Infant and Child Development

Published on November 2016 | Categories: Documents | Downloads: 99 | Comments: 0 | Views: 703
of 4
Download PDF   Embed   Report

Infant and Child Development

Comments

Content

Infant and Child Development
Inf. Child. Dev. 20: 246–248 (2011)

Book Review
THE CHILD’S CONCEPTION OF THE WORLD: A 20TH-CENTURY CLASSIC OF CHILD PSYCHOLOGY, Second Edition. Edited by Jean Piaget, Forward by Jacques Voneche. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc, Lanham, MD, 2007. pp. 432. Price: £19.99, h31.48. ISBN 9780742559516 Reading this edition in light of the preface by Jacques Voneche, the Director of Piaget Archives, enables students of Piaget to gain important new insights into his early work as well as the man himself. The eloquent preface informs us of the intellectual climate of the 1920s when Piaget crafted his early work, describes the clinical method and its evolution, and provides a concise summary of the enormous amount of work reported in the book about children’s egocentrism expressed in terms of their realism, animism, and artificialism. According to Voneche, the intellectual climate of the 1920s was dominated by Gestalt Psychology, Behaviorism, and testing when Piaget began his work. Disturbed by the view that human functioning is one and the same as that of the environment in which it takes place (Gestalt) or that it is solely the result of environmental influences (Behaviorism), Piaget sought to describe it as emerging from the individual’s effort to adapt to the environment. This desire found its first form of expression in Piaget’s reaction to the task of standardizing the antecedent of the test that we know today as the ‘Stanford-Binet’. Piaget recognized that the consideration of children’s responses to test items only as right or wrong without a focus on how they reach their answers does not inform us about how children construct knowledge and adapt their thinking. Hence, Piaget set out to explore the structure and content of thinking. This book on the content of thought during
Copyright r 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

childhood emerged as part of this early effort. In rereading this volume in light of Voneche’s preface, we recognized that developmental psychologists had previously taken Piaget’s methods for granted, and devoted their attention to Piaget’s ideas about children’s thinking. A careful inquiry into Piaget’s methods led us to greater appreciation of Piaget’s arguments on both methodological and theoretical grounds. Regarding the former, in the first substantive chapter on the description of his clinical method, Piaget states the limitations of testing and direct observation arguing that testing does not allow the researcher to have access to spontaneous interests of the children in context and that direct observation can reveal misleading information since it does not allow differentiation of play from children’s beliefs. In contrast, his clinical method allows the researcher to find out children’s current functioning through open-ended questions. Regarding the latter, rereading Piaget on the clinical method revealed his emphasis on the role of communication and language in children’s development, for Piaget stated that guiding children through open-ended questions enables children to come to consciously recognize their thoughts that they were previously not aware of having. As noted by Becker (Becker, 2004; Becker & Varelas, 2001), these ideas of Piaget expressed in his early work indicate potential similarities between his and Vygotsky’s theories that deserve exploration in future work. Voneche’s commentary portrays Piaget as a researcher who strikes out on his own collecting and interpreting qualitative data. His work demonstrates that capturing children’s meanings requires delving into their world and learning to live with them while you maintain your

Book Review

247

own separate identity without loosing sight of your goal. Moreover, Piaget’s contributions go beyond introducing his clinical method to include childhood memories of his collaborators as well as data and ideas from other thinkers such as Freud, Hall, James, and Stern. Seen from our current cultural perspectives, then, this method of triangulation qualifies the Piaget of the 1920s as an ethnographer of thinking that was not perhaps initially noticed. As such, Piaget’s methods emerge as a resource to be used in graduate level courses on qualitative methodology. We agree with Voneche that this book offers an accessible, warm, and lyrical account of children’s thinking. In his investigation of realism, animism, and artificialism, Piaget talked to children about curious phenomena such as dreams, magic, words, the sun and the moon, thunder and lightening, and mountains. As people who are interested in young children’s language, communication, play, and education, we find comfort in the themes and descriptions of children’s thinking as such. Given the current trends in testing and neuroscience which put the content of children’s thought on the back burner, rereading Piaget is a welcome breath of fresh air. Piaget’s central tenet in this volume is to illustrate that children’s realism, animism, and artificialism are the results of children’s attribution of their thoughts, desires, and imaginations to the external world. The failure to draw a boundary between the self and the external world results in a fusion of the two. As such, realism emerges as children’s inability to distinguish internal from external and the sign from the signified. This is evident in his interviews with children on psychological phenomena such as thought, words, and dreams. According to Piaget, realism is transformed through stages moving from identifying the psychological and physical phenomena as one to understanding them as separate.
Copyright r 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Animism is defined as attributing living qualities such as intentions and personality to inanimate objects. As with realism, in his discussion of animism, Piaget addresses children’s attribution of consciousness to things and the notion of life in stages. Children move from initially attributing animism and consciousness to everything to thinking that only animals are conscious. Finally, Piaget addresses artificialism, which he defines as children’s explanations of the origins of things such as the sun, moon, meteorology, and mountains. This development follows a pattern whereby the initial thoughts of children that everything is made by and for humans is replaced with attributions of natural origin. For example, first, children think of clouds as made by human beings, then think of clouds existing in some relation to humans such as clouds being made of smoke coming out of people’s chimneys, and finally, thinking that clouds as condensed air. Piaget’s proposals about children’s egocentrism and its different manifestations and transformations continue to be relevant to our understanding of children today. A quick glance at the recent literature reveals that researchers continue to seek evidence in support of his ideas as he had called for as well as reanalyzing his own original data to offer alternative explanations of the work reported in his book (Pramling, 2006).

REFERENCES
Becker, J. (2004). Reconsidering the role of overcoming perturbations in cognitive development: Constructivism and consciousness. Human Development 47, 77–93. Becker, J., & Varelas, M. (2001). Piaget’s early theory of the role of language in intellectual development: A comment on DeVries’s account of Piaget’s social theory. Educational Researcher 30(6), 22–23.
Inf. Child. Dev. 20: 246–248 (2010) DOI: 10.1002/icd

248

Book Review

Pramling, N. (2006). ‘‘The clouds are alive because they fly in the air as if they were birds’’: A re-analysis of what children say and mean in clinical interviews in the work of Jean Piaget. European Journal of Psychology of Education XXI(4), 453–466.

Artin Goncu and Barbara Abel University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA
DOI: 10.1002/icd.719

Copyright r 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Inf. Child. Dev. 20: 246–248 (2010) DOI: 10.1002/icd

Copyright of Infant & Child Development is the property of John Wiley & Sons, Inc. and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.

Sponsor Documents

Or use your account on DocShare.tips

Hide

Forgot your password?

Or register your new account on DocShare.tips

Hide

Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link to create a new password.

Back to log-in

Close