the role of capital market research in assessing the information content of accounting disclosures.
Understand
the difference between capital market research that looks at the information content of accounting disclosures, and capital market research that uses share price data as a benchmark for evaluating accounting disclosures.
08/28/11
+
The features of and Rationale for the Capital Market Research
08/28/11
5
Features of Capital Market Research Explores
the role of accounting and other financial information in equity markets
Involves
examining statistical relations between financial information and share prices
Reactions
of investors evident from capital market transactions (financial and nonfinancial information)
No
share price change implies no reaction
08/28/11
6
Views
“A
large fraction of published research in leading academic accounting journals examines the relation between financial statement information and capital market, referred to as capital market research”- S. P. Kothari (2001)
08/28/11
7
Capital Market Vs. Behavioural Research Capital market research: Assesses
the aggregate effect of financial reporting on
investors considers
only investors
Behavioural research: analyses
individual responses to financial reporting
examines
decision-making by many groups (eg. bank managers, loan officers, auditors)
08/28/11
Reasons for capital market research Information
about earnings and its components is the primary purpose of financial reporting
Earnings
are oriented towards the interests of shareholders
Earnings
is the number most analysed and forecast by security analysts
Reliable
data on earnings is readily available
08/28/11
8
+
Underlying Assumptions of Capital Market Research - EMH
08/28/11
Assumptions CMR
relies on the assumption that equity markets are efficient – in accordance with Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH)
Efficient
market defined as a market that adjusts rapidly to fully impound information into share prices when the information is released
08/28/11
10
Three forms of Market Efficiency
Weak form – prices reflect information about past prices and trading volumes
Semi-strong form – all publicly available information is rapidly and fully impounded into share prices in an unbiased manner when released – most relevant for accounting-based capital market research
Strong form – security prices reflect all information (public and private) 08/28/11
11
Market efficiency — implications for accounting If
markets are efficient they will use information from various sources when predicting future earnings
If
accounting information does not impact on share prices then it is deemed not to have any information value above that currently available
08/28/11
12
+
Information Content of Earnings
08/28/11
The information content of Earnings Share
prices are the sum of expected future cash flows from dividends
Dividends
are a function of accounting earnings
Unexpected
earnings rather than total earnings expected to be associated with a change in share price
08/28/11
14
The information content of earnings — market model Used
to separate out firm-specific share price movements from market-wide movements
Assumes
investors are risk averse and have homogeneous expectations
Its
use allows the researcher to focus on share price movements due to firm-specific news
08/28/11
15
Information content of earnings — continued Total
or actual returns can be divided into:
– normal (expected) returns given marketwide movements – abnormal (unexpected) returns due to firmspecific share price movements Abnormal
returns used as an indicator of information content of announcements
08/28/11
16
+
Results of Capital Market Research
08/28/11
18
Seminal Paper (Ball and Brown, 1968) Research Question? whether firms with unexpected increases in accounting earnings had positive abnormal returns, and firms with unexpected decreases had negative abnormal returns
Sample Size Examined data from 261 US firms
08/28/11
Ball and Brown (1968)-Findings Found:
– information contained in the annual report, prepared using historical cost was useful to investors – 85-90% of earnings announcement is anticipated by investors – much of information is obtained from other sources 08/28/11
19
Other Results of CMR Extent
of alternative sources of information
Permanent
versus temporary changes
Information
announcement of other firms
Information
content of earnings forecasts
Benefits
of voluntary disclosure
Recognition
versus footnote disclosures
Size Accounting
earnings and future information 08/28/11
20
Results of CMR—extent of alternative information sources Information
content varies between countries and
companies Compared
to US markets, Australian market had slower adjustments during the year with larger adjustments at earnings announcement (Brown, 1970) – less alternative sources of information for Australian market – Less alternative sources of information for smaller firms than larger firms
08/28/11
21
Results of CMR—permanent and temporary changes Research
(Beaver et al., 1980) examined relation between the magnitude of unexpected changes in earnings (EPS) and magnitude of abnormal returns – known as the earnings response coefficient – a 1% unexpected change in earnings associated with 0.1 to 0.15% abnormal return – depends on whether earnings increases expected to be permanent or temporary
08/28/11
22
Results of CMR—information announcements of other firms Earnings
announcements by one firm also results in abnormal returns to other firms in the same industry
Related
to whether the news reflects a change in conditions for the entire industry, or changes in relative market share within the industry
08/28/11
23
Results of CMR—information content of earnings forecasts Announcements
of expected earnings rather than actual earnings are associated with share returns
Management
and security analysts both make forecasts
08/28/11
24
Results of CMR—benefits of voluntary disclosure Voluntary
disclosures include those in annual reports as well as media releases etc.
Firms
with more disclosure policies have:
– larger analyst following and more accurate analyst earnings forecasts – increased investor following – reduced information asymmetry – reduced costs of equity capital 08/28/11
25
Results of CMR—recognition versus footnote disclosure Recognising
an item in the financial statements is perceived differently to disclosure in footnotes
Investors
place greater reliance on recognised amounts than on disclosed amounts
08/28/11
26
Results of CMR—size Relationship
between earnings announcements and share price movements is inversely related to the size of the entity
Earnings
announcements found to have a greater impact on share prices of smaller firms than larger firms
More
information generally available for larger
firms
08/28/11
27
As
firm size increases, share prices incorporate information from wider number of sources – relatively less unexpected information when earnings are announced
May
be able to argue that share prices anticipate future earnings announcements for larger firms with some accuracy
08/28/11
28
+
Accounting Earnings Reflecting Information
08/28/11
Accounting earnings reflecting information Rather
than determining whether earnings announcements provide information, recent research examines whether earnings announcements reflect information that has been already used by investors – ‘looking back the other way’ – market prices viewed as leading accounting earnings
prices are considered as benchmark measures of firm value
Share
returns are considered as benchmark measures of firm performance
Benchmarks
are then used to compare usefulness of alternative accounting and disclosure methods
Based
on premise that market values and book values are both measures of firm value 08/28/11
31
Accounting earnings reflecting information—continued If
market value is related to book value, returns should be related to accounting earnings per share, divided by price at the beginning of the accounting period – provides an underlying reason why we should expect returns to be related to earnings over time
08/28/11
32
Results of CMR—Accounting earnings reflecting information Share
prices and related returns were related to accounting earnings (Beaver, Lambert and Morse (1980)) – because of various information sources, price appeared to anticipate future accounting earnings – supported by Beaver, Lambert and Ryan (1987) 08/28/11
33
Results of CMR—Earnings reflecting information cont. Collins,
Kothari and Rayburn (1987) found evidence that share prices was a better indicator of future earnings in larger firms than smaller firms
Dechow
(1994) found over short intervals earnings are more strongly associated with returns than are realised cash flows – the ability of cash flows to measure firm performance increases as the measurement interval increases 08/28/11
34
Results of CMR—Earnings reflecting information cont. Studies
examining which asset value approaches provide accounting figures that best reflect market valuation found: – fair value estimates of bank’s financial instruments seem to provide a better explanation of bank share prices than historical cost (Barth, Beaver and Landsman 1996) – revaluation of assets results in better alignment of market and book values (Easton, Eddy and Harris 1993) 08/28/11
35
+
Relaxing Assumptions about Market Efficiency
08/28/11
+
37
Questionable Efficiency? In
recent years, there has been some research which has questioned assumptions of market efficiency (see Kothari 2001). Share prices are found to take time to react to particular information-such as corporate earnings announcement-referred to as 'drift' Leads to opportunities for some capital market participants to make gains in periods when share prices do not fully reflect the available information 08/28/11
+
38
Questionable Efficiency? In
light of market failures surrounding the subprime banking crisis, the credit crunch and the global financial crisis that came to light from 2007 onwards, several commentators have argued that some of the fundamental assumptions underlying much modern economic theory (including the efficiency of markets) have been shown to be unrealistic in practice (McSweeny, 2009)
08/28/11
+
39
Questionable Efficiency? At
the present time, there is some research into capital markets that does not rely upon market efficiencies. The consideration of 'other forces' that shape share prices and returns might eventually lead to a revolution in thought-but it will arguably take a long time. (Kuhn-1962- view of religious conversion--- Attacking existing theory----Proving new one superior----knowledge develops----New paradigm replaces or resurrects prior paradigm----Religious conversion).