SCAA SLP V AOR

Published on February 2017 | Categories: Documents | Downloads: 30 | Comments: 0 | Views: 97
of 35
Download PDF   Embed   Report

Comments

Content


IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
[Under Article 136 ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%&
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION 'C( NO) OF *+1*
[A,%in#t !in%l rder d%ted 13)+*)*+1* P%##ed in -)P)'C(
N) .3*/ ! *+11 01 Hi," C$rt ! Del"i %t Ne2 Del"i&
S$3re4e C$rt Ad5c%te# A##ci%tin Petitiner
Ver#$#
S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% %nd Anr) Re#3ndent#

-it"
I) A) N) ! *+1*
A33lic%tin !r 3er4i##in t !ile SLP
PAPER BOOK
' FOR INDE6 7INDL8 SEE INSIDE(
Ad5c%te !r Petitiner9 P%r4%n%nd P%nde1
INDEX

Sl No. Particulars Page Nos
1) An !!ice re3rt n li4it%tin A
*) Li#tin, Pr!r4% A1: A*
3) Li#t ! D%te# %nd E5ent# ; : M
<) Certi!ied C31 ! !in%l rder d%ted 13)+*)*+1* 1 : **
P%##ed in -)P)'C( N) .3*/ ! *+11 01 t"e
Hi," C$rt ! Del"i %t Ne2 Del"i
=) S3eci%l Le%5e Petitin 2it" A!!id%5it) *3 : 36
6) ANNEXURE -P.1
T13ed c31 ! t"e Min$te# ! E>ec$ti5e 3/ : <+
C44ittee ! SC;A d%ted<)3)*++?
/) ANNEXURE -P.2
T13ed c31 ! t"e Min$te# ! E>ec$ti5e <1 : <=
C44ittee ! SC;A d%ted 1<)+1)*+11
.) ANNEXURE -P.3
T13ed c31 ! t"e letter d%ted 1?)+<)*+11 <6 : <.
! Mr) R%4 Jet"4%l%[email protected] Senir Ad5c%te A
Me40er ! P%rli%4ent
?) ANNEXURE -P.4
T13ed c31 ! t"e !!ici%l B%Cette Nti!ic%tin <? : =+
S)O) 13<? 'E( d%ted +?)+6)*+11 i##$ed 01 t"e
Mini#tr1 ! L%2 D J$#[email protected] B5t) ! Indi%
1+) ANNEXURE -P.
T13ed c31 ! t"e J$d,4ent d%ted 1*)1+)*+11 =1 E =6
3%##ed in 'ViF%1 D"%nFi C"%$d"%r1 Ver#$# S$"%#
J%1%nt N%t%2%dG%r( SLP 'C ( N) 1.<.1 ! *++?
01 t"e HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt
11) I) A) N) ! *+1* =/ : =?
A33lic%tin !r Per4i##in t !ile
S3eci%l Le%5e Petitin
LISTINB PROFORMA
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
1) N%t$re ! t"e 4%tter Ci5il
*) '%(N%4e ! Petitiner'#(AA33ell%nt'#( S$3re4e C$rt Ad5c%te#:
A##ci%tin
'0( e:4%il ID
3) '%(N%4e'#( ! Re#3ndent '#( S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% D Anr)
'0(e:4%il ID
<) N$40er ! c%#e S) L) P) 'C( N) ! *+1*
=) '%(Ad5c%te'#( !r Petitiner'#( P%r4%n%nd P%nde1
'0(e:4%il ID
6) '%( Ad5c%te'#( !r Re#3ndent '#( N) A)
'0( e:4%il ID
/) Sectin de%lin, 2it" t"e 4%tter 6IV
.) D%te ! t"e i43$,ned OrderAJ$d,4ent 13)*)*+1*)
.A) N%4e ! HnI0le J$d,e# HnH0le Mr) A) 7) [email protected] Actin, C) J)
HnH0le Mr R%Fee5 S%"%1 Endl%[email protected] J)
.;) In L%nd AcJ$i#itin M%tter# 9 N) A)
i( Nti!ic%tinAB5t) Order N) $A#) <@6())))))))))))))
d%ted)))))))))))))))))))))))i##$ed 01 CentreASt%te !)))))))))))
ii( E>%ct 3$r3#e ! %cJ$i#itin D 5ill%,e in5l5ed))))))))
.C) In Ci5il M%tter# 9: N)A)
i( S$it N)@ N%4e ! L2er C$rt))))))))
D%te ! J$d,4ent)))))))))))))))))) N) A)
.D) In -rit Petitin#9: N) A)
KC%tc"2rdL ! t"er #i4il%r 4%tter#)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))
.E) In c%#e ! Mtr Ve"icle Accident M%tter# 9 N) A)
Ve"icle N))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))
.F) In Ser5ice M%tter# N) A)
'i( Rele5%nt #er5ice [email protected] i! %n1))
'ii(B)O)ACirc$l%rANti!ic%[email protected] i! %33lic%0le r in J$e#tin)))))))))
.B) In L%0$r Ind$#tri%l Di#3$te# M%tter# 9 N) A)
I)D) Re!erenceAA2%rd N)@ i! %33lic%0le ))))))))))))))))))))))))
.E) N%t$re ! $r,enc19 M%tter rel%ted Ri,"t t Pr%ctice ! t"er
Ad5c%te# in t"e HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt
! Indi% %!ter nti!ic%tin ! Sectin 3+ !
t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61
?) In c%#e it i# % T%> 4%tter 9 N) A)
%( T%> %4$nt in5l5ed in t"e 4%tter)))))))))))))))))))
0( -"et"er % re!erenceA#t%te4ent ! t"e c%#e 2%# c%lled !r r
reFected)))))))))
c( -"et"er #i4il%r t%> 4%tter# ! #%4e 3%rtie# !iled e%rlier
'4%1 0e !r e%rlierAt"er A##e##4ent 8e%r(M)))))))))))))
d( E>e43tin Nti!ic%tinACirc$l%r N)))))))))))))
11) V%l$%tin ! t"e 4%tter 9 N) A)
1*) Cl%##i!ic%tin ! t"e 4%tter 9
'Ple%#e !ill $3 t"e n$40er D n%4e ! rele5%nt c%te,r1
2it" #$0 c%te,r1 %# 3er t"e li#t circ$l%ted(
N) ! S$0Fect C%te,r1 2it" !$ll n%4e 9
N) ! #$0:c%te,r1 2it" !$ll n%4e 9
:*:
13) Title ! t"e Act in5l5ed 'CentreASt%te( Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% %nd
Ad5c%te# [email protected] S$3re4e C$rt R$le#@ 1?66
1<) '%( S$0:Cl%##i!ic%tin 'indic%te SectinAArticle ! t"e St%t$te()))
Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?66
'0( S$0:Sectin in5l5ed)))) N)A)
'c( Title ! t"e R$le# in5l5ed 'CentreASt%te())))))))))N) A)
'd( S$0:cl%##i!ic%tin 'indic%te R$leAS$0:r$le ! t"e St%t$te())N) A)
1=) Pint ! l%2 %nd J$e#tin ! l%2 r%i#ed in t"e c%#e9 -"et"er t"e
Di5i#in ;enc" ! HnH0le Hi," C$rt "%# !%iled t %33reci%te t"%[email protected]
t"e d$%lit1 e>i#tin, in t"e !ield ! le,%l 3r!e##in 2%# ended 01 t"e
en%ct4ent ! t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61 %nd t"e S$3re4e C$rt R$le#
cntin$in, t"i# d$%lit1 in t"e S$3re4e C$rt 01 5irt$e ! Sectin =. !
t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61 c%4e t %n end %!ter c4in, int !rce !
Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61M
16) -"et"er 4%tter i# nt t 0e li#ted 0e!re %n1 HnI0le J$d,eM
Mentin t"e n%4e ! t"e HnI0le J$d,e)))) N) A)
1/) P%rtic$l%r# ! identic%lA#i4il%r c%#e#@ i! %n1
%( Pendin, c%#e#)))))))))))))))
0( Decided c%#e# 2it" cit%tin))))))))))
1/A) -%# SLPAA33e%lA-rit !iled %,%in#t #%4e i43$,ned J$d,4entArder
e%rlierM I! 1e#@ 3%rtic$l%r#))))))

1.) -"et"er t"e 3etitin i# %,%in#t interlc$tr1A!in%l rderAdecree in t"e
c%#e Fin%l
1?) I! it i# % !re#" 4%[email protected] 3le%#e #t%te t"e n%4e ! t"e Hi," C$rt %nd
t"e Cr%4 in t"e i43$,ned J$d,4entAOrder)))) Del"i Hi," [email protected]
HnH0le Mr) A) 7) [email protected] A) C) J) %nd HnH0le Mr R%Fee5 S%"%1 Endl%[email protected])
*+) I! t"e 4%tter 2%# %lre%d1 li#ted in t"i# C$rt 9 N) A)
%( -"en 2%# it li#tedM))))))))))
0( -"%t 2%# t"e Cr%4M)))))
c( -"%t 2%# t"e directin ! t"e C$rt))))))
*1) -"et"er % d%te "%# %lre%d1 0een !i>ed eit"er 01 C$rt r n 0ein,
4entined !r t"e "e%rin, ! 4%tterM I! #@ 3le%#e indic%te t"e d%te
!i>ed))))))) N) A)
**) I# t"ere % c%5e%trM I! #@ 2"et"er % ntice "%# 0een i##$ed t "i4M
N) A)
*3) -"et"er d%te entered in t"e C43$terM))))))) N) A)
*<) I! it i# % cri4in%l 4%[email protected] 3le%#e #t%te 9 N) A)
%( -"et"er %cc$#ed "%# #$rrendered)))))))))))))))
0( N%t$re ! [email protected] i)e) cn5icted $nder Sectin 2it" Act)))))))))))
c( Sentence %2%rded))))))))))
d( Sentence %lre%d1 $nder,ne 01 t"e %cc$#ed))))))))
*< e( 'i( FIRARCAetc)))))))))) N) A)
D%te ! Re,i#tr%tin ! FIR etc)))))))))))))
N%4e D 3l%ce ! t"e Plice St%tin)))))))
'ii( N%4e D 3l%ce ! Tri%l C$rt9
C%#e N) in Tri%l C$rt %nd D%te ! J$d,4ent
'iii( N%4e %nd 3l%ce ! 1#t A33ell%te C$rt9
C%#e N) in 1#t A33ell%te C$rt D d%te ! J$d,4ent9
D%ted9 +*)/)*+1* 'P%r4%n%nd P%nde1(
Ad5c%te !r Petitiner 'S(AA33ell%nt'#(
LIST OF DATES AND EVENTS
T"e 3re#ent S3eci%l Le%5e Petitin i# !iled 01 t"e 3etitiner
%##ci%tin %,%in#t t"e i43$,ned !in%l rder %nd F$d,4ent d%ted
13)+*)*+1* 3%##ed 01 HnH0le Del"i Hi," C$rt in -rit Petitin 'C (
N).3*/ ! *[email protected] ;%lr%F Sin," M%liG Ver#$# S$3re4e C$rt !
Indi%@ 2"ere01 t"e Hi," C$rt "%# di#4i##ed t"e 3etitin %t t"e
%d4i##in #t%,e it#el! 2it"$t i##$in, ntice t t"e S$3re4e
C$rt A t"e re#3ndent 2it"$t in5itin, %n1 re#3n#e !r4 t"e
re#3ndent %# 2ell %# Unin ! Indi% in 5ie2 ! t"e nti!ic%tin !
Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te [email protected] 1?61 %!ter =+ 1e%r# #$c" 3r5i#in
! t"e #t%t$te c%4e int !rce)
1?*+ Under t"e ;riti#" [email protected] NT"e J$dici%l C44ittee ! t"e
Pri51 C$ncil in En,l%ndH "%d 0een t"e "i,"e#t Tri0$n%l !r
Indi%@ %nd !r !$nctinin, ! t"e F$dici%l #1#te4 Pri51 C$ncil
R$le# 2ere !r%4ed %nd $nder KT"e Pri51 C$ncil R$le#@ 1?*+L
%nd KR$le# ! t"e J$dici%l C44ittee ! Pri51 [email protected] 1?*=L
t"e #1#te4 ! KABENTL 2%# 3re5%ilin,)
1?3/ T"e NB5ern4ent ! Indi% [email protected] 1?3=H e#t%0li#"ed %
KFeder%l C$rt ! Indi%L %nd it 2%# in%$,$r%ted in Ne2 Del"i)
T"e in%$,$r%tin ! t"e Feder%l C$rt nece##it%ted t"e
e#t%0li#"4ent ! % 2ell:r,%niCed Feder%l ;%r) A# Del"i 2%#
nt t"e #e%t ! %n1 Hi," [email protected] t"ere 2%# n ;%r "%5in,
di#tin,$i#"ed l%21er# "ere %nd t"%t nece##it%ted !r%4in, !
r$le# in %0#ence ! L%21er# !r 3r3er c44$nic%tin t t"e
%r,$in, C$n#el# %nd !r !$nctinin, ! Feder%l [email protected] %nd in
t"e 1e%r 1?3/ it#el! Feder%l C$rt R$le# 2ere !r%4ed A
i##[email protected] in t"%t 5er1 r$le# t"e #1#te4 ! Ad5c%te %nd A,ent
2%# 3re5%ilin, in Order [email protected] t"e cnditin ! 3r%ctice !r Senir
Ad5c%[email protected] Ad5c%te %nd A,ent 2%# cdi!ied)
It i# e##enti%l t 3int $t "ere t"%t d$rin, t"e ;riti#"
er% t"e le,%l 3r!e##in%l# in Indi% "%5in, li4ited ri,"t# %nd
d$tie# t 3r!e## A 3r%ctice 0e!re t"e di!!erent C$rt#@
Tri0$n%l# %# 2ell %# 0e!re t"e A$t"ritie# %nd $nder t"e
R$le# ! C$rt# t"e Le,%l Pr!e##in%l# ,t t"e4#el5e#
enrlled A re,i#tered %# 3er t"e 3r5i#in# ! t"e t"en l%2#@
%t di!!erent 3l%ce#O 5iC9 Le,%l Pr%ctitiner# [email protected] 1./[email protected]
;40%1 Ple%der# [email protected] 1?*[email protected] T"e Indi%n ;%r C$ncil# [email protected]
1?*6)
1?</ T"%t 2it" t"e 3litic%l c"%n,e# in t"e c$ntr1 Indi%n
Inde3endence Act 2%# 3%##ed in t"e 1e%r 1?</ %nd t"e
Cn#tit$ent A##e40l1 3%##ed NFeder%l C$rt 'Enl%r,e4ent !
J$ri#dictin( [email protected] 1?</H %nd NA0litin ! Pri51 C$ncil
J$ri#dictin [email protected] 1?<?H %nd Feder%l C$rt 2%# ,i5en %ll
32er# ! Pri51 C$ncil)
*.
t"
J%n$%r1 1?=+ HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% 2%#
in%$,$r%ted n in t"e C$ncil C"%[email protected] in t"e C$rt [email protected]
2"ere t"e Feder%l C$rt $#ed t "%5e it# #ittin,#) A# 3er t"e
3r5i#in ! Article 1<= ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%@ t"e
HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt !r%4edA4%de KT"e S$3re4e C$rt
R$le#@ 1?=+L '"erein%!ter re!erred %# NSCR 1?=+H(@ %nd 2it"
t"e %33r5%l ! t"e Pre#ident ! Indi% #$c" R$le# c%4e int
e>i#[email protected] t"e ORDER IV ! NSCR 1?=+H 2%# !r t"e
Ad5c%te# %nd ABENTS %nd t2%rd# t"e end ! 1?<? %
!eelin, 2%# 5iced in #4e J$%rter# t"%t in rder t red$ce
c#t ! liti,%tin t"e d$%l #1#te4 #"$ld 0e %0li#"ed %nd
J$nir Ad5c%te# #"$ld %ct !r t"e client# 2"ere%# Senir
Ad5c%te #"$ld nl1 3le%d !r t"[email protected] %ccrdin,l1 it 2%#
c%te,ric%ll1 4entined t"erein in t"e nte %#O
Nte#9: T"e R$le# cnt%ined in t"i# Order %re
#$0Fect t re5i#in %t t"e end ! 3erid ! t2 1e%r#)
!"e #o$%&le 'u(ges o) t"e *ourt "a+e u$(er
co$si(eratio$ a ,ro,osal to a&olis" t"e -(ual.
s/ste0)
R$le 1 ! Order IV ! NSCR 1?=+H 3r5ide# %# !ll2#9
1 T"e n%4e# ! %ll 3er#n# 2" "%5e "eret!re
0een enrlled %# Ad5c%te# %nd A,ent# ! t"e Feder%l
C$rt #"%[email protected] %# !r4 t"e c44ence4ent ! t"e#e R$le#
0e dee4ed t "%5e 0een tr%n#!erred t t"e Rll# !
Ad5c%te# %nd A,ent#@ re#[email protected] ! t"e S$3re4e
[email protected] %nd #$c" Ad5c%te# #"%ll t%Ge 3recedence in t"e
S$3re4e C$rt in t"e rder in 2"ic" t"e1 2ere enrlled
in Feder%l C$rt)
1?=1 NT"e S$3re4e C$rt Ad5c%te# 'Pr%ctice in Hi,"
C$rt#( [email protected] 1?=1L c%4e int !rce %nd Ad5c%te# 3r%cticin,
in S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% 2ere ,i5en %n eJ$%l ri,"t t
3r%ctice in t"e Hi," C$rt#)
1?=3 T cn#lid%te t"e l%2 rel%tin, t Le,%l Pr%ctitiner# A
Pr!e##in%l# in t"e 1e%r KAll:Indi% ;%r C44itteeL 2%#
cn#tit$ted %nd !r cre%tin ! $ni!r4 All:Indi% ;%[email protected] #$c"
C44ittee !r4$l%ted 3r3#%l#)
1?=< S4e %4end4ent 2ere 4%de in NSCR [email protected]
rele5%nt %4end4ent# %re !ll2in,9
'1( in ORDER I
R$le *@ #$0:r$le '1(:
'0( !r t"e de!initin ! KA,entL t"e !ll2in, #"%ll 0e
#$0#tit$ted n%4el19:
-Age$t. 4e%n# %n A,ent ! t"e Rll# ! t"e C$rt %#
n t"e *6
t"
J%n$%r1 1?=<)L
'd( in t"e de!initin ! KP%rt1L !r t"e 2rd KA,[email protected]
2"ere5er it cc$r#@ t"e 2rd# KAd5c%te n recrdL
#"%ll 0e #$0#tit$ted)
*6
t"
J%n$%r1 1?=< It i# 3ertinent t 4entin "ere t"%t
3$r#$%nce t t"i# %4end4ent %ll t"e KABENTSL n t"e Rll !
NS$3re4e C$rt ! Indi%H %re c%lled %# KAd5c%te#:n:
RecrdL)
1?=. T"%t in 5ie2 ! t"e 3r3#%l# ! KAll:Indi% ;%r
C44itteeL t"e KL%2 C44i##in ! Indi%L 3re3%red %
det%iled P$e#tinn%ire %nd in5ited t"e le,%l E>3ert# %nd le,%l
Pr!e##in%l# !r4 %ll 5er Indi%@ %nd % l%r,e n$40er ! #$c"
Le,%l E>3ert# A Pr!e##in%l# %n#2ered t"e det%iled
P$e#tinn%ire !r4$l%ted 01 L%2 C44i##[email protected] %nd %!ter
det%iled cn#ider%tin# ! 4%teri%l#@ t"e NL%2 C44i##in !
Indi%H #$04itted it# Fourteenth Report n KREFORMS OF
JUDICIAL [email protected] t"e C"%3ter *6 ! t"i# Re3rt
2%# 2it" re,%rd t ;AR %nd t"e L%2 C44i##in
rec44ended t t"e B5ern4ent ! Indi% t 3r5ide t"e
Ad5c%te# ! t"i# c$ntr1 n % C44n Rll %nd t"e1 #"$ld
"%5e ri,"t t 3r%ctice in %ll c$rt# ! Indi% !r4 "i,"e#t t
t"e l2e#t)
1?61 In 3$r#$%nce t t"e rec44end%tin# ! L%2
C44i##in ! Indi% $r P%rli%4ent "%# en%cted NT"e
Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61L 2it" 0Fect t %4end %nd cn#lid%te
t"e l%2 rel%tin, t le,%l Pr%ctitiner# %nd t 3r5ide !r t"e
cn#tit$tin ! t"e ;%r C$ncil# %nd %n NAll:Indi% ;%[email protected] t"e
Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61 3r5ide# !r %
3r5i#in t"%[email protected] e5er1 Ad5c%te 2"#e n%4e entered in t"e
St%te Rll "%# ri,"t t 3r%ctice in %ll C$rt# incl$din,
S$3re4e C$rt %# 2ell %# 0e!re Tri0$n%l# %nd %$t"ritie#) A#
3er t"e 3r5i#in ! Sectin =+ ! t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected] [email protected]
Le,%l Pr%ctitiner# [email protected] 1./[email protected] ;40%1 Ple%der# [email protected] 1?*[email protected]
T"e Indi%n ;%r C$ncil# [email protected] 1?*6 %nd Letter# P%tent ! t"e
Hi," C$rt# %nd %n1 t"er l%2 rel%tin, t t"e %d4i##in %nd
enrl4ent ! le,%l 3r%ctitiner# c%4e t 0e re3e%[email protected] %nd
!r4 ti4e t ti4e St%te ;%r C$ncil# 0ec%4e !$nctin%l)
1=)1)1?66 S$3re4e C$rt R$le# re!r%4ed 01 t"i# HnH0le
C$rt c%4e int !rce %nd n 1)3)1?66 Re,$l%tin# re,%rdin,
Ad5c%te E n : Recrd E>%4in%tin 2%# nti!ied)
T"e S$3re4e C$rt R$le#@ 1?66 '"erein %!ter
re!erred %# KSCR 1?66L( de!ined t"ree c%te,rie# !
Ad5c%te# 3r%cticin, 0e!re t"i# HnH0le [email protected] R$le * '%(
%nd '0( ! Order I ! KSCR 1?66L %l# de!ined t"e 2rd
KAd5c%teL %nd KAd5c%te:n:[email protected] 2"ic" %re %# !ll2#9
I) Senir Ad5c%te
II) Ad5c%te:n:Recrd
III) J$nir Ad5c%te ANn Ad5c%te:n:Recrd
'!"e 1or( 'u$ior A(+ocate i$ t"e -S*R 1233. is i$
co$tra(ictio$ to t"e ,ro+isio$s o) A(+ocates Act4 1231(
Under t"e KSCR 1?66L !r 0ein, J$%li!ied %nd
re,i#tered %# %n Ad5c%te:n:Recrd $nder t"e R$le = !
Order IV ! t"e KSCR 1?66L rele5%nt 3r5i#in# %re %# $nder9
=) N %d5c%te #"%ll 0e J$%li!ied t 0e re,i#tered %# %n
Ad5c%te n Recrd $nle##9:
'i( "i# n%4e i#@ %nd "%# 0een 0rne n t"e rll !
%n1 St%te ;%r C$ncil !r % 3erid ! nt le## t"%n !$r
1e%r# n t"e d%te ! c44ence4ent ! "i# tr%inin, %#
3r5ided "erein%!terO
Pr5ided "[email protected] i! %n1 c%ndid%te "%# e%rlier
%33e%red in %n1 ! t"e Ad5c%te:n:Recrd E>%4in%tin
"e #"%ll cntin$e t 0e # eli,i0le t #it in %n1 #$0#eJ$ent
e>%4in%tin)
['%%(& % Slicitr n t"e rll# ! t"e ;40%1
Incr3r%ted L%2 Sciet1 #"%ll 0e e>e43ted !r4 #$c"
tr%inin, %nd te#t i! "i#A"er n%4e i#@ %nd "%# 0een 0rne
n t"e rll ! St%te ;%r C$ncil !r 3erid nt le## t"%n
#e5en 1e%r# n t"e d%te ! 4%Gin, t"e %33lic%tin !r
re,i#tr%tin %# %n Ad5c%te:n:Recrd&)
'ii( "e "%# $nder,ne tr%inin, !r ne 1e%r 2it" %n
Ad5c%te:n:Recrd %33r5ed 01 t"e [email protected] %nd "%#
t"ere%!ter 3%##ed #$c" te#t# %# 4%1 0e "eld 01 t"e
C$rt !r %d5c%te# 2" %33l1 t 0e re,i#tered %#
Ad5c%te:n:Recrd 3%rtic$l%r# 2"ere! #"%ll 0e
nti!ied in t"e O!!ici%l B%Cette !r4 ti4e t ti4e
3r5ided "2e5er t"%t:
a An Attrne1 #"%ll 0e e>e43ted !r4 #$c" )
tr%inin, %nd te#tO %nd
b T"e C"ie! J$#tice 4%[email protected] in %33r3ri%te ) c%#e#@
,r%nt e>e43tin:
1 Fr4 t"e reJ$ire4ent ! tr%inin, $nder t"i#
cl%$#e in t"e c%#e ! %n %d5c%[email protected] 2"#e n%4e i#
0rne n t"e rll ! %n1 St%te ;%r C$ncil %nd "%#
0een 0rne n #$c" rll !r % 3erid ! nt le## t"%n
ten 1e%r#O
1?.= A l%r,e n$40er ! Ad5c%te# %re nt ,ettin, %n1 #ci%l
#ec$rit1 01 t"e ,5ern4ent r%t"er t"e1 %re di5ided int
3litic%l ,r$3#@ nt 3$r#$in, 3r3er 4ec"%ni#4 !r
3rtectin ! t"eir intere#t t"ere!re %!ter en%ct4ent ! t"e
Ad5c%te# [email protected] [email protected] Sectin 3+ 2%# nt nti!ied t"ere!re
t"i# 0ene!ici%l 3r5i#in did nt c4e int [email protected] $lti4%tel1
t"e HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt 0#er5ed %# re3rted inO
125 S** 617 482 'Lin,%33% Pc"%nn% A33el2%r And Or#)
Ver#$# St%te O! M%"%r%#"tr% %nd Anr) Etc)(@
KS$c" % ri,"t i# n d$0t cn!erred 01 S)3+ ! t"e
Ad5c%te# Act) ;$t $n!rt$n%tel1 !r t"e le,%l
3r!e##[email protected] S)3+ "%# nt 0een 0r$,"t int !rce # !%r
t"$," t"e Act "%# 0een n t"e St%t$te ;G !r t"e
l%#t ** 1e%r#) T"ere i# 5er1 little t"%t 2e c%n d in t"e
4%tter %nd it i# !r t"e ;%r t t%Ge it $3 el#e2"ere) A
3er#n enrlled %# %n %d5c%te $nder t"e Ad5c%te Act
i# nt i3# !%ct entitled t % ri,"t ! %$dience in %ll
C$rt# $nle## S)3+ ! t"%t Act i# !ir#t 0r$,"t int
!rce) T"%t i# % 4%tter 2"ic" i# #till re,$l%ted 01
di!!erent #t%t$te# %nd t"e e>tent ! t"e ri,"t t 3r%ctice
4$#t de3end n t"e ter4# ! t"#e #t%t$te#) T"e ri,"t
! %n %d5c%te 0r$,"t n t"e rll# t 3r%cti#e i#@
t"[email protected] F$#t 2"%t i# cn!erred n "i4 01 S)l<'1('%(@
'0( %nd 'c( t"e ;%r C$ncil# [email protected] 1?*6L)

1?.. A,%in ne ! t"e Ad5c%te# ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt !iled
% -rit Petitin %nd %!ter det%iled cn#ider%tin t"e HnH0le
S$3re4e C$rt "%d i##$ed % 2rit in t"e n%t$re ! 4%nd%4$#
t t"e Centr%l B5ern4ent 2"ic" re3rted inO 612557 4 S**
4 'Aelte4e#" Rein Ver#$# Unin ! Indi%(
Kt cn#ider 2it"in % 3erid ! #i> 4nt"# 2"et"er
#ectin 3+ ! t"e Act #"$ld 0e 0r$,"t int !rce r
[email protected] 0$t %!ter l%3#e ! 4%n1 1e%r# B5t) "%d nt dne
%n1t"in,)
*++3 HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt "%d %,%in #"2n it# di#3le%#$re
%nd 0#er5ed t"%t 2"ic" re3rted inO
2993 65 7S** 29 'C44n C%$#e Ver#$# Unin ! Indi% D
Or#)(
K2e %re ! t"e 5ie2 t"%t t"i# deci#in de# nt c4e in
t"e 2%1 ! t"i# C$rt i##$in, % 2rit in t"e n%t$re !
4%nd%4$# t t"e Centr%l B5ern4ent t cn#ider
2"et"er t"e ti4e !r 0rin,in, Sectin 3+ ! t"e Act int
!rce "%# %rri5ed r ntQ))R
+<)+3)*++? T"%t t"e E>ec$ti5e C44ittee ! t"e S$3re4e
C$rt ;%r A##ci%tin 'SC;A in #"rt( 3%##ed % re#l$tin n
<)3)*++? !r 4%Gin, re3re#ent%tin t t"e HnH0le C"ie!
J$#tice ! Indi% reJ$e#tin, "i4 !r cn#ider%tin ! %4endin,
t"e SCR 1?66 n t"e !ll2in, line#9 i() Pr5idin, t"e
e>e43tin t Ad5c%te Me40er# "%5in, ten 1e%r# %t ;%r
'SC;A ( %nd e>3erience ! dr%!tin, 3etitin# ! 1++ r %05e
in %[email protected] 0e e>e43ted !r4 t"e 3%##in, ! E>%4A te#t %#
3re#cri0ed in t"e Order IV ! SCR 1?66 !r re,i#terin,A
enrllin, t"e4#el5e# %# AOR ! t"i# [email protected] %# e>e43tin
%5%il%0le t t"e K Attrne1#L %nd K Slicitr#L $nder R$le ='i(
'%%( %nd 'ii('%( re#3ecti5el1)
ii() T %4end SCR 1?66 %nd 4%Ge % 3r5i#in t"%t 2"ene5er
% 3etitin liGe SLPA-PAA33lic%tin# etc) %re [email protected] in t"#e
3etitin# n%4e ! cnd$ctin, Ad5c%te# 2" dr%2# t"e
3etitin 4%1 0e reJ$ired t 0e 2ritten in t"e 3etitin %nd in
t"e C%$#e Li#t i##$ed 01 t"e Re,i#tr1 ! t"i# C$rt %ln, 2it"
t"e n%4e ! AOR#) A t13ed c31 ! t"e E>cer3t# !
Min$te# ! E>ec$ti5e C44ittee ! SC;A dt)<)3)*++? i#
%nne>ed %# A$$e:ure ; P. 1 'P%,e#3/ : <+ (
1<)+1)*+11 A,%in t"e E>ec$ti5e C44ittee ! SC;A 3%##ed
%n $n%ni4$# re#l$tin n 1<)+1)*+11 !r #$04ittin, 0e!re
t"i# HnH0le C$rt in t"e c%#e ! ViF%1 D"%nFi C"%$d"%[email protected] SLP
'C( NO) 1.<.1A*++? %nd t"e re#l$tin cnt%ined 5%ri$#
#$,,e#tin# 2it" re,%rd t #l5in, t"e i43lic%tin# ! AOR
#1#te4 J$% 4%Frit1 ! SC;A 4e40er# 3r%cticin, 0e!re t"e
S$3re4e C$rt) A t13ed c31 ! t"e Min$te# ! E>ec$ti5e
C44ittee ! SC;A dt)1<)+1)*+11 i# %nne>ed %# A$$e:ure
; P. 2 'P%,e# <1 E <=()
1?)+<)*+11 In 5ie2 ! t"e %05e #%id circ$4#t%nce# %nd
F$dici%l 3rn$nce4ent# ! t"e S$3re4e [email protected] Mr) R%4
Jet"4%l%[email protected] Senir Ad5c%te A Me40er ! P%rli%4entA t"e
t"en Pre#ident ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt ;%r A##ci%tin 4%de %
re3re#ent%tin t t"e t"en L%2 Mini#[email protected] B5ern4ent ! Indi%
reJ$e#tin, "i4 t"%t t"e 3r5i#in cnt%ined in Sectin 3+ !
t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61 #"$ld 0e 0r$,"t int !rce)
A t13ed c31 ! t"e re3re#ent%tin d%ted 1?)+<)*+11 ! Mr)
R%4 Jet"4%l%[email protected] Senir Ad5c%te A Me40er ! P%rli%4ent
#ent t L%2 Mini#[email protected] B5ern4ent ! Indi% i# %nne>ed
"ere2it" %nd 4%rGed %# ANNEXURE; P. 3
'P%,e# <6 E <. (
+?)+6)*+11 It %33e%r# t"%t in re#3n#e t t"e reJ$e#t 01 #%id
letter d%ted 1?)+<)*+11 ! Mr) R%4 Jet"4%l%[email protected] t"e Mini#tr1
! L%2 %nd J$#[email protected] B5ern4ent ! Indi% i##$ed % nti!ic%tin
$nder Sectin 1'3( ! t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected] [email protected] 0rin,in, int
!rce 2) e) !) 1=
t"
J$ne *[email protected] Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te#
[email protected] [email protected] 2"ic" i# 3$0li#"ed in !!ici%l ,%Cette)
A t13ed c31 ! t"e !!ici%l B%Cette Nti!ic%tin S)O)
13<? 'E( d%ted +?)+6)*+11 i##$ed 01 t"e Mini#tr1 ! L%2 D
J$#[email protected] B5t) ! Indi% i# %nne>ed "ere2it" %nd 4%rGed %#
ANNEXURE ; P. 4 'P%,e# <? : =+()
1*)1+)*+11 It i# 2rt" 2"ile t 4entin "ere t"%t t"e HnH0le
S$3re4e C$rt "%d #$ 4t t%Gen $3 t"e i##$e re,%rdin, t"e
4%l3r%ctice# %d3ted 01 t"e Ad5c%te n Recrd %nd #$,"t
%##i#t%nce ! ;%r A##ci%tin# !r Kt !ind %33r3ri%te #l$tin#
%nd 3r5ide nece##%r1 c"ecG# %nd 0%l%nce#L in t"e 4%tter ! 'ViF%1
D"%nFi C"%$d"%r1 Ver#$# S$"%# J%1%nt N%t%2%dG%r( SLP 'C ( N)
1.<.1 ! *++? 2"ic" i# di#3#ed ! 2it" t"e 0#er5%[email protected]
K-e %re in!r4ed 01 t"e re,i#tr1 t"%t t"e
R$le C44ittee ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% i#
%lre%d1 #eiCed ! 4#t ! t"e i##$e# t"%t "%5e 0een
r%i#ed in t"e#e #$,,e#tin#) T"ere!re 2e
dee4 it %33r3ri%te t 3l%ce %ll t"e#e
#$,,e#tin# 0e!re t"e R$le C44ittee # t"%t t"e
C44ittee c%n t%Ge nte ! t"e #%4e 2"ile
!r4$l%tin, ne2 r %dditin%l r$le# r 2"ile
#$,,e#tin, %4end4ent# t t"e e>i#tin, r$le#)L
;$t %# 3er t"e Gn2led,e ! t"e 3etitiner t"e 4%tter i#
3endin, 0e!re t"e HnH0le R$le C44ittee ! t"e
S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi%) A t13ed c31 ! t"e
J$d,4ent d%ted 1*)1+)*+11 3%##ed in 'ViF%1 D"%nFi
C"%$d"%r1 Ver#$# S$"%# J%1%nt N%t%2%dG%r( SLP 'C ( N)
1.<.1 ! *++? 01 t"e HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt i# %nne>ed
"ere2it" %nd 4%rGed %# ANNEXURE; P. 'P%,e# =1 : =+()
1=)11)*+11 An %d5c%te ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt !iled % -rit Petitin 'C( N)
.3*/A*+11 in Del"i Hi," C$rt c"%llen,in, t"e #1#te4 ! Ad5c%te:
n:Recrd in t"e S$3re4e C$rt)
1*)1*)*+11 A #i4il%r A##ci%tin "%# !iled % Inter5entin A
I43le%d4ent A33lic%tin 5ide C)M) N) 1?616 ! *+11 t
i43le%ded %# 3%rt1 re#3ndent in -)P)'C(N).3*/ ! *+11
13)+*)*+1* H2e5er t"e Hi," C$rt di#4i##ed t"e 3etitin
01 3%##in, t"e i43$,ned !in%l rder %nd F$d,4ent d%ted
13)+*)*+1* in -rit Petitin 'C( N).3*/ ! *[email protected] ;%lr%F Sin,"
M%liG Ver#$# S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% 2it"$t i##$in, ntice t
t"e #le re#3ndent %nd 2it"$t #eeGin, t"e re#3n#e ! t"e
S$3re4e C$rtAre#3ndent %# 2ell %# Unin ! Indi%) -"ile
# di#4i##in, t"e [email protected] t"e HnH0le Hi," C$rt !%iled t
cn#ider t"e %r,$4ent# 4%de 01 t"e C$n#el !r inter5ener:
3etitiner t"erein 2it" re,%rd t t"e 5il%tin ! !$nd%4ent%l
ri,"t# ! Ad5c%te# $nder Article 1?'1(',( %nd Article 1< !
t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%) T"e Hi," C$rt relied $3n t"e
F$d,4ent ! Lill1 I#%0el T"4%#H# c%#[email protected] 1?6<'6( SCR **?
2"ic" i# 0%#ed n tr%n#itr1 3r5i#in n%4el1 Sectin =. !
t"e Ad5c%te# Act) -"ile # din, t"e Hi," C$rt !%iled t
%33reci%te t"%t Sectin =. ! t"e Act l#t it# !rce %# #n %#
Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te# Act 2%# 0r$,"t in t !rce in
J$ne *+11 %nd t"[email protected] t"e F$d,4ent "%# n 3recedenti%l
5%l$e in re#3ect ! t"e e!!ect ! Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te#
Act n t"e ri,"t $nder Article 1? '1( ',( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin)
T"e t"er 3r5i#in relied $3n 01 t"e Hi," C$rt i# Sectin
=* ! t"e Ad5c%te Act 2"ic" it 2%# %r,$ed 01 t"e C$n#el
!r t"e 3etitiner "erein t"%t t"e #%4e i# $ncn#tit$tin%l %#
$nder t"e ,%r0 ! #%5in, cl%$#e it "%# t"e e!!ect ! %4endin,
Article 1<= '1( '%( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin)
+*)+/)*+1* HENCE THE PERESENT SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION)
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
[Under Order 6VI R$le <'1('%(&
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
[UNDER ARTICLE 136 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA&
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION 'CIVIL( NO) OF *+1*
;ET-EEN9 PARTIES NAME
IN THE IN THIS
HIBH COURT COURT
Su,re0e *ourt A(+ocates Associatio$4
Re3re#ented t"r$," it# Hnr%r1 Secret%[email protected]
;%r l$n,[email protected] B)F)@
S$3re4e C$rt C%43$#@
Ne2 Del"i:11+++1 Q)Petitio$er

AND
1. Su,re0e *ourt o) I$(ia
t"r$," it# Re,i#tr%r Bener%[email protected]
S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi%@ Til%G M%r,@
Ne2 Del"i:11+++1 Re#3ndent Cnte#tin,
) Re#3ndent
2. Balra< Si$g" =ali>@
SA L%te S") R)D)S) M%[email protected]
C"%40er N) [email protected]
S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi%@ Til%G M%r,@
Ne2 Del"i:11+++1 Petitiner Pr!r4% )
Re#3ndent

TO
HONI;LE THE CHIEF JUSTICE OF INDIA AND HIS
COMPANION JUDBES OF THE HONI;LE SUPREME COURT)
T"e S3eci%l Le%5e Petitin ! t"e Petitiner %05e n%4edO
=OS! RESPE*[email protected]@A S#OBE!#C
1. T"e Petitiner %05e n%4ed re#3ect!$ll1 #$04it# t"i#
3etitin #eeGin, S3eci%l Le%5e t A33e%l %,%in#t t"e i43$,ned !in%l
rder d%ted 13)+*)*+1* P%##ed in -)P)'C( N) .3*/ ! *+11 01 t"e
Hi," C$rt ! Del"i %t Ne2 Del"i 2"ere01 t"e HnI0le Hi," C$rt
"%d di#4i##ed t"e 2rit 3etitin !iled 01 t"e re#3ndent n)* "erein)
DUES!IONS O? @ABC
2. T"e !ll2in, #$0#t%nti%l J$e#tin# ! l%2 %ri#e !r t"e
cn#ider%tin ! t"i# HnH0le C$rt9
I. -"et"er t"e d$%lit1 e>i#tin, in t"e !ield ! le,%l
3r!e##in 2%# ended 01 t"e en%ct4ent ! t"e
Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61 %nd t"e S$3re4e C$rt R$le#
cntin$in, t"i# d$%lit1 in t"e S$3re4e C$rt 01 5irt$e
! Sectin =. ! t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61 c%4e t %n
end %!ter c4in, int !rce ! Sectin 3+ ! t"e
Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61)

II. -"et"er Sectin =* ! t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61
de# nt in e!!ect %4end Article 1<='1('%( ! t"e
Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% %nd t"ere01 i# 0e1nd t"e #c3e
! t"e le,i#l%ti5e 32er ! t"e P%rli%4ent $nder Article
*<= t *<6 ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%M

III. -"et"er Order IV R$le ='ii( %nd 1+ i# nt %n
ille,%l re#trictin n t"e ri,"t ! %n Ad5c%te $nder
Article 1?'1(',( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%M

IE. -"et"er t"e Sc3e ! t"e 32er $nder Article
1<='1('%( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% i# nt
circ$45ented 01 t"e 3$r3#e ! t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected]
1?61 %nd it# e>3re## 3r5i#in#M

E. -"et"er t"e HnI0le S$3re4e C$rt "%# %n1
32er $nder Article 1<='1('%( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin !
Indi% t !r%4e r$le# i43#in, re#trictin# n t"e
#t%t$tr1 ri,"t t 3r%ctice ,r%nted 01 Sectin 3+ ! t"e
Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61 2"ic" %re cntr%r1 t t"e
3$r3#e# ! t"e ActM

EI. -"et"er t"e Order IV R$le ='ii( %nd 1+ ! t"e
S$3re4e C$rt R$le#@ 1?66 cre%tin, 3rd c%te,r1 !
Ad5c%te# in cntr%5entin ! Sectin 16 ! t"e
Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61 i# nt 5il%ti5e ! Article 1< ! t"e
Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%M
3. DE*@ARA!IONS IN !ER=S O? [email protected] 4627C
T"e 3etitiner# #t%te# t"%t n t"er 3etitin #eeGin, le%5e t
#3eci%l %33e%l "%# 0een !iled 01 t"e 3re#ent 3etitiner %,%in#t t"e
!in%l F$d,4ent A order dated 13.02.2012 Passed in W.P.(C) No. 8327 of
2011 by the High Court of Dehi at Ne! Dehi)
4. DE*@ARA!IONS IN !ER=S O? [email protected] 3C
T"e Anne>$re 3rd$ced %ln, 2it" t"i# S3eci%l Le%5e Petitin %re
tr$e %nd crrect c3ie# ! t"e Ple%din,#ADc$4ent# 2"ic" !r4ed
3%rt ! t"e recrd# ! t"e c$rt# 0el2 %,%in#t 2"#e rder# t"e
le%5e t %33e%l i# #$,"t !r in t"i# 3etitin#)
. FROUNDS
T"e Petitiner# 3re!er# t"i# S3eci%l Le%5e Petitin n t"e
!ll2in, ,r$nd#@ %4n,#t t"er#@ 2"ic" %re t%Gen 2it"$t
3reF$dice t ne %nt"er9
A. ;ec%$#e t"e HnI0le Hi," C$rt "%# !%iled t %33reci%te
t"%t ri,"t t 3r%ctice ! Ad5c%te# in %n1 C$rt incl$din, t"e
HnI0le S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% "%# 0een ,r%nted 01 Sectin 3+ !
t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61 #$0Fect t t"e cnditin# 4entined $nder
t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61 %nd t"e #%4e i# 3rtected $nder Article
1?'1(',( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%)

B. ;ec%$#e t"e HnI0le Hi," C$rt "%# !%iled t %33reci%te
t"%[email protected] t"e r$le 4%Gin, 32er ! HnI0le S$3re4e C$rt $nder
Article 1<='1('%( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% "%# 0een 4%de
#$0Fect t %n1 l%2 4%de 01 t"e 3%rli%4ent) Order IV R$le ='ii( %nd
1+ ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt R$le#@ 1?66 0ein, cntr%r1 t Sectin 3+
! t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61 0ec4e# 5id !r t2 Re%#n#9
6i7 It 0ein, cntr%r1 t t"e Sectin 3+ ! t"e
Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61 i# 0e1nd t"e r$le 4%Gin, 32er ! t"e
HnI0le S$3re4e C$rt $nder Article 1<='1('%( ! t"e
Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%)
6ii7 It i43#e# %n ille,%l re#trictin n t"e ri,"t ! %n
Ad5c%te $nder Article 1?'1(',( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%
t 3r%ctice in t"e S$3re4e C$rt) Since t"e re#trictin i#
cntr%r1 t Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61 it i# nt
#%5ed 01 Article 1?'6( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%)
*. ;ec%$#e t"e HnH0le Hi," C$rt "%# !%iled t %33reci%te
t"%t Article 1?'6( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% #3eci!ic%ll1 3r5ide#
!r 3re#cri0in, J$%li!ic%tin# !r 3r%cticin, %n1 3r!e##[email protected]
cc$3%[email protected] tr%de r 0$#ine## 01 2%1 ! % re#trictin in t"e intere#t
! ,ener%l [email protected] t"ere!re nce t"e IActI 3r5ide# !r #$c"
J$e#tin#Are#trictin# t"e r$le 4%Gin, 32er 2"ic" i# #3eci%ll1
#$0Fect t t"e IActI c%n "%5e n F$ri#dictin t i43#e %dditin%l
re#trictin #3eci%ll1 2"en t"e r$le 4%Gin, 32er i# nl1 !r t"e
3$r3#e ! Re,$l%tin, t"e Pr%ctice ! Le,%l Pr!e##in in t"e
S$3re4e C$rt) It i# #$04itted t"%t Re#trictin %nd Re,$l%tin %re
t2 di!!erent cnce3t#@ Re,$l%tin in Article 1<= '1( in t"e cnte>t
! Article 1?'1( '6( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% c%nnt 4e%n t"e
#%4e t"in, %# re#trictin) Re,$l%tin 2$ld 4e%n t 4%Ge t"e ri,"t
4re e!!ecti5e) T"e te#t t deter4ine 2"et"er % 3r5i#in i#
re,$l%tr1 r re#tricti5e i# 2"et"er it e!!ect$%te# t"e e>erci#e !
ri,"t r #ti!le# it M
D. ;ec%$#e t"e HnI0le Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te
t"%t Sectin =* ! t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61 %# %4ended i# clr%0le
e>erci#e ! [email protected] #ince $nder t"e ,%r0 ! en%ctin, % #%5in, cl%$#e
it #eeG# t re:dr%!t Article 1<='1( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% 01
renderin, t"e 2rd# R #$0Fect t t"e 3r5i#in# ! %n1 l%2 4%de 01
3%rli%4entQQQ))L ine!!ecti5e %nd R#$0#tit$tin, Cl%$#e '%( ! Article
1<='1( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% !r t"e 2rd#9
Kr$le# %# t t"e 3er#n# 3r%cticin, 0e!re t"e c$rtOR
01 t"e 2rd#9
R!r deter4inin, t"e 3er#n# 2" #"%ll 0e entitled t
GActG r GPlea(G in t"%t [email protected]
E. ;ec%$#e t"e HnI0le Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te t"%t nce
t"e P%rli%4ent 3re#cri0e# 3r!e##in%l J$%li!ic%tin !r Ad5c%te#
%nd t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% ,r%nt# % li4ited 32er $nder Article
1<= t 4%Ge r$le# #$0Fect t t"e 3r5i#in# ! l%2 4%de 01 t"e
P%rli%[email protected] t"e HnI0le S$3re4e C$rt "%# n 32er t !r%4e
r$le# i43#in, %n %dditin%l re#trictin ! tr%inin, %nd e>%4in%tin
%# 3r5ided $nder Order [email protected] R$le = ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt R$le#@
1?66 %nd t"e cn#eJ$enti%l re#trictin $nder Order [email protected] R$le 1+ !
t"e S$3re4e C$rt R$1e#@ 1?66) T"[email protected] Order [email protected] R$le = %nd
1+ ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt R$le#@ 1?66 %re 5il%ti5e ! Article 1?'1(
',( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% %nd nt #%5ed 01 Article 1? '6( !
Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%) Hence Order [email protected] R$le = %nd 1+ %re
$ncn#tit$tin%l %nd li%0le t 0e J$%#"ed)

F. ;ec%$#e t"e HnI0le Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te
t"%t Sectin 16 ! t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61 rec,niCe# nl1 t2
c%te,rie# ! Ad5c%te# %nd t"e r$le 4%Gin, 32er $nder Article
1<= '1( '%( ! Cn#tit$tin ! Indi% 0ein, % 32er t !r%4e r$le#
re,$l%tin, t"e 3rced$re# %nd #$0Fect t %n1 l%2 4%de 01
P%rli%[email protected] t"e HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt c%nnt !r%4e r$le# cre%tin,
% t"ird c%te,r1 ! “Ad5c%te#:n:RecrdR) T"$# Order [email protected] R$le =
%nd 1+ ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt R$1e#@ 1?66 %re 5il%ti5e ! Article
1< ! Cn#tit$tin ! Indi%)
F. ;ec%$#e t"e HnH0le Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te
t"%t t"e c43#itin ! t"e %d5c%te# 3r%cticin, in t"e S$3re4e
C$rt ! Indi% %# re!lected in t"e 4e40er#"i3 ! t"e S$3re4e
C$rt ;%r A##ci%tin '"erein %!ter re!ereed %# SC;A( re5e%l# t"%t
t"ere %re %r$nd [email protected]=++ %d5c%te# 2" %re 4e40er# ! t"e SC;A
$t ! 2"ic" %r$nd 16++ %re Ad5c%te:n:Recrd# '"erein %!ter
re!ereed %# AOR( %nd %r$nd 6++ %re Senir Ad5c%te# %nd t"e
re4%inin, 63++ %re Nn: Ad5c%te#:n:Recrd) T"e S$3re4e
C$rt R$le# 1?66 cre%ted t"ird c%te,r1 ! %d5c%te# c%lled
KAd5c%te E n E Recrd L cntr%r1 t t"e Ad5c%te# Act %nd
4%Frit1 ! t"e NON: AOR# "%5e ,t nl1 cn#l%tin t"%t t"e
S$3re4e C$rt %cGn2led,e# t"e4 %# KOt"er Ad5c%te# L n it#
2e0#ite %# $nder9
-6iii7 O!#ER ADEO*A!ES.C
T"e#e %re Ad5c%te# 2"#e n%4e# %re entered n t"e rll !
%n1 St%te ;%r C$ncil 4%int%ined $nder t"e Ad5c%te# [email protected]
1?61 %nd t"e1 c%n %33e%r %nd %r,$e %n1 4%tter n 0e"%l! !
% 3%rt1 in t"e S$3re4e C$rt 0$t t"e1 %re nt entitled t !ile
%n1 dc$4ent r 4%tter 0e!re t"e C$rt L) ;ec%$#e ! t"e
%cGn2led,4ent ! t"e !%ct t"%t %n1 Ad5c%te enrlled 2it"
t"e St%te ;%r C$ncil i# entitled t 3r%ctice in HnH0le
S$3re4e [email protected] client# %re %0le t en,%,e #$c" Ad5c%te# n
t"e 3re4i#e t"%t t"e1 %re S$3re4e C$rt Pr%ctitiner#)
Under ;%r C$ncil R$le# #ince Ad5c%te# %re nt %ll2ed t
%d5erti#e t"eir #er5ice#@ client# in5%ri%0l1 "%5e t %33r%c"
Ad5c%te# n t"e 0%#i# ! re!erence 2"ic" in#till cn!idence in
% client in % 3%rtic$l%r Ad5c%te) I! t"e AOR #1#[email protected] %#
en5i#%,[email protected] 2ere t 0e 4%de 4%nd%[email protected] it 2$ld i43#e
$ntld "%rd#"i3# $3n t"e %d5c%te 2" i# in t$c" 2it" t"e
client 0$t %l# n t"e client "i4#el! %# AOR# 2" %re %t
3re#ent c"%r,in, nl1 !r lendin, t"eir n%4e# !r !ilin, t"eir
4%tter# 2$ld 0e %0le t c"%r,e e5en !r %33e%rin, in t"e
4%tter %ln, 2it" t"e t"er Ad5c%te 2it"$t "%5in, %n1
Gn2led,e %0$t t"e 4%tter %nd 2it"$t "%5in, %n1 cntr%ct
2it" t"e client) In $r #1#[email protected] it i# nt 3##i0le t !rce %
client t c43$l#ril1 cnt%ct t"e AOR directl1 n 2"4 "e
4%1 "%5e n cn!idence 2"en #$c" client %lre%d1 "%# %cce##
t #4e t"er Ad5c%te 2" i# re,$l%rl1 3r%cticin, in t"e
HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% %nd n 2"4 "e "%#
cn!idence)
#. ;ec%$#e t"e HnH0le Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te t"%t
t"e nece##it1 ! "%5in, %n Ad5c%te#:n:Recrd !r t"e S$3re4e
C$rt ! Indi% i# n2 l#in, it# #i,ni!ic%nce 0ec%$#e ! t"e l%r,e
n$40er ! Nn: Ad5c%te#:n:Recrd re,$l%rl1 3r%cticin, in t"e
S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi%) In !%[email protected] i! % #$r5e1 ! t"e Ad5c%te#:n:
Recrd re,i#tered in t"i# HnH0le C$rt 2ere t 0e 4%[email protected] it 2$ld
0#er5e t"%t 5er1 !e2 ! t"e4 %re %cti5e 3r%ctitiner# %nd %
4%Frit1 ! t"e4 %re 4erel1 n%4e lender#@ c"%r,in, 4ne1 !r
lendin, t"eir n%4e# in t"e 4%tter !r !ilin, ! 3etitin#) In5%ri%0l1
dr%!tin, ! 3etitin# %re nt 0ein, dne 01 t"e Ad5c%te#:n:
Recrd %nd %re in !%[email protected] 0ein, dne 01 t"e t"er Ad5c%te# 2" %re
0ein, re3re#ented 01 t"e 3etitiner %##ci%tin)
I. ;ec%$#e t"e HnH0le Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te t"%t
2"en t"ere %re l%r,e n$40er ! Ad5c%te# in t"e S$3re4e C$rt @
2" %re in 4%n1 2%1# 4re c%3%0le t"%n t"e Ad5c%te#:n:Recrd
0$t %re nt %ll2ed t !ile 4%tter# in t"e C$rt 0ec%$#e ! t"e
e>i#tence ! t"e #%id in#tit$tinA#1#te4 %nd in recent 3%#t @ t"e
S$3re4e C$rt %l# "%# nticed in F$dici%l rder# t"e !%ct t"%t t"e
Ad5c%te#:n:Recrd %re 4erel1 n%4e lender# %nd %!ter lendin,
t"eir n%4e# %re nt ,i5in, %n1 %##i#t%nce t t"e HnH0le C$rt 2it"
t"e re#$lt t"%t t"e 4%tter# %re nt 0ein, 3r#ec$ted 3r3erl1 %#
t"e %ct$%l %d5c%[email protected] 2" i# "%ndlin, t"e 4%tter i# nt 0ein,
inde3endentl1 rec,niCed 01 t"e HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi%)
T"e S$3re4e C$rt e%rlier %l# in t"e c%#e ! NState of Punjab &
Anr. Vs. Ashok Singh GarchaH re3rted in 629927 2 S** 322 @
NVijay Dhanji Chaudhary Vs.Suhas Jayant Natawadkar
re3rted in 2919 617 S** 133 "%# nticed t"e $n"e%lt"1 3r%ctice
! AOR# 4erel1 lendin, t"eir n%4e# !r !ilin, t"e SLP# r !r
enterin, %33e%r%nce# 2it"$t t%Gin, t"e re#3n#i0ilit1 !r t"e
3r3er 3re3%r%tin !r !ilin, t"e SLP r t"e re#3n#i0ilit1 !r 3r3er
%33e%r%nce in t"e c%#e 2%# de3rec%ted) A 3rtin ! t"e rder !
t"e HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt in t"e c%#e ! Vijay Dhanji
Chaudhary'#$3r%( i# J$ted "erein 0el2:
K3) -"%t i# 3$CClin, i# t"e rle r r%t"er t"e %0#ence ! t"e rle
! t"e Ad5c%te:n:Recrd in t"i# 4%tter) P%r% < ! t"e
%33lic%tin #"2# t"%t t"e Ad5c%te:n:Recrd "%d nt"in, t d
2it" t"e #3eci%l le%5e 3etitin e>ce3t t lend "i# n%4e !r !ilin,
t"e 3etitin) He did nt t%Ge in#tr$ctin# !r4 t"e
clientA3etitiner) He did nt 3re3%re t"e #3eci%l le%5e 3etitin) He
did nt in#tr$ct %n1 c$n#el) He 2%# nt reJ$ired t r e>3ected
t %ttend t"e "e%rin, ! t"e c%#e)
=) Un!rt$n%[email protected] 4%n1 #3eci%l le%5e 3etitin# %re 0ein, !iled
2it" Ad5c%te#:n:Recrd 0ein, 4ere n%4e:lender#@ 2it"$t
"%5in,@ r t%Gin,@ %n1 re#3n#i0ilit1 !r t"e c%#e) A# % re#$lt !
3re5%lence ! #$c" % 3r%[email protected] in #$c" c%#e#@ t"e Ad5c%te#:n:
recrd d nt %33e%r 2"en t"e 4%tter# %re li#ted eit"er 0e!re
t"e Re,i#tr%r# r 0e!re t"e C"%40er J$d,e r t"e C$rt nr d
t"e1 t%Ge %n1 intere#t r re#3n#i0ilit1 !r 3rce##in, r
cnd$ctin, t"e c%#e) T"e1 %l# 3l%1 n rle in 3re3%r%tin ! t"e
#3eci%l le%5e 3etitin#@ nr en#$re t"%t t"e reJ$ire4ent# ! t"e
R$le# %re !$l!illed %nd de!ect# %re c$red) I! t"e rle ! %n
%d5c%te: n:recrd i#
4erel1 t lend "i# n%4e !r !ilin, c%#e# 2it"$t 0ein,
re#3n#i0le !r t"e cnd$ct ! t"e c%#[email protected] t"e 5er1 3$r3#e !
"%5in, t"e #1#te4 ! Ad5c%te#:n:Recrd 2$ld ,et de!e%ted)
6) T"e J$e#tin t"%t %ri#e# !r cn#ider%tin i# 2"et"er %n
Ad5c%te:n:Recrd c%n !ile %33e%r%nce# %# 4ere n%4e: lender
!r !%cilit%tin, !ilin, ! 3etitin# 01 t"er#@ 2it"$t
3er!r4in, %n1 ! t"e !$nctin# %##ci%ted 2it" %n Ad5c%te:n:
Recrd)
/) In rder t en!rce di#ci3line in t"e 2rGin,
! %d5c%te#:n:recrd %nd t %5id t"e 4i#$#e ! t"e #1#[email protected]
%nd t en#$re t"%t t"e c$rt "%# t"e 0ene!it ! e!!ecti5e
%##i#t%nce ! t"e Ad5c%te#:n:[email protected] % #l$tin "%# t 0e
!$nd)L
'. ;ec%$#e t"e Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te t"%t @ t"e
S$3re4e C$rt in -rit Petitin N) .6A*+1+ ! S"t. Poona" Vs.
Su"it #a$war re3rted in *+1+'3( *66 "%# %l# nticed t"e
!%ll%c1 in t"e #1#te4 ! t"e in#[email protected] t"%t i#@ Ad5c%te#:n:recrd
%nd t"[email protected] t"e #1#te4 ! AOR i# li%0le t 0e %0li#"ed 01 t"i#
HnH0le C$rt)
K. ;ec%$#e t"e Hi," C$rt errne$#l1 relied $3n t"e
F$d,4ent ! Lill1 I#%0el T"4%#H# c%#[email protected] 1?6<'6( SCR **? 2"ic" i#
0%#ed n tr%n#itr1 3r5i#in n%4el1 Sectin =. ! t"e Ad5c%te#
Act) -"ile # din, t"e Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te t"%t Sectin
=. ! t"e Act l#t it# !rce %# #n %# Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te#
Act 2%# 0r$,"t in t !rce in J$ne *+11 %nd t"[email protected] t"e
F$d,4ent "%# n 3recedenti%l 5%l$e in re#3ect ! t"e e!!ect !
Sectin 3+ ! t"e Ad5c%te# Act n t"e ri,"t $nder Article 1? '1(
',( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin) T"e t"er 3r5i#in relied $3n 01 t"e Hi,"
C$rt i# Sectin =* ! t"e Ad5c%te Act 2"ic" 2%# %r,$ed t"%t t"e
#%4e i# $ncn#tit$tin%l %# $nder t"e ,%r0 ! #%5in, cl%$#e it "%#
t"e e!!ect ! %4endin, Article 1<= '1( '%( ! t"e Cn#tit$tin)
@. ;ec%$#e t"e Hi," C$rt !%iled t %33reci%te t"%t t"e 2rit
3etitin $,"t t "%5e 0een tr%n#!erred t %nt"er 0enc" ! t"e
Hi," C$rt 0ec%$#e !%4il1 4e40er ! t"e ne ! t"e HnH0le
J$d,e# ! t"e 3re#ent 0enc" "%33en# t 0e Ad5c%te n Recrd
%nd t"ere!re t re45e %n1 it% ! 0i%#ene## t"e 2rit 3etitin
#"$ld "%5e 0een "e%rd %nd decided 01 #4e t"er 0enc" ! t"e
HnH0le Hi," C$rt)
6. FROUNDS ?OR IN!ERI= [email protected]?C
Interi4 relie! nt reJ$ired)
8. =AIN PRAAERC
It i#@ t"[email protected] 4#t re#3ect!$ll1 3r%1ed t"%t t"i# HnH0le
C$rt 4%1 ,r%ci$#l1 0e 3le%#ed t9
A7. Br%nt S3eci%l Le%5e t A33e%l t t"e Petitiner "erein %,%in#t
t"e i43$,ned fina "udg#ent dated 13.02.2012 Passed in W.P.(C) No.
8327 of 2011 by the High Court of Dehi at Ne! [email protected] %nd
B7. P%## #$c" %n1 t"er r !$rt"er rder#@ %# t"i# HnH0le
C$rt 4%1 dee4 !it %nd 3r3er in t"e circ$4#t%nce# ! t"e c%#e)
5. PRAAER ?OR IN!ERI= [email protected]?C Nt Pr%1ed
AND FOR THIS ACT OF 7INDNESS THE PETITIONERS AS IN DUT8
;OUND TO SHALL EVER PRA8)

Dra1$ &/C
R%5i S"%nG%r 7$4%r D
;) 7) C"$d"%[email protected] Ad5c%te#
SETTLED ;89 FILED ;89
Mr) Tri3$r%ri R%1
Ad5c%te
Dr%2n n9 *=)+6)*+1* [P%r4%n%nd P%nde1&
Filed n 9 +*)+/)*+1* Ad5c%te n Recrd !r 3etitiner
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION 'C( NO) OF *+1*
S$3re4e C$rt Ad5c%te# A##ci%tin Petitiner
$ersus
S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% D Anr) %es&ondents
CERTIFICATE
Certi!ied t"%t t"e S3eci%l le%5e Petitin i# cn!ined nl1 t t"e
3le%din,# 0e!re t"e C$rtATri0$n%l 2"#e rder i# c"%llen,ed %nd
t"e t"er dc$4ent# relied $3n in t"#e 3rceedin,#) N
%dditin%l !%ct#@ dc$4ent# r ,r$nd# "%5e 0een t%Gen t"erein r
relied $3n in t"e S3eci%l le%5e Petitin) It i# !$rt"er certi!ied t"%t
t"e c3ie# ! t"e dc$4ent#A %nne>$re %tt%c"ed t t"e #3eci%l
le%5e 3etitin %re nece##%r1 t %n#2er t"e J$e#tin ! l%2 r%i#ed in
t"e 3etitin r t 4%Ge $t ,r$nd# $r,ed in t"e S3eci%l le%5e
Petitin !r cn#ider%tin ! t"i# HnH0le C$rt) T"i# Certi!ic%te i#
,i5en n t"e 0%#i# ! t"e in#tr$ctin# ,i5en 01 t"e 3etitiner A
3er#n %$t"riCed 01 t"e 3etitiner 2"#e %!!id%5it i# !iled in
#$33rt ! t"e in#t%nt S)L)P)
'P%r4%n%nd P%nde1(
FILED ON9 +*)+/)*+1* ADVOCATE FOR PETITIONER
INTHE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION 'C( NO) OF *+1*
S$3re4e C$rt Ad5c%te# A##ci%tin Petitiner
$ersus
S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% D Anr) %es&ondents
A??IDAEI!
[email protected] R%5i S"%nG%r 7$4%[email protected] Ad5c%[email protected] Hnr%r1 Secret%[email protected] S$3re4e
C$rt Ad5c%te# A##ci%[email protected] re#idin, %t ;[email protected] S%!d%r J$n,
Encl%[email protected] Ne2 Del"i:11++*[email protected] d "ere01 #le4nl1 %!!ir4 %nd decl%re
%# $nder9
1) T"%t I %4 Hnr%r1 Secret%r1 ! t"e 3etitiner:A##ci%tin in
t"e %05e c%3tined 4%tter %nd %# #$c" I %4 2ell cn5er#%nt 2it"
!%ct# %nd circ$4#t%nce# ! t"e 3re#ent c%#[email protected] "ence I %4 c43etent
t #2e%r t"i# %!!id%5it)
*) T"%t I "%5e ,ne t"r$," t"e %cc43%n1in, S3eci%l Le%5e
Petitin Cnt%inin, P%r% 1 t . %nd 3%,e# N#) *3 t %nd t"e li#t
! d%te# P%,e# ; t M %nd t"e %cc43%n1in, Interlc$tr1
A33lic%tin# "%# 0een dr%!ted 01 41 C$n#el# n 41 in#tr$ctin#) I
"%5e re%d %nd $nder#td t"e cntent# ! t"e #%[email protected] 2"ic" %re tr$e
%nd crrect t t"e 0e#t ! 41 Gn2led,e %nd 0elie!) N 3%rt ! it i#
!%l#e %nd nt"in, 4%teri%l "%# 0een cnce%led t"erein)
3) T"%t t"e Anne>$re# !iled %ln, 2it" t"e S3eci%l le%5e Petitin
%re tr$e %nd crrect c3ie# ! t"eir re#3ecti5e ri,in%l#@ 2"ic"
!r4 3%rt ! t"e recrd# ! t"e C$rt 0el2)
<) T"%t 3etitiner "%# nt 45ed e%rlier t t"i# HnH0le C$rt
!r t"e relie! 3r%1ed in t"e in#t%nt S3eci%l le%5e Petitin)
=) T"%t t"e cntent# ! t"e %05e 3%r%# ! t"i# %!!id%5it %re tr$e
%nd crrect t t"e 0e#t ! 41 Gn2led,e %nd [email protected] n 3%rt ! it i#
!%l#e %nd nt"in, 4%teri%l i# cnce%led t"ere !r4)

De3nent
Veri!ic%tin
[email protected] t"e %05e n%4ed [email protected] d "ere01 #le4nl1 %!!ir4 %nd
decl%re %t Ne2 Del"i n *
nd
d%1 ! [email protected] *+1* t"%t t"e cntent# !
P%r% 1 t 6 %t %05e %!!id%5it %re tr$e t 41 Gn2led,e %nd 0elie!)

De3nent
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
I)A) NO) OF *+1*
IN
S)L)P) 'CIVIL( NO) SSSSSSSSSSS OF *+1*
IN THE MATTER OF9
S$3re4e C$rt Ad5c%te# A##ci%tin Petitiner
Ver#$#
S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi% D Anr) Re#3ndent#


AN [email protected]*A!ION ?OR PER=ISSION !O
[email protected] SPE*[email protected] @EAEE PE!I!ION
T
HONI;LE THE CHIEF JUSTICE OF INDIA AND HIS
COMPANION JUDBES OF THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
T"e S3eci%l Le%5e Petitin ! t"e Petitiner %05e n%4edO
=OS! RESPE*[email protected]@A S#OBE!#9
1. T"e Petitiner %05e n%4ed re#3ect!$ll1 #$04it# t"i# Petitin
#eeGin, S3eci%l Le%5e t A33e%l %,%in#t Fin%l J$d,4ent %nd
Order d%ted 13)+*)*+1* 3%##ed 01 t"e Hi," C$rt ! Del"i %t
Ne2 Del"i in -P 'C( N).3*/ ! *+11)
2. T"%t !r t"e #%Ge ! 0re5it1 t"e 3etitiner i# nt n%rr%tin, t"e
!$ll !%ct# ! t"e c%#e "erein in t"i# %33lic%tin %nd cr%5e#
le%5e ! t"i# HnH0le C$rt t re!er t %nd rel1 n t"e !%ct#
#t%ted in t"e S)L)P) %# !r4in, 3%rt %nd 3%rcel ! t"i#
%33lic%tin !r 3er4i##in t !ile SLP)
3. T"%t t"e 3etitiner i# %n %##ci%tin ! S$3re4e C$rt
Ad5c%te# 2" %re nt Ad5c%te#:n:Recrd 0$t 2" %re
re,$l%rl1 3r%cticin, in t"i# HnH0le C$rt %# 2ell %# 2" %re
4e40er# ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt ;%r A##ci%tin) T"e
c43#itin ! t"e %d5c%te# 3r%cticin, in t"e S$3re4e C$rt
! Indi% %# re!lected in t"e 4e40er#"i3 ! t"e S$3re4e C$rt
;%r A##ci%tin '"erein %!ter re!ereed %# SC;A( re5e%l# t"%t
t"ere %re %r$nd [email protected]=++ %d5c%te# 2" %re 4e40er# ! t"e
SC;A $t ! 2"ic" %r$nd [email protected]++ %re Ad5c%te:n:Recrd#
'"erein %!ter re!ereed %# AOR( %nd %r$nd 6++ %re Senir
Ad5c%te# %nd t"e re4%inin, %r$nd [email protected]++ %re Ot"er
Ad5c%te#. H2e5er d$e t t"e e>i#tin, #1#te4 ! Ad5c%te
n Recrd in t"e HnH0le S$3re4e C$rt ! Indi%@ ri,"t t
3r%ctice 2it" di,nit1 ! 4%Frit1 ! Ot"er Ad5c%te# %re
c$rt%[email protected] 2"ic" i# $nF$#ti!ied %nd $ncn#tit$tin%l in 5ie2 !
'Anne>$re:P)<( ,%Cette nti!ic%tin ! Sectin 3+ ! t"e
Ad5c%te# [email protected] 1?61 in J$ne *+11)
4. T"%t it i# #$04itted t"%t t"e Petitiner 2%# nt % 3%rt1 in t"e
-rit Petitin) [email protected] t"e Petitiner 0ein, %n %##ci%tin !
S$3re4e C$rt Pr%cticin, Ad5c%te# %,,rie5ed 01 t"e
F$d,4ent ! t"e Hi," C$rt c%n 3re!er % S3eci%l Le%5e
Petitin %,%in#t t"e #%id F$d,4ent) Hence t"e 3re#ent
%33lic%tin !r 3er4i##in t !ile SLP i# 0ein, !iled 0e!re t"i#
HnH0le C$rt)
. T"%t it i# in t"e intere#t ! F$#tice t"%t t"e Petitiner #"$ld
0e 3er4itted 01 t"i# HnH0le C$rt t 3re!er t"e %cc43%n1in,
3etitin !r S3eci%l Le%5e t A33e%l)
3. T"%t t"e A33lic%tin i# 0ein, 4%de 0n%!ide %nd in t"e
intere#t ! F$#tice)
PRAAER
It i#@ t"[email protected] re#3ect!$ll1 3r%1ed t"%t t"i# HnI0le C$rt 4%1
,r%ci$#l1 0e 3le%#ed t9
i) Br%nt Per4i##in t t"e Petitiner t !ile S3eci%l Le%5e
Petitin %,%in#t Fin%l J$d,4ent %nd Order
d%ted13)+*)*+1* 3%##ed 01 t"e Hi," C$rt ! Del"i %t
Ne2 Del"i in -P ' C ( N) .3*/ ! *+11)
ii7 P%## #$c" t"er r !$rt"er rder#Adirectin# %# t"i#
HnH0le C$rt 4%1 dee4 !it %nd 3r3er in t"e !%ct# %nd
circ$4#t%nce# ! t"i# c%#e)
DRA-N ;89
;) 7) C"$d"%r1 FILED ;89
Ad5c%te

Dr%2n n9 *=)+6)*+1* [P%r4%n%nd P%nde1&
Filed n 9 +*)+/)*+1* Ad5c%te n Recrd !r 3etitiner

P%r4%n%nd P%nde1
Advocate
Supreme Court of India
1, Garuda Vihar, (Behind Shankar Market),
Cannauht !"ace, #e$ %e"hi &1
!h. '()1**+1, ,*-*..(./+
%ated: /'./+.'/1'
0o
0he 1ei2trar,
Supreme Court of India,
#e$ %e"hi
Su34ect: 5etter of Authori2ation
1ef: S5! (C) #o. '/1'
(Supreme Court Advocate2 A22ociation Ver2u2 Supreme Court of
India 6 Anr.)
%ear Sir,
I authori7e Mr. 1avi Shankar 8umar9 B.8. Choudhar:, Advocate2,
Supreme Court, to fi"e, proce22 and take 2tep2 for urent "i2tin and
mentionin of the S5! (C) #o. of '/1' (Supreme Court Advocate2
A22ociation Ver2u2 Supreme Court of India 6 Anr.) of the matter on
3eha"f of me.
0he 2pecimen 2inature of Mr. 1avi Shankar 8umar 9 Mr. B.8.
Choudhar:, Advocate2 are atte2ted for needfu".
0hankin :ou,
(1avi Shankar 8umar 9 B.8. Choudhar:) (!armanand !ande:)
Advocate, Supreme Court Advocate on 1ecord

Sponsor Documents

Or use your account on DocShare.tips

Hide

Forgot your password?

Or register your new account on DocShare.tips

Hide

Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link to create a new password.

Back to log-in

Close