Effectual Knowledge Services
Monthly Litigation Updates – July 2014
Effectual Services is a well established and fast growing patent and legal support services company
having experience and expertise in providing patent and legal services. With an exceptional mix of
technical and legal knowledge, research proficiency, and analytical depth, we are able to consistently
provide cost-effective top-notch patent research and legal support services.
Effectual Services has technical and legal experts to handle every conceivable technology or situation
and support at every stage of patent life cycle from drafting and prosecution to enforcement and
litigation. Our firm’s clientele range from IP law firms, general law firms, patent licensing firms, patent
brokers, legal departments at mid-sized companies, multinational conglomerates, research institutions
and includes university and venture capital backed clients. We help our clients improve their business
effectiveness and maximize ROI by leveraging deep domain expertise, engineering excellence, rock-
solid execution and a comprehensive delivery model.
Our team members are tech savvy, proactive and have passion for excellence and are always on the
forefront in bringing satisfaction to customers’ needs. Our team of paralegals has deep knowledge of
rules and processes which allows us to reduce cost and still maintain quality and efficiency. Lawyers at
Effectual Services successfully help clients in document review, legal research, deposition
summarization, due diligence, and contract management.
A Benchmark For Perfection In IP
High
T
fi
41
W
C
fi
20
D
M
F
B
cl
an
T
ta
20
hlights:
Total numbe
led in the m
13.
With 92 lawsu
Court was a
ling lawsuits
014, followe
District Court
Most of the l
reeny et al (
Bryan E. Free
losely follow
nd Network
Top US class
argeted for p
014 were 514
er of Patent
month of Ju
uits, Delawar
preferred c
s in the mon
ed by Texa
t with 87 law
lawsuits wer
Charles C. F
eny, James P
wed by Rec
Congestion S
ses which w
patent lawsui
4, 455, and 70
t lawsuits
ly 2014 is
re District
choice for
nth of July
s Eastern
wsuits.
re filed by
Freeny, III
P. Freeny)
Software,
Solutions.
were most
its in June
09.
PA
Filing v
Patent li
lawsuits
from the
previous
filing tre
Also, the
presented
Week 2 w
Source: http
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
ATENT L
velocity:
itigation trend
were filed, w
e previous mo
s year (J uly 2
ends observed
e week wise p
d below:
witnessed pea
p://info.thomsonin
A
p
r
-
1
3
M
a
y
-
1
3
J
u
n
-
1
3
612
516
988
Week 1
83
Patent Li
LITIGATI
July
ds for the mo
which indicat
onth and ~16.
2013). The gr
d since April 2
patent lawsui
ak lawsuit fili
novation.com/
J
u
l
-
1
3
A
u
g
-
1
3
S
e
p
-
1
3
O
c
t
-
1
3
492
533
453 45
Week 2
127
itigation U
TION INS
y 2014
onth of J uly
tes an increas
7% decrease
raph below il
2013.
its trends for
ing activity cl
N
o
v
-
1
3
D
e
c
-
1
3
J
a
n
-
1
4
F
b
1
4
51
558
330
292 3
Week 3
126
pdates – F
SIGHTS F
2014 show th
se of approxi
than the sam
llustrates the
the month of
losely followe
F
e
b
-
1
4
M
a
r
-
1
4
A
p
r
-
1
4
M
a
y
-
1
4
302
487
678
375
Week 4
77
Filing trend
FOR
hat 413 paten
imately 9.84%
me month in th
patent lawsu
f J uly 2014 ar
ed by Week 3
J
u
n
-
1
4
J
u
l
-
1
4
5 374
413
ds
nt
%
he
uit
re
3.
The F
were f
Top P
The fi
et al
Netwo
Oth
37
Figure above
filed in the D
Plaintiffs &
figure above s
(Charles C. F
ork Congestio
Delaware
District Cour
22%
hers
7%
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
S
a
m
s
u
n
g
7
Most of the
by Freeny e
by Rec Soft
Congestion
shows top 5 p
Delaware Distr
Defendants
shows the top
Freeny, III B
on Solutions (
New Jers
District Co
5%
rt
S
o
n
y
7
lawsuits wer
et al closely fo
tware, and N
Solutions
P
preferred US
rict Court, clo
s:
p 8 Plaintiffs,
Bryan E. Free
(11 lawsuits).
sey
ourt
C.D. Californ
7%
N
L
G
E
l
e
c
t
r
o
n
i
c
s
6
re filed
followed
Network
Patent Litig
District Cou
osely followed
for the month
eny J ames P.
.
ia
.D. California
8%
E.D. Texas
21%
Network Cong
Nexus Displ
Quest Nett
E
H
T
C
5
gation Upd
urts for patent
d by Eastern
h of J uly 201
Freeny – 12
Freeny et a
Rec Softwar
estion Solution
ay Technologie
tech Corporatio
Sequent Dat
Uniloc USA
EMG Technolog
A
c
t
a
v
i
s
L
a
b
o
r
a
t
o
r
i
e
s
M
i
c
r
o
s
o
f
t
5 5
ates – Top
t lawsuit filin
District Cour
4. Clearly, m
2 lawsuits) fo
0 2
al
re
ns
es
on
ta
A
gy
5
Delaware D
for filing la
followed by
Together, th
lawsuits file
p Courts, Pl
ng. Evidently,
rt of Texas.
most of the law
ollowed by R
Sony (7)
Electronic
top 6 de
followed
(5), HTC
4 6
1
11
11
10
10
10
9
8
District Cour
awsuits in t
Texas Easte
he top 5 cour
ed during the
laintiffs &
, maximum P
wsuits were f
Rec Software
, Samsung (
cs (6) were a
fendants for
by Actavis L
(5) and Micr
6 8
12
rt was a pre
the month o
ern District C
rts accounted
e past month
Defendant
Patent Lawsui
filed by Freen
(11 lawsuits
(7) and LG
amongst the
the month,
Laboratories
osoft (5).
10 12
ferred choic
of July 2014
Court.
d ~63% of th
.
ts
its
ny
s),
ce
4,
he
The n
incre
comp
Patent
have
shows
Arriva
S.A. e
Stand
Zydus
Pharm
the m
The Top
Top US s
455/550.1
709/235 w
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Others
51%
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
number of
eased, Com
panies or i
t litigation i
increased th
s the trend
alStar and W
et.al Stands
ds second wit
s Pharmaceu
maceuticals I
month of J uly
PATENT L
Subclasses cov
of the entir
sub classes targ
1 which relates
which relates to
J
a
n
-
1
3
F
e
b
-
1
3
M
a
r
-
1
3
A
p
r
-
1
3
7
4 4
2
514/
7%
5
514 455 70
29
23
2
f patent inf
mputer/Ele
industries
itself has be
heir patent a
of Patent L
Wyncomm L
first with 45
th 38 Patent
uticals USA
Inc. and Len
y-2013.
15
12
7
6
6
LITIGATION
vered ~7% litiga
re class.
geted were:
to –Telecomm
o – Electrical C
M
a
y
-
1
3
J
u
n
-
1
3
J
u
l
-
1
3
A
u
g
1
3
4 4
2
023
%
514/279
7% 51
514/
7
51
514/4
7%
514/210.
13
7%
09 340 725
22
14 14
fringemen
ectronics, B
have incre
come a boo
actions and c
Litigations f
LLC. Arrival
5 number of
Litigations
Inc., Dell In
novo are the
5
5
5
N CASES FIL
ation US
munications: R
Computers An
A
u
g
-
1
3
S
e
p
-
1
3
O
c
t
-
1
3
N
o
v
-
1
3
4
5
2
0
14/314
7%
/345
%
14/411
7%
469
%
455
3
358 717 36
13 13
1
nt lawsuits
Business/C
easingly be
oming busine
continuing to
filed by the
lStar has thr
f Patent Litig
filed in the s
nc., Rea, Son
top defenda
4
LING BY TO
Subclass 455/5
litigation of th
Radio Telephon
nd Digital Proc
D
e
c
-
1
3
J
a
n
-
1
4
F
e
b
-
1
4
M
a
r
-
1
4
7
1
3
1
5/550.
1
30%
Others
22%
69 370 424
12 12
11
Pa
brought b
Consumer,
ecome targ
ess. NPE’s (
o filing Pate
e top 10 Pla
reatened man
gations filed
same month
ny Corporati
ants who are
45
38
OP PLANTI
550.1 covered ~3
he entire class.
ne Equipment
cessing System
M
a
r
1
4
A
p
r
-
1
4
M
a
y
-
1
4
J
u
n
-
1
4
1
2
4
3
455/009
13%
45
45
455/450
13%
Top
51
fo
co
Top
were
45
co
cla
Pate
atent Litig
by Non-Pra
, Biotech/P
gets.
(Non-Practic
ent Litigatio
antiffs and
ny Compani
in Past mon
of J uly.
on, Unisour
e defending t
FFS
IT
In
co
In
J o
an
Sy
A
C
te
30%
Details
ms: Multicompu
J
u
l
-
1
4
5
55/258
9%
55/418
13%
0
US classes th
14 covered ~9
llowed by 45
overed ~7% of
US subclass
e:
55/550.1 whic
overed ~50%,
asses.
ent Litigati
gations Fi
acticing En
Pharmaceu
cing Entities
ons in the U
the Chart i
ies with cost
nth (J uly-20
ce Worldwid
two or more
ArrivalStar S.
Wyncomm LL
UCB Inc. et al
Telecomm In
Sundesa LLC
Arunachalam
GlobeTecTrus
Icon Health a
Digital Signal
Eisai Co. Ltd.
TC Complai
n the month
omplaints we
nc., Enterpr
ohnson Outd
nd Valeo. T
ystems Tech
Apple, LG E
irrus Logic
echnology or C
Source:
US Subcla
litigati
uter Data Tran
709/235
50%
hat witnessed
9% of the litig
55 which cov
f the litigation
ses that wit
ch covered ~
of the litigati
on Update
iled by To
ntities (NP
utical and
s) and practi
S jurisdictio
is topped by
tly litigation
13) and Wyn
de Inc., Gato
e litigation c
A. et. al.
LC
l
novations LLC
m
st LLC
and Fitness Inc
Innovations L
et al.
ints trend
h of J uly
ere filed by
rise system
doors Inc, B
The complain
hnologies wa
Electronics,
c Inc on
Computer De
http://info.usitc.g
ass 709/235 cove
ion of the entire
nsferring; Con
709
18
Others
5%
d litigation ac
gation activity
vered ~7% an
n activity in Ju
nessed litiga
~30% and 7
on activity in
es – Techno
op Plantif
PEs) has
Telecom
icing entitie
ons. Figure 3
y NPE’s i.e
n, ArrivalSta
ncomm LLC
orade, Mylan
cases, filed in
c
LLC
2014, five
Choon’s De
m Technolog
ose Corpora
nt by Enterp
as filed aga
Samsung, H
Communica
evices.
gov/sec/dockets.nsf
ered ~50%
e class.
ngestion Avoid
/203
8%
709/206
14%
709/223
9%
709/224
4%
ctivity were:
y in July 2014
nd 709 which
uly 2014.
ation activity
709/235 which
respective US
ology tren
ffs
s
3
e.
ar
C
n
n
ITC
esign
gies,
ation,
prise
ainst
HTC,
ation
f/337?
ding
4,
h
y
h
S
ds
EFFE
We reco
we emp
when se
most sk
having o
to retain
technica
Effectua
MS) in
and hav
the clos
ensuring
Our tea
Law Sc
systems
Noida
B-55,
Noida
Phone
90136
ECTUAL
ognize our staf
ploy a sophisti
electing person
illed, diligent,
one of the best
n the brightest
al experts in In
al’s subject ma
science & tec
ve years of ind
se supervision
g quality and c
ams consist of
hools. They a
to meet the re
a, India
Ground Floor,
201301 – Indi
e: +91 120 456
73286
TEAM
ff to be our num
icated and thor
nnel. We do
and dedicated
t-trained teams
and most talen
dia.
atter experts ha
chnology, exc
dustry experien
n of US paten
onsistency on
f experienced
are educated an
equirements of
Sector 2,
ia
1797, +91
mber one asset
rough screenin
our utmost to
d staff. We prid
in the industry
nted patent pro
ave advanced d
ellent commun
nce. Our team
nt and tradem
all work produ
Lawyers from
nd trained in C
our Global cus
Delhi, In
210, DDA
District Ce
New Delh
Phone: +9
. Accordingly,
ng mechanism
o maintain the
de ourselves in
y. We are able
ofessionals and
degrees (PhD /
nication skills
m works under
mark attorneys,
ucts.
m India's Best
Common Law
stomers.
ndia
A Building No-
enter, J anak Pu
hi-58
91 9013948557
Email: info@
m
n
d
/
r
t
w
OUR
L
C
P
P
R
In
G
In
B
Cust
We se
Cust
We ke
when
Offices
Texa
-5,
uri,
7
2727
Dalla
Phon
Fax:
@effectualservi
R CUSTO
Law Firms – G
Corporations/I
Patent Monetiz
Patent Brokers
Research Instit
ndividual Inv
Government a
nsurance com
Banks
tomers – G
erve customer
tomers – K
eep our custom
it comes to cus
as, USA
LBJ Freeway,
as, Texas 7523
ne: +1-972-256
+1-972-910-06
ices.com
OMERS
General/ Spec
In-house Cou
zation Compa
s
tutions / Acad
entors
gencies
mpanies
Global foo
rs across the
Keeping C
mers happy – w
stomers.
U
, Suite 309,
4, US
6-8133
664
P
Simp
cialized
unsels
anies
demia
otprint
globe
Customers
we have a very
UK/Europe S
Phone: +44-20
lifying Le
s happy
high retention
Sales Contac
03-286-8233
gal Servic