Brick by Brick Vol I - Remodel and Construction Protection

Published on January 2017 | Categories: Documents | Downloads: 22 | Comments: 0 | Views: 183
of 2
Download PDF   Embed   Report

Comments

Content


PROLOGUE
  "# $o& 'a)e e)er 'ad a -a.or re-ode/ or 0ons3r&03ion 5or6 done on $o&r 7ro7er3$8 or e)en 3'o&g'3 a:o&3 'a)ing i3 done8 3'is ar3i0/e is #or $o&;  
<'e s0ene :e/o5 7/a$s o&3 a0ross San Diego 0o--&ni3ies #ro- 3'e :ea0' 'o-es o# ?a @o//a 3o 3'e 0ra#3s-an :&nga/o5s o# Aor3' Bar6 and Mission Di//s;  
Ero- 0on3ra03ors 3o 7ro7er3$ o5ners8 #irs3F3i-e :&$ers 3o seasoned in)es3ors8 i3 0an :e 'ard 3o a)oid /ega/ 'eada0'es in e)en 3'e -os3 5e// 3'o&g'3 o&3 
7ro.e03;  
  <o &nders3and 3'e si3&a3ion8 i-agine 3'e #o//o5ing s0enario;  <'e S-i3's8 o&r #i03iona/ 0o&7/e8  7/anned a 7ro.e03 3'a3 'as :een &nder 5a$ #or 
se)era/ -on3's and 3'e$ ass&-ed e)er$3'ing is going 5e//;  G s&--ons and 0o-7/ain3 arri)es H5'i0' is 3'e 3e0'ni0a/ na-e #or 3'e s3ar3 o# a /a5s&i3I8 and 
Mr; S-i3' rea0'es #or 3'e 3e/e7'one 3o 0a// 'is /a5$er;  <'e 0on)ersa3ion goes so-e3'ing /i6e 3'isJ
    Mr. SmithJ !"#$%$&d%(%)*#+%,-+%#.r0.d%1"+2%+2"#%3$1#*"+4%12$+%d-%1.%d-5
 
    Jill the LawyerJ !.+6#%7",*r.%-*+%12$+6#%,-"&,%-&8%%92.&%d"d%:-*%,.+%+2.%;$;.r1-r<%$&d%12$+%d-.#%"+%#$:5
 
    Mr. SmithJ (+%=$>.%3$#+%?r"d$:4%@*+%1.%)*#+%r.$d%"+%+2"#%>-r&"&,8%%A-*%<&-14%1.%7"&$33:%;*33.d%>-&.:%-*+%
% % -7%+2.%=->;$&:%+-%r.#+-r.%+2-#.%@*&,$3-1#%1.%@-*,2+%"&%BCCD8
 
    Jill the LawyerJ A.#4%3$#+%+">.%1.%#;-<.%:-*6d%@..&%1$"+"&,%7-r%+2.%r",2+%+">.%+-%7"&$33:%d-%+2.%7*33%r.>-d.34%
% % 12$+%2$;;.&.d5
 
    Mr. SmithJ E@-*+%&"&.%>-&+2#%$,-%1.%2"r.d%FAG%H*"3d.r#%+-%1-r<%1"+2%-*r%d.#",&.r%$&d%=->;3.+.%
% % >$)-r%-0.r2$*3#%-&%@-+2%;r-;.r+".#%d-1&%+2.r.%&.$r%I-3d7"&=28%%J2.%;r-).=+#%2$d%@..&%r*&&"&,%#>--+23:4
% % %1.%+2-*,2+4%@*+%$;;$r.&+3:%1.%2$0.%@..&%#*.d%@:%$&%.>;3-:..8%%
%
    Jill the LawyerJ K$&%:-*%r.$d%>.%+2.%#.=+"-&%+2$+%d.#=r"@.#%+2.%.>;3-:..%$&d%12$+%2$;;.&.d5
 
    Mr. SmithJ L.r.%"+%"#4%"+%#$:#%MMr8%O-&.#%1$#%1-r<"&,%-&%+2.%;r-;.r+:%r.;$"r"&,%+2.%r--7%12.&%2.%3.$&.d%
% % $,$"&#+%$%;--r3:%=-&#+r*=+.d%r$"3"&,%$&d%7.33%+.&%7..+%+-%+2.%,r-*&d4%12.r.%2.%#*77.r.d%>$)-r4%;.r>$&.&+%
% % "&)*r".#%+-%2"#%&.=<%$&d%@$=<8P%%O"334%"+%#$:#%+2"#%,*:%=$&6+%.0.r%r.+*r&%+-%1-r<4%12$+%$r.%1.%,-"&,%+-%d-5
%
    Jill the LawyerJ !.+6#%+$<.%$%d..;%@r.$+2.4%#.&d%>.%-0.r%+2.%=->;3$"&+%$#%#--&%$#%1.%2$&,%*;4%$&d%(633%1-r<%
% % -*+%$%;3$&%+-%,.+%+2"#%#-r+.d%-*+8
AN INTRODUCTION TO THE ISSUE
  "n rea/i3$8 3'e si3&a3ion is no3 as gri- as 3'e #i03iona/ s0enario a:o)e s&gges3s;  Do5e)er8 i# 3'is 'a77ened 3o $o&8 i3 is i-7or3an3 3o &nders3and 
3'e :asi0s o# 3'e iss&e and8 -os3 i-7or3an3/$8 5'a3 in#or-a3ion 3o 'a)e #or $o&r a33orne$ so s'e 0an a77/$ 3'e /a5;  "n o&r s0enario8 Mr; S-i3' 'asn’3 gi)en 
'is a33orne$ -&0' de3ai/;  L:)io&s/$ @i// 5i// need 3o #ind o&3 5'en 3'e 0o-7/ain3 5as a03&a//$ ser)ed and -a6e 0on3a03 5i3' 3'e B/ain3i##’s a33orne$8 :&3 
-an$ M&es3ions re-ain;
   Mig'3 3'e S-i3's :e /ega//$ res7onsi:/eN  Oas 3'e in.&red 5or6er an e-7/o$ee o# PQR :&i/dersN  Oas 'e an inde7enden3 roo#ing 0on3ra03orN  
Do an$ o# 3'e 0on3ra03ors 'a)e )a/id Oor6ers’ So-7ensa3ion ins&ran0eN  <'e S-i3's’ 0ase s3ands a3 3'e in3erse03ion o# 7re-ises /ia:i/i3$8 5or6er’s 0o-7enF
sa3ion8 0ons3r&03ion and e-7/o$-en3 /a58 and :eing a:/e 3o gi)e 3'eir a33orne$ 3'e rig'3 in#or-a3ion is 6e$ 3o -ini-izing 3'eir ris6–no3 3o -en3ion 3'eir 
s3ress /e)e/!
  ?a5s in Sa/i#ornia are -ade in 35o 5a$s–ei3'er 3'ro&g' So&r3 de0isions H0a//ed W0o--on /a5XI or :$ s3a3&3e Hi;e; 3'ro&g' o&r e/e03ed /egis/aF
3&reI;  Ynder 3'e 0o--on /a5 in Sa/i#ornia8 3'e o5ner o# 7ro7er3$ 5as no3 'is3ori0a//$ /ia:/e 3o 3'ird 7ar3ies #or in.&ries 0a&sed :$ 3'e a03s o# a 7erson or 
0o-7an$ 'ired 3o 7er#or- 5or6 on 3'a3 7ro7er3$;  <'e 3'eor$ 5as 3'a3 3'e 7ar3ies 3o 3'e 0on3ra03 'ad in0/&ded 3'e 0os3 o# sa#e3$ -eas&res or ins&ran0e 
in 3'e 7ri0e o# 3'e 0on3ra03; L)er 3i-e8 Sa/i#ornia 0o&r3s rea/ized 3'a3 inno0en3 3'ird 7ar3ies 0o&/d ge3 in.&red and no3 :e /ega//$ a:/e 3o 'o/d an$one 
res7onsi:/e;
Brick-by-Brick Series
If You Build It: The Dream Home Remodel Gone WrongM
H:%Q>$r%J8%R$##-&#
Los Angeles
Z[\;]Z^;]_``
San Francisco
^[a;Z[b;]__`
San Diego
][_;a[a;`Z]_
Orange County
_^_;^^`;]]_`
Scottsdale
^c`;^bb;aZ]_
www.manningllp.com February 2012
!"#$%!&$%'(()*)+++$,-../.0112$34,
5677879):);6<<=)>??@AB=)@658@>C=)D@><D>@)??E
E69>)!
COPYRIOHT AND REPRODLCTION NOTICE. Copyri¸ht © 2012, Mannin¸ e Kass, Ellrod, Ramirez, Trester LLP. All ri¸hts reserved. Reproduction ot
all or part ot the contents in any torm other than tor individual use is expressly prohibited. The document is published by the law tirm ot MANNINO e
KA$$, ELLROD, RAMIREZ, TRE$TER LLP as a service to our clients, the le¸al protession, the insurance industy, and others with interests in le¸al issues.
All intormation provided is ot a ¸eneral nature and not intended nor represented to replace protessional, specialized le¸al advice. The articles provided by
contributin¸ authors do not necessarily retlect the views ot the tirm.
A,-F)E-GG4.G)is an attorney with Mannin¸ e Kass, Ellrod Ramirez, Trester LLP. He is a liti¸ation attorney and practices in the areas
ot land use, construction and premises detense. He can be reached directly at (619) 565·6+56 or via email at otp©mannin¸llp.com.
This led to the birth ot the Peculiar Risk Doctrine, which holds that a person who hires an independent contractor to pertorm work that is
inherently dan¸erous (i.e. is a ¨peculiar risk") can be held liable tor dama¸es when the contractor's ne¸li¸ent pertormance ot that work causes injuries to
others. An independent contractor is the le¸al name tor a person who is contracted to do work but has treedom to choose how the work is done. Over
time, Calitornia courts extended this basic idea to cover not just innocent bystanders, but the employees ot ne¸li¸ent independent contractors. Not surpris·
in¸ly, the pendulum quickly swun¸ in the opposite direction and the le¸islature enacted the Workers' Compensation Act, so courts be¸an to chan¸e their
view.
DH>)I7>JK)@L?>M)E@AD>ND8A7)L7B>@)E@8O>DD>)67B)DA?67B
Courts quickly realized that injured employees could ¸et a ¨double dip" by collectin¸ workers compensation and suin¸ the property owner. Out
ot this untairness Calitornia courts decided two cases that created a new rule that protected property owners who hire contractors to pertorm work–Privette
v. $uperior Court and Toland v. $unland Housin¸ Oroup.
In Privette, the owner ot a duplex hired a rootin¸ company to install a new root. The rootin¸ company's employee was injured when he tell ott
a ladder and the bucket ot hot tar he was carryin¸ tell on top ot him. He sued the duplex owner, claimin¸ that the owner's ne¸li¸ent selection ot the
contractor was a cause ot the injuries he suttered. The Court ruled that the property owner could not be liable tor the injuries ot the rooter's employee.
In the next case, Toland, the plaintitt was an employee ot a sub·contractor, injured when a wall tell on him. A sub·contractor is a person or
company hired by the main contractor to do specitic work on a project. Electricians, plumbers and carpenters are examples ot trades typically pertormed
by sub·contractors on lar¸e projects. The employee sued and said that the law in Privette did not apply it the property owner had tailed to include precau·
tions tor satety in the contract tor hire. The $upreme Court quickly claritied that its rulin¸ in Privette applied even it the contractual precautions tor satety
were not in place because the owner hired a contractor to be responsible tor the satety ot its workers.
74P)QR/PS)ARP)AT)DUS)J44VGM)>F4V/.0)DUS)>W3S2P/4.
Calitornia courts have evolved several exceptions to the exception. A tew remainin¸ questions Mr. and Mrs. $mith may be asked are did they...
1) Retain control tor the satety ot the work or how it would be done.
2) Provide any ot the equipment on the job.
3) For¸et to disclose some hidden hazard on the job site that led to the injury.
+) Breach a re¸ulatory duty.
Each ot the exceptions described above involves a tact·intensive inquiry, so settin¸ aside some time to really help your attorney understand the
project will be important. The cautious attorney will speak with her clients, but also with the desi¸ner, the independent contractor–it he or she is willin¸·
and possibly even other sub·contractors who were on the project.
Fortunately tor those considerin¸ new construction or remodel projects, the $upreme Court recently took additional steps to limit property
owner liability.
N4XSF/.0)DUS)H41SG)8.)DUS)?-+M)<R2FS,S)N4RFP)N1-F/T/3-P/4.
In 2011, the $upreme Court pumped the brakes on the property owner liability tor injuries to contractors' employees. In $eabri¸ht Insurance
Co. v. L$ Airways Inc, an injured employee and the insurance company who paid his workers' compensation benetits sued L$ Airways because a satety
¸uard required by Cal·O$HA was missin¸ trom the conveyor. Cal·O$HA is a state a¸ency that re¸ulates workplace satety, includin¸ at construction projects.
The $upreme Court held that L$ Airways was not liable. The Court explained that, because it hired the independent contractor, L$ Airways had passed
its responsibility on to the contractor and theretore it could not be responsible tor the employee's injuries.
D-YS)H4,S)5SGG-0SG)Z4F)5F$)-.V)5FG$)<,/PU)[-.V)\AL]
By now, their attorney has thorou¸hly dia¸nosed the situation, done enou¸h investi¸ation to teel comtortable with the analysis, and prepared to
advise Mr. and Mrs. $mith about the lawsuit. Fortunately Mr. $mith and Mrs. $mith a¸reed to only hire a licensed contractor. And they are ¸ratetul that
the contract ]ill dratted tor them two years a¸o when they started thinkin¸ about the project included a clause that required XYZ builders to have excess
insurance covera¸e and explicitly put the responsibility ot its workers on the contractor. The steps ]ill the Lawyer took in the early sta¸es paid ott to avoid
the pittalls they would not have seen comin¸. Now the attorney can have Mr. and Mrs. $mith down to the ottice, ¸ive them the ¸ood news, and start
workin¸ on that victory celebration.

Sponsor Documents

Or use your account on DocShare.tips

Hide

Forgot your password?

Or register your new account on DocShare.tips

Hide

Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link to create a new password.

Back to log-in

Close