's, an' /) Online Appen'i. !! - HRA su/mission (23 ), setions o* +hih are re*erene' +ithin the te.t (e#g#, HRA 12e)# "#" $ffice of the cler% The authorit, 'uties an' responsi/ilities o* the hie* lerk o* the ourt in the 8tate o* !srael +ere 'e*ine' in a series o* la+s an' respetie regulations (HRA 1#2)# The regulations, +hih +ere promulgate' in 3-C, 'uring the perio' o* implementation o* the urrent generation o* !T sstems o* the ourts, are o* partiular interest# The la+s an' regulations are at times inonsistent in their /asi terms an' leae onsi'era/le amount o*  am/iguit# On suh /akgroun', the initial steps in 'eeloping an' implementing the urrent !T sstems o* the ourt, ourt, i#e#, i#e#, 'e*ini 'e*ining ng the spei*i spei*iatio ations, ns, +as parti partiular ularl l sensiti sensitie# e# <ither <ither the authoritie authorities, s, 'uties 'uties an' responsi/il responsi/ilities ities o* the hie* lerk an' the respetie respetie proe'ures proe'ures +ere to /e unam/iguousl unam/iguousl 'e*ine', or else inali' !T sstems +oul' /e 'eelope' an' implemente'# !t is note+orth that the !sraeli !sraeli ourts themseles rule' that a ourt, operating +ith no la+*ul o**ie o* the lerk, is an inompetent ourt# &# 'ethods &#" IT system analysis and data mining The sstems are analse' / reie+ o* the their implementation an' operation in arious ourts# Data mining is largel on'ute' on'ute' using the inherent /uilt-in searh searh engines# 8stem rules are in*erre' through reie+ o*  the sstems an' the reor's, sine har'l an pu/li reor's are aaila/le (e#g# users7 manuals), an' the o**ie o* A'ministration A'ministration o* 1ourts 'enie' respetie respetie :ree'om o* !n*ormation !n*ormation re?uests, re?uests, or +rong*ull +rong*ull re*use' to respon' on them (HRA 1e)# &#& Case studies 1ase 1ase stu'ie stu'iess are proi'e' proi'e' in Online Online Appen'i. Appen'i. ! to 'emons 'emonstrat trate e the impat impat o* the !T sstem sstemss o* on the a'ministration o* "ustie in the !srael to'a# &#( )uman rights* national and international legal im+lications 6egal analsis analsis is largel restrite' restrite' to tehnial an' proe'ural proe'ural matters, +hih nee'e' to /e a''resse' a''resse' in the ourse o* implementing an !T sstem o* the ourts, e#g#, the sa*eguar' o* ali', authenti reor's through ali' signatures, signatures, authentiati authentiation, on, erti*iation, erti*iation, authorities authorities an' permission permissions# s# <mphasis is gien to reor's, reor's, pertaining to the initiation (e#g# summonses) an' termination ("u'gments) o* litigation, +hih are reogni$e' *or enturies as ritial *or integrit o* the ourts an' the "u'iial proess# 58imulate' 58imulate' 6itigation5, 58imulate' 1ourt Reor'5, Reor'5, 58imulate' 58imulate' 6itigation;Reor's5 6itigation;Reor's5 are use' here pursuant pursuant to the Te.as Penal 1o'e E3#F, +hih is instrutie in 'etailing the un'erling on'ut (see Online Appen'i. !)4 Disseminati Disseminating ng inali', inali', ine**etual, ine**etual, unen*orea/le, unen*orea/le, an' tpiall tpiall a/usie a/usie ourt reor's, reor's, then *rau'ulentl in'uing or e.torting ompliane +ith them# !n terms o* 08 *e'eral la+, suh on'ut / "u'ges, lerks, an' attornes *alls un'er :rau' upon the 1ourt# 8uh on'ut is onsi'ere' 5e.tra-"u'iial5 on'ut, +hih is not not oere' / an immunit# The la+ o* the 8tate o* !srael nota/l *ails to spei*iall a''ress suh on'ut# on'ut# 8imulate' legal proess has /een kno+n *or enturies as a ommon *orm o* "u'iial orruption# The o**ie o*  the lerk, lerk, its 'uties 'uties an' respon responsi/ si/ili ilities ties,, eole eole' ' enturi enturies es ago spei* spei*ial iall l to preen preentt suh suh on'u on'ut# t# Aor'ingl, emphasis is gien to the +as in +hih the ne+ !T sstems ena/le the issuane an' pu/liation o*  simulate' "u'iial reor's# ( IT system analysis (#" The systems The urrent report primaril reie+s the !T sstems o* the !sraeli 8upreme 1ourt (name unkno+n), the 'istrit an' magistrate ourts (Net-Hamishpat), the 'e/tors ourts (&TO, Ornet, an' elim 8hluim), an' the 'etainees ourts ourts (name unkno+n unkno+n)# )# Net-Ha Net-Hamis mishpa hpat, t, /ut none o* the other sstems sstems proi'es proi'es the *ull range range o* ase ase management, pu/li aess, an' eletroni eletroni *iling apa/ilities# The other sstems, suh as the one use' / the 8upreme 1ourt, proi'e ase management an' limite' pu/li aess, /ut no eletroni *iling apa/ilities# (#& ,eelo+ment and im+lementation - disregard of standards* dubious lawful authority As note' in the 8tate Om/u'sman7s Report (2), e**etual stan'ar's an' proe'ures, pertaining to the 'eelopment o* 8tate !T sstems, +ere esta/lishe' in the Oto/er , 22 1a/inet Deision 23;eo, an' *urther ela/orate' in Aounting O**ie o* the >inistr o* Treasur >a*tah Proe'ures# The 8tate Om/u'sman7s Report (2) notes that none o* these rules an' proe'ures +ere omplie' +ith in the 'eelopmen 'eelopmentt o* the urrent urrent generation generation o* !T sstems o* the ourts (HRA 13/)# >oreoer, >oreoer, the 8tate Om/u'sman7 Om/u'sman7ss Report Report (2) notes that ontrats ontrats *or sstem 'eelopmen 'eelopmentt +ere unla+*ull a+ar'e' to orporations +ith no legal ten'er, that the serers o* the ourts +ere remoe' *rom the usto' o* the lerks o* the ourts ourts to the usto' usto' o* a orporati orporation on @ in iolation iolation o* the Regulations of the Courts , an' that an

unkno+n num/er o* in'ii'uals +ere issue' 'ou/le !D ar's (HRA 13/)# The urrent generation generation o* !T sstems o* the !sraeli !sraeli ourts represents a sea-hange sea-hange in ourt proe'ures an' ourt a'ministration# These hanges in ourt proe'ures hae not /e legistate'# 6imite' authori$ation is proi'e' in hanges, +hih are promulgate' in the Regulations of Civil Court Procedure # A partiularl alarming hange hange is promulgate' promulgate' in the Regulations of the Courts – Office of the Clerk  (F),   (F), EC @ >ehanial 8stems (see (see Online Appen' Appen'i. i. !)# !n Artile Artile C, the >iniste >inisterr o* Justie Justie in *at *at 'elega 'elegates tes to the Diret Diretor or o* the A'ministration o* 1ourts the authorit to hange the Regulations of the Courts as neessar in on"untion +ith implementation o* the ne+ !T sstems# Artile C patentl iolates the priniple o* 8eparation o* Po+ers# >oreo >oreoer, er, the hange hangess to the Regula Regulatio tions, ns, +hih +hih +ere +ere o/iou o/iousl sl intro' intro'ue ue' ' / the Diret Diretor or o* the A'mini A'ministra stration tion o* 1ourts, 1ourts, +ere neer neer pu/lis pu/lishe' he',, in iolati iolation on o* the prini priniple ple o* Pu/li Pu/liit it o* the 6a+# 6a+# :urthermore, the A'ministration o* 1ourts re*use' to respon' on a :ree'om o* a !n*ormation re?uest, asking *or 'islosure o* suh hanges (HRA 1e)# Regar'less, reie+ o* the sstems, 'ata mining, an' other :ree'om o* !n*ormation responses ena/le the i'enti*iation o* the ar'inal hanges in ourt proe'ures, inherent in the ne+ !T sstems o* the ourts# !n all !sraeli ourts (inlu'ing the 8upreme 1ourt), the most signi*iant hange +as a/olishing the responsi/ilit an' aounta/ilit o* the hie* lerk relatie to integrit o* ourt reor's, issuane o* summonses, authentiation, serie, an' erti*iation o* "u'iial reor's# !n the 8upreme 1ourt, +here the paper reor's are 'eeme' the authoritatie soure, the ali'it o* all eletro eletroni ni reor's reor's in the pu/li aess aess sstem sstem +as a''itio a''itional nall l oi'e' oi'e' /4 a) a''ing a''ing to all reor's reor's the 'islaimer su/"et to e'iting an' phrasing hangesB, an' /) omitting the stan'ar' statement / the 1hie*  1lerk o* the 8upreme 1ourt, +hih ha' appeare' on all reor's prior to , True 1op o* the OriginalB, +ith an ele eletro troni ni o'e o'e (pro (pro/a /a/l /l an earl earl *orm *orm o* pass pass+o +or' r' seu seure re' ' *ile *ile sst sstem em)) (:ig (:igur ure e 2)# 2)# =oth =oth the A'ministration o* 1ourts an' urrent Presi'ing Justie o* the 8upreme 1ourt Asher Grunis re*use' to 'islose un'er +hose authorit an' un'er +hat legal *oun'ation suh pro*oun' hanges +ere intro'ue' in the eletroni reor's o* the 8upreme 1ourt in #

'eisions Figure "# 1hanges in the !T sstem o* the 8upreme 1ourt I # .eft 0ntil earl , all eletroni 'eisions o* the 8upreme 1ourt arrie' erti*iation, True 1op o* the OriginalB, / the late 1hie* 1lerk 8hmarahu 1ohen# Right 8ine earl , the erti*iation statement an' an other re*erene to a hie* lerk +ere omitte'# On the ontrar, the 'islaimer su/"et to e'iting an' phrasing hangesB +as a''e' (HRA ...)# !n the 'istrit, magistrate, an' la/or ourts, +here Net-Hamishpat is implemente', an' +here eletroni reor's are 'eeme' the authoritatie soure, the ali'it o* all eletroni reor's +as oi'e' through the implementation o* inisi/le eletroni signatures - The <mperor7s Ne+ 1lothesB# 1lothesB# :or e.ample, prior to the implementation o* Net-Hamishpat, "u'ges +ere permitte' to insri/e un*ormatte' 'eisionsB on the *ae o* motion reor's un'er their signatures# signatures# ith the implementation o* Net-Hamishpat, suh suh pratie +as esta/lishe' as Post-it DeisionsB +ith no isi/le signatures at all (:igure )#

Figure &# 1hanges relate' to implementation I  o* Net-Hamishat !T sstem# .eft 0n'er paper a'ministration - Rotem v Baram and State of Israel  (K3;F) in the Tel-Ai >agistrate 1ourt - the :e/ruar L, L Deision / Ju'ge 8hoshana Almagor is insri/e' on the *ae o* Plainti**7s >otion *or 8u/poena o* itnesses# The Ju'ge7s stamp an' han' signature appear ne.t to the insription, as +ell as the stamp / the o**ie o* the lerk o* the ourt 8ent / *a. or email on :e/ruar L, LB# Right  !n Net-Hamispat !T sstem  (2KC-) in the Tel-Ai Distrit 1ourt @ the August 3, 2 Deision / Ju'ge Hagai Silman v Social Security  (2KC-) =renner is a Post-it DeisionB - a semi-transparent *rame, superimpose' on the *ae page o* the >otion *or Dis?uali*iation *or a 1ause +ith no isi/le signature signature an' no in'iation o* its serie# The Deision in part sas4 ### There is not a single su/stantial laim o* a reasona/le onern o* /ias### instant >otion is super*luous###B#

(#( Serers of unerified identity identity and dubious security Reie+ o* the i'entit o* the serers o* the arious ourts, using stan'ar' /ro+sers, *aile' to 'isoer a single serer serer o* erti*ie' erti*ie' i'enti* (HRA 1/)# The *ailure to erti* the i'entit i'entit o* the serers, serers, in itsel*, is likel to /e 'eeme' su**iient to hol' the sstems inali'# :urthermore, the A'ministration o* 1ourts re*use' to respon' on a :ree'om o* !n*ormation re?uest4 ho hol's the ultimate a'ministratie authorit *or the serers o* the 8upreme 8upreme 1ourt o* the 8tate o* !sraelM (HRA 1e)# Tpiall, Tpiall, the 8hin-=et (seret (seret serie) hol's the ultimate ultimate authorit oer seurit o* state !T sstems# Ho+eer, in response on re?uest, the o**ie o* Prime >inster (+ho is in harge o* the 8hin-=et) state' that the 8hin-=et hol's no authorit oer o* the serers o* the ourts# (#/ Inalid im+lementation of electronic signatures To'a, To'a, all 'eisio 'eision n reor's reor's o* the !sraeli !sraeli ourts, ourts, +ith the nota/le nota/le e.ept e.eption ion o* the 8uprem 8upreme e 1ourt, 1ourt, are maintaine' as eletroni reor's# Regar'less, no isi/le eletroni reor' an /e *oun' on an ourt reor's# The notion o* inisi/le signatures, 'e*ies the essene o* a signature @ a sm/ol a**i.e' +ith the intent to aept responsi/ilit (HRA 1')# 8uh inali' implementation o* the Electronic Signature Act  (2)   (2) e.ten's /eon' the ourts# :or e.ample, L-K Annual Annual Report o* the >agistrate o* Data/ases (+ho (+ho also hol's the authorit o* >agistrate o* 1erti*ing Authorities, pursuant to the Electronic Signature Act ), ), as pu/lishe' online / the >inistr o* Justie, sho+s no isi/le signature (Haohen, K) (:igure 3)# The >inistr o* Justie 'enie' a :ree'om o* !n*ormation re?uest *or a op o* the Report, /earing a isi/le eletroni signature, un'er the laim that the eletroni signature o* a goernment o**ier is a priate instrumentB# The implementation o*  inali' eletroni signatures +as relate' to the priati$ationB o* the eletroni signature sstem o* the 8tate o* !srael to 1omsign, a priate orporation @ a 'u/ious measure#

Figure Figure (# !mplementation o* inisi/le eletroni signatures# 0nsigne' signature /o. o* the L-K Annual Report / Attorne oram Haohen, >agistrate o* Data/ases, as pu/lishe' online / the >inistr o* Justie# The signature /o. sas4 Trul, oram Haohen, A'#, >agistrate >agistrate o* Data/ases, Data/ases, Justie Tehnolog an' !n*ormation Authorit (Originall signe' / a seure eletroni signature)B the parenthetial part in re' in the original, "$# The >inistr o* Justie 'enie' 'enie' a :ree'om o* !n*ormation !n*ormation re?uest *or a isi/l signe' op o* the Report, laiming that the eletroni signature o* a goernment o**ier is a priate instrumentB# (#0 Inalid im+lementation of summonses* summonses* authentication* certification* serice Instruments and +rocedures !n almost all ourts, originating in the <nglish ommon la+, inlu'ing the !sraeli ourts, the initiation o* litigation through the issuane an' e.eution o* serie o* a ali' summonses un'er the signature o* the lerk o* the ourt an' the seal o * the ourt is presri/e' *or the esta/lishment o* the "uris'ition o* the ourt in a gien matter on the gien parties# There*ore, the ali'it an' an' integrit o* the summons is ritial *or ali'it an' integrit o* the su/se?uent litigation as a +hole# Ho+eer, sine implementation o* the urrent !T sstems o* the !sraeli ourts4 !n the 8upreme 1ourt - petitions (matters o* original "uris'ition) are hear' as Preliminar Proee'ingsB +ith no issuane o* the the 1on'itional Deree, +hih aor'ing to the respetie Regulations is the 8ummons in suh proe'ure# !n the 8upreme 1ourt - +hile all ali' ourt reor's are maintaine' in paper ourt *iles, the Noties to Appear in 1ourt (*or hearings on petit ions) are maintaine' as eletroni reor's, +hih aor'ing to the 8upreme 1ourt sta**, are automatiall eliminate' *rom the !T sstem a*ter the 'ate o* the hearing (Zernik, 2Fa)# !n the 'istrit an' magistrate ourts - summonses are issue' / an unname' person, unsigne', onl note' as issue' / the O**ie o* the 1lerkB (:igure F)#

Figure /# !mplementation o* inali' summonses in Net-Hamishpat# Ben-aakov v Rolnick (C3KFK@-2) in the Tel-Ai >agistrate 1ourt# The summons is unsigne', /ears /ears no seal o* the ourt, an' is issue' in the name o* O**ie o* the 1lerk o* the >agistrate 1ourt, Tel-AiB#

Authentiation o* all "u'iial reor's is a *un'amental proe'ure in all ourts, originating in the <nglish ommon la+, inlu'ing the !sraeli !sraeli ourts, *or ren'ering ourt 'eisions ali', e**etual, an' en*orea/le# The matter is no+ internationall akno+le'ge' in the Hague 1onention (2L2), to +hih the 8tate o* !srael is a part (see /elo+)# Authentiation o* "u'iial reor's is e.eute' through the 'ue serie o* suh reor's on the parties to the matter /e*ore the ourt, 'ul signe', +ith an aompaning letter, signe' un'er the authorit o*  the 1hie* 1lerk# Ho+eer, sine the implementation o* the urrent !T sstems o* the !sraeli ourts4 !n the 8upreme 1ourt - all 'eisions are maile' unsigne' / the "usties, /earing the 'i slaimer su/"et to e'iting an' phrasing hangesB an' +ith no aompaning letter / the lerk o* the ourt at all# !n the 'istrit, magistrate, an' la/or ourts - all 'eisions are maile' +ith an unsigne' aompaning letter / an unname' person (:igure C)#

 (2KCFigure 0# !mplementation o* inali' authentiation letters in Net-Hamishpat# Silman v Social Security  (2KC) in the Tel-Ai Distrit 1ourt @ the August 3, 2 Aompaning letter o* the 'eision (:igure 3) / Ju'ge Hagai =renner sas4 sas4 Aompaning 6etter# Attahe' is a 'eision reor'# Date4 August 3, 2# 8ignature o*  a 1lerkB# The reor' is unsigne', *ails to name its issuer, an' /ears no seal o* the ourt (=renner, 2)# O* note, oer the past 'ea'e, 'ea'e, "u'ges hae stoppe' using the proper legal term, serieB# serieB# !nstea', !nstea', "u'iial reor's instrut the o**ie o* the lerk to in*orm the partiesB o* "u'iial 'eisions, or mail to the partiesB, et# The erti*iation o* ourt reor's / the lerk o* the ourt is a routine proe'ure in all ourts, originating in the <nglish <nglish ommon la+# Dul erti*ie' erti*ie' ourt reor's are 'eeme' 'eeme' sel*-authentia sel*-authentiate'B, te'B, an' are re?uire' *or en*or en*oreme ement nt o* ourt ourt or'ers or'ers an' "u'gme "u'gments nts,, or +hen +hen *iling *iling suh suh reor' reor'ss as a'miss a'missi/le i/le ei'ene ei'ene## The Regulations of the Courts! Office of the Clerk  (F), ELa esta/lish the authorit erti* ourt reor's, True 1op o* the OriginalB, +ith the 1hie* 1lerk# :ollo+ing the implementation o* the urrent !T sstems o* the ourts, no ali' erti*iation o* ourt reor's oul' /e o/taine' o/taine' *rom an o* the ourts, +here +here it has /een attempte'# Ho+eer, Ho+eer, numerous numerous e.amples o*  *orgeries +ere 'isoere'# !n the 8upreme 1ourt - petitioners, +ho hae aske' *or signe' an' erti*ie' opies o* 'eisions in their matter matters, s, routine routinel l reei reeie' e' simula simulate' te' an';or an';or *orge' *orge' reor's# reor's# 8uh 8uh reor' reor'ss tpial tpiall l /ear /ear an inali' inali' erti*iation erti*iation statement, statement, Dupliation Dupliation is True to the OriginalB, instea' instea' o* True 1op o* the OriginalB, an' are either signe' either / an unname' person, using an illegi/le signature, or / a person, +ho is not the 'ul appointe' 1hie* 1lerk o* the 8upreme 1ourt (:igure L)#

Figure 1# 8imulation an';or *orger o* erti*iations o* 8upreme 1ourt 'eision reor'# a# June 2,  Deision in "acmull "acmull v Bank of Israel and State of Israel (3C2;)# The petition originate' in *rau' / a /ank on De/tor >amull in the Jerusalem De/tors7 1ourt, an' re*usal o* =ank o* !srael to per*orm its 'uties as /anking regulator# The petition +as summaril 'enie'# The signatures o* the "usties are all in +et inkB, in the *orm (-)B, an' in the same han'-+riting as the signature o* 8arah 6i*shit$ 1hie* 1lerkB# The erti*ing statement is inali' - Dupliation is True to the OriginalB - instea' o* True 1op 1op o* the OriginalB# 8arah 6i*shit$ +as not 'ul appointe' 1hie* 1lerkB# The *ootnote sas4 Dupliate su/"et to e'iting an' phrasing han ges#B

!n the Tel-Ai 6a/or 1ourt - erti*iation +as issue' / a person, *alsel in possession o* the 1hie* 1lerkB stamp, +hile the person, +ho appears as 1hie* 1lerkB hol's no appointment reor' as suh (:igure K)#

Figure 2# 8imulation an';or *orger o* erti*iation o* the Tel-Ai 6a/our 1ourt 'eision reor'# .eft The +e/ page o* the Tel-Ai 6a/our 1ourt lists 1hie* 1lerk4 >s Orl HammerB# Right  The , 2F Ju'ge Gilt$er-at$ Deision, imposing an unusual unusual N!8 F, pament in attornes *ees on Plainti** Genosar, the !srael <letri 1ompan +histle-/lo+er, +as erti*ie' using a True 1op o* the OriginalB stamp QF o* an unname' male 1hie* 1lerkB (Gilt$er-at$, 2F)# :ree'om o* !n*ormation response sho+s that >s Orl Hammer hol's no la+*ul appointment as 1hie* 1lerkB o* the Tel-Ai 6a/our 1ourt, an' that stamp QF is unla+*ull hel' / >s Galit >agli', a seretar in the Tel-Ai 6a/our 1ourt# (#1 Inalid im+lementation of authorities and +ermissions* and discrimination in access to the courts Attornes, +ho are authori$e' as Net-Hamishpat users, are permitte' aess to eletroni *iling *rom remote loations at all times# 8uh attornes are permitte' to enter reor's into ourt 'oket, /passing the authorit o* the lerk o* the ourt# 0nrepresente' parties must *ile on paper in the o**ie o* the lerk 'uring +orking hours# hours# 8erie 8erie on attornes attornes is / email, on unrepresent unrepresente' e' parties - / paper mail# Authori$e' Authori$e' attornes are permitte' omprehensie aess to Net-Hamishpat eletroni reor's *rom remote loations at all time# <.ept *or the Tel-Ai Distrit 1ourt, aess to eletroni ourt reor's is also seerel limite' or prohi/ite' on unrepresente' parties in their o+n ourt *iles, in 'isregar' o* the la+# 8uh on'itions also ena/le the appearane o* attornes, +ho are not authori$e' as 1ounsel o* Reor' *or the parties, +hih the purport to represent, a +ell-kno+n metho' o* *rau' upon the ourt (=ohm, )# :ollo+ing the implementation o* Net-Hamishpat, numerous ases +ere 'oumente', +here unauthori$e' attornes attornes appeare' an' *ile' o* papers papers +ithout *iling the erti*iates erti*iates o* ounsel ounsel o* reor's, reor's, as presri/e' presri/e' / la+4 !n the ase o* !srael <letri 1ompan +histle-/lo+er >oran Genosar, unauthori$e' attornes appeare' on /ehal* o* the !srael <letri 1ompan9 in the riminal proseution o* Ta. Authorit +histle-/lo+er Ra*i Rotem, unauthori$e' attornes appeare' as purporte' Pu/li De*en'ersB, an' in the ase o* sel*-immolate' soial protest atiist >oshe 8ilman, unauthori$e' attornes appeare' on /ehal* o* the 8oial 8eurit# (#2 Uniersal failure to doc%et summonses and authentication records Reie+ o* ourt *ile reor's reor's in Net-Hamishpa Net-Hamishpatt *aile' *aile' to 'isoer 'isoer the summonses summonses in a num/er num/er o* ases, ases, an' it remains remains unkno+n i* the are maintaine' maintaine' among the eletroni reor's in Net-Hamishpat Net-Hamishpat at all# 8imilarl, no authentiation reor's hae /een 'isoere' upon inspetion o* th e eletroni reor's in Net-Hamishpat# (#3 Adulterated* forged* and missing court records :ollo+ing :ollo+ing the implementa implementation tion o* the ne+ !T sstems sstems o* the ourts, numerous ases +ere reporte', reporte', +here  "u'ges hae altere' or *orge' ourt reor's# !n the 8upreme 1ourt - 'ata mining le' to the 'isoer o* numerous 'eision reor's, /earing *orge' erti*iation / the late 1hie* 1lerk, up to C ears a*ter his 'eath in  (:igure )#

Figure 3# :alsi*iation an';or *orger o* 8upreme 1ourt 'eision reor'# The signature an' erti*iation /o. o* 8upreme 1ourt Deision in #udith $ranco $ranco Sidi et al al v Authority %ursuan %ursuantt to the Persons Persons &isa'led &isa'led 'y (a)i  (2C;) in part sas4 !ssue' this 'ate, :e/ruar 2F, K# =oa$ Okon, >agistrate# This Persecutions Act  (2C;) 'upliate is su/"et su/"et to e'iting an' phrasing hanges# 8hmarahu 1ohen @ 1hie* 1lerk#B = :e/ruar K, =oa$ Okon +as no longer Registrar o* the 8upreme 1ourt, an' 8hmarahu 1ohen +as 'ea' *or a/out *ie ears# Numerous other reor's o* the same nature +ere 'i soere'#

The t+o ases, most +i'el reporte' / me'ia, inole' Ju'ge &ar'a Alsheh *rom the Tel-Ai Distrit 1ourt an' Ju'ge Hila 1ohen *rom the Hai*a Distrit 1ourt (Zarhin, 2, oa$, C)# Neither +as hel' aounta/le#

!n other, nota/le ases, Haaret$ 'ail reporte' a ase, +here a 'etainee +as going to /e 'eporte', /ase' on a hearing protool, +hih neer took plae in realit, an' the Annual Report o* the Ju'iiar Om/u'sman (2) notes that "u'ges hol' that the are permitte' to alter 'eisions an' "u'gments, een a*ter the +ere gien in open open ourt# ourt# !n the numerous numerous me'ia me'ia reports reports,, relati relatie e to the *alsi*iat *alsi*iation ion o* "u'ii "u'iial al reor' reor'ss / "u'ges "u'ges,, the *un'amental ?uestion +as neer raise'4 Ho+ +as it tehniall possi/leM The most plausi/le e.planation *or urrent on'itions in the !sraeli ourts is relate' to the implementation o*  the urrent !T sstems o* the ourts an' un'ermining o* the authorit o* the lerk o* the ourt *or integrit o*  ourt reor's# 0n'er paper a'ministration o* the ourts, "u'iial reor's +ere entere' into the 'okets onl throughthe lerk o* the ourt, an' one stampe' an' entere', +ere no longer aessi/le *or "u'ges to mo'i*# !n ontrast, the ei'ene sho+s that to'a, the ne+ !T sstems o* the ourts permit "u'ges aess to alter, mo'i*, or *orge "u'iial reor's an time, at +ill# (#4 ,ouble boo%s = la+, pu/li aess is permitte' to all "u'iial 'eisions, unless la+*ull seale'# !n pratie, Net-Hamishpat permits "u'ges to seletiel permit pu/li aess to 'eisions (:igure )#

a# b# 8eptem/er 3, 2F 6ist o* Deisions in State of Israel v Rafi  Figure 4 Dou/le-/ook sstem in Net-Hamishpat# 8eptem/er  (2KF--23) in the Tel-Ai >agistrate 1ourt4 a# A remote pu/li aess terminal sho+s no 'eisions, Rotem (2KF--23) an' the sreen sas4 5No 'etails *oun'5# b# The o**ie o* the lerk ter minal lists a 'o$en 'eisions# (#"5 Unlawful filing of eidence in criminal +rosecutions with no +rior ins+ection by the ,efendant The Criminal Criminal Court Procedure Act prohi/its the *iling o* ei'ene in riminal proseution, unless the 'e*en'ant an' his ounsel +ere *irst proi'e' proi'e' the opportunit opportunit to inspet the ei'ene# ei'ene# !nspetion !nspetion o* ourt *iles sho+s that in Net-Hamishpat, the Proseution eletroniall *iles the ei'ene +ithout proi'ing the 'e*en'ant an' his ounsel the opportunit to inspet the ei'ene (:igure 2)#

Figure "5 0nla+*ul *iling o* ei'ene in a riminal proseution# 6ist o* Relate' :iles in State of Israel v Rafi Rotem (2KF--23) in the Tel-Ai >agistrate 1ourt sho+s hperlinks to seen (K) !srael Polie inestigation *iles, although the De*en'ant ha' not /een proi'e' an opportunit to inspet the ei'ene, regar'less o* repeat re?uests# The hperlinks are inaessi/le to the pu/li an' the De*en'ant# De*en'ant# (#"" Failure to register 6udgments Honest Honest registration registration o* "u'gments "u'gments is ritial *or honest a'ministration a'ministration o* the ourts# Tpiall, Tpiall, a Ju'gment Ju'gment =ook, =ook, or an !n'e. o* Ju'gme Ju'gments nts is onsi' onsi'ere ere' ' on the *un'ame *un'amental ntal =ooks =ooks o* 1ourtsB 1ourtsB## Registr Registratio ation n o*   "u'gments in Net-Hamishpat is ar/itrar an' apriious (:igure 22)#

Figure "" !nali' registration o* "u'gments# State of Israel v Roman *adorov (C-K) in the Na$areth Distrit 1ourt# 0n'er the Ju'gmentsB Ju'gmentsB ta/ in Net-Hamishpat, the 8eptem/er 2F, 2 Ju'gment, Ju'gment, oniting Za'oro o* mur'er an' sentening him to li*e in prison is not liste'# The :e/ruar F, 2F 8upplemental Ju'gment, +hih again onite' Za'oro o* mur'er, is liste' as Or'er on De*en'ant7s attorne to *ile erti*iate o* ounselB#

/# Case studies A series o* ase stu'ies, *urther 'oumenting the 'e*iienies in t he ne+ !T sstems o* the ourts, outline' a/oe, is proi'e' in Online Appen'i. Appen'i. !# The series o* ases relate' to Ta. Authorit +histle-/lo+er Ra*i Rotem is partiularl instrutie# !sraeli me'ia 'esri/e' him as /eing 7a/use' / the ourt s *or oer a 'ea'e7 (Online Appen'i. !)4 a) !n Rotem v +a, Authority et al in the Tel-Ai 6a/our 1ourt, Rotem trie' to gain protetion against retaliation# The ase, ommene' in  C, an' +as on'ute' as a paper ourt *ile# !nspetion o* the ourt *ile reeale' onl an unsigne', unauthentiate' "u'gment reor', +hih the 1ourt re*use' to ert i*# /) Rotem v Baram in the Tel-Ai >agistrate 1ourt, ommene' in F, +as like+ise on'ute' as a paper ourt *ile# !nspetion *aile' to 'isoer summonses or authentiation reor's, /ut unoere' numerous unsigne' unsigne'  "u'iial reor's, +hih +ere neer 'ul sere'# Re?uest *or erti*iation o* the purporte' "u'gment in the ase, iel'e' a reor', +hih shoul' /e 'eeme' *orger;simulate' ourt reor'# ) The still ongoing State of Israel v Rotem in the Tel-Ai >agistrate 1ourt ! ommene' in 23, proi'es a 'etaile' e.ample o* the on'ut o* a/usie, simulate' riminal proseution un'er Net-Ha mishpat# The hallmarks are eletroni r eor's o* ague an' am/iguous ali'it, purporte'l /earing inisi/le eletroni signatures, a 'ou/le-/ooks sstem, +here pu/li aess is purporte'l permitte', /ut e**etiel 'enie' to all 'eision reor's i ssue' so *ar so *ar (:igure ), eletroni *iling o* ei'ene / the proseution +ithout proi'ing De*en'ant an opportunit to inspet it *irst, as re?uire' / la+ (:igure 2), an' the appearane o* unauthori$e' outsi'e attornes as purporte' pu/li 'e*en'ersB, +ho onsistentl *aile' to per*orm t heir 'uties# ') The petition Rotem v Samet in the 8upreme 1ourt, ommene' an' summaril 'enie' in  , proi'es a 'etaile' e.ample o* the 'enial o*  aess to a national tr i/unal *or protetion o* rights, an' the issuane o* simulate' 8upreme 1ourt 'eision reor's, +hih the 8upreme 1ourt re*use' to hae 'ul erti*ie'# 0# )ague A+ostille Treaty 7"41"8 The Hague Apostille Apostille Treat a/olishe' a/olishe' the re?uiremen re?uirementt *or legali$ation legali$ation o* *oreign *oreign pu/li 'ouments, 'ouments, an' esta/lishe' instruments *or mutuall reogni$e' erti*iation o* ourt reor's# The 8tate o* !srael entere' the Treat Treat in 2K, /ut the ei'ene ei'ene sho+s that the 8tate o* !srael !srael emplos emplos a *alse *alse proe' proe'ure ure *or apostill apostille e erti*iation erti*iation / priate notaries, notaries, in iolation o* /oth !sraeli la+ an' the Treat# The A'ministration A'ministration o* 1ourts re*use' to ans+er on a :ree'om o* !n*ormation re?uest4 0n'er +hose authorit an' +hat legal *oun'ation suh proe'ure +as pu/lishe'M (HRA 12a)# 1# ,iscussion The *un'amental *un'amental 'e*iienies 'e*iienies in the ne+ !T sstems o* the !sraeli ourts, sstems that hol' high signi*iane signi*iane relatie to the a'ministration o* "ustie an' +ere 'eelope' through a high ost, long-term pro"et, oerseen / senior national "u'iial o**iers, annot /e reasona/l 'eeme' 'eeme' the result o* oersight or human error# The ne+ sstems onsistentl strip "u'iial reor's o* an ei'ene o* authentiit, ali'it, *ore an' e**et4 <letroni signatures are ague an' am/iguous, un'er ontrol o* a priate orporation# 8ignature o* the hie* lerk are omitte' *rom summonses an' authentiation reor's, e**etiel inali'ating all serie proe'ures# 1erti*iation o* "u'iial reor's is routinel e.eute' / han'-signatures o* persons, +ho are not authori$e' to 'o so / la+, using an inali' erti*iation statements# The serers serers are no longer longer un'er state state usto' usto',, their their i'enti i'entit t is unert unerti*ie i*ie', ', an' the ultima ultimate te a'ministratie authorit oer them is unla+*ull hel' on*i'ential# The most plausi/le e.planation *or the entire /o' o* ei'ene is that the "u'iiar 'eli/eratel esta/lishe' inali' !T sstems an' inali' reor's in all ourts# There*ore, the sstems shoul' /e /e ie+e' as suspension o*  the la+ o* the lan', or 'enial o* aess to the iil ourts# As suh, the represen representt a regime hange, hange, or a onstitutional risis in a nation +ith no onstitution# The ei'ene sho+s that inali' litigation reor's +ere issue' also prior to implementation o* the sstems# Ho+eer, the ol'er reor's re*let +rong'oing on a loal /asis, +hereas the ne+ !T sstems re*let +rong'oing on a national sale# Pu/li Pu/li reor's reor's,, inlu' inlu'ing ing ourt ourt reor's reor's,, emerge emerge' ' in the late mi''le mi''le ages as ke instrum instrument entss in the a'ministration o* a iil soiet, starting +ith /irth, marriage, an' /urial reor's# 6ater, in the <nglish ommon la+, ourt reor's reor's +ere aor'e' the same status, status, +ith the o**ie o* the lerk as their la+*ul usto'ian# usto'ian# !n ontras ontrast, t, the urren urrentt !T sstems sstems o* the !srael !sraelii ourts ourts a**et a**ete' e' the priati priati$ati $ation on o* pu/li pu/li reor' reor's, s, their their signatures, an' their apostille erti*iation - a onept +hih 'e*ies the purpose o* pu/li reor's# The sstem o* state (or roal) an' ourt seals eole' in the mi''le ages as part o* e**orts to enhane the integrit an' seurit o* the respetie reor's# &ali', isi/le eletroni signatures oul' hae pratiall elim elimina inate te' ' the the possi possi/il /ilit it o* *org *orger er,, or the the issu issuan ane e o* simu simula late te' ' our ourtt reo reor' r's# s# !n ont ontras rast, t, the the implementation o* inisi/le eletroni signatures - the <mperor7s Ne+ 1lothesB - in *at enhane' the a/ilit  





to generate *orge' *orge' or inali', simulate' ourt ourt reor's# The priati$ation priati$ation o* erti*ing authorities authorities o* state eletroni signatures again 'e*ies their o+n purpose# The right o* the pu/li to inspet an' to op ourt reor's originate' hun're's o* ears ago in the <nglish ommon la+, an' is onsi'ere' essential *or transparen o* the ourts an' integrit o* the "u'iial proess# !n 08 la+ it is inherent inherent to the :irst :irst Amen'm Amen'ment ent to the 1onstitu 1onstitutio tion# n# &ali' &ali' !T sstems sstems oul' hae proi'e' proi'e' unpree'ente' pu/li aess an' unpree'ente' transparen o* the ourts# !n ontrast, the sstems +hih +ere +ere implem implement ente' e' e**et e**etie iel l reate reate' ' a 'ou/le 'ou/le /ooks /ooks sstem sstem,, +hih +hih un'erm un'ermine iness pu/li pu/li aess aess an' transparen o* the ourts# :urthermore, in a ke 'eision o* the !sraeli 8upreme 1ourt ( Association for Civil  Rights v "inister of #ustice! C2K;K ! su/"et o* +hih +as pu/li aess to ourt reor's un'er the ne+ !T sstems, then Presi'ing Justie Dorit =einish rule' that pu/li aess ha' to /e restrite', /ase' on the 7onstitutional7 right *or pria# The on'ut o* the !sraeli ourts, inherent in the ne+ !T sstems, stan's ontrar to the *un'amentals o* the <nglish ommon la+, in +hih the !sraeli ourts originate'# 8uh on'ut, like+ise, stan's ontrar to the *un'amentals o* *air hearing an' aess to national ourts *or protetion o* rights in Human Rights# !t also stan's stan's ontrar to the *un'amental *un'amental o* Je+ish la+, another ma"or soure o* !sraeli !sraeli la+, +here ali' issuane an' e.eution o* summonses, e.eution o* ourt reor's through ali' signatures an' authentiation;serie proe'ures, partiularl in matters o* marriages an' 'iore, hae /een +ell-esta/lishe' *or oer  ears# !n reie+ing on'itions on'itions in the !sraeli ourts, one shoul' note that although the 8tate o* !srael !srael akno+le'ge akno+le'gess Human Rights in !nternational 6a+, 'eisions o* the 8upreme 1ourt learl 'istinguish /et+een 7proe'ural 'e*iienie 'e*iienies7 s7 an' 7essential 7essential 'e*iienies7 'e*iienies7 in ourt on'ut# !n a lan'mark lan'mark  'eision 'eision in the ase or Amos =aranes, +ho +as *alsel onite' o* mur'er an' +as *alsel imprisone' man ears, the 8upreme 1ourt notes that 7proe'ural matter7 shoul' /e onsi'ere' 7upgra'e'7, sine the enatment in 2 o* the Basic .a/  - 0uman &ignity and .i'erty , +hih purporte'l esta/lishe' the right *or 'ue proess in !srael# The 'eelopment an' implementation o* the ne+ !T sstem o* the !sraeli ourts +as launhe' un'er the tenure o* 8upreme 1ourt Presi'ing Justie Aharon =arak (in o**ie 2C- L)# 0n'er his tenure, the 8upreme 1ourt purporte' to onstrue arious *un'amental human an' iil rights o* onstitutional *ore an' e**et /ase' on the enatment o* =asi 6a+s# =arak a'ertise' himsel* as lea'ing o* a 71onstitutional Reolution7 in !srael (Zernik, 2)# !n ontrast, outsi'e o/serers pereie' =arak as an 7enlightene' 'espot7 at /est, or the +orl'7s reor' hol'er in 7"u'iial hu/ris7 (Posner, K)# The notion o* a 71onstitutional Reolution7 annot /e su/stantiate' / an 'iserni/le enhanement in the a'herene o* the 8tate o* !srael +ith Human Rights, either in the treatment o* its o+n iti$ens +ithin !srael proper, or the treatment o* resi'ents o* the Palestinian territories# The urrent report proposes that Justie =arak in *at presi'e' oer unpree'ente' orruption o*  the !sraeli ourts# The implementation o* the ne+ !T sstems in the !sraeli ourts orrelate' +ith a perio', +hih has /een marke' / unpree'ente', rampant goernment orruption an' the emergene o* e.treme gaps in asset an' inome 'istri/ution# The eonom has gro+n to /e 'ominate' 'ominate' / a han'*ul o* 7toons7, an' !srael has /een /een propelle' to the *irst plae among O<1D nations in poert rate +ithout su**ering an eonomi risis# The soio-e soio-eon onomi omi trans* trans*orm ormati ation on has also le' to the emergen emergene e in reent reent ears o* a soial soial protes protestt o*  unpree'ente' sale# The 8tate o* !srael is not alone# 8imilar on'itions +ere reporte' in the !T sstems o* the state an' *e'eral ourts in the 0nite' 8tates, +hih ha' /een 'eelope' an' implemente' a 'ea'e or t +o earlier than those o*  the !sraeli ourts (HRA, 2C/)# !n the 0nite' 8tates, the implementation implementation o* suh sstems sstems is like+ise orrelate' +ith unpree'ente' orruption o* the "ustie sstem, the emergene o* e.treme soio-eonomi gaps, an' the +i'esprea' notion that the 08 1onstitution has /een oi'e' or suspen'e' suspen'e' (Zernik, 2C)# !n this onte.t, the ke role o* t+o 08-/ase' 08-/ase' international orporations, !=> an' <D8, in the unla+*ul 'eelopment an' implementation o* the ne+ !T sstems o* the !sraeli ourts shoul' / e note', as +ell as the on'ut o* !=> in other nations (Zernik, 2F")# 2# 9ro+osed Correctie Actions The implementation o* the ne+, *rau'ulent !T sstems in the !sraeli ourts, impliate the "u'iiar as a lass, as +ell as the !sraeli =ar Assoiation an' the >inistr o* Justie# There*ore, orretie ations are likel to /e neither neither *ast nor eas# <**orts ma eentuall eentuall re?uire re?uire an approah similar to a Truth an' Reoniliation Reoniliation 1ommission# 0n'er similar irumstanes in the 08 ourts a entur ago, ke orretie measures inole' re*orm o* the o**ie o* the lerk o* the ourt (>essinger, )# 8imilar measures ma /e nee'e' in !srael# 1orretie measures shoul' note the uni?ue relationship /et+een o'e an' la+ (6essig, ), 'emonstrate' in !T sstems sstems o* the ourts, ourts, there* there*ore ore re?uiring re?uiring transpar transparen en  @ pursua pursuant nt to Pu/li Pu/liit it o* the 6a+, 6a+, an'

aoun aounta/i ta/ilit lit to the legisla legislature ture @ pursua pursuant nt to the 8eparat 8eparation ion o* Po+ers Po+ers @ plain plaing g the 'eelo 'eelopme pment nt an' implementatio implementation n o* suh sstems sstems un'er aounta/ilit aounta/ilit to the legislature# legislature# Human rights an' internet internet atiists atiists shoul' keep igilane in monitoring suh sstems# !T e.perts shoul' assume more prominent 'uties in the sa*eguar' o* iil soiet in our era# 3# $nline A++endices !# Zernik, J# (2C) 5:rau'ulent Ne+ !T 8stems o* the !sraeli 1ourts - 0nannoune' 0nannoune' Regime 1hangeM5 https4;;+++#sri/'#om;'o;CCCK; !!# Human Rights Alert, NGO, (23) Appen'i. to 8u/mission *or the 0PR o* Human Rights in the 8tate o* !srael / the 0N Human Rights 1ounilB https4;;'rie#google#om;*ile;';=Aa.G/mkC"N.'s$SCo>k0;e'itMuspsharing References =ohm, J# () >arh C,  >emoran'um Opinion in Case of Borro/er 1illiam Parsley   (C-3KF), Dkt QF, Te.as =ankrupt 1ourtB, online Human Rights Alert (NGO) :er$iger, J, an' ainer, D# (2F) 8tartup !srael 8u**ering >ost O<1D Poert as Poor 8urgeB, online =loom/erg Haohen, # (K) L-K Annual Report o* the >agistrate o* Data/asesB, online >inistr o* Justie, 8tate o* !srael Human Rights Alert (NGO) (2) 8u/mission to the 0nite' Nations Human Rights 1ounil 0niersal Perio'i Reie+ o* Human Rights in the 0nite' 8tateB, online 0nite' Nations Human Rights 1ounil Human Rights Alert (NGO) (2) Appen'i. to 8u/mission to the 0nite' Nations Human Rights 1ounil 0niersal Perio'i Reie+ o* Human Rights in the 0nite' 8tatesB, online 0nite' Nations Human Rights 1ounil Human Rights Alert (NGO) (23) 8u/mission to the 0nite' Nations Human Rights 1ounil 0niersal Perio'i Reie+ o* Human Rights in !sraelB, online 0nite' Nations Human Rights 1ounil Human Rights Alert (NGO) (23) Appen'i. to 8u/mission to the 0nite' Nations Human Rights 1ounil 0niersal Perio'i Reie+ o* Human Rights in !sraelB, online Human Rights Alert (NGO) Human Rights Alert (NGO) (2Ca) 8u/mission to the 0nite' Nations Human Rights 1ounil 0niersal Perio'i Reie+ o* Human Rights in the 0nite' 8tatesB, online Human Rights Alert (NGO) Human Rights Alert (NGO) (2C/) Appen'i. to 8u/mission to the 0nite' Nations Human Rights 1 ounil 0niersal Perio'i Reie+ o* Human Right s in the 0nite' 8tatesB, online Human Rights Alert (NGO) 6essig, 6# () The 1o'e in 6a+, an' the 6a+ in 1o'eB, online Harar' 6a+ 8hool >essinger, 8# () Or'er in The 1ourt - Histor o* 1lerks o* 0nite' 8tates 1ourtsB, online :e'eral Ju'iial 1enter Posner, R# (K) <nlightene' DespotB, online Ne+ Repu/li 8tate Om/u'sman7s Report L/ (2) Deelopment o* !T sstems o* the !sraeli >inistr o* Justie an' the !sraeli ourtsB online 8tate o* !srael Om/u'sman7s O**ie oa$, # (C) Panel rules to *ire Ju'ge Hila 1ohenB, online Haaret$ Zarhin, T# (2) !srael =ar Assoiation hea' sas Tel-Ai 'istrit ourt "u'ge must goB, online Haaret$ Zernik, J# (2) Data >ining as a 1ii Dut @ Online Pu/li PrisonersU Registration 8stemsB online !nternational Journal on 8oial >e'ia4 >onitoring, >easurement, >ining 24 F-L Zernik, J# (2a) 5Design an' Operation o* the <letroni Reor' Reor' 8stems o* the 08 1ourts are 6inke' to :ailing =anking Regulation5, online Data Analtis Zernik, J# (2/) 5!ntegrit, 5!ntegrit, or 6ak Thereo*, o* the <letroni Reor' 8stems o* the 1ourts o* the 8tate o* !srael5, !srael5, online Data Analtis Zernik, J# (2) 71onstitutional Reolution7 in the 8tate o* !sraelM ompilation o* me'ia reportsB online Human Rights Alert (NGO) Zernik, J# (2F*) >ounting ei'ene o* :rau' 0pon the 1ourt in riminal proseution o* !sraeli +histle-/lo+er RotemB, online Human Rights Alert (NGO) Zernik, J# (2Fg) Gro+ing onerns o* *rau' on !srael <letri 1o +histle-/lo+er >oran Genosar in the TelAi 6a/or 1ourt#B, online Human Rights Alert (NGO) Zernik, J# (2Fh) 8pei*iation, ali'ation o* !T sstems o* the ourts no+ /e*ore the !sraeli 8upreme 1ourtB, online Human Rights Alert (NGO) Zernik, J# (2F") 1orruption o* goernments an' !=> @ ompilation o* me'ia reportsB, online Human Rights Alert (NGO) Zernik, J# (2C) !T sstems o* the 08 *e'eral ourts, "ustie, an' goernaneB, online !1<G

Sponsor Documents

Or use your account on DocShare.tips

Hide

Forgot your password?

Or register your new account on DocShare.tips

Hide

Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link to create a new password.

Back to log-in

Close