Proton Therapy for Prostate Cancer
Content
+,+-./
"0'1'2 +3%0#45 ('0 "0'61#1% 7#28%0
9:+;<=/
>?@A13 B#C63D EFD E"; "0'(%66'0 '( E%@A8A2% FAGA6A'2 '( H%2%0#C ,21%02#C E%@A8A2% F%4#01I%21 '( E%@A8A2% :2AG%06A15 '( 7#CA('02A# J#2 K0#28A68'
":L-,J;.=/
7#CA('02A# +%832'C'$5 966%66I%21 K'0?I
F9+. <K ":L-,79+,<M/
<81'N%0 &OD *P&*
"-97. <K ":L-,79+,<M/
J#2 K0#28A68'D 79
"#$% & '( )*
"=<+<M L.9E +;.=9"Q K<= "=<J+9+. 79M7.= ! #$%&'()(*+ !,,$,,-$'.
,M+=<F:7+,<M
+3% 7#CA('02A# +%832'C'$5 966%66I%21 K'0?I A6 0%R?%61%@ 1' 0%GA%S 13% 68A%21A(A8 %GA@%28% ('0 13% ?6% '( 40'1'2 13%0#45 ('0 13% 10%#1I%21 '( C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0U +3A6 A6 13% (A061 1AI% 13#1 7+9K 3#6 #@@0%66%@ 13A6 1'4A8U
L97VH=<:MF
.4A@%IA'C'$5 '( "0'61#1% 7#28%0
"0'61#1% 8#28%0 A6 13% I'61 8'II'2C5 @A#$2'6%@ 8#28%0 A2 :UJU I%2 #2@ A6 6%8'2@ '2C5 1' C?2$ 8#28%0 #6 # 8#?6% 8#?6% '( 8#28%0 @%#13 A2 :UJU I%2U ,1 A6 %61AI#1%@ 13#1 A2 13% 5%#0 *P&*D 13%0% SACC N% *)&D&OP 2%S 8#6%6 A2 13% :UJU #2@ 13#1 *WD&OP I%2 SACC @A% (0'I 40'61#1% 8#28%0U&
+0%#1I%21 '41A'26 ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0 @%4%2@ '2 %X1%21 '( @A6%#6% #1 @A#$2'6A6U K'0 I%2 SA13 8CA2A8#CC5 C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0 Y8#28%0 8'2(A2%@ 1' 13% 40'61#1%ZD 10%#1I%21 '41A'26 ('8?6 '2 I'0% C'8#C #440'#83%6D S3%0%#6 6561%IA8 #440'#83%6D 6?83 #6 #2@0'$%2 @%40AG#1A'2 13%0#45D #0% ?6%@ A2 I%2 SA13 I'0% @A61#21 @A6%#6%U
K'0 I%2 S3' 3#G%
40'61#1% 8#28%0 13#1 %X1%2@6 N%5'2@ 13% 40'61#1A8 8#46?C%D A21' 13% 6%IA2#C G%6A8C%6 '0 13% "#$% * '( )*
#@\#8%21 2'@%6D 0#@A8#C 40'61#1%81'I5 A6 6'I%1AI%6 8'INA2%@ SA13 #@\?G#21 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45U
9 4#01A8?C#0 83#CC%2$% A2 13% 10%#1I%21 '( 40'61#1% 8#28%0 A6 13#1 N%8#?6% '( 13% 40'C'2$%@ 2#1?0#C 3A61'05 '( 40'61#1% 8#28%0D I#25 I%2 SACC @A% B,+; N?1 2'1 K=<E 40'61#1% 8#28%0D S3%0%#6 6'I% SACC @% @%G%C'4 G%C'4 I%1#61#1A8 #2@ 4' 4'1%21A#CC5 1%21A#CC5 (#1#C @A6%#6%U =A6] 610#1A(A8#1A'2 3%C46 A@%21A(5 S3A83 4#1A%216 #0% C'S G%06?6 3A$3 0A6] #2@ 8#2 N% 3%C4(?C A2 $?A@A2$ 13%0#45U =A6] 610#1A(A8#1A'2 ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0 A28C?@%6 13% ('CC'SA2$/ 8CA2A8#C 61#$% '( @A6%#6%D N#6%CA2% 6%0?I 40'61#1% 64%8A(A8 #21A$%2 Y"J9Z C%G%CD 13% HC%#6'2 68'0% #2@ 13% %X1%21 '( 40'61#1A8 A2G'CG%I%21U +3% HC%#6'2 68'0% A6 # $0#@A2$ 68#C% Y*^&PZ ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0 1A66?% #2@ A2@A8#1%6 13% CA]%CA3''@ 13#1 13% 8#28%0 1?I'0 SACC 640%#@U
;A$3%0
HC%#6'2 68'0%6 63'S $0%#1%0 @A((%0%28%6 N%1S%%2 13% 8#28%0 1A66?% #2@ 2'0I#C 40'61#1% 1A66?% #2@ A2@A8#1%6 $0%#1%0 CA]%CA3''@ '( 13% 8#28%0 1A66?% 1' I%1#61#6AT%U
_%05 C'S 0A6] 8CA2A8#CC5 C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0 A6 @%(A2%@ #6 @A6%#6% @%1%81%@ N5 NA'465 '2C5 Y2' #N2'0I#CA1A%6 @%1%81%@ '2 0%81#C %X#IA2#1A'2 '0 AI#$A2$ZD HC%#6'2 68'0% '( ` '0 C%66 '2 NA'465 #2@ # 6%0?I "J9 a&P2$bICU BA13A2 13% 40'61#1%D 13% %X1%21 '( @A6%#6% I?61 N% CAIA1%@ Y(%S%0 13#2 130%% 4'6A1AG% NA'465 8'0%6 SA13 C%66 13#2 cPd A2G'CG%I%21 A2 #25 8'0% #2@ # "J9 @%26A15 '( C%66 13#2 PU&c 2$bI-b$0#IUZ*
-'S 0A6]D 8CA2A8#CC5 C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0 A6 @A6%#6% CAIA1%@ 1' '2% C'N% '( 13% 40'61#1% '0 SA13 2' #44#0%21 1?I'0 Y@A#$2'6A6 N#6%@ '2C5 '2 NA'465D 6%0?I "J9 a &P 2$bIC #2@ # HC%#6'2 68'0% ≤ `UZ
E%2 SA13 C'S '0 G%05 C'S 0A6] 40'61#1% 8#28%0 #0% 154A8#CC5 '((%0%@ 10%#1I%21 '41A'26 13#1 A28C?@% #81AG% 6?0G%ACC#28%D 0#@A'13%0#45 #2@ 0#@A8#C 40'61#1%81'I5U "#$% [ '( )*
+0%#1I%21 '( -'8#CAT%@ "0'61#1% 7#28%0
J1#2@#0@ 10%#1I%21 '41A'26 ('0 I%2 @A#$2'6%@ SA13 C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0 A28C?@% 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45 Y%X1%02#C N%#I '0 N0#83513%0#45ZD 0#@A8#C 40'61#1%81'I5 #2@ ('0 6'I% 4#1A%216D #81AG% 6?0G%ACC#28%U
B3%2 @A6%#6% 3#6 640%#@ 130'?$3 13% 40'61#1A8 8#46?C%D
40'61#1%81'I5 I#5 N% 8'INA2%@ SA13 #@\?G#21 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45 '0 #2@0'$%2 @%40AG#1A'2 13%0#45 I#5 N% #@@%@ 1' 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45U
&U ='C% '( 40'61#1%81'I5 ('0 10%#1I%21 '( C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0
=#@A8#C 40'61#1%81'I5 A6 #2 %61#NCA63%@ 10%#1I%21 '41A'2 ('0 C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0U +3% %21A0% 40'61#1% A6 0%I'G%@U "0'61#1%81'I5 3#6 N%%2 #66'8A#1%@ SA13 3A$3 0#1%6 '( C'2$ 1%0I 8#28%0 8'210'CD N?1 A6 #C6' #66'8A#1%@ SA13 6A$2A(A8#21 8'I4CA8#1A'26 A28C?@A2$ A28'21A2%28% #2@ AI4'1%28%U
*U ='C% '( %X1%02#C N%#I 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45 ('0 C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0
+3% 'G%0#CC $'#C '( 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45 ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0 A6 1' @%CAG%0 # 13%0#4%?1A8 @'6% '( 0#@A#1A'2 1' 13% 1?I'0 S3AC% IA2AIATA2$ 0#@A#1A'2 '( 6?00'?2@A2$ 2'0I#C 1A66?%U .X1%02#C N%#I 0#@A'13%0#45 ?6%6 #2 %X1%02#C 0#@A#1A'2 6'?08% 1' 0#@A#1% 13% 40'61#1% #2@ # 6I#CC #I'?21 '( 6?00'?2@A2$ 1A66?%U ,21%26A15 I'@?C#1%@ 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45 A6 13% 61#2@#0@ 1%832AR?% N5 S3A83 0#@A#1A'2 A6 #@IA2A61%0%@ #2@ A6 #2 #@G#28%@ 154% '( 130%% @AI%26A'2#C 8'2('0I#C 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45 Y[F^7=+ZU +3A6 1%832AR?% 3#6 0%4C#8%@ 13% 40%GA'?6C5 ?6%@ 1S' @AI%26A'2#C #440'#83%6D S3A83 #0% 2'S 8'26A@%0%@ '?1@#1%@U +3% 0#@A#1A'2 N%#I G#0A%6 A2 A21%26A15 SA13 13% $'#C '( 1#0$%1A2$ # 8'I4C%X 1?I'0 I'0% %((%81AG%C5 #2@ IA2AIATA2$ 13% AI4#81 '2 6?00'?2@A2$ 1A66?%6U "#$% ) '( )*
,2 #@@A1A'2 1' 0%8'II%2@A2$ 13% ?6% '( [F 8'2('0I#C 1%832AR?%6D 13% M#1A'2#C 7'I40%3%26AG% 7#28%0 M%1S'0] YM77MZ H?A@%CA2%6 A2 <28'C'$5 0%8'II%2@6 13#1 # 8'2G%21A'2#C @'6% '( OP H5 A6 2'1 8'26A@%0%@ #@%R?#1% #2@ 0%8'II%2@6 @'6%6 N%1S%%2 OcU` #2@ Oe H5 ('0 A2@AGA@?#C6 SA13 C'S 0A6] 40'61#1% 8#28%0U K'0 4#1A%216 SA13 A21%0I%@A#1% '0 3A$3%0 0A6] @A6%#6%D 13%5 0%8'II%2@ 13#1 @'6%6 ?4 1' W& H5 #0% #440'40A#1%U*
[U ='C% '( N0#83513%0#45 ('0 13% 10%#1I%21 '( C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0U
L0#83513%0#45 A2G'CG%6 13% AI4C#21#1A'2 '( # 0#@A'#81AG% 6'?08% @A0%81C5 A21' 13% 40'61#1%U JA28% 13% 0#@A#1A'2 6'?08% A6 SA13A2 13% 1?I'0D 13% $'#C A6 1' I#XAIAT% 13% 0#@A#1A'2 1' 13% 1?I'0D S3AC% IA2AIATA2$ 13% %((%81 '2 6?00'?2@A2$ 2'0I#C 1A66?%6U +0%#1I%21 '41A'26 A28C?@% AI4C#21A2$ # 4%0I#2%21 0#@A#1A'2 6'?08%D ?6?#CC5 ?6A2$ A'@A2%^ &*c '0 4#CC#@A?I^&P[ '0 # 1%I4'0#05 0#@A#1A'2 6'?08% 6?83 #6 A0A@A?I ^&e*U
+%832'C'$A8 9@G#28%6 A2 "0'61#1% 7#28%0 +0%#1I%21
"0'61#1% 8#28%0 10%#1I%21 A6 #2 #0%# S3%0% 13%0% 3#G% N%%2 I#25 0%8%21 1%832'C'$A8 #@G#28%6U +3%6% #@G#28%6 A28C?@% IA2AI#CC5 A2G#6AG% 0#@A8#C 40'61#1%81'I5D A21%26A15 I'@?C#1%@ 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45 Y,E=+Z #2@ 40'1'2 13%0#45U 9@'41A'2 '( 13%6% 1%832'C'$A%6 0%6?C1%@ A2 # f[cP IACCA'2 A280%#6% A2 3%#C13 8#0% %X4%2@A1?0%6 A2 *PPcU [ +3% ,261A1?1% '( E%@A8A2% 3#6 0%8'II%2@%@ 13#1 13% 10%#1I%21 '( C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0 N% 8'26A@%0%@ '2% '( 13% (A061 R?#01AC% 40A'0A1A%6 ('0 8'I4#0#1AG% %((%81AG%2%66 0%6%#083U )
"#$% c '( )*
"0'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45
"0'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 A6 # 154% '( %X1%02#C N%#I 0#@A'13%0#45 ?6A2$ A'2ATA2$ 0#@A#1A'2U +3% 13%'0%1A8 #@G#21#$% '( ?6A2$ 40'1'26 ('0 0#@A'13%0#45 A6 13#1 N%8#?6% '( 13%A0 0%C#1AG%C5 C#0$% I#66D 13%0% A6 C%66 68#11%0 #2@ 13%0%('0% 13% 0#@A#1A'2 @'6% 8#2 N% I'0% 8'28%210#1%@ '2 13% 1?I'0U 96 83#0$%@ 4#01A8C%6 I'G% 130'?$3 13% 1A66?%D 13%5 6C'S @'S2 #2@ %2%0$5 A6 10#26(%00%@ 1' #@\#8%21 1A66?%6U E'61 '( 13% %2%0$5 $%16 @%4'6A1%@ #1 13% end of a “linear track.” known as the “Bragg Peak.” For protons, the dose of radiation
N%5'2@ 13% L0#$$ 4%#] @0'46 R?A8]C5 1' T%0' Y%XA1 @'6%Z 13%0%N5 CAIA1A2$ 13% AI4#81 '( 13% 0#@A#1A'2 '2 1A66?% N%5'2@ 13% L0#$$ 4%#]U +3?6D 1A66?% 13#1 A6 N%5'2@ '0 @A61#C 1' 13% 1?I'0 0%8%AG% IA2AI#C 0#@A#1A'2D S3%0%#6 1A66?%6 13#1 #0% 8C'6%0 1' 13% N'@5 6?0(#8% 13#2 13% 1?I'0 SACC 61ACC 0%8%AG% 6'I% 0#@A#1A'2U
+3% ?6% '( 40'1'2 N%#I6 '0 4#01A8C% 13%0#45 #6 #2 '28'C'$A8 10%#1I%21 S#6 A2A1A#CC5 40'4'6%@ A2 &e)` N5 F0U ='N%01 BAC6'2Uc F?0A2$ 13% &ecP6D 4#01A8C% 13%0#45 ?6% N%$#2 #1 13% -#S0%28% L%0]%C%5 -#N'0#1'05D 13% ;#0G#0@ 758C'10'2 #2@ A2 :446#C#D JS%@%2U `^W -'I# -A2@# :2AG%06A15 '4%2%@ 13% (A061 3'64A1#C N#6%@ (#8ACA15 #2@ 61#01%@ 10%#1A2$ 4#1A%216 A2 13% &eeP6Ue E#66#83?6%116 H%2%0#C ;'64A1#C #C6' 3#6 # 40'1'2 (#8ACA15U
"0'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 8#2 N% $AG%2 %A13%0 N5 A16%C( '0 #6 # N''61 1' X^0#5 %X1%02#C N%#I 0#@A'13%0#45U "0'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 N''61 8#2 N% 8'I4#0%@ SA13 %A %A13%0 13%0 2' N''61 '0 #2 X^ 0#5 N''61U "0'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 Y#C'2% '0 #6 # N''61Z 8#2 N% 8'I4#0%@ SA13 '13%0 40'61#1%
8#28%0
10%#1I%216
A28C?@A2$
N0#83513%0#45D
S#183(?C
S#A1A2$D
40'61#1%81'I5 '0 61#2@#0@ 0#@A'13%0#45U
"#$% ` '( )*
0#@A8#C
=#@A#1A'2 13%0#45 @'6% A6 154A8#CC5 I%#6?0%@ A2 H0#5 ?2A16 Y%$ 1'1#C @'6% S#6 OP H5ZU +3% 0%C#1AG% NA'C'$A8#C %((%81AG%2%66 Y=L.Z A6 13% 0#1A' '( 13% 43'1'2 @'6% 1' 13% 4#01A8C% @'6% 0%R?A0%@ 1' 40'@?8% 13% 6#I% NA'C'$A8#C %((%81U K'0 40'1'2 N%#I6D 13% 0%C#1AG% NA'C'$A8#C %((%81AG%2%66 A6 &U&U +' I%#6?0% 13% 1'1#C 0#@A#1A'2 @'6% SA13 40'1'2 N%#I6D H0#5 %R?AG#C%216 YH5.Z '0 8'N#C1 H0#5 %R?AG#C%216 Y7H.Z #0% '(1%2 ?6%@ SA13 40'1'26U +3% 7H. A6 13% H0#5 I?C1A4CA%@ N5 13% =L. (#81'0 64%8A(A8 ('0 13% N%#I ?6%@U
"0'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 3#6 N%%2 ?6%@ ('0 13% 10%#1I%21 '( I#25 8#28%06D A28C?@A2$ C?2$D 3%4#1'8%CC?C#0D 3%#@ #2@ 2%8]D 8%0GA8#CD 0%2#C 8%CCD N'2% #2@ 6'(1 1A66?% 6#08'I#6D I%C#2'I#D 83'0@'I# #2@ 83'2@0'6#08'I#6 '( 13% 6]?CC N#6%D 40'61#1% 8#28%0 #2@ 4%@A#10A8 I#CA$2#28A%6U K'0 6'I% '( 13%6% 8#28%06D 6?83 #6 C#0$% ?G%#C I%C#2'I#6 #2@ 6%C%81%@ 4%@A#10A8 I#CA$2#28A%6D 4#01A8C% 13%0#45 A6 8'26A@%0%@ 13% 61#2@#0@ '( 8#0%D N?1 ('0 '13%0 8#28%06D 13% ?6% '( 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 3#6 N%%2 I'0% 8' 8'210'G%06A#CU 210'G%06A#CU +3% ?6% '( 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 A6 A280%#6A2$ #6 I'0% 40'1'2 N%#I 10%#1I%21 8%21%06 #0% '4%2A2$D #2@ @A0%81 1' 8'26?I%0 #@G%01A6A2$ A6 CA]%C5 1' C%#@ 1' #2 A280%#6% A2 ?6%U&PD&& +3% $'#C '( 13A6 #66%66I%21 A6 1' %G#C?#1% 13% %GA@%28% ('0 13% ?6% '( 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 A2 13% 10%#1I%21 '( C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0U
"#$% O '( )*
+.7;M<-<HQ 9JJ.JJE.M+ Y+9Z
+9 70A1%0A'2 &/
+3% 1%832'C'$5 I?61 3#G% (A2#C #440'G#C (0'I 13% #440'40A#1% $'G%02I%21 0%$?C#1'05 N'@A%6U
"0'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 A6 # ('0I '( %X1%02#C 0#@A'13%0#45 ?6A2$ A'2ATA2$ A'2ATA2$ 0#@A#1A'2U ,1 A6 # 40'8%@?0% #2@ 13%0%('0% 2'1 ?2@%0 KF9 0%$?C#1A'26 #2@ 'G%06A$31U +3% %R?A4I%21 ?6%@ 1' 80%#1% #2@ @%CAG%0 13% 40'1'2 N%#I Y858C'10'2D 652830'10'2D I#$2%16D #2@ '13%0 4A%8%6 '( %R?A4I%21 1' I'@A(5 13% 0#2$% '( 40'1'26 #2@ 1' 63#4%b('8?6 13% N%#IZ A6 8'26A@%0%@ # I%@A8#C @%GA8% #2@ ?2@%0 KF9 0%$?C#1A'26 #2@ 'G%06A$31U
+9 70A1%0A'2 & A6 I%1U
+9 70A1%0A'2 */
+3% 68A%21A(A8 %GA@%28% I?61 4%0IA1 8'28C?6A'26 8'28%02A2$ 13% %((%81AG%2%66 '( 13% 1%832'C'$5 0%$#0@A2$ 3%#C13 '?18'I%6U
+3% E%@CA2% @#1#N#6%D 7'830#2% 8CA2A8#C 10A#C6 @#1#N#6%D 7'830#2% 0%GA%S6 @#1#N#6% #2@ 13% F#1#N#6% '( 9N610#816 '( =%GA%S6 '( .((%816 .((%816 YF9=.Z S%0% 6%#083%@ ?6A2$ 13% ]%5 S'0@6/ “40'61#1% 8#28%0 ” and “proton therapy” or “protons.” +3% 6%#083 S#6 4%0('0I%@ (0'I @#1#N#6% A28%41A'2 130'?$3 9?$?61D *P&*U +3% NANCA'$0#43A%6 '( 6561%I#1A8 0%GA%S6 #2@ ]%5 #01A8C%6 S%0% I#2?#CC5 6%#083%@ ('0 #@@A1A'2#C 0%(%0%28%6U
+3% #N610#816 '(
8A1#1A'26 S%0% 0%GA%S%@ ('0 0%C%G#28% #2@ #CC 4'1%21A#CC5 0%C%G#21 #01A8C%6 S%0% 0%GA%S%@ A2
"#$% W '( )*
(?CCU J1?@5 3#@ 1' %G#C?#1% 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 #6 # 10%#1I%21 ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0
J1?@5 3#@ 1' %G#C?#1% 8CA2A8#C '?18'I%6 ,28C?@%@ '2C5 3?I#26
"?NCA63%@ A2 .2$CA63 #6 # 4%%0 0%GA%S%@ #01A8C%
<?0 6%#083 0%G%#C%@ *cP 4'1%21A#CC5 0%C%G#21 #01A8C%6U B% 0%GA%S%@ #CC 13% 1A1C%6 #2@ A@%21A(A%@ ** 4'1%21A#CC5 0%C%G#21 #N610#816U
9N610#816 S%0% 0%GA%S%@ A2 (?CC #2@ S%
A@%21A(A%@ &[ 61?@A%6 #6 4'1%21A#CC5 0%C%G#21 ('0 A28C?6A'2U =%#6'26 ('0 %X8C?6A'2 A28C?@%@ 2'1 ('8?6A2$ '2 8CA2A8#CC5 0%C%G#21 '?18'I%6D '0 N%A2$ # @?4CA8#1% '( #2 %#0CA%0 4?NCA8#1A'2U
9 1'1#C '( &) 61?@A%6 %G#C?#1%@ 13% ?6% '( 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 ('0 13% 10%#1I%21 '( 40'61#1% 8#28%0 #2@ #66%66%@ 8CA2A8#C '?18'I%6U
J%G%2 '( 13%6% 61?@A%6 S%0% 2'2^
8'I4#0#1AG% 61?@A%6U&*^&W #2@ 6%G%2 S%0% 8'I4#0#1AG%&e^*` Y+#NC% [ZU
<( 13% 2'2^
8'I4#0#1AG% 61?@A%6D 1S' S%0% 0#2@'IAT%@&eD*&D** #2@ 13% 0%I#A2A2$ (AG% S%0% 2'1U*[^*cD*O
-%G%C '( .GA@%28%/ *D[Dc
+9 70A1%0A'2 * A6 I%1
"#$% e '( )*
H # 0 @ 2 % D0
M A 3 % DA * P & &
M A 3 % DA * P P c
* E P % & * 2 @ % 2 3 # C DC
* P P O
7 = # # " 1 # 2 3 % 2 ' % 0 0 I @ 1 # I # 3 0 C 6 ' ' 5 % 6 0 6 ' X % 6 4 = 1 % 0 0 6 ( 4 6 , ? A A G 2 8 7 % 0 1 A 1 G + A ? I A C G @ ' ' % 0 2 % 5 6 2 ' $ 1 # ( C
J ? N $ 0 ' ? 4
" A E 3 2 ? # 6 1 A C 6 1 A % ? 1 ^
" 3 # 6 %
8 = ' % 3 1 0 ' ' 0 6 / 1 4 % 8 1 A G %
8 = + ' % 5 3 1 0 4 ' ' 0 6 % 4 1 % 8 1 A G %
& * c c
[ e
& c &
[ P
* & &
* M W O
7 - 9 ' I # - A 2 @ # D
L ' 6 1 ' 2 D E 9
> # 4 # 2
> # 4 # 2
K C ' 0 A @ #
> - # ' 4 # 8 2 #
0 O O O O g 2 N O @ @ O A A Y A O W W W O = ) ' ` % ' W 6 2 U) + 1 ^ 7 W ^ % 8 H ' H 4 8 7 ] W C % 0 H 4 I ? 5 6 * H * 5 0 A 1 H @ 1 % G A @ # 5 C 6 . 7 % 7 . # 1 X ' g = # % 4 ? 6 % @ @ H ( H ( % A 0 + ' C 0 6 . ' A N ' 4 # 0 . 2 % # 1 3 1 4 ' ( ' C 2 3 ' ' % ' C ' 2 A @ $ ? S 0 1 0 6 ' 6 A 1 1 # 3 A 0 3 2 2 6 ] S % 4 2 0 A 1 0 @ 6 A % 6 N 4 A 0 ] ' 0 0 # ' # 1 ] 1 3 4 I @ ' ' ' 1 A $ S A 5 % 2 6 % 6 % 1 A 1 2 @ % 2 3 # 1 A 6 # 6 Z 1 % %
" , 0 2 ' 1 % 1 ' 0 2 G 1 3 % 2 % 1 0 A # ' 4 2 5 O ) H 5 .
O g c = H + 5 4 C 6 ? 4 0 ' 1 ' 2 N ' ' 6 1
" # $ % & P ' ( ) *
E J # 1 5 ? # @ 3 5 # 0 # D
* P P *
J C # 1 % D0 * P P )
Y - 6 ' 1 # 8 $ # % C A T 6 % , # @ ^ 4 , 0 , , ' Z 6 1 # 1 % 8 # 2 8 % 0
& # 6 + e 1 I ? [ W 0 ^ [ @ ) h ' 5 6 J ( # ? 3 = 2 0 A 7 @ G 4 A C + % G % ' X 5 Y 0 D F 4 6 & ? % ' e A ( O 1 1 0 e % I " Z 2 3 3 % 3 2 # # 1 6 G # % % C , , D0
( I C K % K A 0 0 A % G % G # 6 A @ A % C % ? 1 @ S C 0 % @ 0 A # 6 % 2 6 % 5 S / 8 ' I % A [ N 1 % 3 8 ' ( 0 ' ( ' 1 S 1 3 2 @ I % % 6 6 A % @ % % N 2 # 8 # ' A 1 ? 6 8 1 3 % 1 % A G 3 % ' % % 2 ( 0 I # ( 6 A A @ # 8 % A C # A ? 6 0 C 0 A # % 2 2 @ N " % J 1 3 $ A 2 9 %
- # 1 % 2 ' 0 I # C 1 A 6 6 ? % 6 % R ? % C # %
,
' A , 1 2 # C
+ & ^ * M P E P
+ & ^ [ M P E P
+ - H H ' # : , X 1 1 ' A % 1 8 ' X H A 1 X A 0 A 8 5 # A 1 # @ 8 A A % 1 % 1 A % 6 * * 6 5 ' % # 0 0 $ 6 0 % # 1 % 0 = % 8 1 # C
1 A ' 2
A 4 " O 4 8 + 2 , ? S 3 2 & A 1 ' 4 1 0 # ` ' 0 # A $ ^ 2 8 1 3 3 % ) C A H 0 1 5 1 8 ' % % M ? # 0 I 8 2 % ' A % ' 1 Z 2 0 ' 6 1 6 A 6 # C ] @ 1 % C 3 2 E ' A 6 ' 2 # 4 # ' % @ 6 0 1 S 2 0 1 ' 4 7 % A # # 1 0 0 0 * 6 0 1 4 3 4 % ' A 1 5 A # 6 4 5 # 6 ' 1 1 % ] C ' % 1 0 Y 1 % % F # S # 0 # @ 2 S # 8 % 1 % G 0 6 ' ( 0 # A A @ ' 2 @ 6 % A ] C 8 1 C 3 D ' % S 0 H H F : , 6 A 1 ' % 1 ' X # X 8 A 6 A A % 8 1 A 5 4 1 0 5 ' $ 0 % 6 6 A ' 2
9 9 < 8 8 ? ? ? 1 1 % 8 % 1 H H ' # % I 6 2 % 1 A 0 1 ' ' 6 A ? 2 0 1 A % 2 6 # 1 0 A 5 2 # I C E ' 0 ' N 0 A N @ A A 1 @ A 5 1 5
+ # N C % & / M ' 2 ^ 8 ' I 4 # 0 # 1 A G % 6 1 ? @ A % 6 ' ( 1 3 % ? 6 % ' ( " 0 ' 1 ' 2 L % # I + 3 % 0 # 4 5 ( ' 0 1 3 % + 0 % # 1 I % 2 1 ' ( ( " 0 ' 6 1 # 1 % 7 # 2 8 % 0
" # $ % & & ' ( ) *
" g H H ' + 7 H J = : / ( i H 9 + / , 1 M . 5 . H $ i / / H / / E , # H " g % 6 D 7 ^ 2 1 # i 0 0 0 / ' # ' 2 A 0 N # 5 ' 6 5 1 @ 9 ? A 1 # 1 A . 0 2 E 6 # C R 1 2 1 3 1 % % # % # 1 H ? 6 j $ 0 A J 0 5 0 1 G 4 # A # 2 A # # 2 % 4 N $ 5 % C # 5 8 . 2 C 6 A % 6 R 1 ( A AG 6 8 A 6 5 ? 8 2 1 9 % % # 2 I % C ' 1 A 0 ( 2 $ 4 ' 1 % 0 0 6 2 % 6 4 0 % ' 2 6 8 1 % # ' 1 % ( 8 - # $ 2 . 2 8 % , 0 . 2 U , + $ j , I % # 6 ? 0 % 6 1 3 % X 1 % 2 1 ' ( 1 3 % 4 0 A I # 0 5 . / ( D0 M j S 3 % 1 3 % 0 1 3 % 8 # 2 8 % 0 3 # 6 6 4 0 % # @ 1 ' 2 % # 0 N 5 C 5 I 4 3
* > J P ' 3 1 ? & * # @ 2 5 2 6 ' 2 D 8 = + ' % 5 3 1 0 4 ' ' 0 6 % 4 1 % 8 1 A G %
* M O W J S % @ % 2
- ' 8 # 1 A ' 2
, H g 2 5 = 1 + % 4 0 G 6 ? C % 2 4 1 0 A ' ' 1 2 ' 2 N ' ' 6 1 O P 8 # 2 8 % 0
, 2 8 C ? 6 A ' 2 7 0 A 1 % 0 A 3 # # 1 A % $ 0 - A ' 6 ] S C D ' 8 I # % C A @ T A % ? @ I 4 # 0 2 ' 6 @ 3
H c < , 5 ? # % 1 2 # 8 @ 0 ' " I H J : 9 % 1 ' 4 6 0 X ' A $ 8 A 0 1 A % % 6 6 6 A ' 2 ( 0 % % 6 ? 0 G G A # C
* H * > J C P # P ' # 3 P " = 7 H H & 0 1 % * @ J 7 U, : / , * # 2 0 2 9 + U / D 6 % / / 7 / H * 6 0 H ' P # D " = ' % 6 2 P 0 # 2 2 1 D ' ) 2 0 ( A ' 6 @ @ A 1 1 A # ' % ' 2 ? 1 1 A J 8 = 8 = ' % , % I 2 0 , 6 % ? 2 ? ' % ' % ( X 6 A 8 2 6 0 4 J A 3 1 3 1 T C N = % 1 1 ' ' 0 ' 0 7 ? G 4 % % # ' ' A 2 $ 2 0 A G @ % @ , 2 5 # 0 6 0 6 + 0 A $ 0 ? ' 0 0 4 1 4 5 1 I 8 A % 1 C 7 ( % % % # 6 1 A ' 0 % ' 8 8 8 G 2 2 ' 0 4 2 # 1 1 @ ( I # 1 9 1 A A G G # 0 C 2 2 ' " # % % C 1 3 C # A C C $ % # 5 0 I 6 % @ 6 A % 2 + 6 0 A # * [ C D& O e * W c c
" # $ % & * ' ( ) *
c O I ' 2 1 3 6
` [ I ' 2 1 3 6
O ) 5 c d % ( # ' 0 0 " C J ' 9 S D 4 0 A 2 ' $ 1 % 0 0 % I 6 6 % A @ ' A 2 # 1 ( % % 0 # % 2 @ 6 ? 3 0 A G A $ G 3 # / 0 C A 6 & ] P P d
< G G % 0 # C C N A ' 8 3 % I A 8 # C @ A 6 % # 6 % ( 0 % % 6 ? 0 G A G # C O
D e c d # 2 @
[ d
S L C % # 0 @ % @ @ % ' 0 6 1 % ' X C A A I 8 A 1 A A 1 % A 6 2 $ Y 2 ' 1 H , Z
& [ U& 5 % # 0 6
M A 3 % DA * P & &
M A 3 % DA * P P c
* E P % & * 2 @ % 2 # C DC
* P P O
E # 5 # 3 # 0 # D
J 1 ? @ 5
" E 3 # ? C 6 1 % A ^ , 2 , 6 1 A 1 ? 1 A ' 2 # C
" 3 # 6 %
8 = ' % 3 1 0 ' ' 0 6 1 4 % 8 1 A G %
8 = ' % 3 1 0 ' ' 0 6 4 1 % 8 1 A G %
+ 5 4 %
& c &
[ P
* & &
* W O
M
) [ U) I ' 2 1 3 6
[ P I ' 2 1 3 6
0 5 E % % A 4 # ' 6 0 2 A I 0 1 % I ? @ % I # 2 * 2 ' 1
,
& Y % H 9 4 5 % H * 1 U& b D ` ' M P 0 5 0 H 0 e W U c ' X 1 ) b c e # # # # # A 1 # H d d P * 0 @ @ d 8 0 @ 6 S 1 6 3 2 A ' A 0 H A 1 / % / % % 7 # H 0 A & * ) * * U 5 5 % 1 2 $ @ [ % # , 0 O * % 1 # 3 0 d ' d ' ' U P d # 6 % @ @ % 0 I 0 0 0 U [ 3 0 6 % A $ $ $ e Y 6 % # ' ^ e D @ 0 0 % 0 O [ [ ] @ c A % % 0 H A 2 N 4 # # # # U [ d 8 $ H : # 1 1 1 A 0 , % A ' @ % % 1 % d 7 1 % 1 A 0 0 0 0 Z U % 8 # ' 6 % A , 2 3 1 X 5 H 3 H 2 6 I U % 8 ] A % : 1 , P 8 % 6 4 0 I I % I ^ A 1 S 4 ) ' A # 1 A ' # # I % ' 8 8 U A 1 [ 1 ( # ? 6 I 1 0 A ? ' 3 d N 0 C C 6 @ % # 0 1 0 N 2 % A A Z @ 1 # @ A A 1 6 # % % A C ' 6 1 # 1 # 2 A 0 % 5 H S 1 5 4 C @ # 0 6 # # A c # 1 6 # % 1 1 N @ % 3 % 5 1 c C % # % & 4 @ 1 @ # c 5 ' A 0 6 * ' % 0 @ X % 6 5 # $ # A ' % / % 8 0 0 0 0 6 A * # 6 1 % % 4 / & ' 1 d & 6 $ 0 0 0 6 6 % A / [ X X % A h c 0 ' ' A # d 8 2 $ A 1 # e h 1 % d 1 5 0 0 # % & ) / c 1 6 U& % 0 6 & A d 8 c ' 2 1 # C K A 4 - % 2 # ' S ' 1 2 A $ 3 % 6 1 2 1 % % 1 0 0 6 % A ' 6 # 0 I ? 1 C ? 0 6 @ ( % ' % A # C ( % @ ' ( 6 5 C % S 8 A 2 ? 1 6 8 4 C ? @ ' % ( @
K % # 6 A N A C A 1 5 6 1 ? @ 5
e [ ' M d $ # # 0 2 @ @ % & * d 3 ' # 0 3 @ A H $ 3 0 % # @ 0 % H * , I # ' 2 0 @ N A H @ 0 1 A # @ 5 % [ H :
( F ' ? C C 0 ' S # 1 A ^ ' ? 2 4 ' ( E # A 2 < ? 1 8 ' I % 6
I ' 0 N A @ A 1 A % 6
. # 6 W C 5 O # 4 0 3 I d C 5 # 4 ' ' N 1 ( ? C ' 4 ' I # 1 8 8 ' ] 6 1 A I % 3 % # 2 % 0 @ 1 6 1 3 0 6 S % % 0 A C 1 A # % 4 ( 3 5 S H A : 1 3
7 ' I I % 2 1 6
+ # N C % * / < ? 1 8 ' I % 6 ' ( 2 ' 2 ^ 8 ' I 4 # 0 # 1 A G % 6 1 ? @ A % 6 ' ( 1 3 % ? 6 % ' ( 4 0 ' 1 ' 2 N % # I 1 3 % 0 # 4 5 ( ' 0 1 3 % 1 0 % # 1 I % 2 1 ' ( 4 0 ' 6 1 # 1 % 8 # 2 8 % 0
H # C N 0 # A 1 3 D * P P &
& F e ? W 1 [ 1 % 2 3 # G % D0
J ?
8 " 8 I 6 ' 3 ' # 8 ' I I 8 1 % 6 4 4 # % 3 0 # , # % 0 0 A @ A b , 6 6 ' , ' 2 2
0 G % 5
" # $ % & [ ' ( ) *
J M 3 % ' 2 % 0 1 # 6 D 2 * @ P ' & * I A T % @ J 4 % 0 N " 1 ? ' 0 # ' $ @ 6 A % 4 6 4 ? 6 % A % 1 C 0 @ # 2 5 1 6 ^ A ' A 1 5 2
& W c
& W P
& D [ ` W
- ' I # - A 2 @ # D
L ' 6 1 ' 2 D E 9
0 N 4 : % # ' J U $ 6 U A % 4 6 ? & @ C ` 1 0 # A 8 % 1 A 6 # 2 ' 8 2 % 0
8 E # 2 % 8 2 % S 0 A S 1 3 3 ' 4 0 3 ' # 6 @ 1 # 1 %
8 - ' # 2 8 8 # % C A 0 T % Y + @ & 4 ^ ) 0 Z ' 6 1 # 1 %
4 2 " ' 0 ' 1 # A 6 2 I % 1 # % 2 1 1 % 1 # 6 8 6 S # 1 A # 1 2 1 3 8 8 A % 0
& 4 4 g 6 Z ? C = 0 ? S ' 0 $ # 6 + 1 % 1 ' g c 0 8 2 = P 5 3 N + H D ( [ ? ' c 5 Z C ' P G 8 S 6 H % ' # 1 5 0 6 2 A 4 ? G 1 C 6 2 % A ? 2 $ 6 4 1 0 O ' A D* ' ) 1 2 Z '
, E = + G % 0 6 ? 6 4 0 ' 1 ' 2 1 3 % 0 0 # 4 5
# C
7 6 2 H .
E n % ? @ # A C A 8 5 # 1 C ' < ( ? - A 1 ( 8 ' % I , 2 % @ % 6 6 X 1 ? @ 5 H % 2 % 0 #
C J ' 8 ? # 0 C G A G 0 # % 8 DC ? @ 0 A 0 6 % 2 % # 8 6 % % ( 0 ( 0 % % % % 6 6 ? ? 0 G 0 G A G A G # # C C # 2 @
C
# % = 2 % 0 # @ 8 1 % # 1 6 A C ' @ % @ @ ( A 1 5 H A 6 ' , ( # 2 ? # 2 2 C @ 8 8 # 1 A ? ' 0 2 A 8 2 2 % D # 0 3 0 A 5 1 3 4 I % ( 0 ' 0 # # 0 4 8 N 5 1 ? @ A 0 A % 1 6 5 D
J * * * P " = 3 P P P e = # & D < 2 & P P A 4 P c h k l H @ C m h % A b ' + l % 5 A 1 9 I D # % & A C 1 I 7 T 8 e ' I # = % e 1 # 2 e @ c 1 D 2 D c D ^ " 3
= 7
# 6 % , , ,
+
* P *
[ e [
L L 1 E 7 : - ' ' 6 # 9 2 ' 6 6 H 6 A I G 1 6 # ' % ' 1 % # 2 2 # 0 - 2 2 8 @ 6 D E % A 3 A 2 0 1 E # ? 5 @ C 9 D 6 D % 9 # 1 a 8 + J & # 2 N * # 1 c $ 2 8 % 4 % $ 0 0 + ' b & I # 6 N 2 1 C @ # 1 3 % 0 " 1 J ' 9 ? $ 3
* J DE # 1 $ ' % + [ ^ + ) D M X P ^
' @ 8 P 1 & H Y 8 . ' 4 X ( ' ' 3 ' 1 5 8 ' I % ` 6 2 ^ ' # * 2 Y % ( O 0 c 3 G 1 1 N 2 U* ' ' A % ' ' 0 A # 2 2 I E $ 1 2 ( 3 1 # # # C H 7 _ 0 A C 2 1 5 H # ' A # C 4 @ @ @ ' ' @ 2 4 ' . 2 3 A 0 ' 6 # % # ' ' C 6 % 4 1 0 ' Z @ 1 A 0 1 ( ' ' ' U ' ' g ' 2 2 2 ( 1 ' 8 6 ' = 6 % O 2 2 S + 1 6 Z P N ( S A ' 1 ' U* % ' 1 A ' 1 0 3 0 @ 1 ' 3 ' 1 # 6 C % < 0 - ( 0 6 % ? G ' % N 8 0 % G % A # ' A 0 C 6 4 8 ? G # C 6 ' 0 # C C 6 5 2 G Y A ? F G 2 1 0 # J 0 % ' C J G $ C Y A G # Y + Z # # 1 @ = C A 2 G A K < @ Y % $ J A Z 1 J # Z 1 ' Z C D 1 0 # @ % C A 8 0 6 % 1 % # # 8 C ? 6 # % 0 2 0 6 % @ 2 4 8 % A % ( ^ 8 A 8
H # O 5 I # I # e U* 6 C < G % 0 # C C 6 ? 0 G A G # C
H - , ' # 8 2 # C @ K H # A C : ? 0 I % ' 0 N A @ A 1 5
C L % A G ' % 8 C 3 c % 5 I % A # 8 0 # 6 C K # # ( A 1 C % ? 0 0 1 0 % % Y , # 2 1 I 8 0 % % # 2 6 1 2 A Z $ " J 9
J + 1 ? # @ N C 5 % [ / F % 6 8 0 A + 4 1 5 A 2 4 % ' ' ( 7 ' I 4 M # 0 # 1 A G % J 1 - ? ' @ A 8 % # 6 1 A ' ' 2 ( 1 3 % 7 , : 0 % 2 6 A 8 1 C ' % ? 0 A 6 A ( # " ' 0 2 ' 1 ' 2 L % # , I 2 1 % + 3 0 G % % 0 2 # 4 1 A 5 ' 2 ( ' 0 1 3 % + 0 % # 1 I % < 2 ? 1 1 8 ' ' ( I " 0 % ' 6 6 1 # 1 % 7 # 2 8 % 0
" # $ % & ) ' ( ) *
H H " H ' + = " ( i 7 = , J : / 9 5 / 1 M + < / H / $ i / H # " H D , E = H b 0 # i % 6 0 # # 9 2 1 / ' 5 2 2 7 0 6 A ' @ 9 @ = 1 1 ' A # ' 2 E ? 1 1 6 I / 1 0 " % % A j # 2 6 J 0 A $ T ' 1 # A 4 # A 2 % 1 0 2 % N $ @ ' 5 # 8 2 6 C A % 6 7 ( ' = # 8 A 8 2 1 5 6 2 @ 9 % % 1 0 A 2 ' I # ' 1 C A 0 ( C 1 A % $ 4 ' @ ' % 2 0 0 2 % 4 + < 6 0 0 % ' # A 2 2 C 8 ' 8 6 % 1 # C ' 1 ' % $ ( 8 5 - # H 2 $ 0 ' . 2 8 % ? , 0 4 . 2 U Y + , " $ j = , I < % H # Z 6 b ? 9 0 I % 6 % 0 1 A 3 8 # 2 % X 7 1 ' % 2 C C % 1 $ ' % ( 1 ' 3 ( % = 4 # 0 @ A I A ' # C ' 0 $ 5 5 . / Y 9 7 ( = D0 Z M e c j ^ P S e 3 Y % # 1 0 3 # % 2 @ 0 1 ' 3 I % 8 A T # % 2 @ 8 % 1 0 0 A # 3 C # Z 6 6 4 0 % # @ 1 ' 2 % # 0 N 5 C 5 I 4 3
> # N N # 0 DA * P & P
7 ' % 2 D * P & *
J 1 ? @ 5
1 0 4 S 8 8 % 0 + 0 % ' S ? 1 A 6 A ' # I 3 1 ? CC N C 1 C 0 ' A 3 4 ' 6 0 ' 6 6 # 6 4 1 3 0 ' % % % 8 ( @ @ 1 # A G %
# I 7 2 # # 5 # C 8 1 % 6 6 3 ^ A % 6 @
+ 5 4 %
7 & 7 Y e & * P 7 " ' Y * ) e = = ( & = * ) W ) " c D e 1 e < 1 + 3 & * L 0 Z 7 Y 4 Y H A c % = " # ^ b # + F C " Z 9 0 Z , 1 ^ Z
M
; 1 E # - E : : 2 ' A 2 7 ' 6 # @ I 8 G A J 6 H 6 3 % 4 % 6 # A 0 DK A 2 # $ 1 - # 6 # % 8 A A 0 3 C # 2 2 1 ? @ D 5 C 6 ' # % ( 1 8 # 2 8 % 0
- ' 8 # C A T % @ 4 0 ' 6 1 # 1 %
' % 7 S " * " ) ( 2 = 1 0 + A 7 ' 3 , e " C 8 & # C ' * 1 4 L % # = @ 3 ) : 1 A + A ' 4 7 % 2 0 # J 2 1 K 1 # # 1 A S 6 4 2 % 2 % S ? @ 1 3 0 ' N & 6 % C e ( 8 0 A 0 6 3 c ' ' % % 4 I I 8 % @ # # % 4 1 1 A # A G % 0 0 @ A 2 [ % # F 1 C 6 ^ @ 2 % L A # G ' A 8 @ @ A % 3 0 2 % 8 I % A ' 8 ( # C @ 8 A ' 6 % 2 # 1 0 6 ' % C Y Y N N A M ' . 8 F 3 Z % # I 2 A @ 8 # 2 " C J 9 '
- ' 8 # 1 A ' 2
# - 2 ' @ I L # ' 6 - A 2 1 ' @ 2 # 1 0 % 0 8 % # % 1 A I G % % @ 2 G 1 6 # 0 A ' ? 6
7 , 0 2 A 8 1 C % ? 0 6 A ' A # 2
0 S " 4 & 0 4 % 8 # 0 O % % ) # X ' @ P X 0 & 0 1 A = ' @ 8 1 ' 1 I < % % 3 A 1 A H % 4 # # 0 0 N 1 ' # ' 2 A & H 1 5 G 2 1 A ' A 2 # 2 A Z % ) b 2 1 ' # D A 2 N C # 2 ) C @ & 9 b % 7 g 2 Y % N 1 Z N = 1 N 4 A Y = # % ' % O 4 # 0 1 e + 6 O # # # I 2 ) ) 0 I A c # A ' I 8 % ^ ^ 2 ' O 1 3 2 ^ 0 O ' 0 ( c ' 0 P I 3 c 5 1 0 # 6 e A # 1 8 H $ 3 S I @ ' H 2 ' ^ @ 5 5 N % 3 I ( 3 Z A A 2 A # G Z # 0 X 1 D % 1 # @ D % # ' 1 # c A % A 4 ' @ ' 8 I ' % 6 2 5 N # 3 2 2 1 % A Z Y ' % @ ` # 2 2 c I @ # ^ C E + J ; L 0 ' % A ' % % ? # 8 # # 1 C 3 6 1 1 3 ? I 3 % S 0 I J % % % 2 6 ? A 8 Y 0 " 1 # ^ 1 G < % 6 + C J 4 2 5 K J % 8 # 8 ' Z A C A C ? ( A ' 0 8 % 6 $ 5 5 I H 0 4 ' 1 ' ? I 4 6 " 0 ' 6 # 1 1 %
, 2 1 % 0 G % 2 1 A ' 2
8 # 2 8 % 0
- ' 8 # C A T % @ " 0 ' 6 1 # 1 %
< ? 1 8 ' I % 6
N : 7 [ " g E
M 7 " F " = _ , + / ^ / . J L 7 / F K = " g E + = % / / / + ^ % L : / 0 0 I # $ A 2 7 ' + A ' 3 # 5 # G 8 % G 2 2 + ' 3 0 ( 0 % 3 C % 6 ' % % 2 % 1 I 1 A 0 1 0 6 I A 5 # F " # 8 ' A 0 4 # C I ' 5 C ( 4 % 6 M 7 ' # 2 # 1 ' 0 6 C A 1 A 1 % ' ' ( . ' G 0 2 2 , A @ 2 N # I A % C 4 % # 7 C 2 D # 8 J I ' # % # 2 2 0 ' ( 1 ' 2 # L ( K @ 0 0 # F 0 A I 8 ' # 3 A # 6 2 % 8 1 3 C 5 # 6 A % = 1 # 3 6 8 0 % ' # @ % 4 ' A 0 5 1 # 4 3 5 % 0 # 4 5
" # $ % & c ' ( ) *
" # $ % & ` ' ( ) *
H # C N 0 # A 1 3 D * P P &
F ? 1 1 % 2 3 # G % D0 & e W [
` W
` O UO
& W I ' 2 1 3 6
M ' 1 0 % 4 ' 0 1 % @
I " 0 # ' 1 4 8 % 3 % 2 @ 6 A 1 5
C 0 M A M % ( ' ' % ' ? 8 @ 0 G 0 ( A % % % 2 ( 0 # 8 % 0 C % 2 C @ ( 8 A 0 % ( ( % % 6 % 0 6 A 2 % 2 ? 6 0 8 G ? % A G 0 G 6 # A G A C # 2 3 DC % @ # A 6 C % 1 3 # 6 6 % 1 # ( 1 0 ? % 6 % ' 6 0 ? 3 0 G % A G # 1 C # C 3 # 0 2 % @ C # C 1 ' % 8 @ # C R ? # C A 1 5 ' (
M & H ' P , @ P 4 I A % ' ( 0 ( 0 N % 0 6 A ' @ % 2 2 1 A 8 5 5 % % / 6 # & 0 U* A 2 6 * ( 4 ' ' 1 3 0 % % 4 0 0 & 0 ' I 1 P P ' ' 2 4 0 N / % 0 A = 6 @ ' = A 1 A P 2 % 5 6 U ` % ` # 0 Y e 6 ( c ' d 0 , 7 E = U,, P + U c G c % 0 ^ 6 P ? UO 6 e Z & O U W 4 % 0
0 " J # 2 # ? A 0 @ 1 G ' % 2 % I 1 5 6 A T 2 % ' @ 1
6 M 1 ? ' @ 2 5 # 0 2 @ ' I A T % @ % # 0 C 5
J M 3 % ' 2 % 0 1 # 6 D 2 * @ P ' & * I A T % @ J 1 ? @ M % A I 4 0 0 ' # 6 ' 1 4 1 8 3 % 8 % 2 # C 8 @ 6 A ? 1 C 5 # 1 % @ ^
I 4 # " G ' 0 C # # # 8 1 A 1 8 % # C 3 6 N ' A 6 C 2 2 $ ' % 1 3 A % 4 2 0 0 ( # ' 4 4 % % S 5 ' 2 2 6 A C 1 5 5
J 3 A 4 C % 5 D & e e c
+ l l " = # % % = # C A A < 2 8 1 I H @ ' I 1 1 # # b ' 1 D 2 2 9 I * D D A T P * * 7 = % & P P P & e @ m P c P c ^ h h P e h
' 8 # O 2 P 2 @ A G ` 2 % W 4 2 U 0 1 A ` ' ' ' 2 1 2 A 2 # C # # 0 0 I I
3 $ 8 ` O A 0 0 ' $ ' 2 A 3 ? G 2 @ 4 % ' # 2 6 2 1 A % @ ' 2 $ ` # 0 ` C ' ? 2 A 4
` & I ' 2 1 3 6
W U e 5 % # 0 6
G : 4 = 4 @ , M H H M @ & G " % 0 j % a A 2 ' , : ' ' P % 0 6 0 % 1 % ( 0 @ ' ' 0 4 5 6 1 1 @ 6 1 % % ? ? U U 8 3 P # P 0 8 ' A % # P % ' # ( A X 6 0 P 6 Y C ( X & P A 0 ( 8 A % ( 4 0 W 1 2 6 W # % % * N Z 1 8 A C a A L P ' C 0 1 0 d 6 Z % A A % A % 5 # K 1 P U 2 2 2 5 2 U % Z 1 1 0 ≥ P 0 ) % C 8 @ A ≥ 8 P # d ( 8 [ ' @ 0 A % / [ % P 1 % 1 2 8 6 % ( % ? / 1 $ # A ' & 6 0 ? C A d 2 Z / 0 & % * ( 3 I 8 2 0 [ 3 ' ' d A 2 ' < $ * ' G A A ' I 2 $ 2 % U 3 0 1 J A 0 ) 3 2 6 % D 3 2 # L d 0 6 0 Y F $ A % C A c ' K $ @ C A C # 6 ( ' # 2 3 8 ' 2 5 ' J J 6 ? % 3 A 0 4 1 2 D @ % ( 0 # 5 A 0 8 Y c ' # G 8 ' 0 C + ' 4 5 A = # 6 0 G 1 C A 2 a % 2 2 K % I # ' ' J # C G P # 1 2 8 C 4 % 5 # # # ' 0 0 2 U P 6 $ 1 C 1 0 I 3 P / 1 0 8 % A A A ' C & ` ' Z $ ' % ' A 1 ? 2 3 2 2 8 3 U& 4 ) 1 # % # 1 % 6 0 d C C 0 0 ' S 8 Y @ [ A 1 C A ' 2 ( A * ' 0 1 I ' d # 3 2 6 4 0 ' 0 G G % 1 4 8 ' 1 0 % % # 4 ' / ' C % 1 2 ' ' 2 0 e ' @ 6 A 2 G 0 ) 2 ? C % & d 5 1 $ 6 2 ` 0 G 1 & U ' O A * ' % ? d d 2 0 4 6 # / ( ? ' C Y & 6 @ 0 e ` ' 3 d ) 6 A $ % d 3 /
4 $ X @ E ^ ' 0 0 0 ' # ' # 6 A ? 1 % 2 ' 4 5 6 C 5 2 6 1 3 ' 8 1 0 % ( ' 3 % 0 % 8 # I 0 % # A 4 4 5 G U 4 % # 5 0 % U @ L @ ' 1 1 3 ' S
J + 1 # ? N @ C % 5 ) / < ? 1 8 ' I % 6 E ' % ( # 2 7 ' 9 I $ % 4 # 0 # 1 A G % K F 9 ' ? G J 1 C 0 % C ? ' # # 0 @ S 1 A A % ^ ' $ : 2 % 6 4 ' ' ( ( " 0 ' 1 ' = 2 % 6 ? C 1 6
7 ' I I % 2 1 6
L % # I + 3 % 0 # 4 5 ( ' 0 1 3 % + 0 % # 1 I % 2 1 ' ( " 0 ' 6 1 # 1 % 7 # 2 8 % 0
+ F < . = , L = E = J J = / = K J + = + J / / / % / / F < + A G . # C , 2 ' 6 % X 1 1 0 1 1 A % G % # % # # 2 0 6 C C 2 % 6 C = % J A % # = 1 ? J C 6 A 5 0 L ] E 8 ? 4 % G % A 0 G # ' 0 8 A # I @ % ( 2 A C 8 = = ? CC 8 % J # # 1 K ? @ % 0 0 A @ % G # A G % 1 = A # ' # J 2 @ ? C A 0 + # G 3 1 A A G % ' # 0 2 C # 4 + 5 3 % 0 # 4 5
J 7 H H L " > # K = ' 1 , / : / N ? < % / H N @ 2 L H # H # A D 5 0 b ' * % 6 8 9 DA P 2 1 * 0 3 7 & A ' 1 P * = ' 2 A % & I / ? 1 P 0 A " % 8 A 6 2 0 # ' # 1 A C 1 2 0 K ' 5 # # 2 C A C = ? % 0 @ ` ` N E # ` # O ` [ 0 P O 0 c I # % A A Y A 2 Y 8 2 # [ Y " 7 # 3 1 F " " 2 A . 5 ' , L ^ L 1 Z 2 3 7 = 9 = % = + < + $ 0 + Z # % 2 # Z 4 8 2 5 ' @ C ' $ 5 H 7 c [ c c N 5 . W K F 9 0 " U ' 0 % L U [ # c F W U G ' # = ` C ? % ^ I 8 ? L 0 0 + 5 ' C 5 3 6 5 7 = # # 0 4 + % = ' % % 5 ' ( # # S 1 # + 2 # 1 Y A 2 $ 0 0 0 " ' 3 1 ^ 6 3 6 % 0 @ 6 : = 2 % ( ( 0 ( 6 ' < O ' ' 4 # ' U ( 0 H ) 0 4 ' 0 ( 5 Z 0 " b " 9 , I % 0 A 8
" # $ % & O ' ( ) *
# 2 7 ' C C % $ % ' ( = # @ A ' C ' $ 5 Y 9 7 = Z e c ^ P e Y # 0 # @ 2 ' I A T % @ 1 0 A # C Z
1 " c 3 e & " 5 % 6 ' , # 4 % d ' # 0 ( A 1 2 " % A N 1 2 M 3 " , 1 . % 4 6 F 7 # 0 1 " A # 1 L % % 2 = # + 1 6 ( L # 1 % 8 1 0 0 3 A # # A % C G 7 Y " % " J @ L 9 # = + 2 ' C # e @ S & d % A 0 0 ≤ " G 6 P J U e c 9 [ 2 2 d $ # A b I @ ' ( 0 0 DC 8 6 e ' A I & I d A C 4 # # G 0 6 % 0 $ c @ 0 ' e d S ? 4 A 1 3 ' ( 0 2 " J % ' " A I 1 0 2 , ' A G 0 C 6 # 6 # 4 2 7 0 % @ ' 8 ' " ? L 1 I A = 1 G 8 % T A + ' 8 % L I ' @ 2 A % 3 6 ' ( ' 0 6 1 0
# M 2 @ @ ' & A ` ( ( U& % d 0 % 2 ( ' 8 0 % N 2 A 0 # W 8 3 5 5 % 1 3 # 0 % N 0 # ' A 4 8 5 3 % Y 4 I j A P 8 U) # C * ( Z # A C ? 0 % 0 # % 1 6 Y Y O UO d ( ' 0 . L = +
= % 6 ? C 1 6
7 ' I I % 2 1 6
+9 70A1%0A'2 [/
+3% 1%832'C'$5 I?61 AI40'G% 13% 2%1 3%#C13 '?18'I%6U
;%#C13 <?18'I%6 ,@%#CC5D 61?@A%6 '( 40'61#1% 8#28%0 10%#1I%216 S'?C@ I%#6?0% 8CA2A8#CC5 6A$2A(A8#21 C'2$ 1%0I '?18'I%6 6?83 #6 1'1#C '0 40'61#1% 8#28%0 I'01#CA15D #2@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0 6?0GAG#CU <13%0 8CA2A8#CC5 6A$2A(A8#21 '?18'I%6 A28C?@% R?#CA15 '( CA(% #2@ 10%#1I%21 0%C#1%@ 6A@% %((%816U ;'S%G%0D I#25 '( 13% 61?@A%6 '( 40'61#1% 8#28%0 10%#1I%21 I%#6?0% A21%0I%@A#1% '?18'I%6D which are of less clear clinical significance, such as “biochemical failure U” LA'83%IA8#C (#AC?0% #6 @%(A2%@ N5 13% "3'%2AX @%(A2A1A'2 A6 # 0A6% A2 13% "J9 '( * 2$bIC '0 I'0% #N'?1 13% 2#@A0 #(1%0 .L=+ SA13 '0 SA13'?1 3'0I'2#C 13%0#45D SA13 13% @#1% '( (#AC?0% N%A2$ 13% @#1% 13#1 (#AC?0% A6 @%(A2%@U*W 92 %#0CA%0D #C1%02#1AG% @%(A2A1A'2 13% 9J+=< @%(A2A1A'2 A6 130%% 8'26%8?1AG% A280%#6%6 A2 "J9U*e +3% 9J+=< @%(A2A1A'2 3#6 N%%2 0%4C#8%@ N5 13% "3'%2AX @%(A2A1A'2 @?% 1' 61#1A61A8#C 63'018'IA2$6U*W LA'83%IA8#C (#AC?0% 3#6 N%%2 defined as an “appropriate early endpoint for clinical trials,” but it is not equivalent to
8CA2A8#C (#AC?0%U
,I4'01#21 '?18'I%6 A2 40'61#1% 8#28%0 10%#1I%21 #0% 10%#1I%21 0%C#1%@ 6A@% %((%816U +'XA8A15 A6 154A8#CC5 $0#@%@ '2 # 61#2@#0@ 68#C% N#6%@ '2 13% =+<H =#@A#1A'2 +'XA8A15 H0#@A2$ 70A1%0A#[PU +'XA8A1A%6 #0% $0#@%@ (0'I C%G%C & YC'S%61 6%G%0A15Z 1' C%G%C ) Y3A$3%61 6%G%0A15ZU E'61 61?@A%6 ?6% 13%6% 80A1%0A# ('0 $0#@A2$ 1'XA8A1A%6 #2@ 154A8#CC5 8'26A@%0 1'XA8A1A%6 '( H0#@% * '0 $0%#1%0 '0 H0#@% [ '0 $0%#1%0 #6 8CA2A8#CC5 6A$2A(A8#21U
"#$% &W '( )*
+#NC% c/ =+<H =#@A#1A'2 +'XA8A15 H0#@A2$ 70A1%0A#
H0#@% &
H0#@% *
H0#@% [
H0#@% )
H%2A1'?0A2#05 +0#81
H#610'A21%61A2#C J561%I
K0%R?%285 '( ?0A2#1A'2 '0 2'81?0A# 1SA8% 40%10%#1I%21 3#NA1 #2@b'0 @56?0A#D ?0$%285 2'1 0%R?A0A2$ I%@A8#1A'2 K0%R?%285 '( ?0A2#1A'2 '0 2'81?0A# 13#1 A6 C%66 (0%R?%21 13#2 %G%05 3'?0U F56?0A#D ?0$%285D NC#@@%0 64#6I 0%R?A0A2$ C'8#C #2%613%1A8 Y%U$U "50A@A?IZh K0%R?%285 SA13 ?0$%285 #2@ 2'81?0A# 3'?0C5 '0 I'0% (0%R?%21C5b@56?0A#D 4%CGA6 4#A2 '0 NC#@@%0 64#6I 0%R?A0A2$ 0%$?C#0D (0%R?%21 2#08'1A8b$0'66 3%I#1?0A# SA13 '0 SA13'?1 8C'1 4#66#$% ;%I#1?0A# 0%R?A0A2$ 10#26(?6A'2b#8?1% NC#@@%0 'N610?81A'2 2'1 6%8'2@#05 1' 8C'1 4#66#$%D ?C8%0#1A'2 '0 2%80'6A6
,280%#6%@ (0%R?%285 '0 83#2$% A2 R?#CA15 '( N'S%C 3#NA16 2'1 0%R?A0A2$ I%@A8#1A'2 #2@ 0%81#C @A68'I('01 2'1 0%R?A0A2$ #2#C$%6A86 FA#003%# 0%R?A0A2$ 4#0#65I4#13'C51A8 @0?$6 Y%U$U -'I'1ACZD I?8'?6 @A683#0$% 2'1 2%8%66A1#1A2$ 6#2A1#05 4#@6 '0 0%81#C '0 #N@'IA2#C 4#A2 0%R?A0A2$ #2#C$%6A86
FA#003%# 0%R?A0A2$ 4#0%21%0#C 6?44'01D 6%G%0 I?8'?6 '0 NC''@ @A683#0$% 2%8%66A1#1A2$ 6#2A1#05 4#@6D #N@'IA2#C @A61%21A'2 Y(C#1 4C#1% 0#@A'$0#43 @%I'2610#1%6 @A61%2@%@ N'S%C C''46Z
98?1% '0 6?N#8?1% 'N610?81A'2D (A61?C# '0 4%0('0#1A'2/ HA NC%%@A2$ 0%R?A0A2$ 10#26(?6A'2/ #N@'IA2#C 4#A2 '0 1%2%6I?6 0%R?A0A2$ 1?N% @%8'I40%66A'2 '0 N'S%C @AG%06A'2U
"'1%21A#C L%2%(A16
+3% $'#C '( 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 A6 1' 40'C'2$ 'G%0#CC #2@ @A6%#6% 64%8A(A8 6?0GAG#CD 1' @%C#5 40'$0%66A'2 '( @A6%#6% #2@ 1' AI40'G% R?#CA15 '( CA(%U L%8#?6% 40'1'2 N%#I6 8#2 13%'0%1A8#CC5 N% I'0% 8'28%210#1%@ '2 13% 1?I'0 #2@ C%66 8'28%210#1%@ '2 13% 6?00'?2@A2$ 2'0I#C 1A66?%6D 13%'0%1A8#CC5 A1 8'?C@ N% # 10%#1I%21 '41A'2 ('0 4#1A%216 SA13 C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0 13#1 I#XAIAT%6 13% %((%81 '2 13% 1A66?% S3AC% CAIA1A2$ %((%816 '2 "#$% &e '( )*
#@\#8%21 1A66?%U
"'1%21A#C ;#0I6
+3% I#A2 3#0I6 #66'8A#1%@ SA13 0#@A'13%0#45 '( 13% 40'61#1% #0% 1'XA8A1A%6 1' 13% $%2A1'?0A2#05 #2@ $#610'A21%61A2#C 6561%I6U
H%2A1'?0A2#05 1'XA8A1A%6 A28C?@% ?0%130#C
610A81?0%D ?0A2#05 A28'21A2%28% A28'21A2%28% '0 0%1%21A'2D (0%R?%285D 3%I#1?0A# '0 AI4'1%28%U +'XA8A1A%6 '( 13% $#610'A21%61A2#C 6561%I A28C?@% @A#003%#D 40'81A1A6 #2@ 0%81#C NC%%@A2$ '0 4#A2U ;A4 (0#81?0%6 3#G% #C6' N%%2 #66'8A#1%@ SA13 0#@A'13%0#45 ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0U
<?18'I%6 '( M'2^8'I4#0#1AG% 61?@A%6
9 1'1#C '( 6%G%2 2'2^8'I4#0#1AG% 61?@A%6 %G#C?#1%@ 40'1'2 13%0#45 ('0 13% 10%#1I%21 '( 40'61#1% 8#28%0U 8#28%0U +3% @%680A41A'2 '( 13%6% 61?@A%6 A6 A28C?@%@ A2 +#NC% & #2@ 13% I#A2 61?@5 '?18'I%6 #0% @%680AN%@ A2 +#NC% *U J1?@5 6AT% 0#2$%@ (' ('0I 0I [P 1' &D*cc 4#01A8A4#216U +30%% 61?@A%6 S%0% @'2% A2 >#4#2D&*D&)D&c '2% A2 JS%@%2&W #2@ 13% 0%I#A2A2$ 130%% A2 13% :UJU&[D&`D&O +S' '( 13% 61?@A%6 ?6%@ 40'1'2 13%0#45 #C'2%&*D&[D ('?0 ?6%@ 40'1'2 13%0#45 SA13 # N''61&)D&`^&W #2@ '2% ?6%@ # N''61 A2 A21%0I%@A#1% 0A6] N?1 2'1 C'S 0A6] 4#1A%216U &c 9CC ?6%@ 0#@A#1A'2 @'6%6 0#2$A2$ ('0I OP 1' W* H5 '0 7H.U +3% I'61 8'II'2 '?18'I%6 %G#C?#1%@ S%0% H, #2@ H: 1'XA8A1A%6D NA'83%IA8#C (#AC?0% Y@%(A2%@ N5 0A6%6 A2 "J9 C%G%C6Z #2@ 40'$0%66A'2 (0%% 6?0GAG#CU
+3% C#0$%61 2'2^8'I4#0#1AG% 61?@5 '( 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 A6 # 0%10'64%81AG% 8'3'01 (0'I -'I# -A2@# :2AG%06A15D S3%0% 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 ('0 C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0 3#6 N%%2 ?6%@ 6A28% &ee&U&O +3%5 %G#C?#1%@ #CC 4#1A%216 10%#1%@ N%1S%%2 &ee& #2@ &eeO #1 -'I# "#$% *P '( )*
-A2@#U +3% I#A2 '?18'I%6 S%0% 1'XA8A1A%6 #2@ NA'83%IA8#C 0%C#46%U "#1A%216 S%0% 10%#1%@ SA13 N'13 43'1'26 #2@ 40'1'26U ,2A1A#CC5D 13% 10%#1I%21 S#6 # 8'2('0I#C N''61 '( [P 7H. A2 &c (0#81A'26 #2@ S#6 13%2 ('CC'S%@ N5 )c H5 '( 43'1'2 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45U -#1%0 @?0A2$ 13% 61?@5 4%0A'@D 4#01A8A4#216 S%0% @AGA@%@ A21' C'S '0 3A$3 0A6] 8#1%$'0A%6U +3'6% 8'26A@%0%@ 3A$3 0A6] 8'21A2?%@ 1' 0%8%AG% 13% 8'INA2%@ 40'1'2^43'1'2 10%#1I%21 #2@ 13'6% 8'26A@%0%@ C'S 0A6] S%0% 10%#1%@ SA13 40'1'26 #C'2%U
LA'83%IA8#C (#AC?0% S#6
@%(A2%@ ?6A2$ 13% 8'26%26?6 @%(A2A1A'2 A2 4C#8% #1 13% 1AI% N5 13% 9I%0A8#2 J'8A%15 ('0 +3%0#4%?1A8 =#@A'C'$5 Y9J+=<ZD S3A83 S#6 @%(A2%@ #6 130%% 8'26%8?1AG% 0A6%6 A2 "J9 C%G%C6D SA13 13% @#1% '( (#AC?0% N%A2$ IA@S#5 N%1S%%2 13% 2#@A0 #2@ 13% (A061 0A6%U*e "#01A8A4#216 S%0% ('CC'S%@ ('0 #2 #G%0#$% '( `* I'2136U J%G%2 3?2@0%@ 13A015 '2% 4#1A%216 0%8%AG%@ # 8'INA2#1A'2 '( 40'1'26 #2@ 43'1'6 #2@ c*) 0%8%AG%@ #CC 13%A0 10%#1I%216 SA13 40'1'26 1' 13% 40'61#1% #2@ 6%IA2#C G%6A8C%Y6Z '2C5U LA'83%IA8#C @A6%#6% (0%% 6?0GAG#C S#6 I%#6?0%@ #1 (AG% #2@ %A$31 5%#06 #2@ S%0% Ocd #2@ O[d 0%64%81AG%C5U K'0 N'13 H, #2@ H: 1'XA8A1A%6D 13% 0#1% '( =+<H H0#@% [ '0 $0%#1%0 1'XA8A1A%6 S#6 a&dU -#1% H, 1'XA8A15 S#6 0%C#1AG%C5 0#0% N?1 13%0% S#6 '2% 6I#CC N'S%C 'N610?81A'2 0%R?A0A2$ # @AG%01A2$ 8'C'61'I5 #2@ 1S' %4A6'@%6 '( NC%%@A2$ #2@ 4#A2U H: 1'XA8A15 C#1% A2 13% 10%#1I%21 8'?06% S#6 I'0% 8'II'2U 9 1'1#C '( &) 4#1A%216 @%G%C'4%@ C#1% H: 1'XA8A15D A28C?@A2$ %A$31 ?0%130#C 610A81?0%6D ('?0 SA13 3%I#1?0A# #2@ 1S' SA13 @56?0A#U <2% 4#1A%21 @%G%C'4%@ 2%80'6A6 '( 13% 65I43A6A6 4?NA6U +3%0% S%0% 2' @A((%0%28%6 A2 1'XA8A15 N%1S%%2 13'6% 10%#1%@ SA13 43'1'26 #2@ 40'1'26 G%06?6 13'6% 10%#1%@ SA13 40'1'26 #C'2%U
>'3#266'2 #2@ 8'CC%#$?%6 0%8%21C5 0%4'01%@ '2 (AG% 5%#0 '?18'I%6 (0'I # 8'3'01 '( 4#1A%216 A2 JS%@%2 10%#1%@ SA13 40'1'2 N''61 13%0#45U
9 1'1#C '( *OW 4#1A%216 SA13
C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0 0%8%AG%@ g=+ 4C?6 # 40'1'2 N''61 1' # 1'1#C '( OP H5U KAG% 5%#0 6?0GAG#C ('0 13% 8'3'01 S#6 Wed #2@ %A$31 5%#0 6?0GAG#C S#6 O&dU "#1A%216 S%0% @AGA@%@ A21' 130%% 0A6] 8#1%$'0A%6 N#6%@ '2 13% M77M $?A@%CA2%6 #2@ S%0% 8C#66A(A%@ #6 C'SD "#$% *& '( )*
A21%0I%@A#1% '0 3A$3 0A6]U[& +3%5 #2#C5T%@ 6?0GAG#C #2@ "J9 0%C#46% 6%4#0#1%C5 N5 0A6] $0'?4U +3%0% S%0% 2' 6A$2A(A8#21 @A((%0%28%6 A2 'G%0#CC 6?0GAG#C N5 0A6] $0'?4U +3%5 #C6' %G#C?#1%@ 13% CA]%CA3''@ '( "J9 0%C#46% N5 0A6] $0'?4U KAG% 5%#0 #81?#0A#C 0%C#46% S#6 PdD cd #2@ *`d ('0 C'SD A21%0I%@A#1% #2@ 3A$3 0A6] $0'?46 Y4aPUPP&ZU &W
,2 #CC '( 13% 2'2^8'I4#0#1AG% 61?@A%6D H, #2@ H: 1'XA8A1A%6 S%0% #66%66%@U .X8%41 ('0 13% '2% 61?@5 13#1 I%#6?0%@ C#1% '?18'I%6 A2 C'2$ 1%0I 6?0GAG'06D &` H, #2@ H: 1'XA8A1A%6 S%0% $%2%0#CC5 C%66 13#2 cdU ,2 13% '2% 61?@5 13#1 I%#6?0%@ H: #2@ H, I'0NA@A15D #1 (AG% #2@ &c 5%#06D&` 0#1%6 S%0% 3A$3%0U +3%5 ('?2@ 13#1 13% A28A@%28% '( H0#@% * '0 $0%#1%0 H: I'0NA@A15 #1 &c 5%#06 S#6 ced N?1 13#1 13% 65I41'I6 4%06A61%@ 1' 13% 1AI% '( A21%0GA%S A2 '2C5 &Wd '( 4#1A%216U +3% #81?#0A#C A28A@%28% '( H0#@% * '0 $0%#1%0 3%I#1?0A# #1 &c 5%#06 S#6 )OdD N?1 13% A28A@%28% '( H0#@% [ '0 $0%#1%0 3%I#1?0A# S#6 WdU
+3% #81?#0A#C
A28A@%28% '( H0#@% * '0 $0%#1%0 H, I'0NA@A15 S#6 &[d #1 (AG% #2@ &c 5%#06D #C13'?$3 H0#@% & 0%81#C NC%%@A2$ '88?00%@ A2 )&d '( I%2U +3?6D #C13'?$3 13%0% S%0% C'2$ 1%0I 6%R?%C#% #(1%0 40'1'2 N%#I 10%#1I%21D I'61 '( 13% 1'XA8A1A%6 S%0% 2'1 6%G%0%U
+3% 61?@A%6 @A@ 2'1 #66%66 13% AI4#81 '2 40'61#1% 8#28%0 I'01#CA15 '0 1'1#C I'01#CA15D #C13'?$3 130%% 61?@A%6 #66%66%@ 13% AI4#81 '2 6?0GAG#CD 40'$0%66A'2 (0%% 6?0GAG#C '0 (0%%@'I (0'I NA'83%IA8#C %GA@%28% '( @A6%#6%U&[D&OD&W 91 -'I# -A2@#D JC#1%0 #2@ 8'CC%#$?%6 ('?2@ 13#1 13% (AG% #2@ %A$31 5%#0 NA'83%IA8#C @A6%#6% (0%% 6?0GAG#C 0#1%6 S%0% Ocd #2@ 8'CC%#$?%6 CC%#$?%6 #1 13% :2AG%06A15 '( KC'0A@#D ('?2@ 13#1 #1 1S' 5%#0 O[dU&O E%2@%23#CC #2@ 8' ('CC'S ?4D 13% 'G%0#CC 6?0GAG#C 0#1% ('0 10%#1%@ 4#1A%216 S#6 e`dD #2@ 13#1 40'$0%66A'2 (0%% 6?0GAG#C S#6 eed #1 1S' 5%#06U&[ KA2#CC5D >'3#266'2 #2@ 8'CC%#$?%6 0%4'01%@ # (AG% 5%#0 40'$0%66A'2 (0%% 6?0GAG#C '( &PPd ('0 C'S 0A6] 4#1A%216D ecd ('0 A21%0I%@A#1% 0A6] 4#1A%216 #2@ O)d ('0 3A$3 0A6] 4#1A%216U&W 9C13'?$3 13%0% #0% 2' 8'I4#0A6'2 $0'?46 A2 13%6% 61?@A%6D 13%6% '?18'I%6 #0% 6AIAC#0 1' 13'6% 6%% ('0 ,E=+ 10%#1I%21 '( 40'61#1% 8#28%0U[*U "#$% ** '( )*
J?II#05
,2 6?II#05D 6%G%2 2'2^8'I4#0#1AG% 61?@A%6 3#G% %G#C?#1%@ 13% ?6% '( 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 ('0 13% 10%#1I%21 '( C'8 C'8#CAT%@ #CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0U =#1%6 '( @A @A6%#6% 6%#6% (0%% 40'$0%66A'2 6%%I 1' N% 0%C#1AG%C5 3A$3D #2@ 8'I4#0#NC% 1' 0#1%6 6%%2 SA13 '13%0 10%#1I%216 '( C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0U 9C13'?$3 C'S $0#@% 1'XA8A1A%6 #0% 6'I%S3#1 8'II'2D 0#1%6 '( 3A$3%0 $0#@% 1'XA8A1A%6 #0% 0%C#1AG%C5 C'SU <G%0#CCD 13% 2%1 N%2%(A16 #44%#0 1' '?1S%A$3 13% 0A6]6 6?83 13#1 13%0% A6 # 2%1 N%2%(A1 ('0 13% ?6% '( 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 1' 10%#1 40'61#1% 8#28%0U
+9 70A1%0A'2 [ A6 I%1
+9 70A1%0A'2 )/
+3% 1%832'C'$5 I?61 N% #6 N%2%(A8A#C #6 #25 %61#NCA63%@ #C1%02#1AG%6U
9 1'1#C '( 6%G%2 61?@A%6 3#G% 8'I4#0%@ 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 1' #2 #C1%02#1AG% Y+#NC% [ZU
+S' '( 13%6% 61?@A%6 S%0% 0#2@'IAT%@U &eD**
+3% '13%0 (AG% 61?@A%6 S%0% 2'1
0#2@'IAT%@U*[^*O ,2 13% %#0CA%61 0#2@'IAT%@ 61?@5D 4?NCA63%@ N5 +#CN'1 #2@ 8'CC%#$?%6 A2 &eecD # "3#6% ,,, 10A#C S#6 8'2@?81%@ S3%0% 4#1A%216 SA13 J1#$%6 +[^+)D MXP^* 40'61#1% 8#28%0 0%8%AG%@ # 10%#1I%21 8'INA2A2$ &P^*c E_ 43'1'26 SA13 8'2('0I#C 40'1'26 1' # 1'1#C @'6% '( OcU` 7H. '0 8'2G%21A'2#C %X1%02#C N%#I 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45 1 # 1'1#C @'6% '( `OU* H5U +3%0% S%0% &P[ 4#1A%216 A2 13% 40'1'2 #0I #2@ ee 4#1A%216 A2 13% 8'2G%21A'2#C 13%0#45 #0IU
"#1A%216 S% S%0% 0% ('CC'S%@ ('0 #2 #G%0#$% '( `& I'2136U
+3%0% S%0% 2'
"#$% *[ '( )*
@A((%0%28%6 A2 'G%0#CC 6?0GAG#CD @A6%#6% (0%% 6?0GAG#C '0 1'1#C 0%8?00%28%^(0%% 6?0GAG#CU +3% 0#1%6 '( C'8#C 8'210'C #1 (AG% #2@ %A$31 5%#06 ('0 13% 40'1'2 $0'?4 S#6 e)d #2@ W)d #2@ WPd #2@ `Pd ('0 13'6% 0%8%AGA2$ 40'1'2 13%0#45 Y4jPUPePZU +3%0% S%0% 3A$3%0 0#1%6 '( H0#@% * '0 C%66 0%81#C NC%%@A2$ A2 13% 40'1'2 $0'?4 Y[*d G%06?6 &*d/ 4jPUPP*Z #2@ # 2'26A$2A(A8#21 A280%#6% A2 ?0%130#C 610A81?0% Y&ed G%06?6 WdZU
+3% '13%0 0#2@'IAT%@ 10A#CD "=<H^ec^PeD actually compared “low dose” and “high dose” conformal radiation therapy that used a combination of proton #2@ 43'1'2
N%#I6U*P +3% "=<H^ec^Pe 61?@5 0#2@'IAT%@ [e[ 4#1A%216 1' 0%8%AG% %A13%0 OPU* H5 '( 8'INA2%@ 43'1'26 4C?6 40'1'26 G%06?6 OeU* H5 '( 8'INA2%@ 43'1'26 4C?6 40'1'26U 9CC 0%8%AG%@ 8'2('0I#C 43'1'2 13%0#45 #1 # @'6% '( cPU) H5U +3% N''61 @'6% S#6 40'1'26 #2@ S#6 %A13%0 &eUW H5 '0 *WUW H5U The main measured outcome was “biochemical failure” as I%#6?0%@ N5 #2 A280%#6%@ "J9 C%G%C #1 (AG% 5%#06 #(1%0 10%#1I%21U 91 (AG% 5%#06D 13%0% S%0% I'0% I%2 A2 13% 3A$3 @'6% $0'?4 (0%% (0'I NA'83%IA8#C (#AC?0% 13#2 13%0% S%0% A2 13% 8'2G%21A'2#C @'6% $0'?4D 0%6?C1A2$ A2 # )ed 0%@?81A'2 A2 13% 0A6] '( (#AC?0% A2 13% 3A$3 @'6% $0'?4U +3%0% S#6 2' @A((%0%28% A2 'G%0#CC 6?0GAG#C N%1S%%2 13% 1S' 10%#1I%21 $0'?46U <2C5 '2% 4%08%21 '( 4#1A%216 A2 13% 8'2G%21A'2#C $0'?4 #2@ 1S' 4%08%21 A2 13% 3A$3 @'6% *P
$0'?4 %X4%0A%28%@ #8?1% ?0A2#05 '0 0%81#C I'0NA@A15 '( =+<H H0#@% [ '0 $0%#1%0U +3% #?13'06 6?N6%R?%21C5 0%4'01%@ '2 C'2$%0 1%0I ('CC'S^?4U 9(1%0 # I%@A#2 '( WUe 5%#06 '( ('CC'S^?4D 13'6% 0%8%AGA2$ 13% 3A$3 @'6% 10%#1I%21 3#@ # 6A$2A(A8#21C5 C'S%0 CA]%CA3''@ '( C'8#C (#AC?0% Y;= PUcOZU
+3% 1%2 5%#0 0#1%6 '( NA'83%IA8#C (#AC?0% S%0% [*U)d ('0 13%
8'2G%21A'2#C @'6% $0'?4 G%06?6 &`UOd ('0 13% 3A$3 @'6% $0'?4U +3%0% S#6 2' @A((%0%28% A2 'G%0#CC 6?0GAG#C S3%2 8'I4#0A2$ 13% 1S' 10%#1I%21 $0'?46U &e
KA2#CC5D 13% "=<H ecPe H0'?4 #C6' 0%4'01%@ '2 C'2$ 1%0I 4#1A%21 0%4'01%@ '?18'I%6 '( 8'INA2%@ 40'1'2 #2@ 43'1'2 13%0#45U +3%5 8'2@?81%@ # 6?0G%5 '( *WP '( 13% 6?0GAGA2$ "#$% *) '( )*
[[O 4#1A%216 %20'CC%@ A2 13A6 40'1'8'CU +3% I#A2 '?18'I%6 S%0% "0'61#1% 7#28%0 J5I41'I ,2@A8%6D # G#CA@#1%@ I%#6?0% '( ?0A2#05 A28'21A2%28%D ?0A2#05 'N610?81A'2 #2@ A00A1#1A'2D N'S%C 40'NC%I6 #2@ 6%X?#C @56(?281A'2D #2@ '13%0 R?#CA15 '( CA(% I%#6?0%6U +3% 61?@5 S#6 8'2@?81%@ # I%@A#2 '( eU) 5%#06 #(1%0 10%#1I%21U =#1%6 '( 65I41'I6 S%0% 2'1 61#1A61A8#CC5 @A((%0%21 N%1S%%2 10%#1I%21 $0'?46U +3%6% 65I41'I6 A28C?@%@ ?0A2#05 'N610?81A'2 #2@ A00A1#1A'2D ?0A2#05 A28'21A2%28%D N'S%C 40'NC%I6D #2@ 6%X?#C @56(?281A'2U
,2 6?II#05D 13% 0%6?C16 '( 13A6 0#2@'IAT%@ 10A#C 63'S%@ 13#1 3A$3%0 @'6% 8'INA2%@ 40'1'2 #2@ 43'1'2 13%0#45 A6 #66'8A#1%@ SA13 AI40'G%@ 0#1%6 '( NA'83%IA8#C 6?0GAG#CD SA13 2' 6A$2A(A8#21 @A((%0%28% A2 10%#1I%21 0%C#1%@ 6A@% %((%816 A28C?@A2$ C'2$ 1%0I 4#1A%21 0%4'01%@ '?18'I%6 N%1S%%2 10%#1I%21 $0'?4U +3?6D 3A$3%0 @'6% 8'INA2%@ 40'1'2 #2@ 43'1'2 13%0#45 C%#@6 1' AI40'G%@ '?18'I%6 8'I4#0%@ SA13 C'S%0 @'6%U ;'S%G%0D 6A28% 4#01A8A4#216 A2 N'13 61?@5 #0I6 0%8%AG%@ 40'1'2 13%0#45D 13A6 61?@5 @A@ 2'1 8'I4#0% 40'1'2 13%0#45 SA13 43'1'2 13%0#45 #C'2%D S3A83 CAIA16 8'28C?6A'26U
KAG% 2'20#2@'IAT%@ 61?@A%6 3#G% 8'I4#0%@ 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 1' #2'13%0 10%#1I%21 A2 13% %#0CA%61 61?@5U F?11%23#G%0 #2@ 8' 8'CC%#$?%6 CC%#$?%6 8'I4#0%@ '?18'I%6 #I'2$ 4#1A%216 SA13 C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0 0%8%AGA2$ %A13%0 cP H5 '( 8'2G%21A'2#C 13%0#45 #C'2% G%06?6 0%8%AGA2$ # 40'1'2 N''61 1' 0%#83 # 1'1#C @'6% '( O) 7H.U *) +3%0% S%0% 2' 6A$2A(A8#21 @A((%0%28%6 A2 4#1A%21 6?0GAG#CD @A6%#6% (0%% 6?0GAG#C '0 C'8#C 0%8?00%28% (0%% 6?0GAG#CU ;'S%G%0D 13% @'6%6 ?6%@ A2 13A6 61?@5 #0% I?83 C'S%0 13#2 8?00%21C5 ?6%@ @'6%6 #2@ 13% 1%832AR?%6 ?6%@ A2 13#1 61?@5 #0% 2'S '?1I'@%@ #2@ 6' 2'1 0%C%G#21 1' 8?00%21 40#81A8%U
,2 # 0%8%21 8#6%^I#183%@ #2#C56A6D 3A$3 @'6% %X1%02#C N%#I 40'1'2 #2@ 43'1'2 g=+ YOeU* HQ.Z S#6 8'I4#0%@ SA13 N0#83513%0#45 ('0 10%#1I%21 '( C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0U "#$% *c '( )*
+3% &ee 4#01A8A4#216 S3' 0%8%AG%@ 3A$3 @'6% 40'1'2 #2@ 43'1'2 13%0#45 S%0% 13'6% A2 13% "=<H ec^Pe 3A$3 @'6% #0ID #CC 0%80?A1%@ ('0I -'I# -A2@# :2AG%06A15 #2@ E#66#83?6%116 H%2%0#C ;'64A1#C YEH;Z @?0A2$ &ee`^&eee S%0% %CA$ANC% ('0 A28C?6A'2U 9(1%0 %X8C?@A2$ 13'6% SA13 # HC%#6'2 J8'0% '( $0%#1%0 13#2 6%G%2D 13%0% S%0% &OO C%(1 ('0 8#6% I#183A2$U 9 1'1#C '( *P[ 6AIAC#0 4#1A%216 S%0% 10%#1%@ #1 EH; SA13 N0#83513%0#45 (0'I &eeO^*PP* N5 '2% N0#83513%0#4A61U 7#6% I#183A2$D S3A83 A28C?@%@ + 61#$%D HC%#6'2 J8'0%D "J9 #2@ #$% 0%6?C1%@ A2 &)& I#183%@ 8#6%6U E%@A#2 ('CC'S ?4 S#6 WU` 5%#06 ('0 ('0 .L=+ #2@ OU) 5%#06 ('0 N0#83513%0#45U +3% 40AI#05 %2@4'A21 S#6 NA'83%IA8#C (#AC?0%U E%@A#2 #$% S#6 `O 5%#06 'C@U +3% %A$31 5%#0 0#1%6 '( NA'83%IA8#C (#AC?0% S%0% 2'1 6A$2A(A8#21C5 @A((%0%21 N%1S%%2 13% 1S' $0'?46 YOUOd ('0 .L=+ G%06?6 &`U&d (' ('00 N0#83513%0#45/ 4jPU)*ZU +3%0% S#6 #C6' 2' @A((%0%28% A2 'G%0#CC 6?0GAG#C #1 %A$31 5%#06 Ye[d G%06?6 e`d/
4jPU)cZU
92#C56A6 N5
6?N$0'?4 YC'S G%06?6 A21%0I%@A#1% 0A6]h 13%0% S%0% 2' 3A$3 0A6] 4#1A%216Z #C6' 63'S%@ 2' 6A$2A(A8#21 @A((%0%28%6 N%1S%%2 $0'?46U +3% 0%6?C16 6?$$%61 13#1 '?18'I%6 #0% 6AIAC#0 ('0 I%2 10%#1%@ SA13 40'1'2 13%0#45 '0 SA13 N0#83513%0#45D #C13'?$3 13A6 S#6 # 8#6% I#183%@D 2'2^0#2@'IAT%@ #2#C56A6 #I'2$ 4#1A%216 10%#1%@ #1 @A((%0%21 1AI% 4%0A'@6U
H#CN0#A13 #2@ 8'CC%#$?%6 #66%66%@ 13% AI4#81 '( @A((%0%21 40'61#1% 8#28%0 10%#1I%216 '2 3%#C13 '?18'I%6 A2 (AG% @A((%0%21 10%#1I%21 $0'?46U +3%5 8'2@?81%@ # C'2$A1?@A2#C 6?0G%5 '( &Wc I%2 10%#1%@ ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0 #1 '2% 1%01A#05 8#0% I%@A8#C 8%21%0 Y-'I# -A2@# :2AG%06A15ZU +3%0% S%0% # 1'1#C '( &Wc I%2D #CC '( S3'I 3#@ 0%8%AG%@ @A((%0%21 10%#1I%216 ('0 ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0U
+3%6% 10%#1I%216 A28C?@%@ S#183(?C S#A1A2$ Y2j[PZD
6?0$%05 Y2jceZD 8'2G%21A'2#C %X1%02#C N%#I 0#@A'13%0#45 Y2j*cZD 40'1'2 N%#I 0#@A'13%0#45 Y2j*)Z '0 IAX%@ N%#I 0#@A#1A'2 Y2j)OZU 91 6AX I'2136D &`[ '( 13% 4#1A%216 8'I4C%1%@ #2'13%0 6?0G%5 #2@ #1 &* I'2136D &c) 8'I4C%1%@ #2'13%0 6?0G%5 #2@ #1 &W I'2136D &c[ 8'I4C%1%@ # 6?0G%5U +3% I#A2 '?18'I%6 S% S%0% 0% 3%#C13 0%C#1%@ R?#CA15 '( CA(%D 3%#C13 61#1?6 #2@ 40'61#1% 10%#1I%21 64%8A(A8 65I41'I6 #2@ 6%X 0'C% A@%21A15U "#$% *` '( )*
;%#C13
0%C#1%@ R?#CA15 '( CA(% S#6 I%#6?0%@ ?6A2$ 13% n?#CA15 '( -A(% ,2@%X Yn-,ZD # I%#6?0% 1' #66%66 3%#C13 0%C#1%@ R?#CA15 '( CA(% 13#1 S#6 @%6A$2%@ 64%8A(A8#CC5 ('0 4#1A%216 SA13 8#28%0U[[ <G%0#CC D 13% (AG% $0'?46 @A@ 2'1 @A((%0 A2 I%#6?0%6 '( 3%#C13 0%C#1%@ R?#CA15 '( CA(% @?0A2$ 13% &W I'2136 ('CC'SA2$ 40'61#1% 88#28%0 #28%0 10%#1I%21U "'61 3'8 #2#C56%6 63'S%@ 13#1 #1 &* I'2136D 13% IAX%@ N%#I 0#@A#1A'2 $0'?4 #2@ 13% 40'1'2 N%#I 0#@A#1A'2 $0'?4 0%4'01%@ N%11%0 3%#C13 0%C#1%@ R?#CA15 '( CA(% 13#2 13'6% A2 13% S#183(?C S#A1A2$ $0'?4 Y4jPUP* #2@ 4jPUPc 0%64%81AG%C5ZU
;%#C13 61#1?6 S#6 I%#6?0%@ SA13 13% E%@A8#C <?18'I%6 J1?@5
H%2%0#C ;%#C13 J?0G%5U 91 &W I'2136D 13%0% S%0% 2' 'G%0#CC @A((%0%28%6 A2 3%#C13 61#1?6 #I'2$ 13% (AG% $0'?46U "0'61#1% 10%#1I%21 0%C#1%@ 65I41'I6 S%0% I%#6?0%@ ?6A2$ 13% J'?13S%61 <28'C'$5 H0'?4 "0'61#1% +0%#1I%21 J4%8A(A8 J5I41'I6 E%#6?0% Y"+JJZU +3% "+JJ A6 # &e A1%I 68#C% S3A83 S#6 @%G%C'4%@ 1' I%#6?0% #2@ 8'I4#0% 10%#1I%21 0%C#1%@ 65I41'I6 13#1 8#2 '88?0 #(1%0 #25 10%#1I%21 ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0U [) J5I41'I6 #0% 0%C#1%@ 1' N'S%CD NC#@@%0 #2@ 6%X?#C (?281A'2A2$U 91 &W I'213 ('CC'S^?4D 13%0% S%0% @A((%0%28%6 #I'2$ 13% (AG% 10%#1I%21 $0'?46 A2 40'61#1% 10%#1I%21 64%8A(A8 65I41'I6U .#83 $0'?4 S#6 8'I4#0%@ 1' %G%05 '13%0 $0'?4 #1 I?C1A4C% 1AI% 4%0A'@6U 91 &W I'2136D 13%0% S%0% @A((%0%28%6 A2 6%X?#C #2@ H, 65I41'I6 #I'2$ $0'?46D N?1 2' @A((%0%28%6 A2 ?0A2#05 65I41'I6U E?C1A4C% 4'61 3'8 #2#C56%6 S%0% @'2% #1 @A((%0%21 1AI% 4'A216 Y` I'2136 #2@ &* I'2136ZU <( 2'1%D #1 &* I'2136D 13% I%2 S3' 3#@ IAX%@ N%#I 0#@A#1A'2 0%4'01%@ I'0% 65I41'I6 13#2 13'6% S3' 0%8%AG%@ S#183(?C S#A1A2$ Y4jPUPPcZD N?1 13%0% S%0% 61ACC 2' @A((%0%28%6 A2 ?0A2#05 65I41'I6 #I'2$ $0'?46U ,2 6?II#05D A2 13A6 61?@5 '( &Wc 4#1A%216 S3' 3#@ 0%8%AG%@ G#0A'?6 10%#1I%216D 13%0% S#6 2' @A((%0%28% A2 3%#C13 0%C#1%@ R?#CA15 '( CA(% '0 3%#C13 61#1?6 #1 &W I'213 ('CC'S^?4U +3%0% S%0% I'0% H, 65I41'I6 SA13 0#@A#1A'2 10%#1I%21U
>#NN#0A #2@ 8'CC%#$?%6 8'I4#0%@ # 8'3'01 '( *)e 4#1A%216 S3' S%0% 10%#1%@ SA13 4%0I#2%21 40'61#1% AI4C#21 N0#83513%0#45 #1 :7JK SA13 # 8'3'01 '( A2@AGA@?#C6 10%#1%@ "#$% *O '( )*
SA13 [F^7=+ #1 13% :2AG%06A15 '( EA83A$#2 #2@ 13% 4?NCA63%@ 0%6?C16 '( # 3A$3 @'6% 7"L=+ N''61 10A#CU*` "#1A%216 A2 13% 7"L=+ 10A#C*P 0%8%AG%@ # 8'INA2#1A'2 '( 8'2('0I#C 43'1'2 #2@ *P
40'1'2 N%#I6 1' # 1'1#C @'6% '( '0 OeU* H5U +3% I#A2 '?18'I%6 S%0% NA'83%IA8#C 2' %GA@%28% '( @A6%#6% YNM.FZ #2@ "J9 2#@A0 #83A%G%@U K'0 %#83 '( 13% 1S' 8'I4#0A6'26D 13%5 6%C%81%@ 6?N6%16 '( 13% "", 8'3'01 S3' 3#@ 6AIAC#0 4#1A%21 #2@ @A6%#6% 80A1%0A# 1' 13% 0%(%0%28% $0'?4U +3% (AG% 5%#0 NM.F 0#1% S#6 e&d ('0 13'6% S3' 0%8%AG%@ 7"L=+ #2@ e[d ('0 13'6% S3' 0%8%AG%@ "",U E'0% "", 4#1A%216 0%#83%@ # "J9 2#@A0 '( aPUc 2$bIC 13#2 @A@ 13'6% A2 13% 7"L=+ 10A#C Ye&d G6 cedZU ,2 13A6 2'20#2@'IAT%@ 61?@5D I%2 10%#1%@ SA13 "", 3#@ 6AIAC#0 '?18'I%6 S3%2 8'I4#0%@ SA13 13'6% 10%#1%@ SA13 3A$3 @'6% 7"L=+ A2 # 4?NCA63%@ 10A#C U
KA2#CC5D # 0%8%21 61?@5 %G#C?#1%@ 13% 8'I4#0#1AG% %((A8#85 '( ,E=+D 40'1'2 13%0#45 #2@ 8'2('0I#C 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45 ('0 40AI#05 10%#1I%21 '( 40'61#1% 8#28%0U *[ +3A6 S#6 # 4'4?C#1A'2 N#6%@ 61?@5 ?6A2$ @#1# (0'I 13% J?0G%ACC#28%D .4A@%IA'C'$5D #2@ .2@ =%6?C16 YJ..=Z E%@A8#0%^CA2]%@ @#1# (0'I *PPP^*PPe ('0 4#1A%216 SA13 2'2^I%1#61#1A8 40'61#1% 8#28%0U
J..=^E%@A8#0% CA2]6 13% 0%$A6105 @#1# 1' E%@A8#0% 8C#AI6 @#1#U
+3% I#A2
'?18'I%6 S%0% 0#1%6 '( H, #2@ H: I'0NA@A15D %0%81AC% @56(?281A'2D 3A4 (0#81?0%6 #2@ 2%%@ ('0 #@@A1A'2#C 8#28%0 13%0#45U <G%0#CCD 13%5 A@%21A(A%@ `D``` 4#1A%21 10%#1%@ SA13 ,E=+ #2@ `D[&P 10%#1%@ SA13 8'2('0I#C 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45U K'0 13% 40'1'2 G%06?6 ,E=+ 8'I4#0A6'2D 13%5 A@%21A(A%@ `W) I%2 10%#1%@ SA13 40'1'2 13%0#45 (0'I *PP* 1' *PPOU L%8#?6% 13%0% S%0% 6' (%S A261A1?1A'26 13#1 '((%0%@ 40'1'2 13%0#45D N#6%CA2% 83#0#81%0A61A86 N%1S%%2 40'1'2 13%0#45 #2@ ,E=+ 4#1A%216 S%0% G%05 @A((%0%21D 40AI#0AC5 N%8#?6% '( 1S' G#0A#NC%6 ^ J..= 0%$A'2 #2@ A261A1?1A'2#C #((ACA#1A'2 SA13 13% = =+<HU +<HU
+' 'G%08'I% 13A6D 13%5 ?6%@
40'4%26A15 68'0% I#183A2$ 1' 8'I4#0% 13% 4#1A%216 S3' 0%8%AG%@ 40'1'2 13%0#45 SA13 13'6% S3' 0%8%AG%@ ,E=+U E%@A#2 ('CC'S^?4 ('0 13A6 8'I4#0A6'2 S#6 )` I'2136 ('0 ,E=+ #2@ cP I'2136 ('0 40'1'2 13%0#45U 7'I4#0A2$ 13'6% S3' 0%8%AG%@ 40'1'2 13%0#45 SA13 "#$% *W '( )*
13% 40'4%26A15 I#183%@ ,E=+ 4#1A%216D 13%0% S#6 # C'S%0 0#1% '( H, I'0NA@A15 A2 13'6% S3' 0%8%AG%@ ,E=+ Y#N6'C?1% 0A6] &*U* G%06?6 &OUW 4%0 &PP 4%06'2^5%#06/ == PU``/ ecdh 7U,U PUcc^ PUOeZU +3%0% S%0% 2' 6A$2A(A8#21 @A((%0%28%6 A2 0#1%6 '( '13%0 I'0NA@A1A%6 '0 2%%@ ('0 #@@A1A'2#C 13%0#4A%6 N%1S%%2 ,E=+ #2@ 40'1'2 13%0#45U "0'1'2 13%0#45 S#6 2'1 8'I4#0%@ SA13 8'2('0I#C 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45 A2 13A6 #2#C56A6U
,2 6?II#05D 6%G%2 61?@A%6 3#G% 8'I4#0%@ 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0 1' #2'13%0 10%#1I%21U <2C5 1S' '( 13%6% 3#G% N%%2 0#2@'IAT%@U +3% (A061 '( 13% 1S' 0#2@'IAT%@ 61?@A%6 A28C?@%@ *P* 4#1A%216 S#6 @'2% &c 5%#06 #$' #2@ ('?2@ 2' %GA@%28% '( @A((%0%28%6 A2 6?0GAG#C #C13'?$3 13%0% S%0% 3A$3%0 0#1%6 '( 0%81#C NC%%@A2$ A2 13% 40'1'2 N%#I 10%#1%@ $0'?4U +3% 6%8'2@ 61?@5 #81?#CC5 8'I4#0%@ C'S 1' 3A$3 @'6% 43'1'26 4C?6 40'1'26U 9C13'?$3 13%5 ('?2@ 13#1 3A$3 @'6% 8'INA2%@ 13%0#45 S#6 N%11%0D 13%0% S#6 2' 8'I4#0A6'2 $0'?4 13#1 @A@ 2'1 0%8%AG% 40'1'2 13%0#45U +3% '2% 61?@5 13#1 8'I4#0%@ 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 1' N0#83513%0#45 S#6 # 2'2^0#2@'IAT%@ 8#6% I#183%@ 61?@5 #2@ 13% 61?@5 13#1 8'I4#0%@ 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 1' ,E=+ S#6 # 8#6% I#183%@ 40'4%26A15 #2#C56A6 #I'2$ 4#1A%216 10%#1%@ #1 @A((%0%21 1AI% 4%0A'@6D 13?6 CAIA1A2$ 13% 8'28C?6A'26 13#1 8#2 N% @0#S2 (0'I 13%6% 61?@A%6U
+9 70A1%0A'2 ) A6 2'1 I%1U
"#$% *e '( )*
+9 70A1%0A'2 c/
+3% AI40'G%I%21 I?61 N% #11#A2#NC% '?16A@% 13% A2G%61A$#1A'2#C 6%11A2$6U
F%64A1% CAIA1%@ %GA@%28% '( %((A8#85D 13% ?6% '( 2%S 1%832'C'$A%6 ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0 10%#1I%21D 40'1'2 13%0#45 3#6 640%#@ SA@%C5U "0'1'2 13%0#45 A6 SA@%C5 ?6%@ A2 64%8A#CAT%@ 8%21%06U
;'S%G%0D 6A28% #2 AI40'G%I%21 3#6 2'1 N%%2 63'S2 A2 13% A2G%61A$#1A'2#C
6%11A2$D AI40'G%I%21 8#22'1 N% #11#A2%@ '?16A@% 13% A2G%61A$#1A'2#C 6%11A2$U
+9 70A1%0A'2 c A6 2'1 I%1
7<M7-:J,<M
,2 6?II#05D 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 3#6 N%%2 SA@%C5 ?6%@ ('0 13% 10%#1I%21 '( C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0U ,2 2'20#2@'IAT%@ 61?@A%6D 0#1%6 '( @A6%#6% (0%% 40'$0%66A'2 #44%#0 1' N% (#G'0#NC% #2@ #C13'?$3 6A@% %((%816 #0% 8'II'2D 0#1%6 '( 6A$2A(A8#21 1'XA8A15 #0% 0%C#1AG%C5 C'SU ;'S%G%0D 13%0% A6 CAIA1%@ %GA@%28% '( 8'I4#0#1AG% %((A8#85 SA13 '13%0 40'61#1% 8#28%0 10%#1I%216U +3% I#A2 00%8%21 %8%21 =7+ %G#C?#1A2$ 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 #81?#CC5 8'I4#0%@ C'S @'6% SA13 3A$3 @'6% 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 #2@ @A@ 2'1 A28C?@% # $0'?4 13#1 @A@ 2'1 0%8%AG% 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45U +3% 8'I4#0A6'26 SA13 '13%0 10%#1I%216 YN0#83513%0#45D ,E=+Z 3#G% N%%2 CAIA1%@ N5 N%A2$ 0%10'64%81AG% 8#6% I#183%@ #2#C56%6 #2@ 3#G% A28C?@%@ 4#1A%216 10%#1%@ @?0A2$ @A((%0%21 1AI% 4%0A'@6U 4%0A'@6U +3?6 13% 0'C% '( 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 ('0 C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0 SA13A2 13% 8?00%21 CA61 '( 10%#1I%21 '41A'26 0%I#A26 ?28C%#0U
"#$% [P '( )*
=.7<EE.MF9+,<M
,1 A6 0%8'II%2@%@ 13#1 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 ('0 C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0 @'%6 2'1 I%%1 7+9K 80A1%0A# ) '0 c ('0 6#(%15D %((A8#85 #2@ AI40'G%I%21 A2 3%#C13 '?18'I%6U
#&$ 3#!4 52'$) 6(.$1 '7'$ 7' 826(0 (8 .&$ 0$%(--$'12.7(' 2, 907..$' 2'1 '('$ (::(,$1;
D
<81'N%0 &OD *P&*
+3A6 A6 13% (A061 0%GA%S '( 13A6 1%832'C'$5 N5 7+9KU
"#$% [& '( )*
=.7<EE.MF9+,<MJ <K <+;.=J LC?% 70'66 LC?% J3A%C@ 966'8A#1A'2 +%832'C'$5 .G#C?#1A'2 7%21%0 YL7LJ9 +.7Z L7LJ9 +.7 4%0('0I%@ #2 #66%66I%21 '2 13A6 1%832'C'$5 A6 >?2% *P&&U +3% #66%66I%21 noted that “Good comparative studies are lacking for…comparisons addressed in the Assessment”, that “There is inadequate evidence from comparative studies to permit conclusions….” and therefore the technology did not meet BCBSA TEC criteria. The
#66%66I%21 8#2 N% ('?2@ #1 3114/bbSSSUN8N6U8'IbNC?%0%6'?08%6b1%8bG'C6b*cb40'1'2^ N%#I^13%0#45^('0^&U31IC N%#I^13%0#45^('0^&U31IC
7#2#@A#2 9$%285 ('0 F0?$6 #2@ +%832'C'$A%6 A2 ;%#C13 Y79F+;Z ,2 *PPWD 79F+; 4?NCA63%@ # CAIA1%@ CA1%0#1?0% 6%#083 1' #@@0%66 13% ('CC'SA2$ ('?0 R?%61A'26/ &U B3#1 A6 13% 8CA2A8#C %((%81AG%2%66 '( 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 (' ('00 G#0A'?6 A2@A8#1A'26 A28C?@A2$ @A((%0%21 154%6 '( 8#28%0o *U ,6 13%0% %GA@%28% 13#1 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 A6 8CA2A8#CC5 I'0% %((%81AG% ('0 64%8A(A8 A2@A8#1A'26 S3%2 8'I4#0%@ SA13 8'2G%21A'2#C 10%#1I%21 '41A'26o [U B3#1 A6 13% 8'61 %((%81AG%2%66 '( 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45o )U B3#1 #0% 13% $?A@%CA2%6 ('0 ?6% '( 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45o +3% CA61 '( @'8?I%216 8#2 N% ('?2@ #1 3114/bbSSSU8#@13U8#bI%@A#b4@(b31A6b"0'1'2d*PL%#Id*P+3%0#45d*P7CA2A8#Cd*P#2@d*P 7'61^.((%81AG%2%66d*P#2@d*PH?A@%CA2%6d*P('0d*P:6%U4@(
"#$% [* '( )*
M#1A'2#C ,261A1?1% ('0 ;%#C13 #2@ 7CA2A8#C .X8%CC%28% YM,7.Z +3%0% A6 2' 64%8A(A8 I%21A'2 '( 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 A2 13% M,7. 8CA2A8#C $?A@%CA2% 4?NCA63%@ A2 K%N0?#05D *PPW/ 3<=>? 50(,.2.$ 32'%$0 – 172*'(,7, 2'1 .0$2.-$'. U +3% 8CA2A8#C $?A@%CA2% 8#2 N% ('?2@ #1 3114/bb4?NCA8#1A'26U2A8%U'0$U?]b40'61#1%^8#28%0^8$cW U
9$%285 ('0 ;%#C138#0% =%6%#083 #2@ n?#CA15 Y9;=nZ +3% 9;=n +%832'C'$5 966%66I%21 "0'$0#I 4?NCA63%@ 13% 1%832'C'$5 #66%66I%21 A2 9?$?61 *P&P/ 3(-:202.76$ $62)/2.7(' (8 02172.7(' .0$2.-$'., 8(0 %)7'7%2))+ )(%2)7@$1 :0(,.2.$ %2'%$0? 2' /:12.$; +3% 1%832'C'$5 #66%66I%21 2'1%@ that “…current review dA@ 2'1
A@%21A(5 #25 8'I4#0#1AG% 61?@A%6 %G#C?#1A2$ 13% 0'C% '( 4#01A8C% 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45 Y%U$UD 40'1'2Z A2 13e treatment of prostate cancer.” The technology assessment can be found at 3114/bbSSSU8I6U$'GbI%@A8#0%^8'G%0#$%^@#1#N#6%b@%1#AC6b1%832'C'$5^#66%66I%216^ @%1#AC6U#64Xo+9,@j`epN8jL99$99999999p @%1#AC6U#64Xo+9,@j`epN8jL99$99999999p 9;=n (?2@%@ # 6561%I#1A8 0%GA%S #2@ $?A@%D 3(-:202.76$ A88$%.76$'$,, (8 #&$02:7$, 8(0 3)7'7%2))+ B(%2)7@$1 50(,.2.$ 32'%$0 CDEE>FG 13#1 S#6 40%4#0%@ N5 13% EA22%6'1#
.GA@%28%^L#6%@ "0#81A8% 7%21%0U KA2@A2$6 0%C%G#21 1' 13A6 #66%66I%21 A28C?@%/ “Radiation therapy with 40'1'26 I#5 AI40'G% @'6% @A610AN?1A'2 SA13 3A$3%0 @'6%6
@%CAG%0%@ C'8#CC5 1' 13% 1?I'0 40%6%0GA2$ 6?00'?2@A2$ 3%#C135 1A66?%6U ;'S%G%0D 2' 0#2@'IAT%@ 10A#C6 3#G% %G#C?#1%@ 13% 8'I4#0#1AG% %((%81AG%2%66 '( 40'1'26 G6U 43'1'26 A2 I%2 SA13 C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0U “No randomized trials were found that compared clinical outcomes of proton beam
radiation therapy versus other therapies.”
+3% 0%GA%S 8#2 N% ('?2@ #1 3114/bbSSSU%((%81AG%3%#C138#0%U#30RU$'Gb0%4KAC%6b*PPWiP*P)"0'61#1%7#28%0KA2#CU4@( 3114/bbSSSU%((%81AG%3%#C138#0%U#30RU$'Gb0%4KAC%6b*PPWiP*P)"0'61#1%7#28%0KA2#CU4@(
"#$% [[ '( )*
M#1A'2#C 7'I40%3%26AG% 7#28%0 M%1S'0] YM77MZ +3% M77M 3)7'7%2) 502%.7%$ </71$)7'$, H' I'%()(*+? </71$)7'$ J$0,7(' K;DELD? 50(,.2.$ 32'%$0 61#1%6 61#1%6 13% ('CC'SA2$ 0%$#0@A2$ 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45/ 13%0#45/ “"0'1'2 N%#I6 8#2 N% ?6%@ #6 #2 #C1%02#1AG% 0#@A#1A'2 6'?08%U +3%'0%1A8#CC5D
40'1'26 I#5 0%#83 @%%4C5^C'8#1%@ 1?I'06 SA13 C%66 @#I#$% 1' 6?00'?2@A2$ 1A66?%6U ;'S%G%0D 40'1'2 13%0#45 A6 2'1 0%8'II%2@%@ ('0 0'?1A2% ?6% #1 13A6 1AI%D 6A28% 8CA2A8#C 10A#C6 3#G% 2'1 5%1 5A%C@%@ @#1# 13#1 @%I'2610#1%6 6?4%0A'0A15 1'D '0 %R?AG#C%28% '(D 40'1'2 N%#I #2@ 8'2G%21A'2#C %X1%02#C N%#I ('0 10%#1I%21 '( 40'61#1% 8#28%0U” +3% M77M $?A@%CA2% 8#2 N% ('?2@ #1 3114/bbSSSU2882U'0$b40'(%66A'2#C6b4356A8A#2i$C6b4@(b40'61#1%U4@(
9I%0A8#2 7#28%0 J'8A%15 Y97JZ +3% 97J S%N6A1% 63'S6 13% ('CC'SA2$ A2('0I#1A'2 #N'?1 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45/ “"0'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 A6 0%C#1%@ 1' [F^7=+ #2@ ?6%6 # 6AIAC#0 #440'#83U L?1 A261%#@ '(
?6A2$ X^0#56D 13A6 1%832AR?% ('8?6%6 40'1'2 N%#I6 '2 13% 8#28%0U "0'1'26 #0% 4'6A1AG% 4#016 '( #1'I6U :2CA]% X^0#56D S3A83 0%C%#6% %2%0$5 N'13 N%('0% #2@ #(1%0 13%5 3A1 13%A0 1#0$%1D 40'1'26 8#?6% CA11C% @#I#$% 1' 1A66?%6 13%5 4#66 130'?$3 #2@ 13%2 0%C%#6% 13%A0 %2%0$5 #(1%0 10#G%CA2$ # 8%01#A2 @A61#28%U +3A6 I%#26 13#1 40'1'2 N%#I 0#@A#1A'2 I#5 N% #NC% 1' @%CAG%0 I'0% 0#@A#1A'2 1' 13% 40'61#1% #2@ @' C%66 @#I#$% 1' 2%#0N5 2'0I#C 1A66?%6U 9C13'?$3 %#0C5 0%6?C16 #0% 40'IA6A2$D 61?@A%6 #0% 2%%@%@ 1' 6%% A( 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 A6 N%11%0 A2 13% C'2$^0?2 13#2 '13%0 154%6 '( %X1%02#C N%#I 0#@A#1A'2U =A$31 2'SD 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 A6 2'1 SA@%C5 #G#AC#NC%U +3% I#83A2%6 "#$% [) '( )*
2%%@%@ 1' I#]% 40'1'26 #0% %X4%26AG%D #2@ 13%0% #0% '2C5 # 3#2@(?C '( 13%I A2 ?6% A2 13% :2A1%@ J1#1%6U "0'1'2 N%#I 0#@A#1A'2 I#5 2'1 N% 8'G%0%@ N5 #CC A26?0#28% 8'I4#2A%6 #1 13A6 1AI%U 1AI%U” 3114/bbSSSU8#28%0U'0$b7#28%0b"0'61#1%7#28%0bF%1#AC%@H?A@%b40'61#1%^8#28%0^ 10%#1A2$^0#@A#1A'2^13%0#45hh #88%66%@ '2 eb*`b&*U 10%#1A2$^0#@A#1A'2^13%0#45 eb*`b&*U
7%21%06 ('0 E%@A8#0% #2@ E%@A8#A@ J%0GA8%6 Y7EJZ +3%0% A6 2' M#1A'2#C 7'G%0#$% F%1%0IA2#1A'2 YM7FZ ('0 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0U 7'G%0#$% ('0 13% 40'8%@?0% A6 @%1%0IA2%@ ?2@%0 -'8#C 7'G%0#$% F%1%0IA2#1A'2 Y-7FZU 9I%0A8#2 7'CC%$% '( =#@A'C'$5 Y97=Z 97= @A@ 2'1 40'GA@% #2 '4A2A'2 '2 13A6 1%832'C'$5 2'0 6%2@ # 0%40%6%21#1AG% 1' 13% 7+9K 4?NCA8 I%%1A2$U
9I%0A8#2 7'CC%$% '( =#@A#1A'2 <28'C'$5 Y97=<Z 97=< @A@ 2'1 40'GA@% #2 '4A2A'2 '2 13A6 1%832'C'$5 2'0 6%2@ # 0%40%6%21#1AG% 1' 13% 7+9K 4?NCA8 I%%1A2$U
9I%0A8#2 J'8A%15 ('0 =#@A#1A'2 <28'C'$5 Y9J+=<Z 9J+=< 40'GA@%@ #2 '4A2A'2 '2 13A6 1%832'C'$5 #2@ 6%21 # 0%40%6%21#1AG% 1' 13% 7+9K 4?NCA8 I%%1A2$U
"#$% [c '( )*
9I%0A8#2 :0'C'$A8#C 966'8A#1A'2 Y9:9Z 9:9 @A@ 2'1 40'GA@% #2 '4A2A'2 '2 13A6 1%832'C'$5 2'0 6%2@ # 0%40%6%21#1AG% 1' 13% 7+9K 4?NCA8 I%%1A2$U ,2 A16 $?A@%CA2%/ 50(,.2.$ 32'%$0 </71$)7'$ 8(0 .&$ M2'2*$-$'. (8 3)7'7%2))+ B(%2)7@$1 50(,.2.$ 32'%$0? DEEN C0$67$9$1 2'1 62)717.+ %('870-$1 7' DELLFG 13% 9:9 61#1%6 13#1
q.X1%02#C N%#I 0#@A'13%0#45 A6 A2@A8#1%@ #6 # 8?0#1AG% 10%#1I%21 ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0 A2 I%2 S3' @' 2'1 3#G% # 3A61'05 '( A2(C#II#1'05 N'S%C @A6%#6% 6?83 #6 70'32’6 @A6%#6%D ?C8%0#1AG% 8'CA1A6D '0 # 3A61'0y of prior pelvic radiotherapy….techniques include a CT scan for 10%#1I%21 4C#22A2$ #2@ %A13%0 # I?C1AC%#( 8'CCAI# tor, IMRT, or proton radiotherapy….” The 9:9 $?A@%CA2% 8#2 N% ('?2@ #1 3114/bbSSSU#?#2%1U'0$b8'21%21b8CA2A8#C^40#81A8%^ $?A@%CA2%6b8CA2A8#C^$?A@%CA2%6bI#A2^0%4'016b40'68#2POb8'21%21U4@( $?A@%CA2%6b8CA2A8#C^$?A@%CA2%6bI#A2^0%4'016b40'68#2POb8'21%21U4@(
966'8A#1A'2 '( M'013%02 79 <28'C'$A616 Y9M7<Z 9M7< 6%21 #2 '4A2A'2 '2 13A6 1%832'C'$5 N?1 @A@ 2'1 6%2@ # 0%40%6%21#1AG% 1' 13% 7+9K 4?NCA8 I%%1A2$U
7#CA('02A# =#@A'C'$A8#C J'8A%15 Y7=JZ 7=J @A@ 2'1 6%2@ #2 '4A2A'2 '2 13A6 1%832'C'$5 2'0 6%2@ # 0%40%6%21#1AG% 1' 13% 7+9K 4?NCA8 I%%1A2$U
7#CA('02A# :0'C'$A8#C 966'8A#1A'2 Y7:9Z 7:9 40'GA@%@ #2 '4A2A'2 '2 13A6 1%832'C'$5 #2@ 6%21 # 0%40%6%21#1AG% 1' 13% 7+9K 4?NCA8 I%%1A2$U
"#$% [` '( )*
+3% M#1A'2#C 966'8A#1A'2 K'0 "0'1'2 +3%0#45 +3% M#1A'2#C 966'8A#1A'2 ('0 "0'1'2 +3%0#45 40'GA@%@ '4A2A'26 '2 13A6 1%832'C'$5 GA# 6%G%0#C '( A16 I%IN%0 '0$#2AT#1A'26 #2@ 6%21 I?C1A4C% I%IN%0 '0$#2AT#1A'2 0%40%6%21#1AG%6 1' 13% 7+9K 4?NCA8 I%%1A2$U
"#$% [O '( )*
9LL=._,9+,<MJ :J.F ,M +;,J 9JJ.JJE.M+/ MH/
M#2'$0#I6
"J9/ [F^7=+/
"0'61#1% J4%8A(A8 921A$%2 +30%% FAI%26A'2#C 7'2('0I#C =#@A#1A'2 +3%0#45
M77M/
M#1A'2#C 7'I40%3%26AG% 7#28%0 M%1S'0]
H5/
H0#5
=L./
=%C#1AG% LA'C'$A8#C .((%81AG%2%66
H5./
H0#5 .R?AG#C%216 YH5.Z
7H./
7'N#C1 H0#5 %R?AG#C%216
F9=./
F#1#N#6% '( 9N610#816 '( =%GA%S6 '( .((%816
.L=+/
.X1%02#C L%#I =#@A#1A'2 +3%0#45
H,/
H#610'A21%61A2#C
H:/
H%2A1'?0A2#05
g=+/
g^0#5 +3%0#45
"",/
"%0I#2%21 "0'61#1% ,I4C#21 L0#83513%0#45
7"L=+/
7'2('0I#C "0'1'2 L%#I +3%0#45
NM.F/
LA'83%IA8#C M' .GA@%28% '( FA6%#6%
=+<H/ <J
=#@A#1A'2 +3%0#45 <28'C'$5 H0'?4 <G%0#CC J?0GAG#C
FJJ
FA6%#6% J4%8A(A8 J?0GAG#C
+=KJ
+'1#C =%8?00%28%^K0%% J?0GAG#C
E_/
E%$#G'C16
LK/
LA'83%IA8#C K#AC?0%
9J+=</
9I%0A8#2 J'8A%15 ('0 +3%0#4%?1A8 <28'C'$5
,E=+/
,21%26A15 E'@?C#1%@ =#@A#1A'2 +3%0#45
"#$% [W '( )*
"=<H^ec^Pe/ "0'1'2 =#@A#1A'2 <28'C'$5 H0'?4 H0'?4 Y Y"=<H "=<HZb9I%0A8#2 Zb9I%0A8#2 7'CC%$% '( =#@A'C'$5 Y97=Z ec^ ec^Pe Y# Pe Y# 0#2@'IAT%@ 10A#CZ n-,/ "+JJ/
n?#CA15 '( -A(% ,2@%X J'?13S%61 <28'C'$5 H0'?4 "0'61#1% +0%#1I%21 J4%8A(A8 J5I41'I6 E%#6?0%
J..=/
J?0G%ACC#28%D .4A@%IA'C'$5D #2@ .2@ =%6?C16
==/
=%C#1AG% =A6]
7U,U/
7'2(A@%28% ,21%0G#C
;U=U/
;#T#0@ =#1A'
"#$% [e '( )*
=.K.=.M7.J &U *U [U )U cU `U OU WU eU &PU &&U &*U
&[U
&)U
&cU
&`U
9I%0A8#2 7#28%0 J'8A%15U 7#28%0 K#816 p KA$?0%6 *P&*U *P&*U M#1A'2#C 7'I40%3%26AG% 7#28%0 M%1S'0]U "0'61#1% 7#28%0U *P&*U M$?5%2 "-D H? gD -A46A1T J=D %1 #CU 7'61 AI4CA8#1A'26 '( 13% 0#4A@ #@'41A'2 '( 2%S%0 1%832'C'$A%6 ('0 10%#1A2$ 40'61#1% 8#28%0U O 3)7' I'%(); 940 *P *P&&h*eY&*Z/&c&O^&c*)U ,261A1?1% '( E%@A8A2% '( 13% M#1A'2#C 98#@%IA86U &PP ,2A1A#C "0A'0A15 +'4A86 ('0 7'I4#0#1AG% .((%81AG%2%66 =%6%#083U BAC6'2 ==U =#@A'C'$A8#C ?6% '( (#61 40'1'26U P217()(*+; M'G &e)`h)OYcZ/)WO^)e&U 7#610' >=U =%6?C16 '( 3%#G5 A'2 0#@A'13%0#45U P2172. A'670(' Q7(:&+,; E#0 &eech[)Y&Z/)c^)WU K#C]I%0 JD K'06 LD -#066'2 LD -A2@%CC 9D M#%6C?2@ >D J1%26'2 JU "AC'1 61?@5 '2 40'1'2 A00#@A#1A'2 '( 3?I#2 8#08A2'I#U !%.2 0217(); K%N &e`*hcW/[[^c&U V\%CCN%0$ =MD J3A21#2A 9D K0#21T 9HD VCAI#2 LU "0'1'2^N%#I 13%0#45 A2 #80'I%$#C5U R A'*) O M$1; E#0 *W &e`Wh*OWY&[Z/`We^`ecU JC#1%0 >FU F%G%C'4I%21 #2@ '4%0#1A'2 '( 13% -'I# -A2@# :2AG%06A15 E%@A8#C 7%21%0 40'1'2 (#8ACA15U #$%&'() 32'%$0 P$, #0$2.; 9?$ *PPOh`Y) J?44CZ/`O^O*U H''T2%0 EU +3% 40'1'2 N%#I @%N#1%/ #0% (#8ACA1A%6 '?1610A44A2$ 13% %GA@%28%o O R2.) 32'%$0 H',.; 940 O *P&Ph&P*YOZ/)cP^)c[U lA%1I#2 9-U +3% +A1#2A8 #2@ 13% ,8%N%0$/ 40'61#1% 40'1'2 13%0#45 #2@ 3%#C13 8#0% %8'2'IA86U O 3)7' I'%(); 9?$ *P *PPOh*cY*)Z/[c`c^[c``U E#5#3#0# ;D E?0#]#IA ED V#$#S# VD %1 #CU 98?1% I'0NA@A15 '( 40'1'2 13%0#45 ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0/ 13% ;5'$' ,'2 L%#I E%@A8#C 7%21%0 %X4%0A%28%U H'. O P2172. I'%() Q7() 5&+,; <81 & *PPOh`eY*Z/)[)^))[U E%2@%23#CC M"D -A lD ;'44% LJD %1 #CU .#0C5 '?18'I%6 (0'I 130%% 40'64%81AG% 10A#C6 '( AI#$%^$?A@%@ 40'1'2 13%0#45 ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0U H'. O P2172. I'%() Q7() 5&+,; >#2 & *P&*hW*Y&Z/*&[^**&U MA3%A VD <$A2' +D ,63A]?0# JD %1 #CU "3#6% ,, (%#6ANACA15 61?@5 '( 3A$3^@'6% 0#@A'13%0#45 ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0 ?6A2$ 40'1'2 N''61 13%0#45/ (A061 8CA2A8#C 10A#C '( 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0 A2 >#4#2U O:' O 3)7' I'%(); F%8 *PPch[cY&*Z/O)c^Oc*U MA3%A VD <$A2' +D <2'T#S# ED %1 #CU E?C1A^A261A1?1A'2#C "3#6% ,, 61?@5 '( 40'1'2 N%#I 13%0#45 ('0 '0$#2^8'2(A2%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0 ('8?6A2$ '2 13% A28A@%28% '( C#1% 0%81#C 1'XA8A1A%6U H'. O P2172. I'%() Q7() 5&+,; <81 & *P&&hW&Y*Z/[eP^[e`U H#0@2%0 LHD lA%1I#2 9-D J3A4C%5 B:D J]'S0'26]A :.D E8E#2?6 "U -#1% 2'0I#C 1A66?% 6%R?%C#% A2 13% 6%8'2@ @%8#@% #(1%0 3A$3 @'6% 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45 SA13 8'INA2%@ 43'1'26 #2@ 8'2('0I#C 40'1'26 ('0 C'8#CC5 #@G#28%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0U O S0(); >#2 *PP*h&`OY&Z/&*[^&*`U
"#$% )P '( )*
&OU
JC#1%0 >FD ='66A 7>D >0UD Q'2%I'1' -+D %1 #CU "0'1'2 13%0#45 ('0 40'61#1% 8#28%0/ 13% A2A1A#C -'I# -A2@# :2AG%06A15 %X4%0A%28%U H'. O P2172. I'%() Q7() 5&+,; >?2 & *PP)hceY*Z/[)W^[c*U
&WU
>'3#266'2 JD 9610'I -D J#2@A2 KD ,6#866'2 :D E'21%CA?6 9D +?0%66'2 ,U ;54'(0#81A'2#1%@ 40'1'2 N''61 8'INA2%@ SA13 %X1%02#C N%#I 0#@A'13%0#45 ('0 10%#1I%21 '( C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0U 50(,.2.$ 32'%$0; *P&*h*P&*/`c)W`&U lA%1I#2 9-D L#% VD JC#1%0 >FD %1 #CU =#2@'IAT%@ 10A#C 8'I4#0A2$ 8'2G%21A'2#C^@'6% SA13 3A$3^@'6% 8'2('0I#C 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45 A2 %#0C5^61#$% #@%2'8#08A2'I# '( 13% 40'61#1%/ C'2$^1%0I 0%6?C16 (0'I 40'1'2 0#@A#1A'2 '28'C'$5 $0'?4b#I%0A8#2 8'CC%$% '( 0#@A'C'$5 ec^PeU O 3)7' I'%(); E#0 & *P&Ph*WYOZ/&&P`^&&&&U lA%1I#2 9-D F%JACGA' E-D JC#1%0 >FD %1 #CU 7'I4#0A6'2 '( 8'2G%21A'2#C^@'6% G6 3A$3^ @'6% 8'2('0I#C 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45 A2 8CA2A8#CC5 C'8#CAT%@ #@%2'8#08A2'I# '( 13% 40'61#1%/ # 0#2@'IAT%@ 8'210'CC%@ 10A#CU O!M!; J%4 &) *PPch*e)Y&PZ/&*[[^&*[eU +#C8'11 >9D ='66A 7D J3A4C%5 B:D %1 #CU "#1A%21^0%4'01%@ C'2$^1%0I '?18'I%6 #(1%0 8'2G%21A'2#C #2@ 3A$3^@'6% 8'INA2%@ 40'1'2 #2@ 43'1'2 0#@A#1A'2 ('0 %#0C5 40'61#1% 8#28%0U O!M!; E#0 &O *P&Ph[P[Y&&Z/&P)`^&Pc[U J3A4C%5 B:D _%03%5 ->D E?2T%20A@%0 >.D %1 #CU 9@G#28%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0/ 13% 0%6?C16 '( # 0#2@'IAT%@ 8'I4#0#1AG% 10A#C '( 3A$3 @'6% A00#@A#1A'2 N''61A2$ SA13 8'2('0I#C 40'1'26 8'I4#0%@ SA13 8'2G%21A'2#C @'6% A00#@A#1A'2 ?6A2$ 43'1'26 #C'2%U H'. O P2172. I'%() Q7() 5&+,; 940 [P &eech[*Y&Z/[^&*U J3%%16 M7D H'C@A2 H;D E%5%0 9ED %1 #CU ,21%26A15^I'@?C#1%@ 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45D 40'1'2 13%0#45D '0 8'2('0I#C 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45 #2@ I'0NA@A15 #2@ @A6%#6% 8'210'C A2 C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0U O!M!; 940 &W *P&*h[POY&cZ/&`&&^&`*PU F?11%23#G%0 >=D J3A4C%5 B:D "%00'2% +D %1 #CU "0'1'26 '0 I%$#G'C1#$% g^0#56 #6 N''61 13%0#45 ('0 4#1A%216 A00#@A#1%@ ('0 C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1A8 8#08A2'I#U 92 %#0C5 43#6% ,b,, 8'I4#0A6'2U 32'%$0; E#5 & &eW[hc&YeZ/&cee^&`P)U H#CN0#A13 E.D =#IA0%T >ED "%@0' -BU n?#CA15 '( CA(%D 3%#C13 '?18'I%6D #2@ A@%21A15 ('0 4#1A%216 SA13 40'61#1% 8#28%0 A2 (AG% @A((%0%21 10%#1I%21 $0'?46U I'%() R/0, 4(0/-; 940 *PP&h*WY[Z/cc&^c`PU >#NN#0A JD B%A2N%0$ _VD J3A2'3#0# VD %1 #CU .R?AG#C%21 NA'83%IA8#C 8'210'C #2@ AI40'G%@ 40'61#1%^64%8A(A8 #21A$%2 2#@A0 #(1%0 4%0I#2%21 40'61#1% 6%%@ AI4C#21 N0#83513%0#45 G%06?6 3A$3^@'6% 130%%^@AI%26A'2#C 8'2('0I#C 0#@A'13%0#45 #2@ 3A$3^@'6% 8'2('0I#C 40'1'2 N%#I 0#@A'13%0#45 N''61U H'. O P2172. I'%() Q7() 5&+,; >#2 & *P&PhO`Y&Z/[`^)*U 7'%2 >>D lA%1I#2 9-D ='66A 7>D %1 #CU 7'I4#0A6'2 '( 3A$3^@'6% 40'1'2 0#@A'13%0#45 #2@ N0#83513%0#45 A2 C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0/ # 8#6%^I#183%@ #2#C56A6U H'. O P2172. I'%() Q7() 5&+,; >#2 & *P&*hW*Y&Z/%*c^[&U
&eU
*PU
*&U
**U
*[U
*)U
*cU
*`U
*OU
"#$% )& '( )*
*WU
*eU
[PU
[&U [*U
[[U [)U
='#83 ED [0@D ;#2]6 HD +3#I%6 ;D >0UD %1 #CU F%(A2A2$ NA'83%IA8#C (#AC?0% ('CC'SA2$ 0#@A'13%0#45 SA13 '0 SA13'?1 3'0I'2#C 13%0#45 A2 I%2 SA13 8CA2A8#CC5 C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0/ 0%8'II%2@#1A'26 '( 13% =+<H^9J+=< "3'%2AX 7'26%26?6 7'2(%0%28%U H'. O P2172. I'%() Q7() 5&+,; >?C &c *PP`h`cY)Z/e`c^eO)U 7'26%26?6 61#1%I%21/ $?A@%CA2%6 ('0 "J9 ('CC'SA2$ 0#@A#1A'2 13%0#45U 9I%0A8#2 J'8A%15 ('0 +3%0#4%?1A8 =#@A'C'$5 #2@ <28'C'$5 7'26%26?6 "#2%CU H'. O P2172. I'%() Q7() 5&+,; E#0 &c &eeOh[OYcZ/&P[c^&P)&U 7'X >FD J1%1T >D "#\#] +KU +'XA8A15 80A1%0A# '( 13% =#@A#1A'2 +3%0#45 <28'C'$5 H0'?4 Y=+<HZ #2@ 13% .?0'4%#2 <0$#2AT#1A'2 ('0 =%6%#083 #2@ +0%#1I%21 '( 7#28%0 Y.<=+7ZU H'. O P2172. I'%() Q7() 5&+,; E#0 [P &eech[&YcZ/&[)&^&[)`U E'3C%0 >D L#326'2 ==D L'61'2 LD %1 #CU M77M 8CA2A8#C 40#81A8% $?A@%CA2%6 A2 '28'C'$5/ 40'61#1% 8#28%0U O R2.) 3(-:0 32'% R$.9; R$.9; K%N *P&PhWY*Z/&c`U 9CA8A]?6 l9D Q#I#@# QD l3#2$ lD %1 #CU +%2^5%#0 '?18'I%6 '( 3A$3^@'6%D A21%26A15^ I'@?C#1%@ 0#@A'13%0#45 ('0 C'8#CAT%@ 40'61#1% 8#28%0U 32'%$0; 940 & *P&&h&&OYOZ/&)*e^&)[OU "#@ACC# H_U _#CA@A15 '( 3%#C13^0%C#1%@ R?#CA15 '( CA(% 6?N68#C%6U 50(* 32017(62,% R/0,; >#2^E#0 &ee*hOY&Z/&[^*PU E'A24'?0 7ED ;#5@%2 V9D +3'I46'2 ,ED K%A$C "D E%183 LU n?#CA15 '( CA(% #66%66I%21 A2 J'?13S%61 <28'C'$5 H0'?4 10A#C6U I'%()(*+ CT7))7,.(' 520UF; E#5 &eePh)YcZ/Oe^W)D Weh @A68?66A'2 &P)U
"#$% )* '( )*
