of 6

Sentencia Harmony

Published on last month | Categories: Documents | Downloads: 2 | Comments: 0



Expte. N°: 18/13 -Foja: 184- SR. DEFENSOR DEL PUEBLO DE LA PROVINIA DEL !AO S/AION DE INONS"I"UIONALIDAD INONS"I"UIONALIDAD # SEN"ENIA N$1%8/1& !SP'!N° 1%8- E( )a *+,a e Re+te(*+a *ap+ta) e )a P0o+(*+a e) 2a*o a )o e+(t+e+ a e) e e a5oto e) a6o o +) 7,+(*e 0e,(+o )o Se6o0e ',e*e e) S,pe0+o0 "0+,(a) e ',t+*+a D0e. 9ARA LUISA LUAS ALBER"O 9ARIO 9ODI ; ROLANDO I<NAIO "OLEDO toa0o( *o(o*++e(to pa0a , 0eo),*+=( e>+(+t+a e) Expe+e(te N° 18/13 *a0at,)ao: ?SR. DEFENSOR DEL PUEBLO DE LA PROVINIA DEL !AO S/  A[email protected] DE INONS"I"UIONA INONS"I"UIONALIDAD? LIDAD? p)a(te(oe )a +5,+e(te: UES"IONES I. E p0o*ee(te )a a**+=( e +(*o(t+t,*+o(a)+a e,*+aC II. E( , *ao 7, p0o(,(*+a+e(to *o00epo(e +*ta0C ota  2o(o0a0+o. I. A LA PRI9ERA UES"[email protected] LOS SEORES 'UEES DI'ERON:  A >. GH/GG *opa0e*e e) D0. D0. <,tao Ao)>o Ao)>o o00e5+o e( e) *a0*te0 e De>e(o0 e) P,e)o *o( pat0o*+(+o )et0ao e) D0. 9a,0o E*2ea00eta  p0o,ee a**+=( e +(*o(t+t,*+o(a) *o(t0a )a O0e(a(a N$ 1H.H8J e >e*2a 1J/1J/1H +*taa po0 e) o(*ejo 9,(+*+pa) e )a *+,a e Re+te(*+a  )a Reo),*+=( N$ J.&K% (o0a p0o,)5ato0+aM a )o >+(e e p0+a0)a e too e>e*to j,0+*o o *o(e*,e(*+a e( )o *o(*e0(+e(te a )a ?>a*t++)+a e o*,pa*+=(? e )a Pa0*. 8 9a(. J% +ta e( Fo0oa N$ J&1 e eta *+,a. F,(a , )e5+t+a*+=( a*t+a e( )o eta)e*+o e( e) a0t. 11K 11K +(*. 1% e )a o(t+t,*+=( P0o+(*+a) e( )a Le N$ 41KH -o+>+*aa po0 Le N$ %81G-  e( )a Reo),*+=( N$ 1GGG 7,e )o e+5(a De>e(o0 e) P,e)o e) 2a*o. E( ete e(t+o p0e*+a 7,e +(te0*ee e( a)a5,a0a e) e0e*2o a 5oa0 e ,( a+e(te a(o *o(a50ao exp0eae(te *o( )a 0e>o0a e 1KK4 e( )o a0t. 41  G& +(*. JJ e )a a0ta 9a5(a e( )a o(t+t,*+=(  )ee p0o+(*+a)e *oo a ta+( e( e) +to ,(+*+pa) e( )a a0ta O05(+*a  Le O05(+*a e(t0e ot0o. ; 7,e , +(te0e(*+=( oee*e a) 0e*)ao

7,e )e e>e*t,a0o( )o e*+(o e )a o(a *oo *o(e*,e(*+a e) 0e,)tao e )a *a,a ?9a0*=( R,( A.  ot0o */ 9,(+*+pa)+a e Re+te(*+a / Apa0o? Expte. N$1J.%%4/11 7,e 0e*2a= e) 0e*,0o e +(*o(t+t,*+o(a)+a e,*+o po0 )a a*to0a. Deta))a )o p0e*epto 7,e *o(+e0a +(>0+(5+o e(*+o(a )a +o)a*+=( e) p0+(*+p+o e )e5a)+a e )a *opete(*+a e +(eje*,*+=( e ee0e )a a,e(*+a e )e5+t++a e( e) eje0*+*+o e a,to(oa  poe0 e po)+*a.  A>+0a 7,e e))o e a(+>+eta e( )a o0e(a(a *,et+o(aa 7,e a( a pea0 e 0eet+0 e) *a0*te0 e (o0a +(++,a) (o 0epeta e) o0e( e p0e)a*+=( e )ee e( ta(to e*o(o*e  e0o5a e 2e*2o )a p0e++o(e 0e)at+a a )o 0et+0o e >o(o *o(tep)aa *oo ,( 0e*a,o o)+5ato0+o e( )a O0e(a(a N$ &4H3 )o 7,e ))ea a) +(*,p)++e(to po0 pa0te e) ,(+*+p+o e) ee0 e p0ote5e0 e) e+o a+e(te )a e5,0+a a),0+a e 2+5+e(e. E) 0e*,00e(te +t+(5,e e) ?,o? e )a ?o*,pa*+=(? *+0*,(*0+e e) p0+e0o a )a O0e(a(a N$ 18J8 po0 e+o e )a *,a) e 0e5,)a e) exae( e )a o(a e e*+0 + e) ep0e(++e(to e >*t+)e e(t0o e , 0ea +e(t0a 7,e )a o*,pa*+=( e( *a+o e(*,e(t0a , a0*o (o0at+o e( )a O0e(a(a N$ &4H3 7,e e)++ta *,)e o( )o e*to0e o ,pe0>+*+e e )a pa0*e)a 7,e (o p,ee( e0 ap)+*aa a )a aa e+>+*a)e )o 0et+0o e( a)t,0a et*. E(t+e(e 7,e )a 9,(+*+pa)+a +(*,00+= e( ,(a +00e5,)a0+a a) pe0+t+0 )a ap)+*a*+=( e ,(a t*(+*a e(o+(aa *ope(a*+=( o),t0+*a 7,e +p)+*a t0a)aa0 )a aa e+>+*a)e a ,( ),5a0 (o a,to0+ao 0et+0o e >o(oM. Ete too e*0+pto + +e( e e(*,e(t0a 0e5)ao e( )a *+,a e B,e(o A+0e 0e,)ta ext0a6o a )a =0+ta )o*a). Deta*a )a >a)ta e ot+a*+=( e )a e*++=( aoptaa p,eto 7,e (o oto05a >,(ae(to p0op+o pa0a j,t+>+*a0 )a o+>+*a*+=( e )a ,+*a*+=( e )a aa e+>+*a)e , o*,pa*+=( e) ,e)o. No +e(o ,>+*+e(te e) =)o 2e*2o e ta*2a0)a e ?0ao(a)e?. E) 9,(+*+p+o +(*,00e e( ,(a (oto0+a e+5,a)a  +o)a*+=( e e0e*2o e ,,a0+o  *o(,+o0e a) ex+5+0 a ot0o e*+(o e) 0epeto e) 0et+0o e >o(o e( , *o(t0,**+o(e e +(*),o a) p,(to e +(t+a0 a , *,p)++e(to. La 9,(+*+pa)+a a) 2a+)+ta0 e) ,o e) 0et+0o e >o(o e( )a e+>+*a*+=( ))eaa ae)a(te eta0a +(>0+(5+e(o e) ee0 e (o

a6a0 a) p0+a0 a )o e*+(o e )o e(e>+*+o e ,( a+e(te a(o *o(t+t,+o po0 e) ?p,)=( e a(a(a?.  Ae 0e>+e0e a) 0e*o(o*++e(to po0 )a )e5+)a*+=( (a*+o(a) p0o+(*+a)  ,(+*+pa) e) e0e*2o e )o e*+(o a e0 oo *o( *a0*te0 p0e+o a )a toa e e*++o(e 7,e p,ea( a>e*ta0)o. Ete e0e*2o et +(*,)ao *o( )o a0t. KJ 1HH  1&3 e )a a0ta O05(+*a 9,(+*+pa) 7,e o0e(a( )a +(te0e(*+=( e ,( 0ea +(te0+*+p)+(a0+a e( too )o *o(*e0(+e(te a )a 5et+=( ,0a(t+*a  )a *o(o*ato0+a p0e+a a a,+e(*+a p)+*a. S+ +e( )a a,+e(*+a e ))e= a *ao (o )o >,e e( )a etapa p0e+a o)+5ato0+a a) +*tao e )a o0e(a(a *,et+o(aa. o(*),e , a05,e(ta*+=( *+ta(o a )a o0te S,p0ea e ',t+*+a e )a Na*+=( 7,e ao*t0+(a e( *,a(to a) e+o a+e(te *oo +e( e +(*+e(*+a *o)e*t+a 7,e pe0te(e*e a )a e>e0a o*+a)  t0a+(++,a) *,a ejo0a o e50aa*+=( a>e*ta a )a po)a*+=( 7,e +po0ta p0+o0+a ao),ta e( )a p0ee(*+=( e) a6o >,t,0o. O>0e*e p0,ea  >+(a)+a *o( pet+to0+o e et+)o.  A >. G8 e )o t+e(e po0 p0ee(tao  e *o00e +ta a) P0o*,0ao0 <e(e0a) 7,+( e exp+e po0 D+*tae( N$ 888/13 >. GK  ta.M. A >. 83/84 po0 Reo),*+=( N$ 3G%/13 e e*)a0a >o0a)e(te a++)e )a a**+=( e +(*o(t+t,*+o(a)+a +(te0p,eta  e *o00e t0a)ao.  A >. KH/1JH e p0ee(ta )a ea(aa 9,(+*+pa)+a e Re+te(*+a a t0a e , )et0ao apoe0ao Pat0+*+a E)e(a <,+ta0t  A(5e) 9a0*e)o De)oo  0e7,+e0e( e) 0e*2ao e )a ea(a. Sot+e(e( 7,e pee a )a a+++)+a e )a a**+=( (o e e(*o(t0a0a( 0e,(+o )o 0e7,++to pa0a , p0o*ee(*+a p,e e) "0+,(a) (o a(a)+= )a )e5+t++a e )a +(te0e(*+=( e) De>e(o0 e) P,e)o e( *,a(to a )a 0ep0ee(ta*+=( +(o*aa )e5a)+a /o )e5+t++a e )o a*to ata*ao e( >,(*+=( e )a a,to0+a 7,e )o +*t=  )a ex+te(*+a e ot0o t0+te j,+*+a) o0e )a +a *,et+=( *o( e(te(*+a. E50+e( 7,e a te(o0 e )o p0e*0+pto po0 e) a0t. 8 e )a Le N$ 41KH o+>+*ao po0 Le N$ %81G e) "0+,(a) o+te *o(+e0a0 7,e (o e(*,a0a e( ,(a a*t++a +00e5,)a0 e) ,(+*+p+o p,e )a +a +t,a*+=( >,e 0e,e)ta po0 ,( j,e e p0+e0a +(ta(*+a 7,e 0e*2a= )a a**+=( e apa0o p0oo+a po0 )o +o a 7,+e(e

0ep0ee(ta  , *o00e)at+o p)a(teo +(*o(t+t,*+o(a) e )a O0e(a(a N$ 1H.H8J/1H  e )a Reo),*+=( N$ J&K%. Eta ,p)+*+a e p0o*eo ))ea e5( , a()++ +(exo0a)ee(te a ,(a +t,a*+=( e +(e5,0+a j,0+*a po0 pa0te e , 0ep0ee(taa. I(+*a( 7,e )o  50ae e 7,e ,( >,(*+o(a0+o *o(t+t,*+o(a) a a+e(a e )a ex+te(*+a e ,( p0o*eo a(te0+o0  ,( >a))o 0e*ao e( e) +o p0o,ea +0e*tae(te eta a**+=( *o( +(t+*o ojet+o a) a(te0+o0 a 0e,e)to. Rea)ta( 7,e e) a*to0 (o *,p)+= *o( e) p0o*e++e(to a+(+t0at+o p0e+o p,e +(+*+= )a ea(a e( ae a )a expo+*+=( e0a) e )o e*+(o >o0a)+aa a(te )a e>e(o0a a , *a05o +( a*0e+ta0 (+(5( ot0o ,p,eto e )o p0e+to a , e(te(e0 e( e) a0t. K e )a Le N$ 41KH o+>. po0 Le N$ %81G pe+o e +(>o0e a )a 9,(+*+pa)+a e Re+te(*+a a) "0+,(a) +(te0+(+e(te et*.M.  A50e5a( 7,e ot0o e*+(o 2a( p0oo+o e+a j,+*+a)e o0e )a +a *,et+=( a(te )o ',5ao ++)e e )a ,a0ta  D*+o Spt+a No+(a*+=( toa *o( 0e,)tao ae0o a , p0ete(+o(e po0 )o 7,e e(t+e(e 7,e *o( eta e+a e p0ete(e )a o+>+*a*+=( e) e>e*to eo),t+o *o( 7,e )a )e e apa0o *o(*ee e) 0e*,0o e ape)a*+=( e(at,0a)+(o)o. Po(e( e 0ea)to 7,e *,a)7,+e0 p0ete(+=( *oet(ea *o( ot0a 7,e te(5a +(t+*o e)ee(to e0+a +(exo0a)ee(te e( )a >+5,0a e )+t+pe(e(*+a  e *oa j,5aa. ,e e( e) *ao pa0t+*,)a0 e) apa0o e )a *a,a ?9a0*=(? *,e(ta *o( ,(a e(te(*+a e( )a 7,e e exp++= po0 )a *o(t+t,*+o(a)+a e )a (o0a ata*aa 7,e a) t+epo e )a *o(teta*+=( e )a ea(a e e(*o(t0aa e( 50ao e ape)a*+=( a(te )a a0a pe0t+(e(te -)a *,a) a )a >e*2a e e(*,e(t0a >+0e-. E( 0e)a*+=( a )a )e5a)+a e )a O0e(a(a N$ 1H.H8J/1H  )a Reo),*+=( e I(te(e(*+a N$ J.&K% p,(t,a)+a( 7,e >,e0o( +*taa +5,+e(o )o pao p0e+to po0 )o 7,e *o(t+t,e( a*to a+(+t0at+o )e5t+o  ot+ao ,>+*+e(tee(te )+o  aj,tao a e0e*2o 7,e e,et0a( 7,e )a a**+=( +(*oaa 0e,)ta >o0a)  ,ta(*+a)e(te +(a++)e.  A+e0te( 7,e e )a *o(ta(*+a e )a A*t,a*+o(e S+p)e N$ 4%K3H-P-1H  N$ %KKKK-P-1H ,05e 7,e e) ,o p0op,eto t+e(e

)o*a)+a*+=( pe0+t+a *o(>o0e )a O0e(a(a N$ 18J8  7,e poee e+o e(*,a0a+e(to e( e) pto. GM e )a O0e(a(a N$ &4H3 po0 2ae0e 0eae*,ao e) p0oe*to +5,+e(o )a ,5e0e(*+a +pa0t+a po0 )a epe(e(*+a t*(+*a ,(+*+pa)e *opete(te. Exp0ea( 7,e te(+e(o e( *,e(ta 7,e )a eje*,*+=( e )a o0a e0a 0ea)+a)e e+a(te ,( p0o*e++e(to oe0(o  (+*o e( e) (o0ete *o( ,( +tea *o(t0,*t+o +(+to  ate0+a)e (oeoo 7,e ,po(e( (e*ea0+ae(te 7,e e) po+)e +pa*to o0e )a p0op+eae )+(e0a e e0a +t+5ao e) o(*ejo De)+e0a(te e(t0o e )a e>e0a e )a *opete(*+a e) =05a(o ,(+*+pa)  e) a0*o )e5a) pe0t+(e(te 0eo)+= oto05a0 >a*t++)+a e ,o  o*,pa*+=( a )a p0op,eta ajo 0epo(a+)+a e) I(5e(+e0o !o0a*+o P0e. Po0 )t+o t0a(*0+e( )a e(te(*+a +*taa e( )a *a,a ?9a0*=(? a 0e>e0+a  0ea)ta( e) a()++ 0epe*to e )a +(*o(t+t,*+o(a) e )o a*to e a,to0+a p)+*a p)a(teaa  e) 0e*2ao e )a ea(a. O>0e*e( p0,ea >,(ae(ta( e( e0e*2o e>e*ta( 0ee0a e) *ao >ee0a)  *o(*),e( *o( pet+to0+o e et+)o.  A >. 1J1 e t+e(e( po0 p0ee(tao pa0te a )o ao5ao Pat0+*+a E)e(a <,+ta0t  A(5e) 9a0*e)o De)oo e( (o0e  0ep0ee(ta*+=( e )a 9,(+*+pa)+a e Re+te(*+a po0 *o(tetao e( t0+(o e) t0a)ao *o(>e0+o  p0ee(te )a p0,ea o>0e*+a.  A >. 1JK e *o00e +ta a) S0. P0o*,0ao0 <e(e0a) e )a ex*ep*+o(e p)a(teaa po0 )a ea(aa 7,+e( e exp+e a >. 133/13% ta. po0 D+*tae( N$ %J8/14. A >. 13K/14H  ta. po0 Reo),*+=( N$ 3&%/14 e 0e*2aa( )o p)a(teo e )+t+pe(e(*+a  *oa j,5aa.  A >. 14% e 0e7,+e0e )a 0e++=( a e>>e*t, +e(+ e) Expte. N$ 1J%%4/11 ?9a0*=( R,( A. / Apa0o?  e) Expte. N$ 1J%%8/11 ?9a0*=( R,( A. / 9e+a a,te)a0? 0a+*ao e( )a Se*0eta0a o(te(*+oa A+(+t0at+a N$ J 0e*++o )o +o a >. 1%4 e *o00e +ta a) Se6o0 P0o*,0ao0 <e(e0a) 7,+e( e+te D+*tae( N$ 31% +/1& 7,ea(o )a *a,a e( etao e e0 0e,e)ta a >. 183. II. De)+(eao a )o 2e*2o  )o a05,e(to p)a(teao po0 )a pa0te ,05e e) 0e)ato e )a *a,a 7,e e) a*to0 p0ete(e )a e*)a0a*+=( e +(*o(t+t,*+o(a)+a e )a O0e(a(a N$ 1H.H8J/1H

INO J.J3&M *oo apoe0ao a *aa ,(o e e))o. o(  IVA + *o00epo(+e0e. No 0e5,)(oe 2o(o0a0+o a )o D0e. <US"AVO ADOLFO ORRE<IDO  9AURO E!EARRE"A po0 )o >,(ae(to e0t+o e( )o o(+e0a(o. IV. RE<S"RESE  (ot+>7,ee pe0o(a)e(te o po0 *,)a. D0a. 9ARA LUISA LUAS ',ea S,pe0+o0 "0+,(a) e ',t+*+a D0. ALBER"O 9ARIO 9ODI P0e+e(te S,pe0+o0 "0+,(a) e ',t+*+a ROLANDO I<NAIO "OLEDO ',e S,pe0+o0 "0+,(a) e ',t+*+a NELIDA ES"ER AREBALO Se*0eta0+a "*(+*a S,pe0+o0 "0+,(a) e ',t+*+a

Sponsor Documents


No recommend documents

Or use your account on DocShare.tips


Forgot your password?

Or register your new account on DocShare.tips


Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link to create a new password.

Back to log-in