Case Digests in Criminal Law 1

Published on March 2017 | Categories: Documents | Downloads: 116 | Comments: 0 | Views: 1721
of 8
Download PDF   Embed   Report

Comments

Content

 

People vs. Luciano Barroga y Salgado G.R. No. 31563 (1930) FACTS: Luciano prepared fa!ified docu"en#! $i#% fu &no$ed'e of #%eir fa!i#. Suc% docu"en#! $ere u# accordin' #o da#a furni!%ed  %i! i""edia#e c%ief. Suc% ac#! $ere a!o in oedience #o in!#ruc#ion! #o %i". *SS+,:  -%e#%er or no# Luciano Luciano i! ee" ee"p# p# fro" cri"ina iaii# iaii# for oedience oedience of a !uperior/ R+L*NG: No. *n order #o ee"p# fro" 'ui# oedience "u!# e in co"piance $i#% a a$fu order no# oppo!ed #o a %i'%er po!i#ie du# of a !ua#ern and #%a# #%e per!on co""andin' ac# $i#%in #%e !cope of %i! au#%ori#.

 

People vs. Beronilla G.R. No. L25 (1955) FACTS: *n 19 4eronia i! a ii#ar aor and $a! au#%oried  L#. Co.  Arnod #o appoin# appoin# a 7ur of 18 oo"e oo"en n #o #r per!on! accu!ed accu!ed of #rea #rea!on !on e!piona'e or #%e aidin' and ae##in' of #%e ene". *n addi#ion %e receied a i!# of puppe# 'oern"en# officia! of Ara incudin' Ar!enio 4or7a and $a! in!#ruc#ed #o ine!#i'a#e !aid per!on! and 'a#%er co"pain#! a'ain!# #%e".  Are!nio 4or7a 4or7a i! #%e aor of La La a Ara. 4eronia 4eronia pac paced ed 4or7a unde underr cu!#od and a!&ed #%e re!iden#! #o fie c%ar'e! a'ain!# %i". T%e #ria efore #%e 182"an 7ur end up conic#in' 4or7a. T%a# !a"e da 4eronia ordered #%e eecu#ion of 4or7a. acin#o $a! #%e eecu#ioner and An#onio $a! #%e 'rae di''er. 4eronia repor#ed #%i! repor# #o Co. Arnod. *SS+,:  -%e#%er or no# Luciano Luciano i! ee" ee"p# p# fro" cri"ina iaii# iaii# for oedience oedience of a !uperior/ R+L*NG:  ;e!. 4eronia ac#ed upon or order! der! of a !upe !uperior rior officer #%a# %e ccoud oud no# <ue!#ion. oreoer oreoer %e oeed in 'ood fai#%. A cri"e i! no# co""i##ed if #%e "ind of #%e per!on perfor"in' #%e ac# co"pained of e innocen#.

 

Salvador Nassif vs. El Pueblo De Filipinas G.R. No. =509 (191) FACTS: *SS+,: R+L*NG:

U.S. vs. Guevarra G.R. No. 9865 (191) FACTS:  -%ie *'nacia $a! $a! !#arc%in' co#%e! co#%e! o!e Gu Guearra earra !a!%ed !a!%ed %er $i#% a o oo o !eera #i"e!. S%e died af#er "ore #%an one "on#% ecau!e of #%e $ound!. Coun!e for defen!e #ried #o proe #%a# defendan# $a! !ufferin' fro" in!ani# $%en %e co""i##ed #%e ac#. >o$eer i'uea "o#%er of decea!ed #e!#ified #%a# o!e $a! !ane for efore #%e inciden# %e %ad !po&en #o %er nice. re!iden# of oard of %ea#% iare! $a! a!&ed #o ea"ine o!e #o &no$ if %e i! in!ane. A#%oun'% %e $a! !een !$i""in' #o %i! o$n urine $%ie na&ed and a$a! !%ou#in' ?T%e i' "an@ iare! !#i found %i" #o e !ane and nor"a. *SS+,:  -%e#%er or no# o!e o!e i! in!ane/ R+L*NG: No. er #e!#i"on of #%e eper# $i#ne!! %e i! no# in!ane $%en %e co""i##ed #%e cri"e. T%u! %e i! no# ee"p# fro" cri"ina iaii#.

 

U.S. vs. Vaquilar G.R. No!. 9=1  9=5 (191) FACTS: ,ari!#o Ba<uiar $a! c%ar'ed of parricide for &iin' %i! $ife and dau'%#er. T%e "ornin' efore #%e inciden# ,ari!#o fe# pain! in %i! %ead and !#o"ac% %i! ee! $ere er i' red and %i! !i'%# i! pene#ra#in'. Seera  $i#ne!!e! #e!#ified #e!#ified #%a# %e !ee"e !ee"ed d #o e cra. >e of#en !aid #%e $ord! $ord!:: ?-%a# &ind of peope are ou #o "e $%a# are ou doin' #o "e ou are ea!#D@ *SS+,:  -%e#%er or no# ,ari!#o ,ari!#o i! in!an in!ane/ e/ R+L*NG: No. ?Cra@ i! no# !non"ou! #o in!ane un!ound "ind una#ic or idio#. ?Cra@ a! con#e"pa#ed in #%e #e!#i"onie! i! #%a# of %ain' an unna#ura #rai# i.e. ou# of #%e ordinar. *n!ani# i! no# a pre!u"p#ion and !%oud e proen eond rea!onae dou#.

 

People vs. Donao Bascos G.R. No. L219605 (1988) FACTS: Eona#o 4a!co! &ied Bic#oriano Ro"ero $%ie #%e a##er i! !eepin'. T%e  $ife of #%e accu!ed accu!ed and %i! cou!in #e!#ified #%a# Eona#o %a %ad d een con#inuou! con#inuou! ou# of %i! "ind for ear!. Er. Gonao on#e"aor on#e"aor found #%e accu!ed #o e a  ioen# "aniac. *SS+,:  -%e#%er or no# Eona#o Eona#o i! in!ane/ R+L*NG:  ;e!. T%e #e!#i"on #e!#i"on of #%e $ife and %i! cou cou!in !in $a! corr corroora#ed oora#ed  an eper# $i#ne!!. *n!ani# in #%i! ca!e $a! proen eond rea!onae dou#.

 

People vs. !rispino "ancao and !iriaco #guilar G.R. No. 86361 (198=) FACTS: Roer#o Biea refu!ed #o !urrender #%e and! eon'in' #o #%e in#e!#a#e e!#a#e of #%e decea!ed >iaria Ee7an $%ic% $ere in %i! po!!e!!ion. -%ie Cri!pino i! %are!#in' corn! fro" !aid and! %e $a! confron#ed  Roer#o unar"ed u# #%e for"er carried a !#ic& and a oo. Cri!pin a!!au#ed 4er#o. Roer#o #oo& a oo and a##e"p#ed #o !#ri&e Cri!pino. -%en Cri!pino 'o#  $ounded %e 'raed 'raed #%e oo fro" Roer#o and a##a a##ac&ed c&ed #%e a##er. a##er. T%e #$o fe do$n and 4er#o pinned Cri!pin. Ciriaco A'uiar #od Roer#o ?-%a# %ae ou done #o %i"/@ Ciriaco #ried #o %i# Roer#o $i#% a oo u# %e %i# Cri!pin. Ciriaco i! an epiep#ic and a! ae'ed in #%e defen!e %e i! depried of %i! rea!on. *SS+,:  -%e#%er or no# Ciriaco Ciriaco !%oud e ee"p# fro" cri"ina cri"ina iaii#/ R+L*NG: No. ,en if Ciriaco i! an epiep#ic #%erefore !u!cep#ie #o nerou! a##ac&! #%a# "a "o"en#ari deprie %i" of %i! "en#a facii#ie! and ead %i" #o uncon!ciou! uncon!ciou!  a##e"p# #o #a&e %i! o$n ife and ie! of o#%er! i# %a! no# een !%o$n #%a# %e $a! under #%e infuence of an epiep#ic fi# efore durin' and i""edia#e af#er #%e a''re!!ion.

 

People vs. $uan N. $i%ena G.R. No. 33== (1931) FACTS: uan Gi"ena !u!pec#ed Cri!pina %i! $ife of %ain' iici# rea#ion! $i#%  Apoinar Sereno Sereno (ApoH) eca ecau!e u!e !%e 'ae Apo 8.=0. uan a a##ac&ed ##ac&ed Cri!pina Cri!pina $i#% a oo u# $a! !#opped  Gre'orio. Cri!pina died. *n defen!e uan cai"ed #%a# %e $a! in a !#a#e of !o"na"ui!". *SS+,:  -%e#%er or no# uan uan !%oud e ee"p# fro" cr cri"ina i"ina iaii#/ R+L*NG: No. Er. Go"e did no# find uan #o e in a !#a#e of !o"na"ui !o"na"ui!". !". oreoer 'ran#in' #%a# %e $a! !o !ufferin' fro" !uc% !o"na"ui!" !o"na"ui!" doe! no# con!#i#u#e a defen!e o#%er #%an #%a# e"raced in a pea of in!ani#. ISo"na"ui!" i! an anor"a condi#ion of !eep in $%ic% "o#or ac#! (a! ISo"na"ui!"  $a&in') are perfor"ed.J perfor"ed.J

 

People vs. Valenin Doque&a G.R. No. 6539 (1939) FACTS: uan Ra'o7o! and ,pifanio Rara' (,piH) $ere pain' oea in #%eir !c%oo. Baen#in (BaH) a = #% 'rade pupi 7oined #%e" u# %e %i# uan $i#% #%e  a in #%e !#o"ac%. !#o"ac%. uan c%a c%a!ed !ed !apped an and d punc%ed Ba on #%e face. uan re#urned #o ,pi and paed and Ba #oo& a &nife. Ba !#aed uan #o dea#%.  Ba i! one of #%e ri'%#e!# ri'%#e!# in !c%oo a and nd a$a! o#aine o#ained d eceen# rre"ar&!. e"ar&!. T%u! #%e #ria cour# i! coninced #%a# Ba co""i##ed #%e ac# $i#% di!cern"en#. *SS+,:  -%e#%er or no# Ba Ba co""i##ed #%e ac ac## $i#% di!cern"en di!cern"en#/ #/ R+L*NG:  ;e!. Ei!cern"en# Ei!cern"en# per#ain! #o "e "en#a n#a capaci# #o under!#and under!#and #%e differ difference ence  e#$een ri'%# and and $ron'. Suc% capaci# capaci# !%oud e d de#er"ined e#er"ined  #a&in #a&in' ' in#o con!idera#ion a #%e fac#! circu"!#ance! appearance appearance a##i#ude co"por#"en# and e%aior of #%e "inor.

Sponsor Documents

Or use your account on DocShare.tips

Hide

Forgot your password?

Or register your new account on DocShare.tips

Hide

Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link to create a new password.

Back to log-in

Close