SCAA SLP V AOR

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
[Under Article 136 ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%&
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION 'C( NO) OF *+1*
[A,%in#t !in%l rder d%ted 13)+*)*+1* P%##ed in -)P)'C(
N) .3*/ ! *+11 01 Hi," C$rt ! Del"i %t Ne2 Del"i&
S$3re4e C$rt Ad5c%te# A##ci%tin Petitiner
Ver#$#
S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% %nd Anr) Re#3ndent#

-it"
I) A) N) ! *+1*
A33lic%tin !r 3er4i##in t !ile SLP
PAPER BOOK
' FOR INDE6 7INDL8 SEE INSIDE(
Ad5c%te !r Petitiner9 P%r4%n%nd P%nde1
INDEX

Sl No. Particulars Page Nos
1) An !!ice re3rt n li4it%tin A
*) Li#tin, Pr!r4% A1: A*
3) Li#t ! D%te# %nd E5ent# ; : M
<) Certi!ied C31 ! !in%l rder d%ted 13)+*)*+1* 1 : **
P%##ed in -)P)'C( N) .3*/ ! *+11 01 t"e
Hi," C$rt ! Del"i %t Ne2 Del"i
=) S3eci%l Le%5e Petitin 2it" A!!id%5it) *3 : 36
6) ANNEXURE -P.1
T13ed c31 ! t"e Min$te# ! E>ec$ti5e 3/ : <+
C44ittee ! SC;A d%ted<)3)*++?
/) ANNEXURE -P.2
T13ed c31 ! t"e Min$te# ! E>ec$ti5e <1 : <=
C44ittee ! SC;A d%ted 1<)+1)*+11
.) ANNEXURE -P.3
T13ed c31 ! t"e letter d%ted 1?)+<)*+11 <6 : <.
! Mr) R%4 Jet"4%l%ni@ Senir Ad5c%te A
Me40er ! P%rli%4ent
?) ANNEXURE -P.4
T13ed c31 ! t"e !!ici%l B%Cette Nti!ic%tin <? : =+
S)O) 13<? 'E( d%ted +?)+6)*+11 i##$ed 01 t"e
Mini#tr1 ! L%2 D J$#tice@ B5t) ! Indi%
1+) ANNEXURE -P.
T13ed c31 ! t"e J$d,4ent d%ted 1*)1+)*+11 =1 E =6
3%##ed in 'ViF%1 D"%nFi C"%$d"%r1 Ver#$# S$"%#
J%1%nt N%t%2%dG%r( SLP 'C ( N) 1.<.1 ! *++?
01 t"e HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt
11) I) A) N) ! *+1* =/ : =?
A33lic%tin !r Per4i##in t !ile
S3eci%l Le%5e Petitin
LISTINB PROFORMA
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
1) N%t$re ! t"e 4%tter Ci5il
*) '%(N%4e ! Petitiner'#(AA33ell%nt'#( S$3re4e C$rt Ad5c%te#:
A##ci%tin
'0( e:4%il ID
3) '%(N%4e'#( ! Re#3ndent '#( S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% D Anr)
'0(e:4%il ID
<) N$40er ! c%#e S) L) P) 'C( N) ! *+1*
=) '%(Ad5c%te'#( !r Petitiner'#( P%r4%n%nd P%nde1
'0(e:4%il ID
6) '%( Ad5c%te'#( !r Re#3ndent '#( N) A)
'0( e:4%il ID
/) Sectin de%lin, 2it" t"e 4%tter 6IV
.) D%te ! t"e i43$,ned OrderAJ$d,4ent 13)*)*+1*)
.A) N%4e ! HnI0le J$d,e# HnH0le Mr) A) 7) SiGiri@ Actin, C) J)
HnH0le Mr R%Fee5 S%"%1 Endl%2@ J)
.;) In L%nd AcJ$i#itin M%tter# 9 N) A)
i( Nti!ic%tinAB5t) Order N) $A#) <@6())))))))))))))
d%ted)))))))))))))))))))))))i##$ed 01 CentreASt%te !)))))))))))
ii( E>%ct 3$r3#e ! %cJ$i#itin D 5ill%,e in5l5ed))))))))
.C) In Ci5il M%tter# 9: N)A)
i( S$it N)@ N%4e ! L2er C$rt))))))))
D%te ! J$d,4ent)))))))))))))))))) N) A)
.D) In -rit Petitin#9: N) A)
KC%tc"2rdL ! t"er #i4il%r 4%tter#)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))
.E) In c%#e ! Mtr Ve"icle Accident M%tter# 9 N) A)
Ve"icle N))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))
.F) In Ser5ice M%tter# N) A)
'i( Rele5%nt #er5ice r$le@ i! %n1))
'ii(B)O)ACirc$l%rANti!ic%tin@ i! %33lic%0le r in J$e#tin)))))))))
.B) In L%0$r Ind$#tri%l Di#3$te# M%tter# 9 N) A)
I)D) Re!erenceAA2%rd N)@ i! %33lic%0le ))))))))))))))))))))))))
.E) N%t$re ! $r,enc19 M%tter rel%ted Ri,"t t Pr%ctice ! t"er
Ad5c%te# in t"e HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt
! Indi% %!ter nti!ic%tin ! Sectin 3+ !
t"e Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61
?) In c%#e it i# % T%> 4%tter 9 N) A)
%( T%> %4$nt in5l5ed in t"e 4%tter)))))))))))))))))))
0( -"et"er % re!erenceA#t%te4ent ! t"e c%#e 2%# c%lled !r r
reFected)))))))))
c( -"et"er #i4il%r t%> 4%tter# ! #%4e 3%rtie# !iled e%rlier
'4%1 0e !r e%rlierAt"er A##e##4ent 8e%r(M)))))))))))))
d( E>e43tin Nti!ic%tinACirc$l%r N)))))))))))))
11) V%l$%tin ! t"e 4%tter 9 N) A)
1*) Cl%##i!ic%tin ! t"e 4%tter 9
'Ple%#e !ill $3 t"e n$40er D n%4e ! rele5%nt c%te,r1
2it" #$0 c%te,r1 %# 3er t"e li#t circ$l%ted(
N) ! S$0Fect C%te,r1 2it" !$ll n%4e 9
N) ! #$0:c%te,r1 2it" !$ll n%4e 9
:*:
13) Title ! t"e Act in5l5ed 'CentreASt%te( Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% %nd
Ad5c%te# Act@ S$3re4e C$rt R$le#@ 1?66
1<) '%( S$0:Cl%##i!ic%tin 'indic%te SectinAArticle ! t"e St%t$te()))
Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?66
'0( S$0:Sectin in5l5ed)))) N)A)
'c( Title ! t"e R$le# in5l5ed 'CentreASt%te())))))))))N) A)
'd( S$0:cl%##i!ic%tin 'indic%te R$leAS$0:r$le ! t"e St%t$te())N) A)
1=) Pint ! l%2 %nd J$e#tin ! l%2 r%i#ed in t"e c%#e9 -"et"er t"e
Di5i#in ;enc" ! HnH0le Hi," C$rt "%# !%iled t %33reci%te t"%t@
t"e d$%lit1 e>i#tin, in t"e !ield ! le,%l 3r!e##in 2%# ended 01 t"e
en%ct4ent ! t"e Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61 %nd t"e S$3re4e C$rt R$le#
cntin$in, t"i# d$%lit1 in t"e S$3re4e C$rt 01 5irt$e ! Sectin =. !
t"e Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61 c%4e t %n end %!ter c4in, int !rce !
Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61M
16) -"et"er 4%tter i# nt t 0e li#ted 0e!re %n1 HnI0le J$d,eM
Mentin t"e n%4e ! t"e HnI0le J$d,e)))) N) A)
1/) P%rtic$l%r# ! identic%lA#i4il%r c%#e#@ i! %n1
%( Pendin, c%#e#)))))))))))))))
0( Decided c%#e# 2it" cit%tin))))))))))
1/A) -%# SLPAA33e%lA-rit !iled %,%in#t #%4e i43$,ned J$d,4entArder
e%rlierM I! 1e#@ 3%rtic$l%r#))))))

1.) -"et"er t"e 3etitin i# %,%in#t interlc$tr1A!in%l rderAdecree in t"e
c%#e Fin%l
1?) I! it i# % !re#" 4%tter@ 3le%#e #t%te t"e n%4e ! t"e Hi," C$rt %nd
t"e Cr%4 in t"e i43$,ned J$d,4entAOrder)))) Del"i Hi," C$rt@
HnH0le Mr) A) 7) SiGiri@ A) C) J) %nd HnH0le Mr R%Fee5 S%"%1 Endl%2@J)
*+) I! t"e 4%tter 2%# %lre%d1 li#ted in t"i# C$rt 9 N) A)
%( -"en 2%# it li#tedM))))))))))
0( -"%t 2%# t"e Cr%4M)))))
c( -"%t 2%# t"e directin ! t"e C$rt))))))
*1) -"et"er % d%te "%# %lre%d1 0een !i>ed eit"er 01 C$rt r n 0ein,
4entined !r t"e "e%rin, ! 4%tterM I! #@ 3le%#e indic%te t"e d%te
!i>ed))))))) N) A)
**) I# t"ere % c%5e%trM I! #@ 2"et"er % ntice "%# 0een i##$ed t "i4M
N) A)
*3) -"et"er d%te entered in t"e C43$terM))))))) N) A)
*<) I! it i# % cri4in%l 4%tter@ 3le%#e #t%te 9 N) A)
%( -"et"er %cc$#ed "%# #$rrendered)))))))))))))))
0( N%t$re ! !!ence@ i)e) cn5icted $nder Sectin 2it" Act)))))))))))
c( Sentence %2%rded))))))))))
d( Sentence %lre%d1 $nder,ne 01 t"e %cc$#ed))))))))
*< e( 'i( FIRARCAetc)))))))))) N) A)
D%te ! Re,i#tr%tin ! FIR etc)))))))))))))
N%4e D 3l%ce ! t"e Plice St%tin)))))))
'ii( N%4e D 3l%ce ! Tri%l C$rt9
C%#e N) in Tri%l C$rt %nd D%te ! J$d,4ent
'iii( N%4e %nd 3l%ce ! 1#t A33ell%te C$rt9
C%#e N) in 1#t A33ell%te C$rt D d%te ! J$d,4ent9
D%ted9 +*)/)*+1* 'P%r4%n%nd P%nde1(
Ad5c%te !r Petitiner 'S(AA33ell%nt'#(
LIST OF DATES AND EVENTS
T"e 3re#ent S3eci%l Le%5e Petitin i# !iled 01 t"e 3etitiner
%##ci%tin %,%in#t t"e i43$,ned !in%l rder %nd F$d,4ent d%ted
13)+*)*+1* 3%##ed 01 HnH0le Del"i Hi," C$rt in -rit Petitin 'C (
N).3*/ ! *+11@ ;%lr%F Sin," M%liG Ver#$# S$3re4e C$rt !
Indi%@ 2"ere01 t"e Hi," C$rt "%# di#4i##ed t"e 3etitin %t t"e
%d4i##in #t%,e it#el! 2it"$t i##$in, ntice t t"e S$3re4e
C$rt A t"e re#3ndent 2it"$t in5itin, %n1 re#3n#e !r4 t"e
re#3ndent %# 2ell %# Unin ! Indi% in 5ie2 ! t"e nti!ic%tin !
Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te Act@ 1?61 %!ter =+ 1e%r# #$c" 3r5i#in
! t"e #t%t$te c%4e int !rce)
1?*+ Under t"e ;riti#" r$le@ NT"e J$dici%l C44ittee ! t"e
Pri51 C$ncil in En,l%ndH "%d 0een t"e "i,"e#t Tri0$n%l !r
Indi%@ %nd !r !$nctinin, ! t"e F$dici%l #1#te4 Pri51 C$ncil
R$le# 2ere !r%4ed %nd $nder KT"e Pri51 C$ncil R$le#@ 1?*+L
%nd KR$le# ! t"e J$dici%l C44ittee ! Pri51 C$ncil@ 1?*=L
t"e #1#te4 ! KABENTL 2%# 3re5%ilin,)
1?3/ T"e NB5ern4ent ! Indi% Act@ 1?3=H e#t%0li#"ed %
KFeder%l C$rt ! Indi%L %nd it 2%# in%$,$r%ted in Ne2 Del"i)
T"e in%$,$r%tin ! t"e Feder%l C$rt nece##it%ted t"e
e#t%0li#"4ent ! % 2ell:r,%niCed Feder%l ;%r) A# Del"i 2%#
nt t"e #e%t ! %n1 Hi," C$rt@ t"ere 2%# n ;%r "%5in,
di#tin,$i#"ed l%21er# "ere %nd t"%t nece##it%ted !r%4in, !
r$le# in %0#ence ! L%21er# !r 3r3er c44$nic%tin t t"e
%r,$in, C$n#el# %nd !r !$nctinin, ! Feder%l C$rt@ %nd in
t"e 1e%r 1?3/ it#el! Feder%l C$rt R$le# 2ere !r%4ed A
i##$ed@ in t"%t 5er1 r$le# t"e #1#te4 ! Ad5c%te %nd A,ent
2%# 3re5%ilin, in Order IV@ t"e cnditin ! 3r%ctice !r Senir
Ad5c%te@ Ad5c%te %nd A,ent 2%# cdi!ied)
It i# e##enti%l t 3int $t "ere t"%t d$rin, t"e ;riti#"
er% t"e le,%l 3r!e##in%l# in Indi% "%5in, li4ited ri,"t# %nd
d$tie# t 3r!e## A 3r%ctice 0e!re t"e di!!erent C$rt#@
Tri0$n%l# %# 2ell %# 0e!re t"e A$t"ritie# %nd $nder t"e
R$le# ! C$rt# t"e Le,%l Pr!e##in%l# ,t t"e4#el5e#
enrlled A re,i#tered %# 3er t"e 3r5i#in# ! t"e t"en l%2#@
%t di!!erent 3l%ce#O 5iC9 Le,%l Pr%ctitiner# Act@ 1./?@
;40%1 Ple%der# Act@ 1?*+@ T"e Indi%n ;%r C$ncil# Act@
1?*6)
1?</ T"%t 2it" t"e 3litic%l c"%n,e# in t"e c$ntr1 Indi%n
Inde3endence Act 2%# 3%##ed in t"e 1e%r 1?</ %nd t"e
Cn#tit$ent A##e40l1 3%##ed NFeder%l C$rt 'Enl%r,e4ent !
J$ri#dictin( Act@ 1?</H %nd NA0litin ! Pri51 C$ncil
J$ri#dictin Act@ 1?<?H %nd Feder%l C$rt 2%# ,i5en %ll
32er# ! Pri51 C$ncil)
*.
t"
J%n$%r1 1?=+ HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% 2%#
in%$,$r%ted n in t"e C$ncil C"%40er@ in t"e C$rt R4@
2"ere t"e Feder%l C$rt $#ed t "%5e it# #ittin,#) A# 3er t"e
3r5i#in ! Article 1<= ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%@ t"e
HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt !r%4edA4%de KT"e S$3re4e C$rt
R$le#@ 1?=+L '"erein%!ter re!erred %# NSCR 1?=+H(@ %nd 2it"
t"e %33r5%l ! t"e Pre#ident ! Indi% #$c" R$le# c%4e int
e>i#tence@ t"e ORDER IV ! NSCR 1?=+H 2%# !r t"e
Ad5c%te# %nd ABENTS %nd t2%rd# t"e end ! 1?<? %
!eelin, 2%# 5iced in #4e J$%rter# t"%t in rder t red$ce
c#t ! liti,%tin t"e d$%l #1#te4 #"$ld 0e %0li#"ed %nd
J$nir Ad5c%te# #"$ld %ct !r t"e client# 2"ere%# Senir
Ad5c%te #"$ld nl1 3le%d !r t"e4@ %ccrdin,l1 it 2%#
c%te,ric%ll1 4entined t"erein in t"e nte %#O
Nte#9: T"e R$le# cnt%ined in t"i# Order %re
#$0Fect t re5i#in %t t"e end ! 3erid ! t2 1e%r#)
!"e #o$%&le 'u(ges o) t"e *ourt "a+e u$(er
co$si(eratio$ a ,ro,osal to a&olis" t"e -(ual.
s/ste0)
R$le 1 ! Order IV ! NSCR 1?=+H 3r5ide# %# !ll2#9
1 T"e n%4e# ! %ll 3er#n# 2" "%5e "eret!re
0een enrlled %# Ad5c%te# %nd A,ent# ! t"e Feder%l
C$rt #"%ll@ %# !r4 t"e c44ence4ent ! t"e#e R$le#
0e dee4ed t "%5e 0een tr%n#!erred t t"e Rll# !
Ad5c%te# %nd A,ent#@ re#3ecti5el1@ ! t"e S$3re4e
C$rt@ %nd #$c" Ad5c%te# #"%ll t%Ge 3recedence in t"e
S$3re4e C$rt in t"e rder in 2"ic" t"e1 2ere enrlled
in Feder%l C$rt)
1?=1 NT"e S$3re4e C$rt Ad5c%te# 'Pr%ctice in Hi,"
C$rt#( Act@ 1?=1L c%4e int !rce %nd Ad5c%te# 3r%cticin,
in S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% 2ere ,i5en %n eJ$%l ri,"t t
3r%ctice in t"e Hi," C$rt#)
1?=3 T cn#lid%te t"e l%2 rel%tin, t Le,%l Pr%ctitiner# A
Pr!e##in%l# in t"e 1e%r KAll:Indi% ;%r C44itteeL 2%#
cn#tit$ted %nd !r cre%tin ! $ni!r4 All:Indi% ;%r@ #$c"
C44ittee !r4$l%ted 3r3#%l#)
1?=< S4e %4end4ent 2ere 4%de in NSCR 1?=+H@
rele5%nt %4end4ent# %re !ll2in,9
'1( in ORDER I
R$le *@ #$0:r$le '1(:
'0( !r t"e de!initin ! KA,entL t"e !ll2in, #"%ll 0e
#$0#tit$ted n%4el19:
-Age$t. 4e%n# %n A,ent ! t"e Rll# ! t"e C$rt %#
n t"e *6
t"
J%n$%r1 1?=<)L
'd( in t"e de!initin ! KP%rt1L !r t"e 2rd KA,entL@
2"ere5er it cc$r#@ t"e 2rd# KAd5c%te n recrdL
#"%ll 0e #$0#tit$ted)
*6
t"
J%n$%r1 1?=< It i# 3ertinent t 4entin "ere t"%t
3$r#$%nce t t"i# %4end4ent %ll t"e KABENTSL n t"e Rll !
NS$3re4e C$rt ! Indi%H %re c%lled %# KAd5c%te#:n:
RecrdL)
1?=. T"%t in 5ie2 ! t"e 3r3#%l# ! KAll:Indi% ;%r
C44itteeL t"e KL%2 C44i##in ! Indi%L 3re3%red %
det%iled P$e#tinn%ire %nd in5ited t"e le,%l E>3ert# %nd le,%l
Pr!e##in%l# !r4 %ll 5er Indi%@ %nd % l%r,e n$40er ! #$c"
Le,%l E>3ert# A Pr!e##in%l# %n#2ered t"e det%iled
P$e#tinn%ire !r4$l%ted 01 L%2 C44i##in@ %nd %!ter
det%iled cn#ider%tin# ! 4%teri%l#@ t"e NL%2 C44i##in !
Indi%H #$04itted it# Fourteenth Report n KREFORMS OF
JUDICIAL ADMINISTRATIONL@ t"e C"%3ter *6 ! t"i# Re3rt
2%# 2it" re,%rd t ;AR %nd t"e L%2 C44i##in
rec44ended t t"e B5ern4ent ! Indi% t 3r5ide t"e
Ad5c%te# ! t"i# c$ntr1 n % C44n Rll %nd t"e1 #"$ld
"%5e ri,"t t 3r%ctice in %ll c$rt# ! Indi% !r4 "i,"e#t t
t"e l2e#t)
1?61 In 3$r#$%nce t t"e rec44end%tin# ! L%2
C44i##in ! Indi% $r P%rli%4ent "%# en%cted NT"e
Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61L 2it" 0Fect t %4end %nd cn#lid%te
t"e l%2 rel%tin, t le,%l Pr%ctitiner# %nd t 3r5ide !r t"e
cn#tit$tin ! t"e ;%r C$ncil# %nd %n NAll:Indi% ;%rH@ t"e
Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61 3r5ide# !r %
3r5i#in t"%t@ e5er1 Ad5c%te 2"#e n%4e entered in t"e
St%te Rll "%# ri,"t t 3r%ctice in %ll C$rt# incl$din,
S$3re4e C$rt %# 2ell %# 0e!re Tri0$n%l# %nd %$t"ritie#) A#
3er t"e 3r5i#in ! Sectin =+ ! t"e Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61@
Le,%l Pr%ctitiner# Act@ 1./?@ ;40%1 Ple%der# Act@ 1?*+@
T"e Indi%n ;%r C$ncil# Act@ 1?*6 %nd Letter# P%tent ! t"e
Hi," C$rt# %nd %n1 t"er l%2 rel%tin, t t"e %d4i##in %nd
enrl4ent ! le,%l 3r%ctitiner# c%4e t 0e re3e%led@ %nd
!r4 ti4e t ti4e St%te ;%r C$ncil# 0ec%4e !$nctin%l)
1=)1)1?66 S$3re4e C$rt R$le# re!r%4ed 01 t"i# HnH0le
C$rt c%4e int !rce %nd n 1)3)1?66 Re,$l%tin# re,%rdin,
Ad5c%te E n : Recrd E>%4in%tin 2%# nti!ied)
T"e S$3re4e C$rt R$le#@ 1?66 '"erein %!ter
re!erred %# KSCR 1?66L( de!ined t"ree c%te,rie# !
Ad5c%te# 3r%cticin, 0e!re t"i# HnH0le C$rt@ R$le * '%(
%nd '0( ! Order I ! KSCR 1?66L %l# de!ined t"e 2rd
KAd5c%teL %nd KAd5c%te:n:RecrdL@ 2"ic" %re %# !ll2#9
I) Senir Ad5c%te
II) Ad5c%te:n:Recrd
III) J$nir Ad5c%te ANn Ad5c%te:n:Recrd
'!"e 1or( 'u$ior A(+ocate i$ t"e -S*R 1233. is i$
co$tra(ictio$ to t"e ,ro+isio$s o) A(+ocates Act4 1231(
Under t"e KSCR 1?66L !r 0ein, J$%li!ied %nd
re,i#tered %# %n Ad5c%te:n:Recrd $nder t"e R$le = !
Order IV ! t"e KSCR 1?66L rele5%nt 3r5i#in# %re %# $nder9
=) N %d5c%te #"%ll 0e J$%li!ied t 0e re,i#tered %# %n
Ad5c%te n Recrd $nle##9:
'i( "i# n%4e i#@ %nd "%# 0een 0rne n t"e rll !
%n1 St%te ;%r C$ncil !r % 3erid ! nt le## t"%n !$r
1e%r# n t"e d%te ! c44ence4ent ! "i# tr%inin, %#
3r5ided "erein%!terO
Pr5ided "2e5er@ i! %n1 c%ndid%te "%# e%rlier
%33e%red in %n1 ! t"e Ad5c%te:n:Recrd E>%4in%tin
"e #"%ll cntin$e t 0e # eli,i0le t #it in %n1 #$0#eJ$ent
e>%4in%tin)
['%%(& % Slicitr n t"e rll# ! t"e ;40%1
Incr3r%ted L%2 Sciet1 #"%ll 0e e>e43ted !r4 #$c"
tr%inin, %nd te#t i! "i#A"er n%4e i#@ %nd "%# 0een 0rne
n t"e rll ! St%te ;%r C$ncil !r 3erid nt le## t"%n
#e5en 1e%r# n t"e d%te ! 4%Gin, t"e %33lic%tin !r
re,i#tr%tin %# %n Ad5c%te:n:Recrd&)
'ii( "e "%# $nder,ne tr%inin, !r ne 1e%r 2it" %n
Ad5c%te:n:Recrd %33r5ed 01 t"e C$rt@ %nd "%#
t"ere%!ter 3%##ed #$c" te#t# %# 4%1 0e "eld 01 t"e
C$rt !r %d5c%te# 2" %33l1 t 0e re,i#tered %#
Ad5c%te:n:Recrd 3%rtic$l%r# 2"ere! #"%ll 0e
nti!ied in t"e O!!ici%l B%Cette !r4 ti4e t ti4e
3r5ided "2e5er t"%t:
a An Attrne1 #"%ll 0e e>e43ted !r4 #$c" )
tr%inin, %nd te#tO %nd
b T"e C"ie! J$#tice 4%1@ in %33r3ri%te ) c%#e#@
,r%nt e>e43tin:
1 Fr4 t"e reJ$ire4ent ! tr%inin, $nder t"i#
cl%$#e in t"e c%#e ! %n %d5c%te@ 2"#e n%4e i#
0rne n t"e rll ! %n1 St%te ;%r C$ncil %nd "%#
0een 0rne n #$c" rll !r % 3erid ! nt le## t"%n
ten 1e%r#O
1?.= A l%r,e n$40er ! Ad5c%te# %re nt ,ettin, %n1 #ci%l
#ec$rit1 01 t"e ,5ern4ent r%t"er t"e1 %re di5ided int
3litic%l ,r$3#@ nt 3$r#$in, 3r3er 4ec"%ni#4 !r
3rtectin ! t"eir intere#t t"ere!re %!ter en%ct4ent ! t"e
Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61@ Sectin 3+ 2%# nt nti!ied t"ere!re
t"i# 0ene!ici%l 3r5i#in did nt c4e int !rce@ $lti4%tel1
t"e HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt 0#er5ed %# re3rted inO
125 S** 617 482 'Lin,%33% Pc"%nn% A33el2%r And Or#)
Ver#$# St%te O! M%"%r%#"tr% %nd Anr) Etc)(@
KS$c" % ri,"t i# n d$0t cn!erred 01 S)3+ ! t"e
Ad5c%te# Act) ;$t $n!rt$n%tel1 !r t"e le,%l
3r!e##in@ S)3+ "%# nt 0een 0r$,"t int !rce # !%r
t"$," t"e Act "%# 0een n t"e St%t$te ;G !r t"e
l%#t ** 1e%r#) T"ere i# 5er1 little t"%t 2e c%n d in t"e
4%tter %nd it i# !r t"e ;%r t t%Ge it $3 el#e2"ere) A
3er#n enrlled %# %n %d5c%te $nder t"e Ad5c%te Act
i# nt i3# !%ct entitled t % ri,"t ! %$dience in %ll
C$rt# $nle## S)3+ ! t"%t Act i# !ir#t 0r$,"t int
!rce) T"%t i# % 4%tter 2"ic" i# #till re,$l%ted 01
di!!erent #t%t$te# %nd t"e e>tent ! t"e ri,"t t 3r%ctice
4$#t de3end n t"e ter4# ! t"#e #t%t$te#) T"e ri,"t
! %n %d5c%te 0r$,"t n t"e rll# t 3r%cti#e i#@
t"ere!re@ F$#t 2"%t i# cn!erred n "i4 01 S)l<'1('%(@
'0( %nd 'c( t"e ;%r C$ncil# Act@ 1?*6L)

1?.. A,%in ne ! t"e Ad5c%te# ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt !iled
% -rit Petitin %nd %!ter det%iled cn#ider%tin t"e HnH0le
S$3re4e C$rt "%d i##$ed % 2rit in t"e n%t$re ! 4%nd%4$#
t t"e Centr%l B5ern4ent 2"ic" re3rted inO 612557 4 S**
4 'Aelte4e#" Rein Ver#$# Unin ! Indi%(
Kt cn#ider 2it"in % 3erid ! #i> 4nt"# 2"et"er
#ectin 3+ ! t"e Act #"$ld 0e 0r$,"t int !rce r
ntL@ 0$t %!ter l%3#e ! 4%n1 1e%r# B5t) "%d nt dne
%n1t"in,)
*++3 HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt "%d %,%in #"2n it# di#3le%#$re
%nd 0#er5ed t"%t 2"ic" re3rted inO
2993 65 7S** 29 'C44n C%$#e Ver#$# Unin ! Indi% D
Or#)(
K2e %re ! t"e 5ie2 t"%t t"i# deci#in de# nt c4e in
t"e 2%1 ! t"i# C$rt i##$in, % 2rit in t"e n%t$re !
4%nd%4$# t t"e Centr%l B5ern4ent t cn#ider
2"et"er t"e ti4e !r 0rin,in, Sectin 3+ ! t"e Act int
!rce "%# %rri5ed r ntQ))R
+<)+3)*++? T"%t t"e E>ec$ti5e C44ittee ! t"e S$3re4e
C$rt ;%r A##ci%tin 'SC;A in #"rt( 3%##ed % re#l$tin n
<)3)*++? !r 4%Gin, re3re#ent%tin t t"e HnH0le C"ie!
J$#tice ! Indi% reJ$e#tin, "i4 !r cn#ider%tin ! %4endin,
t"e SCR 1?66 n t"e !ll2in, line#9 i() Pr5idin, t"e
e>e43tin t Ad5c%te Me40er# "%5in, ten 1e%r# %t ;%r
'SC;A ( %nd e>3erience ! dr%!tin, 3etitin# ! 1++ r %05e
in %ll@ 0e e>e43ted !r4 t"e 3%##in, ! E>%4A te#t %#
3re#cri0ed in t"e Order IV ! SCR 1?66 !r re,i#terin,A
enrllin, t"e4#el5e# %# AOR ! t"i# C$rt@ %# e>e43tin
%5%il%0le t t"e K Attrne1#L %nd K Slicitr#L $nder R$le ='i(
'%%( %nd 'ii('%( re#3ecti5el1)
ii() T %4end SCR 1?66 %nd 4%Ge % 3r5i#in t"%t 2"ene5er
% 3etitin liGe SLPA-PAA33lic%tin# etc) %re !iled@ in t"#e
3etitin# n%4e ! cnd$ctin, Ad5c%te# 2" dr%2# t"e
3etitin 4%1 0e reJ$ired t 0e 2ritten in t"e 3etitin %nd in
t"e C%$#e Li#t i##$ed 01 t"e Re,i#tr1 ! t"i# C$rt %ln, 2it"
t"e n%4e ! AOR#) A t13ed c31 ! t"e E>cer3t# !
Min$te# ! E>ec$ti5e C44ittee ! SC;A dt)<)3)*++? i#
%nne>ed %# A$$e:ure ; P. 1 'P%,e#3/ : <+ (
1<)+1)*+11 A,%in t"e E>ec$ti5e C44ittee ! SC;A 3%##ed
%n $n%ni4$# re#l$tin n 1<)+1)*+11 !r #$04ittin, 0e!re
t"i# HnH0le C$rt in t"e c%#e ! ViF%1 D"%nFi C"%$d"%r1@ SLP
'C( NO) 1.<.1A*++? %nd t"e re#l$tin cnt%ined 5%ri$#
#$,,e#tin# 2it" re,%rd t #l5in, t"e i43lic%tin# ! AOR
#1#te4 J$% 4%Frit1 ! SC;A 4e40er# 3r%cticin, 0e!re t"e
S$3re4e C$rt) A t13ed c31 ! t"e Min$te# ! E>ec$ti5e
C44ittee ! SC;A dt)1<)+1)*+11 i# %nne>ed %# A$$e:ure
; P. 2 'P%,e# <1 E <=()
1?)+<)*+11 In 5ie2 ! t"e %05e #%id circ$4#t%nce# %nd
F$dici%l 3rn$nce4ent# ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt@ Mr) R%4
Jet"4%l%ni@ Senir Ad5c%te A Me40er ! P%rli%4entA t"e
t"en Pre#ident ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt ;%r A##ci%tin 4%de %
re3re#ent%tin t t"e t"en L%2 Mini#ter@ B5ern4ent ! Indi%
reJ$e#tin, "i4 t"%t t"e 3r5i#in cnt%ined in Sectin 3+ !
t"e Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61 #"$ld 0e 0r$,"t int !rce)
A t13ed c31 ! t"e re3re#ent%tin d%ted 1?)+<)*+11 ! Mr)
R%4 Jet"4%l%ni@ Senir Ad5c%te A Me40er ! P%rli%4ent
#ent t L%2 Mini#ter@ B5ern4ent ! Indi% i# %nne>ed
"ere2it" %nd 4%rGed %# ANNEXURE; P. 3
'P%,e# <6 E <. (
+?)+6)*+11 It %33e%r# t"%t in re#3n#e t t"e reJ$e#t 01 #%id
letter d%ted 1?)+<)*+11 ! Mr) R%4 Jet"4%l%ni@ t"e Mini#tr1
! L%2 %nd J$#tice@ B5ern4ent ! Indi% i##$ed % nti!ic%tin
$nder Sectin 1'3( ! t"e Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61@ 0rin,in, int
!rce 2) e) !) 1=
t"
J$ne *+11@ Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te#
Act@ 1?61@ 2"ic" i# 3$0li#"ed in !!ici%l ,%Cette)
A t13ed c31 ! t"e !!ici%l B%Cette Nti!ic%tin S)O)
13<? 'E( d%ted +?)+6)*+11 i##$ed 01 t"e Mini#tr1 ! L%2 D
J$#tice@ B5t) ! Indi% i# %nne>ed "ere2it" %nd 4%rGed %#
ANNEXURE ; P. 4 'P%,e# <? : =+()
1*)1+)*+11 It i# 2rt" 2"ile t 4entin "ere t"%t t"e HnH0le
S$3re4e C$rt "%d #$ 4t t%Gen $3 t"e i##$e re,%rdin, t"e
4%l3r%ctice# %d3ted 01 t"e Ad5c%te n Recrd %nd #$,"t
%##i#t%nce ! ;%r A##ci%tin# !r Kt !ind %33r3ri%te #l$tin#
%nd 3r5ide nece##%r1 c"ecG# %nd 0%l%nce#L in t"e 4%tter ! 'ViF%1
D"%nFi C"%$d"%r1 Ver#$# S$"%# J%1%nt N%t%2%dG%r( SLP 'C ( N)
1.<.1 ! *++? 2"ic" i# di#3#ed ! 2it" t"e 0#er5%tin@
K-e %re in!r4ed 01 t"e re,i#tr1 t"%t t"e
R$le C44ittee ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% i#
%lre%d1 #eiCed ! 4#t ! t"e i##$e# t"%t "%5e 0een
r%i#ed in t"e#e #$,,e#tin#) T"ere!re 2e
dee4 it %33r3ri%te t 3l%ce %ll t"e#e
#$,,e#tin# 0e!re t"e R$le C44ittee # t"%t t"e
C44ittee c%n t%Ge nte ! t"e #%4e 2"ile
!r4$l%tin, ne2 r %dditin%l r$le# r 2"ile
#$,,e#tin, %4end4ent# t t"e e>i#tin, r$le#)L
;$t %# 3er t"e Gn2led,e ! t"e 3etitiner t"e 4%tter i#
3endin, 0e!re t"e HnH0le R$le C44ittee ! t"e
S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi%) A t13ed c31 ! t"e
J$d,4ent d%ted 1*)1+)*+11 3%##ed in 'ViF%1 D"%nFi
C"%$d"%r1 Ver#$# S$"%# J%1%nt N%t%2%dG%r( SLP 'C ( N)
1.<.1 ! *++? 01 t"e HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt i# %nne>ed
"ere2it" %nd 4%rGed %# ANNEXURE; P. 'P%,e# =1 : =+()
1=)11)*+11 An %d5c%te ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt !iled % -rit Petitin 'C( N)
.3*/A*+11 in Del"i Hi," C$rt c"%llen,in, t"e #1#te4 ! Ad5c%te:
n:Recrd in t"e S$3re4e C$rt)
1*)1*)*+11 A #i4il%r A##ci%tin "%# !iled % Inter5entin A
I43le%d4ent A33lic%tin 5ide C)M) N) 1?616 ! *+11 t
i43le%ded %# 3%rt1 re#3ndent in -)P)'C(N).3*/ ! *+11
13)+*)*+1* H2e5er t"e Hi," C$rt di#4i##ed t"e 3etitin
01 3%##in, t"e i43$,ned !in%l rder %nd F$d,4ent d%ted
13)+*)*+1* in -rit Petitin 'C( N).3*/ ! *+11@ ;%lr%F Sin,"
M%liG Ver#$# S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% 2it"$t i##$in, ntice t
t"e #le re#3ndent %nd 2it"$t #eeGin, t"e re#3n#e ! t"e
S$3re4e C$rtAre#3ndent %# 2ell %# Unin ! Indi%) -"ile
# di#4i##in, t"e 3etitin@ t"e HnH0le Hi," C$rt !%iled t
cn#ider t"e %r,$4ent# 4%de 01 t"e C$n#el !r inter5ener:
3etitiner t"erein 2it" re,%rd t t"e 5il%tin ! !$nd%4ent%l
ri,"t# ! Ad5c%te# $nder Article 1?'1(',( %nd Article 1< !
t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%) T"e Hi," C$rt relied $3n t"e
F$d,4ent ! Lill1 I#%0el T"4%#H# c%#e@ 1?6<'6( SCR **?
2"ic" i# 0%#ed n tr%n#itr1 3r5i#in n%4el1 Sectin =. !
t"e Ad5c%te# Act) -"ile # din, t"e Hi," C$rt !%iled t
%33reci%te t"%t Sectin =. ! t"e Act l#t it# !rce %# #n %#
Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te# Act 2%# 0r$,"t in t !rce in
J$ne *+11 %nd t"ere!re@ t"e F$d,4ent "%# n 3recedenti%l
5%l$e in re#3ect ! t"e e!!ect ! Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te#
Act n t"e ri,"t $nder Article 1? '1( ',( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin)
T"e t"er 3r5i#in relied $3n 01 t"e Hi," C$rt i# Sectin
=* ! t"e Ad5c%te Act 2"ic" it 2%# %r,$ed 01 t"e C$n#el
!r t"e 3etitiner "erein t"%t t"e #%4e i# $ncn#tit$tin%l %#
$nder t"e ,%r0 ! #%5in, cl%$#e it "%# t"e e!!ect ! %4endin,
Article 1<= '1( '%( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin)
+*)+/)*+1* HENCE THE PERESENT SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION)
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
[Under Order 6VI R$le <'1('%(&
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
[UNDER ARTICLE 136 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA&
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION 'CIVIL( NO) OF *+1*
;ET-EEN9 PARTIES NAME
IN THE IN THIS
HIBH COURT COURT
Su,re0e *ourt A(+ocates Associatio$4
Re3re#ented t"r$," it# Hnr%r1 Secret%r1@
;%r l$n,e@ B)F)@
S$3re4e C$rt C%43$#@
Ne2 Del"i:11+++1 Q)Petitio$er

AND
1. Su,re0e *ourt o) I$(ia
t"r$," it# Re,i#tr%r Bener%l@
S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi%@ Til%G M%r,@
Ne2 Del"i:11+++1 Re#3ndent Cnte#tin,
) Re#3ndent
2. Balra< Si$g" =ali>@
SA L%te S") R)D)S) M%liG@
C"%40er N) ?3@
S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi%@ Til%G M%r,@
Ne2 Del"i:11+++1 Petitiner Pr!r4% )
Re#3ndent

TO
HONI;LE THE CHIEF JUSTICE OF INDIA AND HIS
COMPANION JUDBES OF THE HONI;LE SUPREME COURT)
T"e S3eci%l Le%5e Petitin ! t"e Petitiner %05e n%4edO
=OS! RESPE*!?U@@A S#OBE!#C
1. T"e Petitiner %05e n%4ed re#3ect!$ll1 #$04it# t"i#
3etitin #eeGin, S3eci%l Le%5e t A33e%l %,%in#t t"e i43$,ned !in%l
rder d%ted 13)+*)*+1* P%##ed in -)P)'C( N) .3*/ ! *+11 01 t"e
Hi," C$rt ! Del"i %t Ne2 Del"i 2"ere01 t"e HnI0le Hi," C$rt
"%d di#4i##ed t"e 2rit 3etitin !iled 01 t"e re#3ndent n)* "erein)
DUES!IONS O? @ABC
2. T"e !ll2in, #$0#t%nti%l J$e#tin# ! l%2 %ri#e !r t"e
cn#ider%tin ! t"i# HnH0le C$rt9
I. -"et"er t"e d$%lit1 e>i#tin, in t"e !ield ! le,%l
3r!e##in 2%# ended 01 t"e en%ct4ent ! t"e
Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61 %nd t"e S$3re4e C$rt R$le#
cntin$in, t"i# d$%lit1 in t"e S$3re4e C$rt 01 5irt$e
! Sectin =. ! t"e Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61 c%4e t %n
end %!ter c4in, int !rce ! Sectin 3+ ! t"e
Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61)

II. -"et"er Sectin =* ! t"e Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61
de# nt in e!!ect %4end Article 1<='1('%( ! t"e
Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% %nd t"ere01 i# 0e1nd t"e #c3e
! t"e le,i#l%ti5e 32er ! t"e P%rli%4ent $nder Article
*<= t *<6 ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%M

III. -"et"er Order IV R$le ='ii( %nd 1+ i# nt %n
ille,%l re#trictin n t"e ri,"t ! %n Ad5c%te $nder
Article 1?'1(',( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%M

IE. -"et"er t"e Sc3e ! t"e 32er $nder Article
1<='1('%( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% i# nt
circ$45ented 01 t"e 3$r3#e ! t"e Ad5c%te# Act@
1?61 %nd it# e>3re## 3r5i#in#M

E. -"et"er t"e HnI0le S$3re4e C$rt "%# %n1
32er $nder Article 1<='1('%( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin !
Indi% t !r%4e r$le# i43#in, re#trictin# n t"e
#t%t$tr1 ri,"t t 3r%ctice ,r%nted 01 Sectin 3+ ! t"e
Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61 2"ic" %re cntr%r1 t t"e
3$r3#e# ! t"e ActM

EI. -"et"er t"e Order IV R$le ='ii( %nd 1+ ! t"e
S$3re4e C$rt R$le#@ 1?66 cre%tin, 3rd c%te,r1 !
Ad5c%te# in cntr%5entin ! Sectin 16 ! t"e
Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61 i# nt 5il%ti5e ! Article 1< ! t"e
Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%M
3. DE*@ARA!IONS IN !ER=S O? RU@E 4627C
T"e 3etitiner# #t%te# t"%t n t"er 3etitin #eeGin, le%5e t
#3eci%l %33e%l "%# 0een !iled 01 t"e 3re#ent 3etitiner %,%in#t t"e
!in%l F$d,4ent A order dated 13.02.2012 Passed in W.P.(C) No. 8327 of
2011 by the High Court of Dehi at Ne! Dehi)
4. DE*@ARA!IONS IN !ER=S O? RU@E 3C
T"e Anne>$re 3rd$ced %ln, 2it" t"i# S3eci%l Le%5e Petitin %re
tr$e %nd crrect c3ie# ! t"e Ple%din,#ADc$4ent# 2"ic" !r4ed
3%rt ! t"e recrd# ! t"e c$rt# 0el2 %,%in#t 2"#e rder# t"e
le%5e t %33e%l i# #$,"t !r in t"i# 3etitin#)
. FROUNDS
T"e Petitiner# 3re!er# t"i# S3eci%l Le%5e Petitin n t"e
!ll2in, ,r$nd#@ %4n,#t t"er#@ 2"ic" %re t%Gen 2it"$t
3reF$dice t ne %nt"er9
A. ;ec%$#e t"e HnI0le Hi," C$rt "%# !%iled t %33reci%te
t"%t ri,"t t 3r%ctice ! Ad5c%te# in %n1 C$rt incl$din, t"e
HnI0le S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% "%# 0een ,r%nted 01 Sectin 3+ !
t"e Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61 #$0Fect t t"e cnditin# 4entined $nder
t"e Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61 %nd t"e #%4e i# 3rtected $nder Article
1?'1(',( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%)

B. ;ec%$#e t"e HnI0le Hi," C$rt "%# !%iled t %33reci%te
t"%t@ t"e r$le 4%Gin, 32er ! HnI0le S$3re4e C$rt $nder
Article 1<='1('%( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% "%# 0een 4%de
#$0Fect t %n1 l%2 4%de 01 t"e 3%rli%4ent) Order IV R$le ='ii( %nd
1+ ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt R$le#@ 1?66 0ein, cntr%r1 t Sectin 3+
! t"e Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61 0ec4e# 5id !r t2 Re%#n#9
6i7 It 0ein, cntr%r1 t t"e Sectin 3+ ! t"e
Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61 i# 0e1nd t"e r$le 4%Gin, 32er ! t"e
HnI0le S$3re4e C$rt $nder Article 1<='1('%( ! t"e
Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%)
6ii7 It i43#e# %n ille,%l re#trictin n t"e ri,"t ! %n
Ad5c%te $nder Article 1?'1(',( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%
t 3r%ctice in t"e S$3re4e C$rt) Since t"e re#trictin i#
cntr%r1 t Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61 it i# nt
#%5ed 01 Article 1?'6( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%)
*. ;ec%$#e t"e HnH0le Hi," C$rt "%# !%iled t %33reci%te
t"%t Article 1?'6( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% #3eci!ic%ll1 3r5ide#
!r 3re#cri0in, J$%li!ic%tin# !r 3r%cticin, %n1 3r!e##in@
cc$3%tin@ tr%de r 0$#ine## 01 2%1 ! % re#trictin in t"e intere#t
! ,ener%l 3$0lic@ t"ere!re nce t"e IActI 3r5ide# !r #$c"
J$e#tin#Are#trictin# t"e r$le 4%Gin, 32er 2"ic" i# #3eci%ll1
#$0Fect t t"e IActI c%n "%5e n F$ri#dictin t i43#e %dditin%l
re#trictin #3eci%ll1 2"en t"e r$le 4%Gin, 32er i# nl1 !r t"e
3$r3#e ! Re,$l%tin, t"e Pr%ctice ! Le,%l Pr!e##in in t"e
S$3re4e C$rt) It i# #$04itted t"%t Re#trictin %nd Re,$l%tin %re
t2 di!!erent cnce3t#@ Re,$l%tin in Article 1<= '1( in t"e cnte>t
! Article 1?'1( '6( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% c%nnt 4e%n t"e
#%4e t"in, %# re#trictin) Re,$l%tin 2$ld 4e%n t 4%Ge t"e ri,"t
4re e!!ecti5e) T"e te#t t deter4ine 2"et"er % 3r5i#in i#
re,$l%tr1 r re#tricti5e i# 2"et"er it e!!ect$%te# t"e e>erci#e !
ri,"t r #ti!le# it M
D. ;ec%$#e t"e HnI0le Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te
t"%t Sectin =* ! t"e Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61 %# %4ended i# clr%0le
e>erci#e ! 32er@ #ince $nder t"e ,%r0 ! en%ctin, % #%5in, cl%$#e
it #eeG# t re:dr%!t Article 1<='1( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% 01
renderin, t"e 2rd# R #$0Fect t t"e 3r5i#in# ! %n1 l%2 4%de 01
3%rli%4entQQQ))L ine!!ecti5e %nd R#$0#tit$tin, Cl%$#e '%( ! Article
1<='1( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% !r t"e 2rd#9
Kr$le# %# t t"e 3er#n# 3r%cticin, 0e!re t"e c$rtOR
01 t"e 2rd#9
R!r deter4inin, t"e 3er#n# 2" #"%ll 0e entitled t
GActG r GPlea(G in t"%t C$rtR@
E. ;ec%$#e t"e HnI0le Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te t"%t nce
t"e P%rli%4ent 3re#cri0e# 3r!e##in%l J$%li!ic%tin !r Ad5c%te#
%nd t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% ,r%nt# % li4ited 32er $nder Article
1<= t 4%Ge r$le# #$0Fect t t"e 3r5i#in# ! l%2 4%de 01 t"e
P%rli%4ent@ t"e HnI0le S$3re4e C$rt "%# n 32er t !r%4e
r$le# i43#in, %n %dditin%l re#trictin ! tr%inin, %nd e>%4in%tin
%# 3r5ided $nder Order IV@ R$le = ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt R$le#@
1?66 %nd t"e cn#eJ$enti%l re#trictin $nder Order IV@ R$le 1+ !
t"e S$3re4e C$rt R$1e#@ 1?66) T"ere!re@ Order IV@ R$le = %nd
1+ ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt R$le#@ 1?66 %re 5il%ti5e ! Article 1?'1(
',( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% %nd nt #%5ed 01 Article 1? '6( !
Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%) Hence Order IV@ R$le = %nd 1+ %re
$ncn#tit$tin%l %nd li%0le t 0e J$%#"ed)

F. ;ec%$#e t"e HnI0le Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te
t"%t Sectin 16 ! t"e Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61 rec,niCe# nl1 t2
c%te,rie# ! Ad5c%te# %nd t"e r$le 4%Gin, 32er $nder Article
1<= '1( '%( ! Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% 0ein, % 32er t !r%4e r$le#
re,$l%tin, t"e 3rced$re# %nd #$0Fect t %n1 l%2 4%de 01
P%rli%4ent@ t"e HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt c%nnt !r%4e r$le# cre%tin,
% t"ird c%te,r1 ! “Ad5c%te#:n:RecrdR) T"$# Order IV@ R$le =
%nd 1+ ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt R$1e#@ 1?66 %re 5il%ti5e ! Article
1< ! Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%)
F. ;ec%$#e t"e HnH0le Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te
t"%t t"e c43#itin ! t"e %d5c%te# 3r%cticin, in t"e S$3re4e
C$rt ! Indi% %# re!lected in t"e 4e40er#"i3 ! t"e S$3re4e
C$rt ;%r A##ci%tin '"erein %!ter re!ereed %# SC;A( re5e%l# t"%t
t"ere %re %r$nd .@=++ %d5c%te# 2" %re 4e40er# ! t"e SC;A
$t ! 2"ic" %r$nd 16++ %re Ad5c%te:n:Recrd# '"erein %!ter
re!ereed %# AOR( %nd %r$nd 6++ %re Senir Ad5c%te# %nd t"e
re4%inin, 63++ %re Nn: Ad5c%te#:n:Recrd) T"e S$3re4e
C$rt R$le# 1?66 cre%ted t"ird c%te,r1 ! %d5c%te# c%lled
KAd5c%te E n E Recrd L cntr%r1 t t"e Ad5c%te# Act %nd
4%Frit1 ! t"e NON: AOR# "%5e ,t nl1 cn#l%tin t"%t t"e
S$3re4e C$rt %cGn2led,e# t"e4 %# KOt"er Ad5c%te# L n it#
2e0#ite %# $nder9
-6iii7 O!#ER ADEO*A!ES.C
T"e#e %re Ad5c%te# 2"#e n%4e# %re entered n t"e rll !
%n1 St%te ;%r C$ncil 4%int%ined $nder t"e Ad5c%te# Act@
1?61 %nd t"e1 c%n %33e%r %nd %r,$e %n1 4%tter n 0e"%l! !
% 3%rt1 in t"e S$3re4e C$rt 0$t t"e1 %re nt entitled t !ile
%n1 dc$4ent r 4%tter 0e!re t"e C$rt L) ;ec%$#e ! t"e
%cGn2led,4ent ! t"e !%ct t"%t %n1 Ad5c%te enrlled 2it"
t"e St%te ;%r C$ncil i# entitled t 3r%ctice in HnH0le
S$3re4e C$rt@ client# %re %0le t en,%,e #$c" Ad5c%te# n
t"e 3re4i#e t"%t t"e1 %re S$3re4e C$rt Pr%ctitiner#)
Under ;%r C$ncil R$le# #ince Ad5c%te# %re nt %ll2ed t
%d5erti#e t"eir #er5ice#@ client# in5%ri%0l1 "%5e t %33r%c"
Ad5c%te# n t"e 0%#i# ! re!erence 2"ic" in#till cn!idence in
% client in % 3%rtic$l%r Ad5c%te) I! t"e AOR #1#te4@ %#
en5i#%,ed@ 2ere t 0e 4%de 4%nd%tr1@ it 2$ld i43#e
$ntld "%rd#"i3# $3n t"e %d5c%te 2" i# in t$c" 2it" t"e
client 0$t %l# n t"e client "i4#el! %# AOR# 2" %re %t
3re#ent c"%r,in, nl1 !r lendin, t"eir n%4e# !r !ilin, t"eir
4%tter# 2$ld 0e %0le t c"%r,e e5en !r %33e%rin, in t"e
4%tter %ln, 2it" t"e t"er Ad5c%te 2it"$t "%5in, %n1
Gn2led,e %0$t t"e 4%tter %nd 2it"$t "%5in, %n1 cntr%ct
2it" t"e client) In $r #1#te4@ it i# nt 3##i0le t !rce %
client t c43$l#ril1 cnt%ct t"e AOR directl1 n 2"4 "e
4%1 "%5e n cn!idence 2"en #$c" client %lre%d1 "%# %cce##
t #4e t"er Ad5c%te 2" i# re,$l%rl1 3r%cticin, in t"e
HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% %nd n 2"4 "e "%#
cn!idence)
#. ;ec%$#e t"e HnH0le Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te t"%t
t"e nece##it1 ! "%5in, %n Ad5c%te#:n:Recrd !r t"e S$3re4e
C$rt ! Indi% i# n2 l#in, it# #i,ni!ic%nce 0ec%$#e ! t"e l%r,e
n$40er ! Nn: Ad5c%te#:n:Recrd re,$l%rl1 3r%cticin, in t"e
S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi%) In !%ct@ i! % #$r5e1 ! t"e Ad5c%te#:n:
Recrd re,i#tered in t"i# HnH0le C$rt 2ere t 0e 4%de@ it 2$ld
0#er5e t"%t 5er1 !e2 ! t"e4 %re %cti5e 3r%ctitiner# %nd %
4%Frit1 ! t"e4 %re 4erel1 n%4e lender#@ c"%r,in, 4ne1 !r
lendin, t"eir n%4e# in t"e 4%tter !r !ilin, ! 3etitin#) In5%ri%0l1
dr%!tin, ! 3etitin# %re nt 0ein, dne 01 t"e Ad5c%te#:n:
Recrd %nd %re in !%ct@ 0ein, dne 01 t"e t"er Ad5c%te# 2" %re
0ein, re3re#ented 01 t"e 3etitiner %##ci%tin)
I. ;ec%$#e t"e HnH0le Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te t"%t
2"en t"ere %re l%r,e n$40er ! Ad5c%te# in t"e S$3re4e C$rt @
2" %re in 4%n1 2%1# 4re c%3%0le t"%n t"e Ad5c%te#:n:Recrd
0$t %re nt %ll2ed t !ile 4%tter# in t"e C$rt 0ec%$#e ! t"e
e>i#tence ! t"e #%id in#tit$tinA#1#te4 %nd in recent 3%#t @ t"e
S$3re4e C$rt %l# "%# nticed in F$dici%l rder# t"e !%ct t"%t t"e
Ad5c%te#:n:Recrd %re 4erel1 n%4e lender# %nd %!ter lendin,
t"eir n%4e# %re nt ,i5in, %n1 %##i#t%nce t t"e HnH0le C$rt 2it"
t"e re#$lt t"%t t"e 4%tter# %re nt 0ein, 3r#ec$ted 3r3erl1 %#
t"e %ct$%l %d5c%te@ 2" i# "%ndlin, t"e 4%tter i# nt 0ein,
inde3endentl1 rec,niCed 01 t"e HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi%)
T"e S$3re4e C$rt e%rlier %l# in t"e c%#e ! NState of Punjab &
Anr. Vs. Ashok Singh GarchaH re3rted in 629927 2 S** 322 @
NVijay Dhanji Chaudhary Vs.Suhas Jayant Natawadkar
re3rted in 2919 617 S** 133 "%# nticed t"e $n"e%lt"1 3r%ctice
! AOR# 4erel1 lendin, t"eir n%4e# !r !ilin, t"e SLP# r !r
enterin, %33e%r%nce# 2it"$t t%Gin, t"e re#3n#i0ilit1 !r t"e
3r3er 3re3%r%tin !r !ilin, t"e SLP r t"e re#3n#i0ilit1 !r 3r3er
%33e%r%nce in t"e c%#e 2%# de3rec%ted) A 3rtin ! t"e rder !
t"e HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt in t"e c%#e ! Vijay Dhanji
Chaudhary'#$3r%( i# J$ted "erein 0el2:
K3) -"%t i# 3$CClin, i# t"e rle r r%t"er t"e %0#ence ! t"e rle
! t"e Ad5c%te:n:Recrd in t"i# 4%tter) P%r% < ! t"e
%33lic%tin #"2# t"%t t"e Ad5c%te:n:Recrd "%d nt"in, t d
2it" t"e #3eci%l le%5e 3etitin e>ce3t t lend "i# n%4e !r !ilin,
t"e 3etitin) He did nt t%Ge in#tr$ctin# !r4 t"e
clientA3etitiner) He did nt 3re3%re t"e #3eci%l le%5e 3etitin) He
did nt in#tr$ct %n1 c$n#el) He 2%# nt reJ$ired t r e>3ected
t %ttend t"e "e%rin, ! t"e c%#e)
=) Un!rt$n%tel1@ 4%n1 #3eci%l le%5e 3etitin# %re 0ein, !iled
2it" Ad5c%te#:n:Recrd 0ein, 4ere n%4e:lender#@ 2it"$t
"%5in,@ r t%Gin,@ %n1 re#3n#i0ilit1 !r t"e c%#e) A# % re#$lt !
3re5%lence ! #$c" % 3r%ctice@ in #$c" c%#e#@ t"e Ad5c%te#:n:
recrd d nt %33e%r 2"en t"e 4%tter# %re li#ted eit"er 0e!re
t"e Re,i#tr%r# r 0e!re t"e C"%40er J$d,e r t"e C$rt nr d
t"e1 t%Ge %n1 intere#t r re#3n#i0ilit1 !r 3rce##in, r
cnd$ctin, t"e c%#e) T"e1 %l# 3l%1 n rle in 3re3%r%tin ! t"e
#3eci%l le%5e 3etitin#@ nr en#$re t"%t t"e reJ$ire4ent# ! t"e
R$le# %re !$l!illed %nd de!ect# %re c$red) I! t"e rle ! %n
%d5c%te: n:recrd i#
4erel1 t lend "i# n%4e !r !ilin, c%#e# 2it"$t 0ein,
re#3n#i0le !r t"e cnd$ct ! t"e c%#e@ t"e 5er1 3$r3#e !
"%5in, t"e #1#te4 ! Ad5c%te#:n:Recrd 2$ld ,et de!e%ted)
6) T"e J$e#tin t"%t %ri#e# !r cn#ider%tin i# 2"et"er %n
Ad5c%te:n:Recrd c%n !ile %33e%r%nce# %# 4ere n%4e: lender
!r !%cilit%tin, !ilin, ! 3etitin# 01 t"er#@ 2it"$t
3er!r4in, %n1 ! t"e !$nctin# %##ci%ted 2it" %n Ad5c%te:n:
Recrd)
/) In rder t en!rce di#ci3line in t"e 2rGin,
! %d5c%te#:n:recrd %nd t %5id t"e 4i#$#e ! t"e #1#te4@
%nd t en#$re t"%t t"e c$rt "%# t"e 0ene!it ! e!!ecti5e
%##i#t%nce ! t"e Ad5c%te#:n:recrd@ % #l$tin "%# t 0e
!$nd)L
'. ;ec%$#e t"e Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te t"%t @ t"e
S$3re4e C$rt in -rit Petitin N) .6A*+1+ ! S"t. Poona" Vs.
Su"it #a$war re3rted in *+1+'3( *66 "%# %l# nticed t"e
!%ll%c1 in t"e #1#te4 ! t"e in#tit$tin@ t"%t i#@ Ad5c%te#:n:recrd
%nd t"ere!re@ t"e #1#te4 ! AOR i# li%0le t 0e %0li#"ed 01 t"i#
HnH0le C$rt)
K. ;ec%$#e t"e Hi," C$rt errne$#l1 relied $3n t"e
F$d,4ent ! Lill1 I#%0el T"4%#H# c%#e@ 1?6<'6( SCR **? 2"ic" i#
0%#ed n tr%n#itr1 3r5i#in n%4el1 Sectin =. ! t"e Ad5c%te#
Act) -"ile # din, t"e Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te t"%t Sectin
=. ! t"e Act l#t it# !rce %# #n %# Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te#
Act 2%# 0r$,"t in t !rce in J$ne *+11 %nd t"ere!re@ t"e
F$d,4ent "%# n 3recedenti%l 5%l$e in re#3ect ! t"e e!!ect !
Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te# Act n t"e ri,"t $nder Article 1? '1(
',( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin) T"e t"er 3r5i#in relied $3n 01 t"e Hi,"
C$rt i# Sectin =* ! t"e Ad5c%te Act 2"ic" 2%# %r,$ed t"%t t"e
#%4e i# $ncn#tit$tin%l %# $nder t"e ,%r0 ! #%5in, cl%$#e it "%#
t"e e!!ect ! %4endin, Article 1<= '1( '%( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin)
@. ;ec%$#e t"e Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te t"%t t"e 2rit
3etitin $,"t t "%5e 0een tr%n#!erred t %nt"er 0enc" ! t"e
Hi," C$rt 0ec%$#e !%4il1 4e40er ! t"e ne ! t"e HnH0le
J$d,e# ! t"e 3re#ent 0enc" "%33en# t 0e Ad5c%te n Recrd
%nd t"ere!re t re45e %n1 it% ! 0i%#ene## t"e 2rit 3etitin
#"$ld "%5e 0een "e%rd %nd decided 01 #4e t"er 0enc" ! t"e
HnH0le Hi," C$rt)
6. FROUNDS ?OR IN!ERI= RE@IE?C
Interi4 relie! nt reJ$ired)
8. =AIN PRAAERC
It i#@ t"ere!re@ 4#t re#3ect!$ll1 3r%1ed t"%t t"i# HnH0le
C$rt 4%1 ,r%ci$#l1 0e 3le%#ed t9
A7. Br%nt S3eci%l Le%5e t A33e%l t t"e Petitiner "erein %,%in#t
t"e i43$,ned fina "udg#ent dated 13.02.2012 Passed in W.P.(C) No.
8327 of 2011 by the High Court of Dehi at Ne! Dehi@ %nd
B7. P%## #$c" %n1 t"er r !$rt"er rder#@ %# t"i# HnH0le
C$rt 4%1 dee4 !it %nd 3r3er in t"e circ$4#t%nce# ! t"e c%#e)
5. PRAAER ?OR IN!ERI= RE@IE?C Nt Pr%1ed
AND FOR THIS ACT OF 7INDNESS THE PETITIONERS AS IN DUT8
;OUND TO SHALL EVER PRA8)

Dra1$ &/C
R%5i S"%nG%r 7$4%r D
;) 7) C"$d"%r1@ Ad5c%te#
SETTLED ;89 FILED ;89
Mr) Tri3$r%ri R%1
Ad5c%te
Dr%2n n9 *=)+6)*+1* [P%r4%n%nd P%nde1&
Filed n 9 +*)+/)*+1* Ad5c%te n Recrd !r 3etitiner
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION 'C( NO) OF *+1*
S$3re4e C$rt Ad5c%te# A##ci%tin Petitiner
$ersus
S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% D Anr) %es&ondents
CERTIFICATE
Certi!ied t"%t t"e S3eci%l le%5e Petitin i# cn!ined nl1 t t"e
3le%din,# 0e!re t"e C$rtATri0$n%l 2"#e rder i# c"%llen,ed %nd
t"e t"er dc$4ent# relied $3n in t"#e 3rceedin,#) N
%dditin%l !%ct#@ dc$4ent# r ,r$nd# "%5e 0een t%Gen t"erein r
relied $3n in t"e S3eci%l le%5e Petitin) It i# !$rt"er certi!ied t"%t
t"e c3ie# ! t"e dc$4ent#A %nne>$re %tt%c"ed t t"e #3eci%l
le%5e 3etitin %re nece##%r1 t %n#2er t"e J$e#tin ! l%2 r%i#ed in
t"e 3etitin r t 4%Ge $t ,r$nd# $r,ed in t"e S3eci%l le%5e
Petitin !r cn#ider%tin ! t"i# HnH0le C$rt) T"i# Certi!ic%te i#
,i5en n t"e 0%#i# ! t"e in#tr$ctin# ,i5en 01 t"e 3etitiner A
3er#n %$t"riCed 01 t"e 3etitiner 2"#e %!!id%5it i# !iled in
#$33rt ! t"e in#t%nt S)L)P)
'P%r4%n%nd P%nde1(
FILED ON9 +*)+/)*+1* ADVOCATE FOR PETITIONER
INTHE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION 'C( NO) OF *+1*
S$3re4e C$rt Ad5c%te# A##ci%tin Petitiner
$ersus
S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% D Anr) %es&ondents
A??IDAEI!
I@ R%5i S"%nG%r 7$4%r@ Ad5c%te@ Hnr%r1 Secret%r1@ S$3re4e
C$rt Ad5c%te# A##ci%tin@ re#idin, %t ;6A36A1@ S%!d%r J$n,
Encl%5e@ Ne2 Del"i:11++*?@ d "ere01 #le4nl1 %!!ir4 %nd decl%re
%# $nder9
1) T"%t I %4 Hnr%r1 Secret%r1 ! t"e 3etitiner:A##ci%tin in
t"e %05e c%3tined 4%tter %nd %# #$c" I %4 2ell cn5er#%nt 2it"
!%ct# %nd circ$4#t%nce# ! t"e 3re#ent c%#e@ "ence I %4 c43etent
t #2e%r t"i# %!!id%5it)
*) T"%t I "%5e ,ne t"r$," t"e %cc43%n1in, S3eci%l Le%5e
Petitin Cnt%inin, P%r% 1 t . %nd 3%,e# N#) *3 t %nd t"e li#t
! d%te# P%,e# ; t M %nd t"e %cc43%n1in, Interlc$tr1
A33lic%tin# "%# 0een dr%!ted 01 41 C$n#el# n 41 in#tr$ctin#) I
"%5e re%d %nd $nder#td t"e cntent# ! t"e #%4e@ 2"ic" %re tr$e
%nd crrect t t"e 0e#t ! 41 Gn2led,e %nd 0elie!) N 3%rt ! it i#
!%l#e %nd nt"in, 4%teri%l "%# 0een cnce%led t"erein)
3) T"%t t"e Anne>$re# !iled %ln, 2it" t"e S3eci%l le%5e Petitin
%re tr$e %nd crrect c3ie# ! t"eir re#3ecti5e ri,in%l#@ 2"ic"
!r4 3%rt ! t"e recrd# ! t"e C$rt 0el2)
<) T"%t 3etitiner "%# nt 45ed e%rlier t t"i# HnH0le C$rt
!r t"e relie! 3r%1ed in t"e in#t%nt S3eci%l le%5e Petitin)
=) T"%t t"e cntent# ! t"e %05e 3%r%# ! t"i# %!!id%5it %re tr$e
%nd crrect t t"e 0e#t ! 41 Gn2led,e %nd 0elie!@ n 3%rt ! it i#
!%l#e %nd nt"in, 4%teri%l i# cnce%led t"ere !r4)

De3nent
Veri!ic%tin
I@ t"e %05e n%4ed de3nent@ d "ere01 #le4nl1 %!!ir4 %nd
decl%re %t Ne2 Del"i n *
nd
d%1 ! J$l1@ *+1* t"%t t"e cntent# !
P%r% 1 t 6 %t %05e %!!id%5it %re tr$e t 41 Gn2led,e %nd 0elie!)

De3nent
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
I)A) NO) OF *+1*
IN
S)L)P) 'CIVIL( NO) SSSSSSSSSSS OF *+1*
IN THE MATTER OF9
S$3re4e C$rt Ad5c%te# A##ci%tin Petitiner
Ver#$#
S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% D Anr) Re#3ndent#


AN APP@I*A!ION ?OR PER=ISSION !O
?I@E SPE*IA@ @EAEE PE!I!ION
T
HONI;LE THE CHIEF JUSTICE OF INDIA AND HIS
COMPANION JUDBES OF THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
T"e S3eci%l Le%5e Petitin ! t"e Petitiner %05e n%4edO
=OS! RESPE*!?U@@A S#OBE!#9
1. T"e Petitiner %05e n%4ed re#3ect!$ll1 #$04it# t"i# Petitin
#eeGin, S3eci%l Le%5e t A33e%l %,%in#t Fin%l J$d,4ent %nd
Order d%ted 13)+*)*+1* 3%##ed 01 t"e Hi," C$rt ! Del"i %t
Ne2 Del"i in -P 'C( N).3*/ ! *+11)
2. T"%t !r t"e #%Ge ! 0re5it1 t"e 3etitiner i# nt n%rr%tin, t"e
!$ll !%ct# ! t"e c%#e "erein in t"i# %33lic%tin %nd cr%5e#
le%5e ! t"i# HnH0le C$rt t re!er t %nd rel1 n t"e !%ct#
#t%ted in t"e S)L)P) %# !r4in, 3%rt %nd 3%rcel ! t"i#
%33lic%tin !r 3er4i##in t !ile SLP)
3. T"%t t"e 3etitiner i# %n %##ci%tin ! S$3re4e C$rt
Ad5c%te# 2" %re nt Ad5c%te#:n:Recrd 0$t 2" %re
re,$l%rl1 3r%cticin, in t"i# HnH0le C$rt %# 2ell %# 2" %re
4e40er# ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt ;%r A##ci%tin) T"e
c43#itin ! t"e %d5c%te# 3r%cticin, in t"e S$3re4e C$rt
! Indi% %# re!lected in t"e 4e40er#"i3 ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt
;%r A##ci%tin '"erein %!ter re!ereed %# SC;A( re5e%l# t"%t
t"ere %re %r$nd .@=++ %d5c%te# 2" %re 4e40er# ! t"e
SC;A $t ! 2"ic" %r$nd 1@6++ %re Ad5c%te:n:Recrd#
'"erein %!ter re!ereed %# AOR( %nd %r$nd 6++ %re Senir
Ad5c%te# %nd t"e re4%inin, %r$nd 6@3++ %re Ot"er
Ad5c%te#. H2e5er d$e t t"e e>i#tin, #1#te4 ! Ad5c%te
n Recrd in t"e HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi%@ ri,"t t
3r%ctice 2it" di,nit1 ! 4%Frit1 ! Ot"er Ad5c%te# %re
c$rt%iled@ 2"ic" i# $nF$#ti!ied %nd $ncn#tit$tin%l in 5ie2 !
'Anne>$re:P)<( ,%Cette nti!ic%tin ! Sectin 3+ ! t"e
Ad5c%te# Act@ 1?61 in J$ne *+11)
4. T"%t it i# #$04itted t"%t t"e Petitiner 2%# nt % 3%rt1 in t"e
-rit Petitin) H2e5er@ t"e Petitiner 0ein, %n %##ci%tin !
S$3re4e C$rt Pr%cticin, Ad5c%te# %,,rie5ed 01 t"e
F$d,4ent ! t"e Hi," C$rt c%n 3re!er % S3eci%l Le%5e
Petitin %,%in#t t"e #%id F$d,4ent) Hence t"e 3re#ent
%33lic%tin !r 3er4i##in t !ile SLP i# 0ein, !iled 0e!re t"i#
HnH0le C$rt)
. T"%t it i# in t"e intere#t ! F$#tice t"%t t"e Petitiner #"$ld
0e 3er4itted 01 t"i# HnH0le C$rt t 3re!er t"e %cc43%n1in,
3etitin !r S3eci%l Le%5e t A33e%l)
3. T"%t t"e A33lic%tin i# 0ein, 4%de 0n%!ide %nd in t"e
intere#t ! F$#tice)
PRAAER
It i#@ t"ere!re@ re#3ect!$ll1 3r%1ed t"%t t"i# HnI0le C$rt 4%1
,r%ci$#l1 0e 3le%#ed t9
i) Br%nt Per4i##in t t"e Petitiner t !ile S3eci%l Le%5e
Petitin %,%in#t Fin%l J$d,4ent %nd Order
d%ted13)+*)*+1* 3%##ed 01 t"e Hi," C$rt ! Del"i %t
Ne2 Del"i in -P ' C ( N) .3*/ ! *+11)
ii7 P%## #$c" t"er r !$rt"er rder#Adirectin# %# t"i#
HnH0le C$rt 4%1 dee4 !it %nd 3r3er in t"e !%ct# %nd
circ$4#t%nce# ! t"i# c%#e)
DRA-N ;89
;) 7) C"$d"%r1 FILED ;89
Ad5c%te

Dr%2n n9 *=)+6)*+1* [P%r4%n%nd P%nde1&
Filed n 9 +*)+/)*+1* Ad5c%te n Recrd !r 3etitiner

P%r4%n%nd P%nde1
Advocate
Supreme Court of India
1, Garuda Vihar, (Behind Shankar Market),
Cannauht !"ace, #e$ %e"hi &1
!h. '()1**+1, ,*-*..(./+
%ated: /'./+.'/1'
0o
0he 1ei2trar,
Supreme Court of India,
#e$ %e"hi
Su34ect: 5etter of Authori2ation
1ef: S5! (C) #o. '/1'
(Supreme Court Advocate2 A22ociation Ver2u2 Supreme Court of
India 6 Anr.)
%ear Sir,
I authori7e Mr. 1avi Shankar 8umar9 B.8. Choudhar:, Advocate2,
Supreme Court, to fi"e, proce22 and take 2tep2 for urent "i2tin and
mentionin of the S5! (C) #o. of '/1' (Supreme Court Advocate2
A22ociation Ver2u2 Supreme Court of India 6 Anr.) of the matter on
3eha"f of me.
0he 2pecimen 2inature of Mr. 1avi Shankar 8umar 9 Mr. B.8.
Choudhar:, Advocate2 are atte2ted for needfu".
0hankin :ou,
(1avi Shankar 8umar 9 B.8. Choudhar:) (!armanand !ande:)
Advocate, Supreme Court Advocate on 1ecord