Deters Motion to Compel

 

 I

I

-. 

I.

 -... -...r r~

//

.  ,

.M · P ,R E - D E C R E E COUR URT T OF COM MON DOM OME ESTIC

REL ELA ATIO TIONS NS

HAMIILT HAM LTO ON MELISSA

HENDON

PLff~AS: PL ~AS:;: ;:''~ DIVI VIS SION

\.

COU OUN NTY, OHIO

.~.

I, 

DETEJ{S

J

( ) POST DECREE

C ~g .   C U S t. . V . En fo rc e / M o d. d.

O tU h P e ' E S n f O r C e / M O d ..

r:

CASE NO, DR DR1 13022 0223 34

Plaaint Pl intiiff

JlJDG Jl JDGF F: LEWIS

V S.

JOESPH JOESP H TH THE EODORE DETERS

MOTIION MOT

TO CO COM MPEL

Defenda dant nt

N ow

co m e s

D e f e n dant

B y ag r eem ent en t

1.

ln t e r r ogat ogatoo r i es

p ro o f o f s e rv i c e

for P r o d u ct i o n

2 2 ,2 0 1 3

th a t hi s cl i e n t

w o u ld

s e rv e r

D i sc l o s u r e

t h e D ec e m b e r h a ve

c o u n s el ,

(s e e

O rd e r

d o c u m e n ts

a s fo ll o w s :

w as serve d

a n d t h i s C ou rt ' s e m a il

11122/13

at t a c h e d

m e e ti n g

16,2 6,20 013

s t a t es

D e fe n d a n t

o f D oc u m e n t s

ocesss b y a p r oces

a n d M a n d at o r y D u ri n g

2.

t o C i v i l R u le 3 7 ( A )

w itithh D e f e n d a n t ' s

a n d R e qu es t

o rder o n N o v em b er

in d ic a te d

a n d p u r suan suantt

h e r e to

w itithh

m a n d atory

fr o m

d i sc losur losuree

L . A d am s,

G r egor egoryy

A.

a s E x h ib i t

with t h e Court. urt.T Tiefe efen ndant's dant's..co couns unseej-, \ ,

i n r es p o n se

t o P l a intif intiffs fs

d i s co v e r y~ b Y ' 1 h e

rn

6

. ,. : ~2 ~2--i

~

~:;:;:: j

e~

o f~

2.

D efenda efendann t

i n t erro errogg a t o r i e s r e sp o n sive

m e ss ag e

20, 0,2 201:l.

-

P l a inti intiff f w o u l d Defend ndaant

201 14, c o un se l 8, 20

d e f i c ie n c i e s

O n a p p r ox i m a t e l y t h a t h e in t e n d e d

w hat

lJ

l oose oosell y

essen senttially

r e f e r t o a s a r es p o n se

failed

[0

p ro v i d e

TO

f o r D e fe n da n t

the~

i n t h e i r r es p o n se s Ja n u a r y

1 7 ,2 0

( s e e 1 / 8 /  4 J

4 , P la in ti ff

t o h av e t h e b u l k o f hi s r e s p onse onsess

l e tt e r a ttttaa ch ed i nf o rm ed t o d i sc o v e r y

week (s (seee a co c opy ofthe text mes esssag agee at atttac ach hed here ereto to as Exhibit C) C)..

h e r et o

D ef e n d an t

;~ 5 S ~

a 

fo r a s E x h ib i t v ia te x t

b y th e e n d o f t h e n e x t

j

::::xx :

a ri y do c u m e n t s

s e n t a l e t t e r t o c ou n s e l

c o :;:

ry.-(

r e q u es ts .

O n Jan uary

d et a i l i n g 5.

p ro v id e d

o n D ecem ece m b e r

t o P la i n t if f's

4. P l a i n t i ff

f- l

.

~~ C )(j:- ;:

I

th e y e a r .

:~ ,;;,s :

B ).

:: : 0

 

( I \ . .

•• 4

,.

6.

O n J a n u a r y 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , D ef e n d a n t 's

c o u n s e l i nformed P l a in t i ff ' s c o u n se l v i a e m a il

t h at h e w a s m e e ti n g w i t h h is c li e n t t h a t w ee k a n d w o u ld t h e r e a ft e r

d i sc o v e r y

r espo n se s (S e e Un Un//14

p r o vide an u pdat pdatee t o t h e ir

er n a il fr o m G r e gory L . A d a m s a t t a ch e d h er e t o a s E x h i b i t D ).

7.

As of the dat atee o f this motion ion,, n o a d d i t i o n a l i n f o r m a titioo n

8.

A s o f t h e d a t e o f t hi s

m a n d a to r y

m ot i o n , D ef ef e n d a n t

has bee een n p ro v i ded.

h as fa i l e d t o comp comply ly

w i t h t h e C ou ou rtrt 's

d i sc l o s u r e o rd er .

W H E R EFOR E ,

p r ovide t h e approp approprr i a t e

P l a i n t i ff moves f or a n O rd e r f r o m t h e C ourt c o m p e ll i n g

re s p o n se s

t o P l a i n t iff's

d i scov e r y ;

t h e D efend a nt

f o r a t to r n e y f e e s a n d co s ts in c u rr ed

b r i n g in g t h i s a c t io n ; a n d f o r a l l o t h e r r e lie li e f t h a t i s ju st an d e q u it a b l e .

p~~~ o skow skowii tz

~1es ~1 es

( . iM6~oJrtz iM6~oJrtz,, L L C

H . Mosk Moskoo w ititzz A t t or n ey f o r P l a i n t i f f 290 900 0 Car arew ew Tower 44 1 V in e St r ee t C incinn incinnaa t i , O h i o 4 5 2 0 2 (5 1 3 ) 7 2 1 - 3 1 1 1 (513) 7 2 1 - 3 0 7 7 f a x ji m @ mos ko k o w i t z  e g a l.l.cc o m

  0 0 6 :0

to in

 

COUR OURT T OF COMMON PLEAS DOMESTfC DOMES RELATI ELATIONS ONS DIVISION DIVI SION HA  \,IIL TON COU HA OUN NTY; OHIO MEL[S [SS SA

HENDO DON N

DETERS

CASE NO. DR1302234

P la i n t iff if f

JUDGE

LEWIS

VS. IN SUPPORT TO COMPEL

AFFID AFFI DAV AVIIT

JOESPH

THEODOR ORE E

DETERS

MOTION

OF

D efe n d an t 1 , J am am e s

H . Moskow itz it z ,

b e in g

I.

1 a m a n attorn e y ,

2.

  r e p r es e n t

3.

By agreem ent

I nter nterrr ogato ri e s

in g o o d

t h e P la i n t if f

and R equest

an d p ro o f o f s ervi ervice ce

a t ta c h e d

i n d ic a t e d

i1

C IS

th e D ec em b er

l i ce n s e d

co u n se l ,

s t a t e a s fo l l o w s :

to p r a c tic e

D ef e n d an t

o f D o cu m en ts

p ro c e s s

h e r e to

a n d c a u ti o n e d ,

la w i n th e s t a t e o f O h i o .

i n th is a c ti o n .

C o r P ro ro du du c t io n

2 2, 2 01 J b y

D u ri n g

s ta n d in g ,

w i t h D ef ef e nd nd an an t't'ss

o rd e r o n N o v em b er

4.

f ir s t d u l y s w a m

server

E x h i b it

1 6 ,2 0 1 3

(see

h a v e d o cu m e n t s

D efe n d an t

w hat

a n d t h i s C o u rt's

w itithh d i s c l o su r e

m an d atory

1 1 122/ [3 e m a i l f ro m G r e g o r y

L . A dam s

A ).

m ee t i n g

t h a t h i s c l i e n t wo would uld

w a s se r v e d

w i th

th e C o u r t,

i n r e s p o n se

D e fendan t ' s

to P la i ntiff' ntiff'ss

d i s c o v e ry

c o u n se l b y th e e n d of

th e y e a r. 5. int nteerro rog gator oriies resspo re pon nsiv sivee

P l ai nt i f f

2 0,20 0,2011 3.

on December

to Plaintiffs

6.

p r o v id e d

O n J a n u a ry

d e ta i l in g

P la intif ntifff Defen Defe nda dan nt

w o u ld

lo o s e ly

essentiial essent allly

refe ferr

f a il e d

10

[0

a s a r esponse

p ro v id e

to th e

a n y d o c um e n ts

requ eques estts.

8, 2014, c o u n se l

d e f ici cien en ci cies es

t o r D efendan t

in t h ei r r es po n s e s

( s ee

\/8 /1 4

sent a lett lettee r to c o u n s e l l e tt er

attachh e d attac

h e r e to

fo r a s E x h i b it

B ).

 

  i  

_

7.

On app pprroxi xim mately

Jan Ja nua uarry

J

7,20 ,201 14,

Plaintifff infor Plainti orm med Defenda dan nt vi viaa text

hav ve th message that he int nteended to ha thee bulk of hi hiss respo spon nses to discover scovery y by th thee end of the next

wee eek k (s (seee a copy of th thee tex textt messag ssagee at atttac ach hed hereto as Exh E xhiibit C).

8.

O n J a n u a r y 2 8 , 2 0 1 4 , Defend Defendaa n t't'ss

co u ns e l in fo rm ed

P l a i n titiff ff ' s

that h e w a s m e etin g w i t h h is clie clienn t t ha t w e e k a nd w o ul uldd th erea ereaft fter er d i sc o v e r y

re s p o n se s

( Se e

1/28114

email fr froo m G r eg o ry

p r ov i d e a n u pd at atee t o t h ei ei r

L . A d am s a ttttac ac h ed

A s o f th otio n , thee d a t e of t h i s m ot

10.. 10

A s of th e d a te of this mo mottion ion,, De Defe fen ndant has failed to c o m p l y with the Co Cour urt' t'ss

m an dator datoryy

i n f o r m at i o n

h ere to a s E x h ib it D ).

9.

110 11 0

a d di di t i o n al al

c o unse unsell v i a e m a i l

has b e e n p r o v i d e d.

disscl di clo osure order er..

F urther af affian fiantt s a i th na u g h t .

Sw am

t o b e f o r e m e a n d s ub s c r i b e d

rd

i n m y p re s e n c e this 3

 o n

s.

i ¥ 1 v 3 i \O W i iL  

. II \/ \/1 10

.r   ,, 

PUBLI BLIC C

corr co rr   nISSi (' ('Hl Hl ~Cl.:l;\ ;\I I

da y of F e b ru a ry , 2 0 1 4 .

· ;. ;.TI~ TI~~ ~; ~1 S q

Si ,l. l.--; -;  

hng hn g ;t7 Ql

no

~; : ~~:TD

c \;p l r : J t i o H

O R C

 

t ,0

NOTICE

OF HEARIN RING G

P l ease t a k e n o ti ce th a t th e f o rg o in g m a t t e r w i l l b e h e a r d b ef o r e J u d g e L e w i s on t h e _ _ d ay of

T'D\)

2 0 1 4 fj ' o m

C o u nt n ty C o u rt o f D o m e s tic

.tn.to

R e l a tions tions,,

.m.jn Roorn

8 0 0 B r o a d w ay ,

C in ci n n at i ,

-

o f t h e H am i lton

O h io 4520 2 .

 ~~<1.4/( /(//I

~osskow ~o kowit itzz & Mos Mosk k6witz tz,, tec J a m es H. Mo sk o w i tz # 0 0 6 4 l9 0 A t t o r n e y f o r Plaintiff

CER CE RTIFIC IFICA ATE

T h e u n d er s i g n e d

certii f i es here ereby by cert

I d 4. : 3 c l a y o f F ebruary , 2 0 1 4.

\ /

OF SERVIC RVICE E

t h a t a c o p y o f t h e f o r egoi egoinn g

af f id a v i t i n s u p p o rt w a s s e r v e d u p o n G r eg o ry

~-

L . A d a m s , Atto Attorr n ey

moti tio on t o co m p e l an d

fo r D e f e n d a n t ,

b y e m a il i l th i s

-v ,

 

James H  Mo Mosk sk o w i tz

  '_   ' ' '   ' ' ' ' ' ' ' i E l' _' '

• • • • • • • • • .• . , . ,

• • • E•••=t:r_¥

· ,•   ••••• ••• ••• ••••  _ ••-~

& ' •' • ' ''' ' ·

••• •• •

  ' - ' ·   - ·   ' ' ' ' ' ' '''_ ' '''''''''''' _

From:

J a m e s H , M o s kowitz

Sen Se nt:

Friday iday,,

To:: To

' g ad a m s @ c ro s w e ll ad a m s. c o m ' R E : D e te r s

Sub ubjject:

• ••'''' ••• • •' ' ' ' ' ' , . . .' ' ' ' ' ' ''·. ''·... , . _ ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ·   T t '''' ' ' ' '   ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' '_ '

• • • ••• • • _ _

~ M t F • • • _ •

11:1 :19 9 AM N o v e mb mb e r 22, 2013 11

The pape perrs were picked u p by Le Lega gall Te Tend ndeers and wi will ll be de deli live vere red d

to your of offfice sh sho orrlv,

F r o m : G r e g A d a m s [   : D a ilt o : g a d a m s @ c r o s wella welladd a m s . c o m ] S e n t : F r id a y , N o v e m b e r 2 2 , 2 . 0 1 3 1 1 : 1 7 A M To: J a me me s H, Mo Mos skow kowiitz Sub ubjject: De Detters

Jim,, Jim oe''s behal This willco lconfi nfirrm my wi willlingn gnes esss to acce accep pt service of the divor divorcce paper erss on Joe alf, f, Greg Gre g

Gregor regory y L. Adams Crosw e ll & A d a m s C o . , L . P,A. 1 2 0 8 S y c a m o r e S t reet O ld e S y c amore Squa r e C i ncin n a t i , O h i o 4 5 2 0 2 P h o n e: 5 l 3-24   - 5 6 7 0 Fax Fa x: 513-929 13-929--3473 l adams, adams , @ c r o s w el l a dams.co l J} w \ v w , c r o sw e ll a d am s.c s. c o I 1 1

T h e inf info ormation conta tain ineed in this elect ctrronic message is protected b y att atto orney rney--clien lientt p r i v i l e ge g e and/or t h e w or-k pr pro odu duct ct doctri octrin ne, I t i s int inteended forr t h e u s e o f t h e indiv fo ndiviidu dual al a n d / o r entit entity y n a me d a b o v e and t h e p r i v i l e g e s a r e n o t w a i v e d by v i r t u e o f t h i s h av a v i n g bee been n If the person a c t u a l l y r e c e i v i n g t h i s c o mmu n i c a t i o n s ent el ec t r o n i c al l y. i s not t he i nt ended r e c i p i e n t o r e mp l o y e e 6 r a g e n t r e s p o n s i b l e for d e l i v e r i n g i t t o t h e i n t e n d e d r e c i p i e n t . a n y use.. use or copyi opying ng comm ommu unica nication tion in erro is str triictl ctly y d i s s e mi mi n a t i o n . di s t r i b u t i o n  o f this errorr proh ohiibited bited..

_

 

IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLE PLEAS AS DOME DOM ESTIC RELATIO TIONS NS DIVISIO IVISION N HAM AMIILTON COUNTY, OHI OHIO O

MELIS MEL ISSA SA HE HENDO NDON N DETERS,

Case No.

Plaintifff, Plainti

DR1 DR 130223 234 4

Jud Ju dge:

VS.

JOSE, OSE,P PH TH THEO EOD DORE DE DET TERS, Deffendant. De

 

PROOF OF SE PROO S ERVICE OF A SUMM MMONS, ONS, COM COMP PLA LAIINT AND ALL SUPPORT UPPORTIING PAPE PERW RWORK ORK ON JOSEP EPH H TH THEO EOD DORE DE __T _ ERS i ~ ::;:; I i ~  . . .. f:   : ::

~r-~

r   ~~

C

  « ::: : 0 ) : , .

-e

This noti notice ce is give ven n that the servic vice e of a Summo ummons, ns, Co Com mpl plai ain nt, Mot otiion and 1'l.ffidavi~r 0-r e  IJI Tempor Te mporar ary y Parent rentiing Orde rderrs, Affidavit in Comp Complliance with 3127 27..23, GrouptBJa uptBJalth lthb b

~ ~

~~C' )

a 

Cr :: t :  

~2~ ~2 ~

:::: ::: :::s::-0c:~  

Insur ura anc nce e Affid ffidav avit it,, Affidavit of Incom ome e and Expen Expens ses, Mand nda ator ory y Disc scllosu osurre O rd J c <   ;; ; ;; ; : ; C..;

Adminiistrative Admin

Tem emp por ora ary Restr tra aining Order, Order to Attend Iniii niiia al Case Manageme anagemen nt

Conference,, Proper Conference Propertty S t a te m e n t , Plaintiffs F ir s t S e t of In Inte terr rro ogator gatorie ies s Plaiint Pla ntiiffs

tx :

F i r s t Set of In Inte terrrog ogat ato ories

and C O for

on JOSE SEP PH THEODORE DET ETE ERS was perfec fectted

b y Jenn Jenniife ferr Vach Vach,, who is a person not less than eight hte een yea earrs of age and is not a par artty in th the e abo abov ve litigation, on November 22, 20 201 13 by personal rsonallly giving a true copy of each from hand to hand to JOSEPH TH THE EODORE D E T E R S VIA HIS ATT TTOR ORNE NEY Y GREG AOA AO AMS(C MS(CIINOY VINE NEY Y,I\R \RD D) at (hei (heirr place of business 1208 Syca ycamo more re Ave venu nue, e, Cin inc cinnati, Ohio 452 2  2  ~~~ e nifer Vach Spec Sp eciial Pro roc ce s Se Serv rve er Lega gall Tende Tenderrs of Ohio 5 McCormick Tr Trai aill Cinc Cin cin inn nati, Ohio 45150 (513 (51 3) 62 624 4-0110

r -

 

 

/

---:

~ CO U RT OF COMMON PLEAS D I VI S I O N O F D O M ES T I C RELATIONS H A M r l , TO N COU N TY , O H IO

C as e N o , M · 0 9 0 0 0 4 [ \O ~ f[ NrST K A T l V E

RE : MANDATORY D ISC L O SU R E P U R S U A N T TO L O CA L RU LE 1_26

P U R S U AN ANT

TO L OCA L

RU LE

D R 1 302

1.26 I T IS H E R E B Y

ORD ER ED

2 3 4

l U D G E 'S

ORD RDe eR

A S FO L L O W S ;

W ithi ithinn 4S d a y s o f a n y C o m p lai l ai n t f o r D l v o rcc rcc,, L e g a l S e p ar aH on or A nn u l m e nt fi I ~ d w i t h t h i s C o u r t a n d b e i n ~ s e r v e d on t h e d e fe n da nt , each pa rty s ha l l di s c lo s e t o t h e o t h e r JI JIII o f t h e r o llowing in f or m at io n a n d dO CU I / 1CnlS t h a t i s in h i s or h er er c us us to to dy dy , posssessio po session n o r cont ontro roll: (I) D e ed s t o a l l r e a l e s tute

(2 ) (3)  l\\   l

(5)

(6)

0) (8 ) (0 ) (I 0) (II II))

(J 2 )

(1 J)

T h e J i 5clos 5closuu r es ( I) (2)

cn

( 4)

thaa t U1ep a n ) ' ow ns o r c l ai th aim m s a n i nt e r e s t; Ti tltlee s t o a l l v e hi c l e s t h a t th e pa r ty ow n s o r c lai m s a n i n ter e s t; T h e m o s t r e ce n t ly i s s u e d s t a t e m e n ts on a l l b a nk a cc o un ts, annu annuititii e s , s to c k s , a n d b o n d s name a ppea ppearr s o r t o which t h e party c la laii m s a n i n t e re s t ; T h e m o s t re c e n t l y is s ue d s t a teme temenn t s r e g a r d i n g p e n s i o n s , p r o f i t shnri shnrinn g p l a n s, r e titirr em e n t i n c l u d i n g t h e m o st st r e c e n t s u m m a r y p l a n d e s c r i pt i o n , o n w h ic h th thee p a r t y ' s n a m e appea appears rs

Oil

w h i c h the p a r ty 's

b e n e f i t s, a n d l RAs, o r 10 w hi hi c h t h e p a r t y

c l a i m s alinte interr e s t; ~   n A l l li fe in s ur a nc e pol polic iciies own wned ed by th thee part rty y o r for wh whiich the the party ur thei heirr chiid idff re n) is/ s/ar aree u ~ijci~I} ci~I}''-i~ fo r c e no w or w i th thii n t h e I n s l si x m on t hs , in c l u d i n g t h e most r ec en t c a sh v aiu ai u c s tD l cm e T . 1. 'K 't, 'I 'l  ; . ; J;:-> ) , Thee lo Th losst th thrree years' i nc o m e tax ~\u \urrn:;; ;;< < ~ ~' ~'--< P r o o f o f c ur re n t \ [ , c o m e f r om al l so u r ces;

a  -

H e a l t h , d e nt a l , an d v i s io « i n s u r a n c e c o verage a vail purtyy a l o n g w i t h A L L vailaa b le t o t h e purt options a nd c o s ts (i. e . si sinn g le, fa m ililyy , et c . ) ; A l l C OB R A b e n e f ititss to w h ich e i th e r party m ay be e n t itl itlee d, in cl cluu d i n g c o st .

r ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ p r .n ~ ~2 : z~~ » :z~ ( j

0

-R

c su r na t e s: s: Ch i l d c n r e e x pe n s e s in incc u rr e d fo r the c h ilildd ( rcn); 03 The Th e most r ecen ecentt l y i s sued stat statee m en t s f o r a l l l i a b i l i ties ti es i nclud ncludii n g, b u t n o t l i m i t e d t o , m o r t gages gages,, lin li n e s o f c r e d i t, l oa ns , an d c re d it card a cc o un ts o n w h ic h t h e p a rr y 's n a m e ap p ea r s or f o r w h i ch a pa r t y i s r es po n s i b e ; P r o p e rty S t a t e m en t ( F or m N o , D R 4, 1 ) ; C om p leted C om pl p l e t ed . M i i d a v it of In Inccome, Ex Exp penses & F i n an cial D is c l o s u r e ( fo r m No, DR 7,3), r e q u ir e d h e re in s h a l ] b e m a d e by pr o v id in ingg c op i e s o f do cu m e n ts i n o n e of th e f ol l o w in ingg m a nners nners:: E le ct r on i c e-mni] to t h e 01her par arty's ty's a t t o rney rney;; F ac s im i l e t o Ihe o t h e r p a r ty's e t t or n e y; M a il t o t he ot h e r p a r t y 's an or n e y ; o r H an d de l iv e ry W th e ot h e r pa rt y ' s at to r ne y , If J pa r t y i s unrep unrepre re se n te tedd . loss u r e sh a l l b e a s pr ov i d e d he re i n 10 t h e ; p a r t y . r h i s d i s c lo

~~(''11 ~~(

•

(/l /l: :;O

0

:: ::r: r:

F OR G OO D C A U S E S H O W N, N , / \ MOTIO TION N O R A N A G R E ED E D E N T R Y M A Y 8 E FI L E D T O M O D I fY THE M A N D A T O RY RY D I SC L O S U R E O R D E R O R T O E X T EN D ru ruee T f M E T O C J ( S CL O S E lKE . F O R- E G G IN G IN F O RMATIO i'\ IJOCUMEN OCUMENT TS, A N D IJ

FA l l . U R E lNCL NCLUD UDIING,

TO CO M PL Y

W IT H T H E M A N D A T O R Y

C O I 'H E M

(I)

/\ Fll\'DING O F

(2 ) (3 ) (4 )

AW MW OF i\ T T O R N 'E Y F E E S ; o r: C L A IM S ; A N D D IS M IS SA L RE ST RICTIO N S U PO N TH E S U B M IS S IO N

)NS,, )NS

ORC

PT;

Th is Order i s effecti fectiv ve the dal alee i t i s j o ur ur n a lilizz e d A d m i ni s t r a titivv e J u d ge ,

D R 1 ,2 6

O IS C L O S U R E

BUT ~~OT U1v 1v  ITE TED D TO, THE FOLLOWf?'IG:

O F E VI VI D EN EN C E .

w ith th e

hk o fC o u 1 s

a n d r em a i n s

~ ~ ~n~ ~olbe ~~~ ~iv e Susa Su san n kc beri, ri, A d m in i n i s trat trativ

~ ~ Judbc

H a m i l t on C o un t y Co u r t o f C o m m o n D iv ivii s i o n o f D om e s tic Re lat ion s

P le a s

in eff effeect until f u rther O rd e r o f t h e

~~~~ SEP 1 4 ZO D9

 

. 

.  13  

;\--IOS ;\ IOSII {OW TZ

;V [O SI SI{Ow {Ow 'l' 'l'Z Z,

< . 1 /, . :;

LLO

.\'1 '1-1' -1'(( l/~.  I ;\ S ,\'1 ' ( ..\ .\1 11' :  J(I(J

(', ',\\

I~I ;\\  I ()II /,; ,;U U

I·~t \ [,,,{ ,,,{. .:

:-; I ln.:(,: \ 

I)· ~,-.~o \ ' 1 : --- ; ' 1 :---; :--- ; . vr I , \ ) \ II ~o:~ :~ 1.-01:1) ,:21< ,:21<1 1111

\\ \YW \YW Oo\ 1\ lS 1 ; ) \\' I l :I,1.1 :1.\ I. I.. . \ \ )x I j{

),,11 ,11,,\

1:-: 1',\ ,\,,\1

7:21 7: 21-:\0 -:\07 77

II. II . ,\I 0:-; 1{() II I I /. •

.1,\ ,\ 1 / - :. 0 .. ;  t

V \ \  , I l.

1,,1: 1:1) 1)

lI :I. S. .\1( )SI{( lIITI /.

( I ;I~TII  II II  ;) ;): :-;I '1';( '1.\1,1 '1' '1 ' I

r.v

1 .. \\\'

.ian anu uarv 8. 2014

Gregor Greg ory y

L, Ada dams ms

Crosw oswe ell

& Adams

Olde Sycamor more e

Square

1208 120 8 Sycamo morre

Street

Cincinnatii, Cincinnat

Ohio Oh io 45 4520 209 9

Re:: Det Re Dete ers

Dearr Greg: Dea Tha han nk Requ Req uest

you fo forr yo your ur cl cliient

for Produc oducttion

 resp  r espo onse nse  

of Do Docum cume ents nts,,

to the Firs irstt Set of Inte nterro rrog gatories

The following

is my att tte empt

and

to reso esollve

dlscoverv

issue is sues s prior to fil ilin ing g a Mo Moti tion on to Comp Compe el: 1, il, l,ttprr()g ()ga ato torry

P1E 1E C  Cllseprov seproviide the comple mplette account numbers Ilulll,ba Ilul barr E3,f-l.I(th (the er, for \he Fi eck king Fiffnl fllird chec

'fondy the corr rrec ectt accou accoun nt

.iccoon coontt

8S

number as your prelimin mina ary

P l e ase p r o v i d e th e I;om omp plet ete e ac c o un t ri:;' ri :;';p ;po o0S8 to int nt8r 8rrro<:]J.to tory ry num numbe berr 7 ,

?10 10rr\:3 \:3II::?

pro'Aje

\)'')tf:~ \) )tf:~rrs is ;.1W 1W;;;H8 o f til tilll:?

ti;' ;'::: hIW1 IW1f~ f~,,

;1ffiicJ ;1ff cJa a'/it of prope operrty

lis istts that

fo r : 1 1 1d e b t s

listed in

ending in 58 586 6,

~?,

,J .

listed in response to linq 585 plea leas se acco ccoun untt c:nclin

11~ 11 ~UT1f: T1f:??

numbers

:.l (:~sf-lof lofl': l':iie to il1t il1tr? r?ff(() (()''Ftt FttO Of' f',,I

o f \ h 8 ins insttitut utiion

~~iiJ. pr ~~ pr~ ~:3Llln~ r.lr lr.. holdi oldirriCj th r · ) illIJil()8r;e   lf1 r i line of ,~qu quiity on l1ii1r)l[) l1 l[)((-? ?r

 

5, belilie eve

tllilt

1 8 c e i ve

from

1 3.

make mak e

a c la i m

7, thro thr oug ugh h

F'lr:;ils lse e provi vide de ~111 . u i s w e r to il1t 1te errogclt lto ory numbe berr 23,   r in d it nard to nie ni e(8 is 1 0 <lC]ree eeme men nt (1S to wh: wh:..'1t per perc cent nta aqe or .unount Mr. Deters will the f8es ge gen n8rClte ted d

Pla laa ase

.is to

cxpta ptaiin

tr o r n

whe hetther

eparatee his hi s s eparat

tlilie e idel1 ifi ifie ed c a s e s .

it is you ourr con conttentio ention n

p r o p e r ty

in re s p o n s e

to i n te r r o g a to r y

201 J, I wou would ld

expec pectt

a prompt

reque ques sts

have been

~ / : . r rurully

JHM/jcg JHM/ jcg

outsta utstan nding

response ponse..

 j ~.

/

..'

/,,> .~

yours,

.

/ ~ l

 1)

/ j

H   I V i ; ; ~ k ; ; - ~Iz

J ~,;;~5 '

is not d b Ie to

n um be r

P le a se pr to r e q u e st lor produ n u m b e rs pro ovid ide e a respo spon nse produc ction 22, 27 throu hrough gh 33, J5, 36. and J8 through rough 44, 44, . :   7, and ~\8 \8..

  know for a fa fac ct that ma man ny of th the ese August, Aug ust,

th<1 <1tt you ourr clie client nt

2 4.

I, 1 3 . 1 7

sinc ince e

 

 

.'

wo u l d y o u l e t ne x t we e k a n d

t e x t _ O  t x t h i m k n o w t h a t I h o p e t o h a v e t he bu l k t o s t o p t hr e ~t e ni n9 me   i t   s h a r d   t o

P a ge 1

of y o u r d o wh whee n

by t he d i s co co v e r y I   m si ck i n be d

e nd o f

 

D

  ames H. Mosk osko owit witzz Fro m :

Greg Ad Ada ams

Sent: Se nt:

Tuesd uesday ay,, Ja January nuary 28. 20 201 14 2:53 PM

<gadam adams s@cro ros swella ladam dams s.com .com> >

To:

James H. Moskow oskowiitz

Subject

Dete eters rs

Jim. I'll be mee eeti ting ng wi witth Jo Joe e later this week an and d upd pdat ating ing

y o u ther there eaf after ter..

Greg Gr eg

Gregory Gregor y L.

  d  m s

Croswell & Ad Croswel Adam amss Co Co.., L.P.A. 1 2 0 8 Syca Sycam more St Strreet Olde Sy Syccamore Square Cinc inciinnat nnatii, Ohi hio o 45202

P h o n e : 5 \ 3 - 2 4 \- 5 6 7 0 Fax ax:: 5] 3-929 929--347 3473 3  . ada  adams ms((@'c 'croswel roswellladams.co ams.colll1 www..crc www rcsswel wellladam amss.com

T h e i n f o r ma ma t i o n c o n t a i n e d i n t h i s e l e c t r o n i c me s s a g e i s p r o t e c t e d b y a t t o r n e y - c l i e n t p r i v i l e g e a n d / o r t he h e wo r k p r o d u c t d o c t r i n e . I t i s intended f o r the u s e o f t h e i n d i v i d u a l a n d / o r e n t i t y n a me d a b o v e a n d th thee p r i v i l e g e s a r e n o t w a i v e d by v i r t u e o f t h i s h a v i n g b e e n s e nt e l ec t r o ni c a l l y . I f t h e p e r s o n a c t u a l l y r e c e i v i n g t h i s c o mmu n i c a t i o n i s n o t t h e i n t e n d e d r e c i p i e n t o r e mp l o y e e o r a g e n t r e s p o ns n s i b l e for d e l i v e r i n g i t t o · the i n t e n d e d r e c i p i e n t   a n y us e d i s s e mi n a t i o n   di di s t r i but i o n o r c o p y i n g o f t h i s c o mmu ni ni c a t i o n i n e r r o r i s s t r i c t l y pr ohi bi t ed