How to Analyze Gear Failures

Published on November 2016 | Categories: Documents | Downloads: 43 | Comments: 0 | Views: 446
of 7
Download PDF   Embed   Report

How to Analyze Gear Failures

Comments

Content

How to analyze gear failures
By ROBERT L. ERRICHELLO and JANE MULLER of Geartech | Mar 1, !!! 1 "!! #M By fo$$o%&n' a (te)*+y*(te) )roced,re, en'&neer( can d&a'no(e 'ear fa&$,re( and de-e$o) (o$,t&on(. Here.( ho% to cond,ct a fa&$,re ana$y(&(, %hat to $oo/ for, and ho% to reco'n&0e co11on fa&$,re(

Article Tools
• • • • •

E1a&$ 2a-e #r&nt Re)r&nt

Popular Articles
• • • • • •

L,+r&cat&on t&)( for )$a(t&c 'ear( and 1ore Ba$$(cre%( -(. $ead (cre%( #er1anent*1a'net AC 1otor( Mot&on 2y(te1 3e(&'n * 4or )$ant en'&neer(, OEM en'&neer(, &nte'rator(, and (t,dent(. L&near 1ot&on En'&neer&n' +a(&c(

To o)t&1&0e the )erfor1ance of any ()eed red,cer, the 'ear( 1,(t +e or&ented to each other (o that they r,n (1ooth$y %&tho,t +&nd&n' or &nterference. They 1,(t a$(o 1a&nta&n the correct a1o,nt of tooth c$earance 5+ac/$a(h6 at a$$ o)erat&n' cond&t&on(. 4or (),r and he$&ca$ 'ear(, the +e(t or&entat&on nor1a$$y re7,&re( on$y that the center d&(tance and (haft a$&'n1ent +e correct 8 no f,rther ad9,(t1ent &( needed. Th&( &( (e$do1 the ca(e %&th +e-e$ 'ear(, %here 1o,nt&n' arran'e1ent( a$$o% for %&de -ar&at&on( &n )o(&t&on. A$$ ty)e( of +e-e$ 'ear( 8 (tra&'ht, :ero$, ()&ra$, and hy)o&d 8 ha-e an o)t&1,1 )o(&t&on for +e(t )erfor1ance. The 1an,fact,rer deter1&ne( th&( o)t&1,1 )o(&t&on +y r,nn&n' te(t( of &nd&-&d,a$ 'ear(et(. B,t, the 'ear+o; de(&'ner and a((e1+$y techn&c&an (hare the re()on(&+&$&ty for &ncor)orat&n' th&( o)t&1,1 )o(&t&on&n' &n the 'ear+o;. The de(&'ner 1,(t )ro-&de for ea(e of 1ea(,re1ent, (h&11&n', and a((e1+$y. And the techn&c&an 1,(t )ro)er$y a((e1+$e the 'ear( &n the 'ear+o;.

Key assembly parameters

2e-era$ )ara1eter( contr&+,te to )ro)er a((e1+$y (o that the 'ear+o; o)erate( (1ooth$y and eff&c&ent$y. The 1o(t &1)ortant are" < Mo,nt&n' d&(tance. < Matched teeth. < Bac/$a(h. Be-e$ 'ear( of AGMA 7,a$&ty = or +etter are nor1a$$y 1an,fact,red and te(ted &n (et(. Then, the 1an,fact,re 1ar/( the )referred -a$,e( for each of the three )ara1eter( on &nd&-&d,a$ 'ear(. 4re7,ent$y, the 1an,fact,rer a$(o 1ar/( a 'ear(et n,1+er on each of the t%o 'ear( &n a (et. Gear( 1an,fact,red &n (et( (ho,$d only +e a((e1+$ed %&th the&r 1ate(. 2&1&$ar$y, &f one 'ear &n a (et fa&$(, the ent&re (et (ho,$d +e re)$aced. Mounting distance. The d&(tance fro1 a $ocat&n' (,rface on the +ac/ of one 'ear to the center$&ne of a 1at&n' 'ear &( ca$$ed the 1o,nt&n' d&(tance, Figure 1.

Th&( &( the 1o(t &1)ortant )ara1eter for en(,r&n' )ro)er o)erat&on. The 1an,fact,rer e(ta+$&(he( the o)t&1,1 -a$,e for th&( d&(tance +y r,nn&n' the 'ear(et and ad9,(t&n' &t( )o(&t&on to o+ta&n a tooth contact )attern that &( con(&(tent %&th (1ooth r,nn&n' and o)t&1,1 $oad d&(tr&+,t&on +et%een 1at&n' 'ear teeth. Beca,(e of d&1en(&ona$ -ar&at&on( +et%een )art(, each 'ear &n a (et ha( a ,n&7,e -a$,e for the 1o,nt&n' d&(tance and, &n 1o(t ca(e(, the 1an,fact,rer )er1anent$y 1ar/( th&( -a$,e on each 'ear, Figure 2.

It &( )o((&+$e to 1an,fact,re a$$ 'ear( to the no1&na$ 1o,nt&n' d&(tance ()ec&f&ed on the dra%&n'. B,t, the add&t&ona$ co(t to do (o &( ,(,a$$y not %arranted. In ca(e( %here 1o,nt&n' d&(tance( ha-e not +een 1ar/ed on the 'ear(, a((e1+$y techn&c&an( 1,(t re(ort to a co(t$y tr&a$ and error 1ethod of 1ar/&n' teeth %&th 'ear co1)o,nd and ad9,(t&n' the 'ear( to o+ta&n a (,&ta+$e tooth contact )attern. The $ac/ of 1ar/ed -a$,e( 1ay a$(o &nd&cate that the 'ear(et %a( not 1an,fact,red for h&'h ca)ac&ty or con(&(tency. Matched teeth. After o)t&1,1 tooth contact &( o+ta&ned &n the r,nn&n' te(t(, the 1an,fact,rer 1ar/( 1at&n' teeth &n en'a'e1ent for &dent&f&cat&on. The(e 1ar/( ,(,a$$y con(&(t of ;.( or dot(, Figure 2, on t%o ad9acent teeth of one 'ear and the 1at&n' tooth of the other 'ear. >hen a((e1+$&n' the 'ear(et, )o(&t&on the (&n'$e 1ar/ed tooth &n the ()ace +et%een the t%o ad9acent 1ar/ed teeth. Backlash. The th&rd 1o(t &1)ortant )ara1eter for a +e-e$ 'ear(et &( the ()ace +et%een 1at&n' 'ear teeth, ca$$ed +ac/$a(h. Un$e(( other%&(e ()ec&f&ed, +ac/$a(h &( 1ea(,red nor1a$ 5)er)end&c,$ar6 to the tooth (,rface, Figure 3,

and not &n the )$ane of rotat&on. In 1o(t ca(e(, the 1an,fact,rer 1ar/( the nor1a$ +ac/$a(h -a$,e on the 'ear, Figure 2. Mea(,re1ent( &n the )$ane of rotat&on, ca$$ed tran(-er(e +ac/$a(h, are a( 1,ch a( ?!@ $ar'er, and (ho,$d not +e ,(ed for a((e1+$y ),r)o(e(. >here 1o,nt&n' d&(tance( ha-e +een 1ar/ed on one or +oth 'ear(, ad9,(t the(e d&(tance( f&r(t. Then, ,(e the nor1a$ +ac/$a(h -a$,e to -er&fy )ro)er a((e1+$y. The backlash value should not be measured until after assembling at least one of the two gears, preferably the pinion, at its marked mounting distance. The rea(on &( (&1)$e. Beca,(e +e-e$ 'ear( are con&ca$ &n (ha)e, they can +e a((e1+$ed &n an a$1o(t &nf&n&te n,1+er of )o(&t&on( 51o(t of %h&ch ca,(e )oor )erfor1ance6 and (t&$$ o+ta&n the re7,&red +ac/$a(h.

4re7,ent$y, a ca(,a$ ,(er a((e1+$e( +e-e$ 'ear( to o+ta&n a ()ec&f&c a1o,nt of +ac/$a(h %&tho,t re'ard to the 1o,nt&n' d&(tance. Th&( &( e()ec&a$$y tr,e for $o% 7,a$&ty or $&'ht$y* $oaded +e-e$ 'ear(. A$tho,'h th&( 1ethod occa(&ona$$y %or/(, &t &( a r&(/y a))roach %here 'ear( are $oaded to 1a;&1,1 ca)ac&ty. It ,(,a$$y ca,(e( (horter $&fe and )oor )erfor1ance. On$y at the )ro)er 1o,nt&n' d&(tance %&$$ a 'ear(et r,n correct$y and (t&$$ ha-e the r&'ht a1o,nt of +ac/$a(h.

ear assembly
In 1o(t +e-e$ 'ear(et(, )art&c,$ar$y tho(e %&th rat&o( a+o-e "1, the )&n&on )o(&t&on 51o,nt&n' d&(tance6 effect( tooth contact 5the 1o(t &1)ortant )ara1eter for 'ood )erfor1ance6 to a $ar'er e;tent than the 'ear )o(&t&on. Con-er(e$y, the 'ear )o(&t&on ha( a $ar'er effect on +ac/$a(h. 4or th&( rea(on, the 1an,fact,rer 1ay ha-e 1ar/ed the 1o,nt&n' d&(tance on$y on the )&n&on. In (,ch ca(e(, +e (,re to acc,rate$y )o(&t&on the )&n&on accord&n' to &t( 1ar/ed 1o,nt&n' d&(tance +efore ad9,(t&n' +ac/$a(h. Th&( can +e acco1)$&(hed e&ther +y 'a'&n' or +y d&rect 1ea(,re1ent. Ga'e( are ,(ed 1o(t$y for $ar'e 'ear )rod,ct&on r,n(, and are +a(ed on the d&rect 1ea(,re1ent 1ethod. 4or th&( rea(on, on$y the 1ea(,re1ent 1ethod &( de(cr&+ed here. Note that %hen 1at&n' 'ear( are ad9,(ted to the&r o)t&1,1 )o(&t&on, the&r +ac/ an'$e(, Figure 1, %&$$ )ro+a+$y not +e f$,(h %&th each other. Do not attempt to position bevel gears by making the back angles flush.

Measurement method. A ty)&ca$ 'ear+o;, Figure ,

conta&n( +oth an o-erh,n' and a (tradd$e*1o,nted 'ear. The )roced,re for a((e1+$&n' the +e-e$ 'ear( &n th&( 'ear+o; +y the 1ea(,re1ent 1ethod &( (&1)$e" < On the ho,(&n', 1ea(,re the d&(tance fro1 $ocat&n' (,rface to +ore center$&ne &n +oth hor&0onta$ and -ert&ca$ d&rect&on( 5HM3 and AM36. < Record the 'ear and )&n&on 1o,nt&n' d&(tance( 5M3G and M3#6. < Mea(,re the 'ear and )&n&on th&c/ne((e( 5>G and >#6. < A((e1+$e the 'ear( &nto the&r (,+a((e1+$&e(. < Mea(,re the $en'th that contro$( 'ear )o(&t&on &n each (,+a((e1+$y 5MAG and MA#6. < Ca$c,$ate the d&(tance fro1 (h&1 1o,nt&n' (,rface to cro((&n' )o&nt for each (,+a((e1+$y 5M3A and M3H6. < Ca$c,$ate the re7,&red (h&1 th&c/ne((e( and a((e1+$e the 'ear+o; %&th (h&1( &n )$ace. To a&d the a((e1+$y techn&c&an, 1ar/ the ho,(&n' 1ea(,re1ent( on the ho,(&n' after &t &( 1ach&ned and &n()ected. Mea(,re1ent( &n-o$-&n' the )&n&on and 'ear are ta/en on the (,+a((e1+$&e(, %h&ch con(&(t of 'ear, (haft, +ear&n', and 'ear 1o,nt&n' co1)onent(. Th&( 1&n&1&0e( any -ar&at&on( d,e to f&t( +et%een the(e co1)onent( and 'reat$y red,ce( the n,1+er of 1ea(,re1ent( re7,&red. In th&( e;a1)$e, on$y the 'ear th&c/ne(( &( 1ea(,red +efore ),tt&n' to'ether the (,+a((e1+$y. 2,+tract&n' th&( d&(tance fro1 the 1o,nt&n' d&(tance $et( the techn&c&an 1ea(,re fro1 the front of the a((e1+$ed 'ear. !erifying proper assembly. U(e the 1ea(,re1ent 1ethod to a((e1+$e +oth 'ear(, 1a/&n' (,re that the 1atched teeth are )ro)er$y en'a'ed. On$y after )o(&t&on&n' +oth 'ear( at the&r 1o,nt&n' d&(tance( (ho,$d yo, 1ea(,re +ac/$a(h to -er&fy )ro)er a((e1+$y. In ca(e( %here on$y the )&n&on &( 1ar/ed %&th a 1o,nt&n' d&(tance, )o(&t&on the )&n&on at &t( 1o,nt&n' d&(tance f&r(t, then ad9,(t the 'ear )o(&t&on for the re7,&red +ac/$a(h.

To o+ta&n f,rther -er&f&cat&on, yo, can )erfor1 an o)t&ona$ contact )attern chec/. Th&( &n-o$-e( )a&nt&n' the tooth (,rface( on one 'ear %&th a th&n 1ar/&n' co1)o,nd and rotat&n' the a((e1+$ed 'ear( ,nder $&'ht $oad. The co1)o,nd tran(fer( fro1 one 'ear to the other and (ho%( ho% the teeth contact. N,1ero,( ),+$&cat&on( conta&n chart( %&th ty)&ca$ contact )attern( 5AN2IBAGMA !!=*BC! and AN2IBAGMA !!D*B==6. The )attern( (e$do1 $oo/ e;act$y $&/e the ),+$&(hed e;a1)$e( and fre7,ent$y re7,&re (o1e &nter)retat&on. Techn&c&an( fa1&$&ar %&th contact )attern chec/&n' 1ay +e$&e-e that th&( techn&7,e &( the )referred 1ethod of a((e1+$y. Ho%e-er, the 1an,fact,rer ha( a$ready )erfor1ed th&( chec/ a( )art of the te(t&n' 5to deter1&ne 1o,nt&n' d&1en(&on(6 and &nter)reted the contact )attern( (o yo, don.t ha-e to. Robert F. Wasilewski is the design engineering manager for !rrow "ear #o., Downers "rove, $ll.

Sponsor Documents

Or use your account on DocShare.tips

Hide

Forgot your password?

Or register your new account on DocShare.tips

Hide

Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link to create a new password.

Back to log-in

Close