by [)ennis Val"k.s
IAA Libl"al"Y / .Al"chives
[)il"ectf)1"
THE GUGGENHEIM
SAFE AIRCRAFT
COMPETITION (Pt. 2) RESULTS
The opening date for receiving
entries for the competition was Septem-
ber 1, 1927. Entries were fmally closed
on September 1, 1929. The list of
entrants steadily grew until, when it was
fmally closed, no less than 27 entries
had been received and accepted. In the
end, 15 aircraft were actually delivered
to Mitchell Field to take part in the
competition.
It had been hoped that the entries
actually would be presented for tests
well before the closing date for their
arrival, the end of October 1929. In-
deed, it had been anticipated that it
would be possible to carry out most of
the tests during the spring and summer
of that year.
In fact , only one entry (the Handley-
Page) had been presented up to the end
of August and it was well on into the
month of October before the majority
arrived. Several competitors had dif-
ficulty in delivering their entries by the
closing date and a number of airplanes
that were a few days late were allowed
to have a try at the qualifying tests.
The tests in the competition were
conducted by the Guggenheim Fund's
pilots Thomass Carroll, former NACA
test pilot, Edward Rounds, Navy test
pilot, and Lt. Stanley Ulrnstead, Army
test pilot at Mitchell Field. The
Manager of the competition was Capt.
Walter Bender, Army Air Corps.
Of the 15 airplanes which were
pr esented at Mitchell Field, six
withdrew. These were the Alfaro,
Gates, Command-Aire, Bourdon and
Moth entries.
Six others, Handley-Page, Taylor
Brothers , Fleet, Cunningham-Hall,
Ford-Leigh and Brunner-Winkle, failed
to meet requirements of the competi-
tion. The entry of Burnelli failed to
arrive at Mitchell Field within the
4 MARCH 1992
specified time limit, even after this was
extended. It was thus eliminated. The
entry of James McDonnell was
damaged in a test flight while being
flown by McDonnell. His entry was
known as the "Doodlebug." The Cur-
tiss Tanager was the only entry to pass
all of the qualifying requirements, thus
is was not necessary for the Fund to hold
the final competitive tests which were
planned to ascertain the winner on a
point basis.
The January 11 issue of AVIATION
praised the Curtiss entry: "The passing
of eighteen qualifying tests by the not
unusually radical Challenger powered
Tanager, is generally regarded a high
tribute to Curtiss engineers and in par-
ticular Robert R. Osborn, the one most
responsible for the design. Wing slots
were placed on the Tanager along both
upper and lower wings, and the trailing
edges of both wings were equipped with
flaps. These flaps were controlled by a
crank operated from the pilot's cockpit.
Especially striking were the ailerons, of
full floating type which were placed at
the tips of the lower wing. It is reported
that the Curtiss company plans produc-
ing commercial craft with Tanager fea-
tures."
GENERAL COMMENTS
The report on the competition pub-
lished by the Guggenheim Fund
reported on its general fmdings, "As
stated in the Rules for the Daniel Gug-
genheim Safe Aircraft Competition, the
object of the Competition was to
achieve a real advance in the safety of
flying through improvement in the
aerodynamic characteristics of heavier-
than-air craft, without sacrificing the
good qualities of the present day
aircraft.
"Whether or not the above object was
achieved must be a matter of opinion,
but using the conditions as prescribed
by the rules as a measure, two airplanes,
the Curtiss and Handley-Page, ap-
proached very closely to the standard
desired.
"Certain features of the airplanes
competing proved themselves valuable
for specific purposes, but no oppor-
tunity was had to thoroughly investigate
their effect on performance at altitude
either in climb or level speed.
"It is believed that the following
devices, all of which are to be found on
either the Curtiss or Handley-Page
entries, are worthy of incorporation on
various types of aircraft or of further
study: 1. Automatic leading edge slots.
2. Flaps, either automatic or manually
controlled. 3. Floating ailerons. 4.
Long stroke oleo landing gear. 5. Ex-
treme range adjustable stabilizer. 6.
Brakes."
QUALIFYING REQUIREMENTS
Of all the aircraft which actually ar-
rived at Mitchell Field during the last
few months before the closing of the
competition, only three met the require-
ments. These were the Curtiss, Hand-
ley-Page and Command-Aire entries.
The following comments are quoted
from the Fund' s report.
PERFORMANCE: "The maximum
speed requirement (110 mph at full
load) rather surprisingly proved to be
the stumbling block for seven out of the
ten planes tested, although this had no
direct bearing on the Safety Tests, and
any number of stock planes could have
met this condition.
"Those which passed this condition
were the Curtiss, Handley-Page and
Command-A ire entries. Neither the
Command-A ire nor those which failed
on the high speed test showed any pos-
sibility of being able to pass more than
a few of the Safety Tests and
Demonstrations.
"The rate of climb (400 feet per
minute at 1,000 feet) was easily met by
those entries tested for this item of per-
formance. The Curtiss, Command-Aire
and Handley-Page passed this test."
USEFUL LOAD: "All aircraft car-
ried the specified useful load of 5
pounds per horsepower. On several of
the entries it was necessary to increase
the useful load above this figure in order
to have sufficient fuel available for test-
ing."
ACCOMMODATION: "Only one
of the airplanes submitted was con-
sidered unsatisfactory as regards ac-
commodation for the pilot and observer.
The Handley-Page entry had cockpits
so narrow and small that it was impos-
sible to wear a parachute. Due to the
interest in the airplane and since it was
a foreign entry, this matter of accom-
modation was not stressed and the
Handley-Page entry was put through all
the Safety Tests and demonstrations.
"The two planes which satisfactorily
passed all the Qualifying Tests were the
Curtiss and Command-Aire. The
Handley-Page, on account of its
aerodynamic features, and the prob-
ability that it would approach very
closely to the standards set by the rules,
was permitted to remain in the Competi-
tion in spite of failure to provide ade-
quate accommodation for pilot and ob-
server."
SAFETY TEST AND
DEMONSTRATIONS
MINIMUM FLYING SPEED :
"Both the Curtiss and Handley-Page
entries were able to maintain level and
controlled flight at airspeeds below 35
mph. The Command-Aire entry, the
only other airplane to meet the Qualify-
ing Requirements failed on this test by
11 mph, a very considerable amount.
At the request of the competitors, mini-
mum flying speed was measured on the
Cunningham-Hall and Taylor entries.
Neither of them fulfilled the require-
ments, although they performed on this
item better than the Command-A ire. "
MINIMUM GLIDING SPEED:
"The Curtiss Tanager was the only
airplane to meet the minimum gliding
speed requirement. In addition to the
Handley-Page, the minimum gliding
speed was measured on the Cunning-
ham-Hall and Taylor, again at the re-
quest of the competitors."
LANDING RUN: "Only the Curtiss
and Handley-Page entries were tested.
Both airplanes met the requirements,
the Handley-Page being superior to the
Curtiss in this test, in spite of the fact
that the brakes were more readily
operated in the Curtiss entry."
LANDING IN CONFINED SPACE:
"The Curtiss and Handley-Page entries
both were tested. The Handley-Page
failed to meet the requirements while
the Curtiss was successful. One reason
for the failure of the Handley-Page was
the fact that the landing gear was not
rugged enough to permit landing from
the steepest glide."
TAKEOFF: "Both the Curtiss and
Handley-Page entries met the require-
ments, the Handely-Page being superior
to the Curtiss in both takeoff run and
distance to clear the 35 foot obstruc-
tion."
GLIDING ANGLE: "The Curtiss
and Handley-Page entries were both
successful in meeting the requirement
of flattest glide, the Curtiss being slight-
ly superior.
"Neither airplane was able to fulfill
the requirement of steepest glide, and it
was considered by the officials conduct-
ing the tests that the requirement was
VINTAGE AIRPLANE 5
too severe. For this reason the angle
specified was modified from 16 to 12
degrees by unanimous approval of all
Competition officials."
STABILITY: "Both the Curtiss and
Handley-Page entries were determined
to have reasonably satisified the condi-
tions of longitudinal stability, although
neither airplane was perfect under all
conditions.
"The Curtiss entry passed the general
stability requirements, but the Handley-
Page was only satisfactory when
trimmed at airspeeds of about 60 to 80
mph. At other speeds a slight distur-
bance would cause the airplane to even-
tually go into a steep left-land spiral
which gradually steepened with in-
creasing airspeed."
CONTROLLABILITY: "While
both the Curtiss and Handley-Page
entries were assumed to be controllable
at all throttle settings and were probably
more so than any other types, neither
could be controlled perfectly at the stall.
The Curtiss, due to the fact that the flaps
were manually operated, was better than
the Handley-Page in this respect.
"When stalled under power, the
former would drop the nose, pick up
about 3-5 mph and again return to the
stall, continuing this cycle apparently
indefinitely. Lateral and directional
control appeared good at the stall under
any slot or flap adjustment.
"The Handley-Page under power
would, when stalled, do one of two
things. If completely stalled so that the
nose dropped, the slots would close and
the flaps move up, which resulted in the
speed rising some 10-15 mph in a short
dive before sufficient control was
regained to again stall the airplane.
"When flown steadily just above
stalling speed, a slight disturbance often
caused the nose of the plane to swing,
usually toward the right. After stalling,
nothing could stop the tum and resultant
falling off until speed was picked up as
in the former case by a short dive ac-
companied by closing of the slot and
upward movement of the flaps."
AWARD OF THE PRIZE
It was expected that more than one
airplane would pass the Qualifying and
Safety Tests and that the award of the
first prize would depend upon points
made in comparative tests. Since only
one airplane reached the stage for award
of points, the comparative tests were not
conducted and the prize was awarded to
the Curtiss Tanager.
6 MARCH 1992
The Handley-Page passes by one of the observation towers during performance
testing. You can plainly see the deployed flaps and slats in this view.
BRITISH REACTION
In England there was some question
as to whether or not the Curtiss had won
the competition fairly. In fact, it was
suggested that without the Handley-
Page entry there would have been no
competition. The following editorial
comments were made by C. G. Grey,
Editor of THE AEROPLANE, taken
from the January 8, 1930 issue. "The
original rules certainly do seem to have
been stretched or varied very consider-
ably. One can quite understand that the
committee in charge of the competition
found themselves in a very difficult
positlon. Originally there were 20
entrants. The day before the last day
fixed on which competing machines
could arrive; the Handley-Page was the
only machine on the spot.
"Faced with the position that this
world advertised competition looked
---------------------
--- ----------
------------------------ - ---- --
-------------------------------
TABLE OF FINAL DATA
Mini- Landing Mini-
over Steepest Full Wing Power mum Take Flatt esr Maxi- Ilat e of mum
obstruc- Take off over glide Empty Useful load Rated load ing loading c1imo:lt hori- gliding Land- glide mum
(de- weight horse (Ibs. per ti o n off run obstacle (de- weight load speed 1000' zOlltal speed (Ibs'r,er n ~ run
(Ibs.) (eet) (feet) (feet) (feet) grees) (Ibs. ) (Ibs.) power sq. I. ) h.p.) (m .p.h. ) (m.p.h.) grees) (ft / min) speed
(m.p.h.)
. .. ,. 1,100 550 1,650 110 9.7 15.0 .... . . . .. . . . . .... ..... .. .. . . I. Alfaro ....... . . . . . 108.6 - . -. - · -
7.1 . . . . . . -,. 1,179 486 1,665 90 18.5 ... . . . . .... . . . .. . . . .. . . . .... . . 2. Bourdon. .. 103.3 - .. - . .
. . . . 451 1,656 90 6.5 18.1 . . . . ' . . . . 1,205 3. Brunner Winkl e . . 106.0
· -
Field b ut wi t hdrew 4. Burnelli .... red at Appea
170 .. . , .. . . . . . . . . 1,482 85 1 2,333 9.5 13.7 ..... . 5. Command-Aire. 114.8 900 46.0 .. " . . . - . .
· -
1,773 8.7 19.7 1,303 470 90 ...... 4 1.0 6. Cunningham.Hall . 94.2 44.0 . "
13.2 880 2,859 176 8.6 16.3 37.1 293 295 500 6 1,979 700 30.6 90 7. Curtiss .. 111.6
r--
500 1,600 90 8. 1 17.3 1,100 8. Fleet. .... . . . . .. . 108.6 610
575 2,125 115 7.3 . . -, . . . . . . . . . . .. 1,550 18.5 102.1 9. Ford-Leigh . . .. . . . . . -. - . . .
Field b lit wit hdrew 10. Gates .. .... Appea red at
12.8 2,156 155.6 7.4 11 2,4 82 320 290 440 7.2 1,378 77'0 13 .9 730 39.7 11. Handley-Page . ... . . . 33.4
r--
n Ri gh t hed in demon strat io Airpla ne eras 12. McDonnell . ... . . - .
13. Moth .. . .. . .... ... , red at Field b lit wit hdrew Appea
tn ary Ri ght Airpla ne eras hed in prelim 14. Schroeder-Wentworth ..
1,667 .. . ..... . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1, 197 470 90 9.5 18.5 45.5 50.1 15. Taylor . . ... .. ... .. . 108.5 . . .. .
like being a fiasco except for one
English entry, the committee evidently
relaxed the most essential rule, namely,
that if a machine was not ready in time,
it must be put out. Consequently a num-
ber of aeroplanes which arrived a few
days late were allowed to have a try at
the qualifying tests.
"Very soon the fact became evident
that the only two machines which had a
hope of passing the conditions of the
contest were the two machines with
slots, the Handley-Page and the Curtiss.
Between the two machines there was
the important difference that whereas
the flaps on the trailing edge of the
Handley-Page were interconnected
with the slots, and so worked automat-
ically, the flaps on the Curtiss were hand
operated.
"The result was that the Handley-
Page machine was set to do that part of
the stability test which, according to the
original rule, included diving the
machine and letting go of the controls to
prove that it would right itself, the slots
closed, the flaps went up and the wing
assumed a nonnal shape, so that the
machine passed the test. Under similar
circumstances, when the Curtiss
machine was diving, the slots closed but
the flaps remained down and the
machine became unstable.
"This would have put the Curtiss out
of competition altogether, and so ap-
parently, to prevent the competition
from shutting down forthwith, the com-
mittee altered the rule to read that after
diving the machine must right itself
without the controls being handled, -
except those operating the safety
devices.
"As there happened to be only one
entrant whom the rule could effect, the
alteration had the unfortunate look of
having been altered especially for the
benefit of the Curtiss entry, which
would otherwise have been put out of
the competition.
"Obviously unless these rules had
been altered, the competition would
have been a fiasco. Consequently the
committee of the Guggenheim Fund
have unhappily left themselves open to
the charge that they altered the rules to
make an American machine win. One
feels sure that the true reason for alter-
ing the rules was to save the competi-
tion, for such a magnificent prize from
being a complete fiasco, and so disclos-
ing the barren state of Aeronautical
Sciences all over the world so far as new
and original ideas for safe aircraft were
concerned. But one cannot help regret-
ting the weakness of character which
allowed such alterations merely to save
the face of Science."
HERITAGE
Slots, flaps and floating ailerons, fun-
damental changes in wing design which
received marked attention during the
Safe Aircraft Competition were con-
spicuous by their absence from produc-
tion aircraft during the 1930s. The
Curtiss Company considered adapting
its floating aileron to commerical
models but held up its plans.
Some designers considered the
devices as just so many gadgets that
needed maintenance to be kept in work-
ing order. Others felt they offered a
distinct aerodynamic advantage but that
the market was not ready.
The impact was so small that the use
of slots was remarked upon by Leighton
Collins in the July 1, 1939 issue of AIR
FACTS in his flight test of the Stinson
105 which used leading edge slots in
front of the ailerons. He remarked, "It
is hoped that whatever principal felt the
greatest disappointment as a result of
the barren ground on which the Guggen-
heim Contest apparently fell in 1929
may from this ship gain a renewed con-
fidence in the ability of mankind to ul-
timately return to the grove of progress
from our alternate diversions, and that
incenti ve even ahead of full comprehen-
sion is not wholly lost." .....
VINTAGE AIRPLANE 7
Aircraft Restoration
and
FAR 21.303
The preparation of this article was
coordinated with the office ofthe Aircraft
Maintenance Division of the Federal
A viation Administration. Our thanks to
the FAAfor helping us clear up what has
become a confusing issue for many res-
torers during the past year.
A little over a year ago, an article
appeared in Aircraft Technician mag-
azine written by an employee of the
FAA in Washington, D.C. The contents
of that short article dealing with the
restoration of an Aeronca Champ wing
spar has caused a number of airplane
restorers quite a bit of trouble, as they
found that the interpretation of FAR
21.303 had apparently been changed.
They were taken by surprise when the
FAA appeared to reverse a long stand-
ing approval policy, and would not
allow the restoration of a spar using
aircraft quality wood and the original
spar as a guide. As it turns out, FAA
management never intended to change
their policy. Within this article, we will
clear up the confusion regarding what
you can and cannot do during the res-
toration of your aircraft.
Within the FAR's, there are many
regulations concerning the maintenance
of a Type Certificated airplane, but to a
restorer, nothing is more important than
FAR 21.303. To refresh your memory,
here is the applicable text of that FAA
regulation:
FAR 21.303 Replacement and
Modification Parts
(a) Except as provided in paragraph
(b) of this section, no person may
produce a modification or replacement
part for sale for installation on a type
certificated product unless it is
produced pursuant to a Part Manufac-
turer Approval issued under this sub-
part.
(b) this section does not apply to the
following:
(1) Parts produced under a type or
production certificate.
S MARCH 1992
by H.G. Frautschy
(2) Parts produced by an owner or
operator for maintaining or altering
his own product. (Emphasis ours -
HGF)
The key part of that regulation is
paragraph b. Without exaggerating,
that paragraph is the rule that makes
possible the restoration of older aircraft.
Without this FAR, it would be very dif-
ficult, if not impossible, to make re-
placement parts for antique and classic
aircraft. When an aircraft is restored,
there are times when the engineering
data is simply not available, for a variety
of reasons - the company may not exist,
copies are not available from the FAA,
or the current type certificate holder
may not be willing to allow the drawing
to be released. (These days, the current
holder of the Type Certificate generally
will claim they are unwilling to release
the drawing based on product liability.)
An interesting sidebar must be ad-
dressed at this point concerning the cur-
rency of an available drawing. Unless
an AD has been issued against the par-
ticular part in question, the individual
restoring that part is obligated to use
only the blueprint and any added notes
that were in effect at the time his aircraft
was manufactured. It would seem a bit
ridiculous to require a part to reflect all
the subsequent changes made to a
fuselage structure, for instance, that
were required when the Vne of an
airplane was later increased by almost
28 %. If an AD was issued against that
part, then any changes required would
also have to be incorporated during the
part's restoration. It would also be pru-
dent to review any service letters from
the manufacturer that deal the the part
in question.
The writer of the above mentioned
article further defended his interpreta-
tion in a letter to EAA's Washington
Representative, Charlie Schuck. He
stated that a restorer of a 7 series Aeron-
ca could not replace his spars without
using a PMA'd part based on his belief
that there was no proof available to
determine that the restored spar was
equal to or better than the original, un-
less the part could be compared against
the manufacturer's blueprint, which at
that time was believed to be unavail-
able. FAR 43.13 requires that:
43.13 Performance rules (general)
(a) Each person perfonning main-
tenance, alteration, or preventive main-
tenance on an aircraft, engine, propeller
or appliance shall use the methods, tech-
niques, and practices prescribed in the
current manufacturer's maintenance
manual, or Instructions for Continued
Airworthiness prepared by its manufac-
turer, or other methods, techniques, and
practices acceptable to the ad-
ministrator, except as noted in FAR
43.16. (Authors note: Emphasis ours.
For our purposes, 43.16 has little if no
additional impact.) He shall use the
tools, equipment and test apparatus
necessary to assure completion of the
work in accordance with accepted in-
dustry practices. If special equipment
or test equipment or test apparatus is
recommended by the manufacturer in-
volved, he must use that equipment or
apparatus or its equivalent acceptable
to the Administrator.
(b) Each person maintaining or alter-
ing, or performing preventive main-
tenance, shall do that work in such a
manner and use materials of such
quality, that the condition of the aircraft,
airframe, aircraft engine, propeller, or
appliance worked on will be at least
equal to its original or properly altered
condition (with regard to aerodynamic
function, structural strength, resistance
to vibration and deterioration, and other
qualities affecting airworthiness).
If I haven't lost you yet, here is the
point of all this FAR quoting: if you, as
an owner/operator ofan airplane, decide
to make a replacement part for your
airplane, such as a wooden spar, using
FAR 21.303 as the basis, you must show
your AI that it has been made in a man-
ner equal to, or better than, the original
in a way that is "acceptable" to the
FAA in accordance with FAR 43.13.
That part of the FAR is the area that is
generating the problem. For more than
40 years, it has been acceptable for an
aircraft restorer to use the old original
wood spar of his airplane as the pattern
to make a new one out of aircraft quality
spruce. Stating on the Form 337 that the
old spar was used as a pattern, that the
spar was made from aircraft quality
spruce meeting "XYZ" Spec and that all
the old fittings were cleaned and in-
spected was, in the past, considered a
manner that is acceptable to the Ad-
ministrator. Regardless of the state-
ments made to the contrary in the past
year, it is still an acceptable method of
repairing a wooden sparred light
airplane, according to Larry Kephart,
Manager of the General Aviation and
Commercial Branch.
If you use material that is sold to you as
conforming to an accepted industry stand-
ard, say, for instance, a Military Specifica-
tion (Mil Spec) such as Mll..-S-6073, you
are under no further obligation to ensure
that the manufacturer or supplier has in-
deed complied with that specification. As
a matter ofpersonal information and in the
interest ofself-preservation, you will most
likely inspect your purchase as you do any
other part of your airframe, but you, as the
restorer, do not have to certify that the
product meets the Mil Spec, if it is so
identified. By using material that is
aircraft quality by virtue of it meeting an
accepted industry standard, you have met
the major criteria for your part to be ap-
proved for a return to service by your AI.
Remember, however, that no one
without a PMA can supply an individual
with a piece of wood described as a
"Spar". Unless the item was manufac-
tured under a PMA, you simply have a
piece of wood with which you may be
able to restore your spar. Also, unless it
is identified as meeting the Mil Spec for
wood, it is not even a piece of wood that
you can legally use on a Type Certifi-
cated airplane. Unless that airplane is
maintained with materials that conform
to the FAR's, its Airworthiness Certifi-
cate is in jeopardy.
By replacing the damaged spar, you
have executed a major repair, so your AI
must approve the repair, and he will
need to know that the material was
aircraft quality (it should be identified
on the material itself and on your in-
voice), and what criteria was used to
restore the part, i.e. original factory
drawings, the original part, and any
other supporting documentation. It
should be noted that one of the tests in
question, a "Brashness Test" (a test
determining the toughness of a sample
of wood), is currently included as a re-
quirement within MIL Spec MIL-S-
6073. (MIL-S-6073 superceded
AN-S-6 in 1950.) This test is called out
in later Champion specifications
detailed on the Champion, but not
Aeronca prints of the same part.
Supporting documentation can take a
variety of forms, including the original
part. Needless to say, the nature of the
part will determine if it can be safely
reproduced. It does not seem likely, for
instance, that anyone, even someone with
the knowledge, is going to be sandcasting
a new crankcase for his or her 65 horse-
power Continental. But based on the track
record of aircraft restorers for the past 40
or more years, it does not appear to be
unreasonable to expect that a new rudder,
or a new elevator, could be constructed
using the old one as a pattern, using the
same materials as the original as defmed
in the maintenance manual. The same can
be said for the wooden spar of an older
airplane. This type of repair has been
safely done on light airplanes for many,
many years. No one is going to be more
concerned with the safety of his or her
own airplane more than an aircraft re-
storer, and his or her expertise coupled
with the knowledge of his or her AI has,
for a number of years, been sufficient to
ensure the safe reconstruction of these
older airplanes. Many of these airplanes
were hand-built, necessitating the in-
dividual fitting of an elevator, for in-
stance, to a stabilizer. Certainly, as
production methods became more sophis-
ticated, parts were made that fit better and
allowed interchangeability, but the basic
fact that a human craftsman produced the
part has not changed for over a generation.
(Many may argue that only very recently
has that method begun to give way to
automation in light aircraft production.)
The FAA publishes a number of helpful
books on the subject, and one is con-
sidered one of the more comprehensive
manuals on the subject. Advisory Cir-
cular 43. 13-1A and -2A, Acceptable
Methods, Techniques, and Practices -
Aircraft Inspection and Repair was just
updated and reissued within the past
couple of years, and it contains a wealth
of acceptable methods to maintain your
airplane.
One additional item should be
clarified. It is not legal for an A&P or
an AI to manufacture a part and then sell
it to you for use on your plane - that
would violate the FAR governing the
issuing of Parts Manufacturing Ap-
proval. Paragraph (b) of FAR 21.303
was put in place to allow the restoration
of an airplane, but not as a method to
allow individual A&P's or AI's to cir-
cumvent the rules governing PMA's.
An A&P or AI can, however, supervise
the work done by a owner/operator
during the reconstruction of a part.
Remember that if the work constitutes a
major repair, a Form 337 must be
produced and signed off by an AI.
There have also been questions con-
cerning the "legality" of a part
reproduced in this manner. In the past,
the statement has been made that a part
made this way is a "bogus" part. A
bogus part is one the origin of which
cannot be traced, or is not made in ac-
cordance with the FAR's. Since the
construction and installation of the part
would have to be approved by an AI,
and then subsequently by the FAA if a
Form 337 was required, the part would
then be an approved part for installation
on that particular model and serial
number aircraft. The approval would
not extend to any other aircraft of that
model in the same manner as a PMA,
since it is a one time approval, but other
restorers could use the same informa-
tion to present to their AI for an ap-
proval of a similar installation.
To put all this in perspective, it should
be pointed out that the ability to restore
our aircraft using FAR 21.303 as the
basis for restoring a part is a right that
should be guarded by not abusing the
rule. By carefully producing a part for
your own airplane, and following ap-
propriate FAA and industry standards,
it seems reasonable that many parts for
your airplane can be safely restored.
Remember that in the first place, these
components were created by craftsmen
and are made up with few complicated,
difficult to manufacture parts. Be care-
ful though. It should be obvious which
parts are not appropriate to attempt a
recreation of. Most, if not all restorers,
would not give serious thought to
reproducing an engine part, for in-
stance. Using good judgment and tap-
ping the expertise of the FAA books,
suchasAC43.13-1Aand-2A will make
it possible to maintain an older airplane
in excellent condition, and FAR 21.303
allows us to use our collective
capabilities to properly restore a part to
better than new condition. ...
VINTAGE AIRPLANE 9
nd an Georg
by H.G. Frautschy and
Mary Jones,
NBA Executive Director
When George Bush was elected President in 1988, he became the second U.S.
President to have been an airplane pilot. (Dwight Eisenhower has the distinction
of being the first president to hold a civilian Private Pilot license.) Inspired by
an article published in the "Naval Aviation Museum Foundation" magazine,
the National Biplane Association began a search for aircraft flown by the
President during his first days as a Naval A viator. Six of the airplanes flown by
Mr. Bush have been located by the newly-retired Executive Director of the NBA,
Mary Jones. Our thanks to her and NBA's Charlie Harris for providing the
photos and material for this article.
George Bush began his days as a WW
II Naval A viatior training with primary
training at NAS Minneapolis. As luck
(and some would say bad timing!)
would have it, he began his training in
the late fall of 1943, which meant he
flew throughout most of the winter of
1943-44. That must have been a chill-
ing experience for anybody involved in
flight training in open cockpit biplanes
at that time!
The National Biplane Association
has located 6 of the biplanes that the
President flew, 5 Stearmans and 1 N3N-
3. The N3N was flown on a short flight
by Mr. Bush during his advanced train-
ing in the SNJ, and is currently owned
by Dr. Richard Schmidt and his wife
Debbie of Del Mar, California. Dr.
Schmidt has all the logs to his airplane
since it left the Naval Aircraft Factory
in 1941. Two years later, George Bush
and a Lt. Hammer flew the N3N for a
short twenty minute flight.
Before he flew the N3N, though,
Bush flew a succession of Stearmans
and Spartans. He flew his first seven
hops in an NP-l Spartan, and one flight
in an N2S-3 Stearman. After a presolo
check by another instructor, J.A. Boyle,
he was signed off for solo with the fol-
lowing comments:
"Satisfactory check. Taxied a little
fast. Landings were average to above
with the exception of one almost ground
loop. Safe for solo." With that, on
November 21, 1943, Bush soloed in an
NP-l Spartan, a total of 11.8 hours in his
logbook.
Later, most of his training would take
place in Stearmans. 33 different N2S's
10 MARCH 1992
were flown prior to his successful com-
pletion of primary training after 82.5
hours, with 61 flights under his belt.
Enter the National Biplane
Association's Mary Jones. A biplane
owner herself, (she owns and flies an
N3N), she began searching for the
planes that Bush had flown during that
time. A notice was put in the NBA's
"Biplane News", and within a few
weeks, C.J. Alexander of Phoenix, AZ
gave her a call. "I think I found one of
Bush's biplanes" was the opening Mary
had been looking for. It would not be a
quick reference to the FAA register that
would confirm it, though. The Navy
assigned its own serial numbers to their
airplanes, even though the manufacturer
had also given the plane its serial num-
ber. Fortunately, Ken Wilson, the
Stearman Restorer's Association his-
torian, had published a cross reference
list in the SRA "Outfit" Newsletter that
included both the Navy Bureau number
and the manufacturer's serial number.
With additional help from the FAA
Aircraft Registry office in Oklahoma
City, the National Biplane Associations
computer database, and Larry Wilson of
the National Air and Space Museum in
Washington, five biplanes flown by the
President were found listed on the cur-
rent register. Here they are:
N2S-3, N75032, Serial No. 75-6543,
Navy Bureau No. 05369. Currently
owned by retired TWA Captain John W.
"Jack" Parker of Essex, CT, the Stear-
man is flown all over the Northeast at-
tending airshows.
N2S-3, N1222N, Serial No. 75-
6782, Navy Bureau No. 05369 has
been owned by the same individual
«
co
z
>-
.,
o
"
U
As Air Force One taxis in at Springfield Regional Airport, Dave Coursaut and his
Stearman wait for the President's arrival .
President Bush looks over the Stearman
he flew during his training in 1943. "It
brings back a lot of cold memories ... I
flew it in Minnesota in January!" Mr. Bush
recalled. Later, he signed a copy of the
airplanes logbook with the notation "49
years later".
since 1946 - Charles Henderson of Junc-
tion City, OR. John has over 10,000
hours in that particular airplane per-
forming crop-dusting. The airplane has
been in storage since 1968, and he has
no definite plans concerning restoration
of it at this time.
N2S-1, N50061, Serial No. 75-1124,
Navy Bureau No. 3347 is owned by
Robert Hood of Carthage, MO.
N2S-3, N75032, Serial No. 75-6543,
Navy Bureau No. 05369 is owned by
Robert Meyland of Orlando, FL.
And finally, N2S-2, N54896, Serial
No. 75-1332, Navy Bureau No. 3555 is
owned and flown by Norman "Dave"
Corsaut of Greenfield, MO. A duster
after the war years, Norman purchased
the Stearman in 1983. Restored to the
Standard Category, it still has the 450 hp
Pratt & Whitney engine that powered it
during its duster days. He was still in
the process of doing the cosmetic res-
toration when he learned that he owned
an airplane flown by the President. He
was quite thrilled by that fact, but soon,
he was to be surprised with the news that
the President was stopping for a brief
visit in the Ozarks, and Dave and the
Stearman were to be part of his
stopover. Arranged by the Air &
Military Museum of the Ozarks and a
local Confederate Air Force chapter, the
meeting took place over this past 4th of
July at the Springfield Regional Air-
port. For fifteen minutes, Dave and the
President visited, and Mr. Bush was
delighted to see an old military acquain-
tance in the form of the Stearman, 49
years later. As he climbed up onto the
wing, the President said, "It brings back
a lot of cold memories . . I flew it in
Minnesota in January." After Dave ex-
c:
o
g
..
..
«
plained how the search for the biplanes
flown by the President had been pur-
sued, Mr. Bush was pleasantly surprised
when Dave produced a copy of the
Stearman's flight log signed by the
President. Mr. Bush then autographed
a copy of the NBA newsletter. He also
signed off the log copy with the notation
"49 years later".
If any of our readers have found that
their Stearman has been flown by the
President, please contact the National
Biplane Association, Jones/Riverside
Airport, Tulsa, OK 74132. I'm sure
they'd like to hear from you . ......
VINTAGE AIRPLANE 11
.. ~ ~
!jill And Clair-e
by Nann Petersen
This is a story of a 22-year love affair
- not with a woman, but with an
airplane! The man is William (Bill)
Nutting (EAA 54248, AIC 283) of Pres-
cott, Arizona, and the airplane is Waco
SRE, NC1252W, SIN 5153 . The
woman in his life is Bill's lovely wife of
43 years, Claire, a true airplane
aficionado, just like her husband.
This air-minded couple brought their
beautiful yellow and black Waco E-
model cabin to EAA Oshkosh '91 to
complete a trip that had its actual begin-
nings in 1988! Perhaps justice
was admirably served when t h e ~
SRE garnered the Outstanding Closed
Cockpit Biplane Award during the final
evening awards program at the Theater
In The Woods. The story behind this
well deserved award goes back many
years.
Bill and Claire grew up together in
River Forest, IL, attending the same
high school, same family gatherings and
they even had the same dentist! Out of
high school, Bill went into Army Air
Corps cadet training and Claire went off
to Colorado University. With the end of
WW II, Bill entered Colgate University
for two years and then transfered to
Colorado U. He and Claire were mar-
ried in 1948 and Bill received his BA
degree in Business Adminstration In
1950 from Colorado University.
12 MARCH 1992
Their first move was to the San Fran-
cisco Bay area where Bill worked for
Rheem Manufacturing. In 1953, they
bought their first airplane, a 125 Swift
that had landed on its belly and needed
a great deal of work. In two years it was
flying and Bill was back in the air. He
had originally soloed a J-3 Cub back in
1945, so it was good to return to the wild
blue yonder.
Next on the agenda was a single-
place Mooney M18L "Mite", that Bill
enjoyed for a time before buying a
Mooney M20C (N6525U), which be-
Bill Nutting and his bride Claire share a
moment with their Waco SRE.
came the family "hack" for trips up and
down the west coast and into Mexico.
The three children were small enough to
fit into the rear seat and still remain
below gross weight. Claire took the
well-known "pinch hitter" course in this
Mooney so she could land it in case of
emergency. Both have many fond
memories of this airplane and the many
excursIOns.
Other aircraft owned by the Nutting
family included a twin-engine
Cessna Skymaster (business pur-
poses), a Lake amphibian (amphibious
instruction) and a Slingsby Dart (single-
place sailplane). These varied types give us
a good insight into the unusual abilites
and varied interests of Bill Nutting.
A 1969 "For Sale" ad in Trade-A-
Plane for a basket case Waco SRE
brought Bill to Santee, SC where he met
Jack and Golda Cox (EAA's Sport
A viation team), who were working for
Wings & Wheels Museum owned by
Dolph Overton. After purchase, the
huge cabin biplane was carefully loaded
into a U-Haul truck - except the missing
engine, instruments, panel, flap actuator
and other small items. Bill Nutting and
his son, Craig, drove the truck from
Camden, SC to California. (The entire
story of this episode was written by Jack
Cox in the May, 1972 issue of SPORT
AVIATION.)
Working feverishly over the next two
years with Andy Anderson and Doc
Savage helping, the big Waco was to-
tally restored including new upper
wings, fuel tanks, a newly rebuilt Pratt
& Whitney R-985 engine and a
Ham/Standard propeller. The finish
was Ceconite fabric and butyrate dope,
done in bright yellow with black trim as
per the factory original paint scheme.
The interior was done by a specialty
shop in Cupertino, CA, and has lasted
for twenty years. Meanwhile, Bill
joined EAA in March of 1970 while
living in Menlo Park, CA.
About this time, a young man ap-
proached Bill Nutting with the idea of a
coin-operated TV screen game .
Together, they started "Nutting and As-
sociates" and went into the video game
business. For two years, the business
went wild. The young partner then
broke off to form his own company
called Atari! Bill promptly sold out and
retired.
Moving to Reno, Nevada in 1977, he
began flying aircraft charter, which led
to the next episode. While returning
(empty) to Reno late at night with a
Cessna 210, Bill had the misfortune of
having the engine quit cold! Attempts
at restarting were all for naught, so he
was forced to make a belly landing in
the dark - come what may! The plane
came down hard in the Yerington,
Nevada, city dump! Bill was badly
banged up with head and facial injuries
plus two broken ankles. In this condi-
tion, he walked two miles to a farm
house to summon help. He told the
officers the plane had crashed about 300
yards away, however, they could not
locate the wreckage. Only when they
walked over two miles did they fmd it!
After spending time getting all the
bones set in the hospital, Bill was on
crutches for several weeks before he
could get around properly. Three
months later, he was back flying charter
again! However, the accident had
started Bill and Claire thinking about
their purposes in life, so they flew to
Redlands, California to explore the Mis-
sionary Aviation Fellowship (MAF)
and its worldwide program. They spent
a year learning the administrative end of
the business and were assigned to the
MAF in Nairobi, Kenya, as ad-
ministrators from 1981 to 1985. Both
Bill and Claire admit this was a fascinat-
ing and extremely worthwhile ex-
perience for both of them.
In October, 1982, while on vacation
from their African assignment, Bill was
flying the SRE with his son, Craig, out
of the Redlands, CA airport. The dried
seals had allowed oil to leak onto the
windshield and the active runway was
directly into the sun. Bill brought the
big cabin Waco in for a landing with
forward visibility almost nil. The slight
.>< crosswind caused the airplane to drift
sideways, just off the runway. At
Q.
8 touchdown, the left gear caught in a hole
:.:
E which sheared the gear off the airplane.
=; The right gear went next and the SRE
went sliding down the runway apron on
its belly! Both lower wings were
wrecked along with the propeller. It
was not a good day.
The Waco was stored in a hangar
until Bill and Claire would return from
Africa in 1985, their assignment com-
pleted. The restoration was (again)
started at Redlands airport with Mike
Snow doing the critical fuselage and
landing gear welding. (Bill speaks very
highly of Mike Snow and his welding
ability.) In 1986, Bill and Claire moved
to Prescott, Arizona, bringing the big
Waco project with them. Parts went
from their garage, to a shop and finally,
to a hangar at the airport (which they
were very fortunate to obtain.)
It was during this rebuild that Waco
HRE rebuilder, John Rice, of Spicer,
Minnesota (see March 1985 SPORT
VINTAGE AIRPLANE 13
A VIA nON) contributed the necessary
blueprints which were needed for the
job at hand. In addition, John helped in
many areas of the rebuild with timely
suggestions from his own I5 -year
rebuild experience - a service which
John and his lovely wife, Mary Jane,
cheerfully provided.
The engine crankshaft checked out
OK, so a new propeller was installed
and the airplane was covered in Stits
Poly dope fmish with the final colors
done in Stits Aerothane - again bright
yellow with black trim. The fuselage
was done in Stits D-I03 cloth and the
plywood wings were covered with Stits
HS-90X lightweight cloth. The final
14 MARCH 1992
finish on the Waco came out to a bril-
liant shine including the fiberglass
wheel pants, which were made by Miller
in Colorado. The "N" struts are not
identical nor were they marked, so Bill
guessed as to where they went. The
plane flew hands off, so he must have
guessed correctly!
The original Hayes wheels with ex-
pander tubes have been replaced by
1957 Cessna 310 wheels and brakes.
They bolt into position and work with
absolute authority according to Bill.
The SRE has a dual control yoke with
brake pedals on the left side only. The
righthand rudder pedals fold down when
not in use, competely out of the way.
One of the classiest Wacos
ever built, the Waco SRE is
elegant from every angle.
Ready to fly to the big EAA Conven-
tion in 1989, this author made arrange-
ments for Bill and Claire to stay with
Bill and Ellen Lewis in Oshkosh, WI,
knowing the two couples were close to
the same age. Further investigation
revealed the two couples were married
on the very same day!
Then the roof fell in! Bill Nutting
suffered a heart attack and was unable
to fly. The '89 trip was cancelled and
rumors were floating around that the
SRE was for sale. The future was, no
doubt, bleak.
Not one to sit around and mope, Bill
Nutting began an intense period of body
rebuilding with the aid of his doctors,
who quite frankly marveled at the stub-
bornness of this would-be pilot. Lucki-
ly, the heart attack was tempered by
Bill's excellent physical shape from ten-
nis and golf, but best of all - he had quit
smoking some ten years previous! The
doctors told him flat out that this saved
his life! Eventually, his third class
physical was reinstated (with a yearly
stress test) and preparations were made
to attend the 1991 Oshkosh Fly-In.
In late June of '91, Bill and Claire
flew the SRE from Arizona to Ohio to
attend the annual Waco Fly-In with all
its historical pomp and circumstance.
They readily admit it was a really fme
experience and they met both old and
new friends. From Ohio, the SRE was
flown to Oshkosh and placed in Dave
Jameson's hangar until the time came
for the EAA Fly-In. (Blessings on you,
Dave Jameson). Meanwhile, Bill and
Claire toured northern Wisconsin and
saw country they really enjoyed before
returning to the Heidel House at Green
Lake, WI for the duration of the conven-
tion.
During the fly-in, Bill and Claire
filled in the many details on the Waco
as it quietly posed among the many
beautiful antique airplanes on Wittman
Field. NC1252W was built in Septem-
ber 1941 as an HRE (Lycoming R-680
engine) and was subsequently con-
verted to an SRE with the R-985 engine
in 1946. There are presently four SRE
Wacos on the FAA register with a fifth
basket case in California. Only three
are flying out of the approximately 25
that were built in the pre-war period.
The normal cruise is 175 mph burning
20/21 gallons per hour of 80 octane fuel.
Bill also burns lOOLL when 80 is not
available. To date, the Waco has about
920 hours on the airframe and just over
100 hours on the engine. (This is a
lowtime airplane for 50 years of age!)
One sad note was when Bill and
Claire were invited for dirmer with Bill
Lewis of Oshkosh, they learned that Bill
Lewis' wife, Ellen, had passed away the
previous November, so they were un-
able to celebrate their mutual wedding
day with all four participants. How-
ever, the threesome had a most enjoy-
able time discussing the last 43 years!
With their oldest son, Craig, now a
Captain for American Airlines, perhaps
there is hope the magnificent yellow and
black Waco SRE will always be in good
caring hands, such as Bill and Claire
have given her during the past 22 years.
Long live the marque! ......
VINTAGE AIRPLANE 15
Not if Jim Minor and the Continental
Airlines Historical Society have their
way! After the DC-3s were retired, the
President and CEO of Continental, Joe
D. Corr, called Jim Minor and asked if
he would like to see something good
happen to the airplanes. Mr. Corr felt
that a project like the DC-3 would be an
effective way to bring together and unite
all the various organizations that had
become Continental Airlines. As an
FAA DC-3 designated examiner with
over 7,500 hours in the type, Jim cer-
tainly was qualified to fly a -3, but more
than just technical expertise would be
required to meet the challenge of restor-
ing and maintaining the airliner. After
Corr's inquiry, Jim went to meet with
company officials. He had no idea that
he would become the nucleus of the
organization, but he was their man, so
off he went to pick out three DC-3s as
possible subjects for restoration to the
Continental configuration. While he
was down there, two of the three he
chose were sold, so he wound up with
his third choice, NC25673. Manufac-
tured in 1940 by Douglas in Santa
Monica, it was delivered to American
Airlines and designated as Fleet Num-
ber 73. In honor of one of the cities it
served, the silver with orange and blue
trimmed Douglas was christened the
Flagship "Big Springs". After a stint
with the U.S. Army from 1942 to 1945,
the DC-3 was returned to American,
who stored the Flagship until November
24, 1947, when it was sold to a small
start-up feeder airline then known as
Trans-Texas Airlines. Jim Minor re-
lated an interesting story concerning
airline operations in those days. When
Trans-Texas started after the Second
World War, to support its growing fleet
of DC-3's, it purchased 200 Pratt &
Whitney R-1830s surplus from the War
Assets Administration, and stored them
at their San Angelo, Texas maintenance
base. Originally intended for installa-
tion on B-24s, many were still in the
shipping cans, having never been in-
stalled on an airplane. During the years
to follow, whenever a Trans-Texas DC-
3 needed an engine change, one of the
new engines was bolted on, and away it
went. When Minor started flying for
Trans-Texas in 1959, he estimates they
still had at least 100 of the "new"
surplus engines left!
It took 22 years before the -3' s would
be considered too costly to operate on
the routes TTA was flying. The jet age
had long since arrived, and smaller jets
18 MARCH 1992
Preparing to depart on the photo mission during EAA Oshkosh '91, Tim Ruhl checks the
area around the right side of the Douglas prior to starting the No. 2 engine.
sized to the TTA route structure were
available. TTA (later Texas Interna-
tional Airlines, TIA) would fly 01' num-
ber 73 until its sale to an aircraft broker
in 1969. It would not fly again until 1975,
when it was added to the ProvincetownjBos-
ton Airlines (PBA) fleet. It then was
re-registered first as N130PB, and later
as N30PB. As the continuing shake-up
of the airline industry evolved, the air-
liner would eventually become the
property of Continental Airlines when it
acquired the merged PBAfBar Harbor
Airlines. Finally, it came to the Con-
tinental Airlines Historical Society in
1989.
What is the Continental Airlines His-
torical Society? A big group (over 300
now) of energetic and capable volun-
teers, that's what! After selecting the
Douglas to be restored, Jim Minor set
out to get some help putting the old
airliner back in the air. With a $5,000
donation from Continental Airlines as
seed money, the DC-3 was put back into
basic flight condition. It needed some
engine work and a new tail wheel (the
old one had been broken oft) but it was
soon airworthy and ferried from storage
in Florida to Houston's Hobby airport.
The exterior was stripped in New Iberia
and after some sheet metal replacement
and other structural fixes were made, a
new paint job was applied to match the
livery of Continental Airlines as they
flew them in the 1950s. It would be a
year before the silver and white Douglas
would fly again. That year was spent
dedicating an enormous amount of
volunteer time to restoring the Douglas
airliner to show condition, a process that
continues whenever time and resources
can be brought together.
It was then on to the interior, also
done in the style of the 1950s. All sorts
of other mechanical work had to be done
to the airplane, including one of the
more unusual items to be replaced. All
the Hamilton Standard propeller blades
had to be changed - the ones on the
aircraft had simply worn too thin!
Many times the work was performed
by the same mechanics who had worked
on the airliner when it was in scheduled
service. Both currently employed and
retired Continental personnel work on
the airplane, and many of them worked
on Number 73 when it was part of the
Trans-Texas fleet. Often a call for help
only has to hit the floor at the Con-
tinental Maintenance Base, and the
technical expertise to solve the problem
is available.
When we saw the DC-3 during EAA
Oshkosh '91, we were greeted by one
other lovely addition to the cabin, also
decked out in 1950's airlines fashion-
Sherrill Dickey, a current Continental
Airlines Flight Attendant! (She also
happens to be Captain Minor's wife!)
Sherrill shares the enthusiasm of the
crew who brought the DC-3 to the Con-
vention, and really enjoys sharing the
history of the airliner with the throngs
of admirers who climb the stairs to
glimpse into the cabin. She also under-
took the task of training current line
flight attendants to crew the airplane,
and also would retrain members of
Continental's "Golden Penguin" club to
work the airliner. The Golden Pen-
quins? That's the association of retired
flight attendants from the airline. (Pen-
guins can't fly, remember?) Many have
enjoyed crewing the plane for company
functions, and Sherrill has thoroughly
enjoyed hearing about how it was to fly
the line so many years ago.
When you look forward in the cabin,
what you will see is the result of
thousands of man-hours of reconstruc-
tion and restoration by the volunteers.
As Jim and his No. 1 Captain, Tim Ruhl,
walked me around the airplane, the
amount of work that had to be done was
staggering! Just polishing all that bare
aluminum must be an arm-aching,
messy job, but the results are worth it.
Later, in the cockpit, Jim Minor
talked about the work put in by the many
After participating in the Transport aircraft
fly-by during EAA Oshkosh '90, Tim Ruhl
and Jim Minor taxi in with the big Douglas.
Jim says it was one of the greatest thrills in
his aviation career to participate in the
world's largest airshow.
volunteers, and the efforts of one man in
particular, Tim Ruhl. "Tim's done
more work on this airplane than any
other pilot, and that is why he is my
number 1 Captain." Tim and Jim have
known and flown with each other for a
number of years - when Jim moved up
to Captain in 1964, he was assigned a
new co-pilot, Tim Ruhl. They put a lot
of time on -3's in the years that fol-
lowed, and the years of working
together show. When it's time to fly,
they communicate with a series of hand
gestures and finger movements that
have been honed by years of non-verbal
expression in a noisy cockpit. I'm not
so sure that if you clamped a pair of
noise-cancelling headsets on their heads
and plugged them into an intercom, that
they would quite know what to say to
one another when flying the Douglas!
Both are now senior Captains for Con-
tinental, Jim flying intercontinental
routes with the DC-lO, and Tim flying
transcontinental flights with the A-300
Airbus.
One of the ways that Continental sup-
ported the Historical Society in the past
was to carry the DC-3 operation on the
company insurance policy, with the
stipulation that 1 regular line pilot be in
the cockpit (he is, of course, type rated
in the DC-3). The crew normally con-
sists of two Continental pilots. Another
of the Captains on the volunteer staff is
retired DC-3 Captain Norman Mc-
Gowan. All the pilots must go through
VINTAGE AIRPLANE 19
!
a.
"
.t:
jl
o
u
Cruising serenely over the east side of Lake Winnebago, the Continental Airlines Historical Society's Douglas DC-3 reminds us all of
the days when point-to-point transportation was done at an altitude when you could still make out the cars on the highways and
the cows in the barnyard.
DC-3 school.
Both Tim and Jim look forward to a
restoration of the cockpit, but don't look
for a major revision to the layout or
design - they like it pretty much the way
it is, and I agree. When you climb into
the cockpit, you're immediately com-
fortable. Oh sure, there's a hydraulic
fluid drop here, and a bit of chipped
paint there, but this isn't a fresh new
automobile, it's a DC-3, an airliner, a
working machine. You step back a few
years, when it might have been the place
to hang your new hat with three stripes,
waiting for the man with the four stripes
on his sleeve sitting in the left seat to
give you that shot at landing the big
taildragger. You can sense the aura that
new co-pilots must have felt when they
were assigned to their first airplane after
graduation from ground school. In-
timidating but comfortable, all at the
same time. You just knew you'd like
this plane.
Captains Ruhl and Minor are no
strangers to the EAA, having been avid
supporters for a number of years. In
addition to the DC-3, Jim flies a Piper
Cub and a PT-13 for more aerial recrea-
tion. He is quite grateful for the support
the EAA has given the Continental Air-
lines Historical Society during the Con-
vention - "We're a pretty poor
organization, and it takes a lot of sales
of T-shirts and a lot of hats to keep this
thing going. Tom Poberezny was very
20 MARCH 1992
helpful in allowing us to sell these
things under the wing of the airplane,
which made it possible to bring it up
here," Tim said.
Other organizations have helped the
Society with their bills, including a
generous donation of 20,000 gallons of
fuel from the British Petroleum com-
pany. The Society also enjoys strong
support from the highest levels within
Continental Airlines, although financial
support from the airline has had to be
curtailed in recent months as Continen-
tal struggles with the aspects of Chapter
11 bankruptcy. N25673 spent the winter
months at the Lone Star Aviation
Museum in Galveston, Texas, resting in
comfort as the next airshow season ap-
proaches. It is hoped that this summer
the shiny Douglas airliner will again
visit many airshows, as well as make
appearances on behalf of Continental
Airlines.
What's new on the horizon for the
Society? How about the restoration of
the documented highest time aircraft in
the world, N 18121, (formerly
N136PB)? This aircraft also served
with PBA, and has held the distinction
of being the highest time aircraft in the
world for a number of years. it now
shows a total of 91,355 hours in the
logbook, the equivalent of 10 1/2 years
in the air! (Readers may remember the
DC-3 of North Central Airlines, No.
728, that had a total of 83,454 hours
when it was donated to the Ford
Museum in 1975.)
The Society has again been allowed
to lease the DC-3 from the parent com-
pany for a meager amount of cash
(how's a buck a year grab you?), and the
ex-Eastern Airlines aircraft will soon be
leaving New Iberia to be tackled by a
crew of enthusiastic volunteers.
Will we see the Continental DC-3
again at Oshkosh? If Jim Minor and
Tim Ruhl can make it happen, you can
bet that they will be there. Perhaps Jim
will be able to visit Oshkosh with his
two sons, Mark and Cris. Both are
pilots for USAir, Mark the Captain of a
DC-9 and Chris a First Officer of a
737-400. Jim's face lit up as he said
"I've been an airline pilot for 32 years,
and never in my life did I think that I
would be an airshow participant in the
largest airshow in the world ... we felt
the greatest joy in all of us!" I'll bet if
they can, we will all get to hear the
rumble of those 1830's again. I can't
wait! ......
If you would like to know more
about the Continental Airlines His-
torical Society, contact them at :
Continental Airlines
Historical Society
c/o Captain Jim Minor
4123 Hockaday Dr.
Dallas, TX 75229
Fuel Tank Testing
By Bruce Patten
EAA37956
RFD 2 Box 2980
Oakland, ME 04963
While attempting to pressure test my
Taylorcraft wing tanks, I was unable to
find a filler cap that would seal airtight.
My solution was to install a surgical
glove secured with a rubber band over
the filler neck, rather than pressurize
the tank through the outlet. The fitting
shown here is a device I had made
previously for blowing down
automobile cylinders. (The pressure
gauge you see on Bruce's fitting is not
absolutely necessary when using the
glove.-HGF) The key part of it is a
tire valve brazed to a pipe bushing.
The surgical glove is a cheap substitute
for a difficult-to-find sensitive pressure
gauge, and provides a very visible
indication at the low pressure necessary
to prevent damage to the tank. (2 to 3
psi is all that is needed to leak check a
tank - any more and you risk deforming
it. - HGF) seams by brushing on soapy water and
This system holds pressure for ample looking for bubbles. In fact, it is tight
time to throughly inspect the tank enough that the glove will deflate when
the workshop cools down at night, and
reinflate itself when the woodstove is
stoked up the next morning.
Readers are invited to submit entries to EAA, Hints For Homebuilders, Att: Golda Cox, EAA Aviation Center, P.O. Box
3086, Oshkosh, WI 54903-3086. Entries will be reviewed by a panel of EAA judges. Readers whose hints are published in
any EAA magazine will be awarded one of three monthly prizes by Snap-on Tools - a 3/S" Drive Socket Wrench Set, a
114" Drive Socket Wrench Set or a
Nine-piece Long-Handle Com-
bination Wrench Set. Members are
also invited to submit hints of an
electrical nature. Any electrical
hint used will receive a Fluke
Model 23-2 Multimeter with Holster
from the John Fluke Mfg. Co., Inc.
The contest will run from August
through July of each year with a
Grand Prize of a Snap-on Tools
KR657 Roll Cab and KR637 Top
Chest being awarded the best
entry for the year. A Grand Prize
will also be awarded by the John
Fluke Mfg. Co. These awards will
be presented during the EAA
Convention. Our thanks go to
Snap-on Tools and John Fluke
Mfg. Co. for providing these
awards.
VINTAGE AIRPLANE 21
WI-tAT ()UI2
by Veter§en
Dr. Ed Garber's Fairchild 22 C7B
A recent addition to the flyable ranks
of antique airplanes is this 1932 Fair-
child 22 C7B, NC12670, SIN 1500, res-
tored by Dr. Ed Garber (EAA 38078,
A/C 162) of Fayetteville, NC. Finished
in an original paint scheme of Bermuda
Tan and brown, the parasol Fairchild
features full length ailerons, 6:50 X 10
wheels with mechanical brakes and a
Menasco D4-87 engine of 134 hp pull-
ing a wooden Sensenich propeller. Dr.
Garber reports the project required eight
years (on and off) to complete and the
entire cover job was done in Stits
Polydope and Aerothane.
NC12670 was the factory prototype
C7B with a Menasco C-4 engine of 125
hp, the first of nine manufactured.
There are five remaining on the FAA
register. This airplane had been con-
verted to a 145 Warner engine and was
being flown by (a young) Jim Franklin,
who had the wing break loose in a roll.
He had to bailout of the cockpit, and the
resulting crash left few good pieces from
which to commence the rebuild. How-
John Frisbie's Cessna 120 on floats
A most unusual combination is this
highly polished Cessna 120, N73034,
SIN 10242, mounted on a set of polished
Edo 1400 floats and flown by FAA
Seaplane Examiner John Frisbie (EAA
109724, A/C 2934) of Round Lake
Seaplane Base at Hayward, Wisconsin.
Discovered at Sky Harbor Airport on
Duluth's Minnesota Point, the airplane
was sitting on a floatplane dolly that
John wanted to buy. When offered "the
dolly and everything on it", John bought
the whole works, which included a set
of skis!
The Cessna 120 apparently came
with a float kit installed and had been
flying in Minnesota for over 20 years on
Edo 1400 floats. Being somewhat
lighter than a 140 Cessna (no flaps, no
fancy interior, etc.), the 120 gets off the
water nearly as fast as a J-3 Cub, yet
cruises about 7-10 mph faster. It has a
C90-12 engine with only the starter.
John uses a trickle charger to bring up
the battery, which is good for many
22 MARCH 1992
ever, Dr. Garber, along with the help of ber reports the Fairchild is a most
his good friend, Giff Gillingham, stub- delightful flying airplane, light on the
bornly persisted for the eight year span controls and well worth every minute of
it took to complete the rebuild. Dr. Gar- the rebuild time.
starts. The Cessna is used for float and renter's insurance. The polishing is
training ($85/hr) and is available for done with Rolite polish and makes for a
rental after proper checkout ($60/hr) very nice looking combination.
"Dobby" Licktieg's Piper Super
Cub "lOS" Special
Posing for its portrait in the morning
sun is Piper Super Cub N197T, SIN
18-2311, recently restored by R. J.
"Dobby" Lickteig (EAA71468, AIC
2433) of Albert Lea, Minnesota. As-
sisting "Dobby" in the two-year restora-
tion was A & P (with AI) Gary
Underland of Medford, MN. This par-
ticular Super Cub was one of 79 "105
Specials" that were built for the Civil
Air Patrol in 1952-53 featuring toe
brakes. It was built on January 7, 1953,
and assigned to the South Florida CAP.
The airframe had logged over 7,000
hours and had been recovered twice
before being damaged in 1981. When
Dobby bought the basket case in 1988,
it was still equipped with a bevy of
marine radios for CAP Search and Res-
cue. During the restoration, the Lycom-
ing 0-235 was replaced with a
Lycoming 0-290-D2 of 135 hp and
Cleveland wheels and brakes were in-
stalled. Making its first flight on
November 20,1991, the Super Cub gets
into the air "very quickly" and climbs
like a "homesick angel" according to
Dobby. It is one of 118 Piper PA-I8
"105" Specials remaining on the FAA
register. .....
VINTAGE AIRPLANE 23
BY JIM HAYNES
In the not too distant past, the Directors
of the Antique/Classic Division graced
these pages with short biographies of
interesting members. It was a good fea-
ture and afforded the membership an
opportunity to get to know those mem-
bers who had some memorable ex-
periences and backround that could be
shared.
L.W. Hammer is an interesting mem-
ber. My wife Anne and I met the
gentleman the first day of the 1991
Convention, when we were on our
way to the "Theater In The Woods"
program that evening. He and Paul
Stevenson were putting the John
Deere vehicles to bed by chaining
them together. After introductions,
we fell into conversations, Anne with
Paul and I with L.W. I first learned
that he goes by "Mike".
Mike serves as a Judge in the
Antique/Classic Division at the Con-
vention, and is from Phoenix, Arizona.
He owns a Boeing PT -17 Stearman
and a Golden Labrador that goes by the
name "Gunder". The dog only under-
stands commands spoken in Norwegian.
To talk to Mike is to understand why. He
is of that background.
Mike and Gunder set out on June 29,
1991 in the Stearman from Phoenix
bound for Oshkosh. His plans were to
spend July helping prepare the Conven-
tion grounds for the big event. While
cruising along near Oakley, Kansas the
bottom piston on the engine parted com-
pany with the cylinder and a successful
"off airport" landing brought them to a
stop in a plowed wheat field. After
securing the plane at the closest airport,
Mike and Gunder continued their
sojourn by other means of transporta-
tion, and after arrival, Gunder took up
residence in a local kennel and Mike in
one of the dormitories at the University
of Wisconsin, Oshkosh.
When Mike related this tale of his
bizarre experience, it seemed it was in
an almost casual manner. More impor-
tant to him at the time was how he and
Gunder were going to get home. I
learned that notices had been placed on
bulletin boards around the grounds in
the hopes that someone flying would
have room for two, and was bound for
Arizona.
My wife and I also stayed on campus,
and on most mornings we would stop by
Hardee's near the campus for a quick
biscuit and coffee before heading out to
the grounds. Every morning we would
see Mike and Paul as they also stopped
24 MARCH 1992
§
...
f. L..-....,.;:=-______________
Gunder with his master, L.W. Hammer, get set
to fly off on another adventure. You can just
see a bit of the harness that secures Gunder
in the cockpit when he flies.
by for a quick take-out as well. Natural-
ly, we would inquire as to the return
transportation situation and of the good
health of Gunder.
By the first of the week, it was an-
nounced at Hardee's that Gunder had a
ride to Phoenix on a private airplane.
The owner of the airplane would first
have to fly to Indianapolis before con-
tinuing the journey westward, but
Gunder probably wouldn' t mind. Not
that he was tired of Oshkosh kennels,
but home is where the heart is. So, it
was learned that the departure was
scheduled for the crack of dawn on
Tuesday, and that Gunder would have
to be delivered at that time.
After retrieving Gunder from the
kennel on Monday night, Mike faced
the dilemma of where the Lab was going
Gunder, cruising at 11 ,000
feet, seems to be enjoying
himself as he and L.W. fly
over eastern Arizona.
to bed down. So devoted was Mike to
his dog, that he elected to sleep with him
in the rental car. In stepped Paul
Stevenson, Mike's roommate, and per-
suaded him to sneak Gunder into the
dormitory and up the elevator to their
room. It was probably not the first time
that a dog has spent the night in a dor-
mitory room on the campus, nor the last
if college kids are the same as when I
went to school.
Eventually, Mike found a way back
to Phoenix himself and I am happy to
report that both made it back safely. In
late September, I received the accom-
panying photos from Mike and a note
saying that he and Gunder were about to
depart for Oakley, Kansas to overhaul
the Stearman and then find a place to
bed down for the winter. ....
WELCOME NEW MEMBERS
Milton B. Abercrombie
Apple Valley, California
Scott Ackersen Bloomington, Indiana
Mark Albery Rivoli, Torino, Italy
Donald R. Alme Brooklyn, Wisconsin
Merl Aschenbach Bay City,Michigan
James W. Askegren Sterling, Virginia
Robert H. Ball Vienna, Virginia
Gregory H. Bange Newark, Delaware
W. C. Barkley
Martinsburg, West Virginia
Larry Bartlett
Pagosa Springs, Colorado
Bruce M. Barton Henderson, Nevada
Bob Beecher Chicago, Illinois
Glenn Botsford Bellevue, Washington
Phyllis Ackerson Bower
Goshen, Indiana
(Sponsor: Scott Ackerson)
Shelby L. Bowles Waldorf, Maryland
Randall C. Braddock
Syracuse, Kansas
Mike Brauer Ozark, Alabama
Earl R. Brightbill Roswell, Georgia
J. R. Brown Jackson, Mississippi
Steven E. Brown
Paynesville, Minnesota
Mark Burns Ballwin, Missouri
Robert S. Burton
Yankton, South Dakota
Jeffrey W. Byerhof Malta, Illinois
Neville L. Cameron
Coromandel, New Zealand
Scott Camp Snellville, Georgia
Gary W. Capps
Cumberland Gap, Tennessee
Cassa Rurale Ed Artuguana Di
Colombo, Italy
James Cear, Jr.
Long Beach, New York
Todd Christensen Delta, Utah
Peter Clark
Kirbymoorside, Yorks, England
Mark Clonts Sugar Land, Texas
Walter Congdon
New Britain, Connecticut
James H. Cooper, Jr.
Kinston, North Carolina
Billy Copeland Sumner, Texas
Lonzo N. Cornett Lanexa, Virginia
Hugh L. Cox, III Anchorage, Alaska
David Dalfonso Grosse He, Michigan
Thomas R. Dallman
Richfield, Minnesota
Denis A. Darida Grayslake, Illinois
Gerald W. Davidson
Woodbridge, Virginia
Peter De Sanctis Manhasset, New York
Rocco Desimone
Johnston, Rhode Island
Philip N. Dell Lincolnwood, Illinois
Allen Drozs Decatur, Illinois
Bret Dunkley
Bakers Mills, New York
John Durdin
Ottawa, Ontario Canada
David Duman
Sommerville, Massachusetts
Jules Gilbert Engle Les Gray, France
Rudy Eskra Pueblo, Colorado
Russell L. Farris
Charlotte, North Carolina
Richard B. Ferguson
Redding, California
Robert Fischer
Spearfish, South Dakota
Jay Fisher Clark, New Jersey
Steve FordFayetteville, North Carolina
Mark Freese Bonneterre, Missouri
Robert L. Gall
Morgantown, West Virginia
John Goforth Salem, Oregon
Frank P. Haas Hollywood, Florida
Carl A. Haglund
Powassan, Ontario Canada
James M. Hathley Linden, Michigan
R. L. Hawks Durango, Colorado
John Henry Hess
Manhim, Pennsylvania
David R. Hevia Westbury, New York
Robert E. Hodges Houston, Texas
Arthur S. Hollenbeck
Fayetteville, Arkansas
Lonnie C. Hood Beaumont, Texas
George R. Huff Rockwell City, Iowa
John A. Hurley
Drayton Valley, Alberta Canada
Malcolm R. Jantzen
Indianapolis, Indiana
Roger W. Jaworski Mesa, Arizona
David F. Johnson Henderson, Texas
Allan P. Jones Porter Texas
William M. Jones
Ellensburg, Washington
Ray L. Keck Tucson, Arizona
K. Ronald Keesling
Seattle, Washington
Robert A. Kohrs
Lake City, Minnesota
Anthony Krutsch
Puyallup, Washington
George Kuppler Brooklyn, New York
Leo J. Langevin Fort Worth, Texas
Dennis A. Lanier Columbus, Georgia
Howard A. Leadbetter
Carlisle, Massachusetts
David M. Liebegott
Duncanville, Pennsylvania
Dennis D. Lister Springfield, Illinois
Glen T. Lowery Mobile, Alabama
Andy Manganaro Xenia, Ohio
Paul D. Mann
Stinson Beach, California
John J. Mason Sargent, Georgia
Donald P. Maynard Dallas, Texas
John W. Mcarter Canada
Worden L. McCallum
Peterborough, Ontario Canada
John N. McCullough
Etobicoke, Ontario Canada
Arch McGregor
Canoga Park, California
George H. Melter Warsaw, Kentucky
Metro Toronto Library
Toronto, Ontario Canada
Richard L. Miller
Lewistown, Pennsylvania
William K. Miller
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania
Lee Frank Mitchell
Rockwell City, Iowa
Keith J. Moody Oswego, New York
Geryl L. Mortensen Dallas, Texas
Warren M. Nelson
Woodbury, Minnesota
N. H. Nodwell
Biggar, Saskatchewan Canada
Edward F. Nolan Palm Coast, Florida
Terence O'Brien
Rancho Mirage, California
Charles A. O'Brien
Ft. Jones, California
Steven F. Ondra Hammond, Indiana
(Sponsor: Victor Casey)
Capt. William J. Oscroft
Exeter, New Hampshire
Tom Patton Martinez, Georgia
Dean A. Phelps
Spencerport, New York
Sharon K. Powell
Minnetonka, Minnesota
Kirk S. Reynolds
Skaneateles, New York
William Riggs Bumpass, Virginia
Alan L. Roath Madison, Ohio
Richard G. Robinette
Beaverton, Michigan
Stephen Robinson Davenport, Iowa
Gary R. Rogers
Los Angeles, California
Bruce Rosander Tecumseh, Michigan
Paul D. Roth Fort Wayne, Indiana
Richard E. Russell Sparks, Nevada
Peter N. Sanstead Titusville, Florida
Lester Schrage Allison, Iowa
Bob Sidman Fort Morgan, Colorado
Jerry W. Springer
Collinsville, Oklahoma
(Sponsor: Chris McGuire)
(Continued on Next Page)
VINTAGE AIRPLANE 25
5
WELCOME NEW MEMBERS
(Continued from Page 25)
Lee Sprvill Parachute, Colorado
James R. Streeter
Columbia, South Carolina
Richard E. Studebacker
Bow, Washington
Robert S. Susman Midvale, Utah
Rolland Swanson
Brooklyn Park, Minnesota
Bill Terry Edmond, Oklahoma
Michael J. Tiano Westland, Michigan
Richard F. Waldren Newberg,Oregon
Hal E. Walter
New Bern, North Carolina
Joe Warnstedt Inverness, Illinois
John Weigel Natick, Massachusetts
Barry Wells Vacaville, California
Jack Wells Angie, North California
Donald Wendeln Kettering, Ohio
Wilfried Werner Troisdorf, Germany
Phillip F. Wesner Ashland, Wisconsin
William West
Mammoth Lakes, California
Bill Whelchel Auburn, Alabama
David Whitlock Monett, Missouri
Mark Wilkie Modesto, California
Eric Williams Vandalia, Ohio
Michael Williams
West Carrollton, Ohio
(Sponsor: John Estridge)
Phil Williams Julian, North Carolina
Richard Dale Williams
Panama City, Florida
Robert A. Williams
Corpus Christi, Texas
Warren Wilson Bolton, Massachusetts
Donald Winter Jacksonville, Florida
Herbert Wood
Peterstown, West Virginia
John Wootress Seattle, Washington
Norman F. Wright
Cochenour, Ontario, Canada
Joseph W. Yon, Jr.
Anderson, South Carolina
John Yost Hampshire, Illinois
(Sponsor: Robert Helmchen)
Romain Young Venice, Florida
(Sponor: John Yurosko)
Terence Young
Midwest City, Oklahoma
Ted Zarate Aledo, Texas
Eryn P. Zeak
Point Pleasant, New Jersey
Edmond Zeibari
Willow Grove, Pennsylvania
Clifford Zeiger
Ridgefield, Conneticut
Don Zordan Lombard, Illinois
>-
.c;
()
o
::;;
'" o
Q
PASS IT TO
--rJd
An information exchange column with input from readers.
by Buck Hilbert
(EAA 21, Ale 5)
P.O. Box 424
Union, IL 60180
It sure is nice to know that there are
people out there willing and able to help
us with our antiques and classics. I have
been pushing the type clubs for the past
several issues, as you well know, and
now I'm getting letters from individuals
who are trying to render services in a
similar way but not necessarily within
the type club framework. These people
have found that there is a need and they
are trying to fulfill that need.
As with any endeavor, there is
dedication. Sometimes there is an ex-
pense involved and they have to pass it
on to whomever they help. Just like our
own EAA Library. Dennis Parks has on
file reams of information of such varied
and voluminous content that I can't
even begin to tell about it, but for him to
answer requests for historical and tech-
nical data takes research and the use of
the copier along with the mailing ex-
pense. That is why there has to be a
charge. It defrays the expense. You can
contact Dennis for historical and other
data at the EAA Library, EAA Aviation
Center, P. O. Box 3086, Oshkosh, WI
54903-3086; 414/426-4800.
I want to talk about one service that
came across my desk just this week. Al
Fitzgerald, one of our Florida members
who happens to be an A&P and AI and,
incidentally, a real help to the members
in his area with antique and classic
airplanes, and his wife have come up
with a service they call ADs FAST.
Using their computer they can access
all the ADs pertinent to your particular
airplane or engine either in an ab-
breviated or complete form . They will
either FAX it to you or send it first-class
as she receives the request. They will
also come up with a list of owners com-
plete with serial numbers, "N" numbers,
etc. for most airplanes. Wanta know
where and who has all the Aeronca
C-3s?... Brenda has them. This may turn
out to be a real service to the guy who
wants to know something about his
airplane and doesn't know where to get
the information. Contact Brenda and Al
Fitzgerald at P. O. Box 591, Panacea,
FL 32346, phone 904/984-5190 or to
order 800/854-5575. FAX 904/984-
5460.
Also, almost in the same mailing is
Jim Beisner who is starting OX-5 Parts
and Service. For years there has been
a need for this kind of service. As parts
and pieces of Curtiss OX engines have
become more scarce, it has become in-
creasingly more difficult to pinpoint
their location. Now Jim has come up
with a newsletter and a catalog of ser-
vices that will help those people who
want and need OX parts. Contained in
this little publication are stories, want
and disposal ads, and tidbits on
propellers and people who are inter-
ested in OX engines and airplanes.
Contact Jim Beisner at OX-Parts & Ser-
vices, P. O. Box 134, Troy, OH 45373.
Incidentally, Troy is where the Waco
factory was.
Guess what? I got another letter from
Nigeria, from a student named
Okechukrou Akwara. This one is from
a different city than the other two and
again with a request for magazines and
membership information.
Meanwhile, I'll see you guys at
FLABOB's Open House, Casa Grande
mail, and Brenda will do it just as fast or Sun 'N Fun. Over to you! .....
26 MARCH 1992
The following list of coming events is
furnished to our readers as a matter of
information only and does not constitute
approval, sponsorship, involvement,
control or direction of any such event. If
you would like to have your aviation event
(fly-in, seminars, fly market, etc.) listed,
please send the information to EAA, Att:
Golda Cox, P.O. Box 3086, Oshkosh, WI
53093-3086. Information should be
received four months prior to the event
date.
April 5-11 Lakeland, FL - Annual
Sun 'n Fun EAA Fly-In. Make your
plans to join us for the wann weather!
For more information call 813/644-
2431.
April 25 Levelland, TX - EAA
Chapter 19 Fly-In Breakfast at Level-
land Municipal Airport. Call 806/793-
7889 for more infonnation.
May 1 - 3 Burlington, NC Annual
EAA Fly-in for Antique, Classic and
Contemporary Aeroplanes, sponsored
by EAA A/C Chapter 3. Major
speaker, vintage films, good EAA fel-
lowship; awards in all categories. Con-
tact: R. Bottom, Jr., 103 Powhatan
Parkway, Hampton, VA 23661
May 1 - 3 Camarillo, CA - EAA
Chapter 723 and CAF Wing 12th An-
nual Fly -In and aircraft exhibit.
Homebuilts, classics, antiques, war-
birds and more. Pancake breakfast on
Saturday and Sunday, Dinner Friday
and Saturday with a band, seminars and
more . Contacts : Bob Koeblitz
310/443-8056 or Larry Hayes,
805/496-3750
May 2 - 3 Winchester, VA -
Winchester Regional EAA Spring Fly-
In. Trophies for winning showplanes.
Pancake breakfast Sunday. Conces-
sions and exhibitors. All welcome.
Contact Al or Judy Sparks, EAA Chap-
ter 186. Call 703/590-9112.
May 3 Bloomington, IL - Fly-In,
Drive-In pancake and sausage break-
fast sponsored by the Prairie Aviation
Museum and Clark Aviation. 8:00am
til 12:00pm in the Clark Aviation han-
gar. Contact : P.O. Box 856,
Bloomington, II 61702 or phone 309-
663-7632.
May 3 Rockford, IL - EAA Chapter
22 Annual Fly-In Breakfast. Mark
Clark's Courtesy Aircraft, Greater
Rockford Airport. 7am til noon. ATIS
126.7. For more infonnation call Wal-
lace Hunt, 815/332-4708.
May 15-17 Columbia, SC - EAA
Chapter 242 2nd Annual Spring Fly-In
at Owens Field. Contact: Feaster
Coleman, 803/779-6562 or 657-5864,
or John Gardner 803/796-2400 or 796-
5808.
May 17 - Benton Harbor, MI -
EAA Chapter 585 6th Annual pancake
breakfast Fly-In at Ross Field. Classic
car show, aviation art and equipment
exhibits. Contact: Al Todd, 616/429-
8518 or Randy Hunt, 616/428-2837.
May 23-24 - Decatur, AL (DCU)-
EAA Chapter 941 and Decatur-Athens
Aero Service's fourth annual Reunion
and Fly-In. Homebuilts, Classics, An-
tiques, Warbirds and all GA aircraft
welcome. Balloon launch at dawn.
Camping on field, hotel shuttle avail-
able. Contact: Decatur-Athens Aero
Service, 205/355-5770.
June 5 - 6, Bartlesville, OK - Frank
Phillips Field, Sixth Annual National
Biplane Convention and Expo. "Old
Time Airshow", forums, seminars,
workshops. Biplanes and NBA mem-
bers free; all others pay admission fee.
Contact: Charlie Harris, 918/742-7311
or Virgil Gaede, 918/336-3976.
June 7 - DeKalb, IL - EAA Chapter
241 28th Annual Breakfast Fly-In at
DeKalb-Taylor Municipal Airport.
Contact: 815/895-3888.
June 12 - 14 - Middletown, Ohio,
Sixth Annual Aeronca Convention, in-
cluding tours of the Aeronca factory
and the U.S.A.F Museum, Aeronca
forum. Banquet on Saturday night with
speakers and judged aircraft awards.
Contact National Aeronca Association,
Box 2219, Terre Haute, IN 47802,
812/232-1491.
June 13 Newport News, V A - EAA
Chapter 156 20th Annual Colonial Fly-
In at Newport NewsfWilliamsburg In-
ternational Airport. Contact: Bob
Hamill, 123 Robinson Rd., Hampton,
VA 23661, 804/928-0107
June 20 - 21 Coldwater, MI - 8th
Annual Fairchild Fly-In. Branch
County Memorial Field. Contact:
Mike Kelly, 22 Cardinal Dr.,
Coldwater, MI 49036, or call 517 /278-
7654
June 27 - 28 Orange, MA - New
England Regional Fly-In with antique
steam and gas engine show, flea
market, food. Trophies both days for
Homebuilts, antiques, classics war-
birds. Chapter 726, Orange Municipal
Airport, Orange, MA 01364.
June 25 - 28 Mount Vernon, OH -
33rd Annual National Waco Reunion
Fly-In Wynkoop Airport. Make your
reservations at the Curtis Motor Hotel
1-800-828-7847 or (in Ohio) 1-800-
634-6835. For additional infonnation,
contact the National Waco Club, 700
Hill Av., Hamilton, OH 45015 or call
513/868-0084.
July 8-12 Arlington, WA
Northwest EAA Fly-In. Info: 206-435-
5857.
July 10 - 12 Minden, NE - 14th
Annual Stinson National Fly-In and
meeting. Pioneer Village Airport,
Minden, NE. Call 303/744-8048 for
more infonnation.
July 11-12 Emmetsburg, IA -
Fourth Annual Aeronca Fly-In spon-
sored by the Tail Dragger Club. Camp-
ing, Flight Breakfast on Sunday, with
free breakfast for pilot and copilot.
Serving 6:30am til 12:30pm. Contact:
Keith Hamden, Box 285, Emmetsburg,
IA 50536.
July 25 -26 New Berlin, IL -
Flying "S" Fann. Midwest gathering
of Taylorcrafts. Contact: Al and Mary
Smith, 217/478-2671.
July 26 - 31 Marion, IA - 24th An-
nual International Cessna 170 Associa-
tion Convention. Contact Lee Reedy,
319/322-0665.
July 31-Aug. 6 Oshkosh, WI - 40th
Annual EAA Fly-In and Sport Aviation
Convention. Wittman Regional Air-
port. Contact John Burton, EAA A via-
tion Center, Oshkosh, WI 54903-3086,
414/426-4800.
August 22-23 Bloomington, IL -
Eighth Annual Air Show sponsored by
the Prairie A viation Museum. Contact:
P.O. Box 856, Bloomington, II 61702
or phone 309-663-7632.
September 5 -7, Lake Guntersville,
AL - Aerodrome '92. World's largest
WW I Aviation Fly-In Convention.
Contact: Ryder International Corp.,
205/586-1580.
September 19 - 20, Rock Falls, IL
- 6th Annual North Central EAA "Old-
Fashioned" Fly-In. Workshops,
forums, exhibits, swap meet, and
awards. Pancake breakfast on Sunday.
Contact Gregg Erikson, 708/513-0642
or Dave Christianson, 815/625-6556.
.....
VINTAGE AIRPLANE 27
MYSTERY PLANE
This month's Mystery is a rare one
that will require some extra effort by our
enthusiastic researchers. The photo
was submitted by Owen Billman of
Mayfield, New York. Answers will be
published in the June issue of
VINTAGE AIRPLANE; deadline for
that issue is April 20.
The responses to the December 1991
Mystery Plane set a record. There are
many World War I enthusiasts among
our readers. Ralph Nortell, Spokane,
Washington sent a comprehensive
response. He writes:
"The Mystery Plane for December is
the Caudron G-III, one of the planes
with which France went to war in in
1914. It strongly resembles the prewar
G-I1, but differed in having more wing
area, and accommodating two in the
nacelle instead of one.
"Variations in production G-Ills ap-
pears to have consisted mainly in the
variety of engines used. There was a
reconnaissance version with uncowled
100 hp Anzani radial. There were
reconnaissance and trainer versions
powered by rotary Gnome, LeRhone or
Clerget engines of 80 hp. Most rotary
powered versions were equipped with
the open bottom type cowling as used
by many other makes of rotary engined
craft of the period. One intermediate
type between the G-II and the G-III, the
28 MARCH 1992
by George Hardie
G-IIB, appeared in 1915 with the 160 hp
Monosoupape Gnome motor. It had a
span of 33 feet 9 inches and a top speed
of 85 mph, but was otherwise similar to
the G-Ill.
"Most G-Ills had been withdrawn
from front line service by August, 1917,
but continued on with training
squadrons. The type was widely used
for training in England and France
throughout the Great War. It was used
to train many U. S. airmen in France,
and a special clipped-wing version of
the G-II was produced in which a stu-
dent airman could lift into the air for his
first brief solo hop.
"Caudron G-III specs: Dimensions:
Span 43 feet 5 inches; Length 22 feet 6
inches; Height 8 feet 5 inches. Wing
area: 304 square feet. Performance (80
hp Gnome): Max. speed, 66-71 mph at
sea level; climb to 6500 feet, 20
minutes; service ceiling, 10,000 feet;
endurance, 4 hours.
"Reference sources: THE FIRST
WAR PLANES by William E. Barrett
and AIRCRAFT OF THE 1914-1918
WAR by O. G. Thetord and E. J.
Riding."
Pete Bowers of Spokane,
Washington sent in a photo showing
two crashed G-IIIs which give good
detail of color and markings. He notes:
"The G-Ills were as fragile as they
looked, as shown by the accompanying
photo of two that made hard landings on
the same airfield at the same time. The
December photo shows an A. E. F.
trainer with a LeRhone engine and rud-
der stripes in the American order with
blue at the trailing edge. The American
insignia is on the upper surface of the
warping upper wing. Some also had the
insignia on the underside of the wing as
used by French G-Ills. The crash photo
shows an Anzani G-III with rudder
stripes in the American sequence but
underwing French insignia called
Cocardes."
Answers were received from Henry
Hellert, Vincennes, Indiana; Leo Op-
dycke, Poughkeepsie, New York; Char-
ley Hayes, Park Forest, Illinois; Robert
Wynne, Mercer Island, Washington;
Richard Gleason, Austin, Minnesota;
Emil Cassanello, Huntington Station,
New York; Roy Cagle, Prescott, Arkan-
sas; John B. McMaster, Kansas City,
Missouri; Chuck Palmer, San Bernar-
dino, California; Elmer Cunningham,
East Alton, Illinois; Robert J. Clark,
Channel Islands, California; Ted Wales,
Westwood, Massachusetts; Bob
Louderback, Cincinnati, Ohio; H. G.
deBruyn, Bellevue, Washington;
Wayne Van Valkenburgh,Japser, Geor-
gia; and Capt. H. J. Dielwair, Hornell
Heights, Ontario Canada.
· -
GIlL
0 ..
As part of his answer to the December
Mystery Plane, Henry Hellert of Vincennes,
IN sent in this pen and ink rendition of the
Caudron Gill.
Peter Bowers was kind enough to share
these two photos of the Caudron G III.
Note how the wing failed upon impact the
same way on both the G Ill 's in the center
photo.
VINTAGE AIRPLANE 29
Where The Sellers and Buyers Meet. ..
3 5 ~ per word, $5.00 minimum charge. Send your ad to
The Vintage Trader, EAA Aviation Center, P.O. Box 3086, Oshkosh, WI 54903-2591 .
AIRCRAFT
" Now It's a Classic' Meyers 200A - Mfg.
Dec. 1959.820 hrs. TT, 545 hrs. on zero time
engine. 15 hrs. on zero prop. Beautifully main-
tained. IFR plus lots of extras. Call 6 p.m. to 9
p.m., 414/336-2356. (5-3)
MISCELLANEOUS:
CURTISS JN4-D MEMORABILIA - You can
now own memorabilia from the famous "Jenny",
as seen on "TREASURES FROM THE PAST".
We have posters, postcards, videos, pins, air-
mail cachets, etc. We also have R/C documen-
tation exclusive to this historic aircraft. Sale of
these items support operating expense to keep
this "Jenny" flying for the aviation public. We
appreciate your help. Write for your free price
list. Virginia Aviation Co., RDv-8, Box 294, War-
renton, VA 22186. (cf5/92)
SUPER CUB PA-18 FUSELAGES - New
manufacture, STC-PMA-d, 4130 chrome-moly
tubing throughout, also complete fuselage
repair. ROCKY MOUNTAIN AIRFRAME INC.
(J. E. Soares, Pres.), 7093 Dry Creek Rd.,
Belgrade, Montana. 406-388-6069. FAX
406/388-0170. Repair station No. QK5R148N.
Parachutes - Toll Free 1-800-526-2822, New
& Used Parachutes. We take trade-ins, 5-year
repair or replacement warranty, many styles in
stock. Parachute Associates, Inc., 62 Main
Street, Sui te A, Vincentown, NJ 08088,
609/859-3397. (cf7/92)
ANC-19 Bulletin - Wood Aircraft Inspection
and Fabrication, 1951 edition, now available
as reprint. Early aircraft Service Notes, rigging
data, other titles available. Send SASE for
listing and prices. John W. Grega, 355 Grand
Blvd., Bedford, OH 44146. (c-3/92)
VINTAGE AIRCRAFT AND ENGINES - Out-
of-print literature: history: restoration; manuals;
etc. Unique list of 2,000+ scarce items, $3.00.
JOHN ROBY, 3703V Nassau, San Diego, CA
92115. (Established 1960) (c-10/92)
• information on current projects
• news of museums and airshows
• technical drawings and data
• photographs
• scale modelling material
• news of current publications
C-26 Champion Spark Plugs - New and
reconditioned. New - $14.75, reconditioned -
$5.75 to $9.75. New wire ends, $4.75. Eagle Air,
2920 Emerald Drive, Jonesboro, GA 30236,
404/478-2310. (c-10/92)
GEE BEE R-2, MONOCOUPE 110 Spl., Hall
"BULLDOG", top scale rated model PLANS
used by Replica Builders. Plus others by Vern
Clements, EAA 9297, 308 Palo Alto, Caldwell ,
ID 83605. Extensive Catalog $3.00. (3-3)
OX-5 Parts and Service - Free ads to sub-
scribers. Subscription $18.00 yearly. P.O. Box
134, Troy, OH 45373. (7-6)
1930's Kollman "Bubbleface" compass, have
several, N.O.S., $225 each. Many other vintage
items - 44-page catalog, $5. Jon Aldrich, Air-
port Box 706, Groveland, CA 95321 , 209/962-
6121 . (c-12/92)
Aeronca Champ/Chief wings, fully covered and
painted, with Grimes lights and aux. Fuel tank.
$2400 for the pair. 414/727-9632.
PLANS:
Great Lakes Trainer Guru - Harvey Swack
will help you buy or sell a Great Lakes Trainer
or a Baby Lakes. The only source for COR-
RECTED and UPDATED ORIGINAL Great
Lakes drawings. Welded parts available. Write
to P.O. Box 228, Needham, MA 02192 or call
days 617/444-5480. (c-10/92)
WANTED
Wanted - Serviceable Aeronca E113 engine.
Wm. J. Rausch, R.R.1, Box 11 OH, Alex. Bay,
NY 13607, 315/482-3558. (3-1)
Wanted - Heath 16x 4 wheels and brakes. Ed.
Garber, 919/484-6316, 1810 Lake Shore Drive,
Fayetteville, NC 28305. (3-1)
~ . . . . . - - - - -
Wanted - Vol. 2 & 5, U.S. Civil Aircraft by
Joseph Juptner, L.K. Gardner, 800 Madison
Street, Apt. 6, Martinsville, Virginia 24112.
• historical research
• workshop notes
• information on paint/color
• aeroplanes. engines, parts
for sale
• your wants and disposals
WW1 AERO (1900-1919) and SKYWAYS (1920-1940)
For the restorer, builder, & serious modeller of early aircraft
1 year subscrip1ion $25 Overseas $30 Sample issues $4 each
Publisl1cdb\ WORLD WAR 1 ~ , INC.
15 Crescent Road , Poughkeepsie, NY 12601 USA (914) 473-3679
30 MARCH 1992
MEMBERSHIP
INFORMATION
EAA
Membership in the Experimental Aircraft
Association, Inc. is $35.00 for one year,
including 12 issues of Sport Aviation.
Junior Membership (under 19 years of
age) is available at $20.00 annually.
Family membership is available for an
additional $10.00 annually. All major
credit cards accepted for membership
(FAX (414) 426-4873.
ANTIQUE/CLASSICS
EAA Member - $20.00. Includes one
year membership in EAA Antique-Classic
Division. 12 monthly issues of The
Vintage Airplane and membership card.
Applicant must be a current EAA member
and must give EAA membership number.
Non-EAA Member - $30.00. Includes
one year membership in the EAA Antique-
Classic Division. 12 monthly issues of The
Vintage Airplane, one year membership
in the EAA and separate membership
cards. Sport Aviation llQ1 included.
lAC
Membership in the International Aerobatic
Club, Inc. is $30.00 annually which in-
cludes 12 issues of Sport Aerobatics. All
IA C members are required to be members
of EAA.
WARBIRDS
Membership in the Warbirds of America,
Inc. is $30.00 per year, which includes a
subscription to Warbirds. Warbird mem-
bers are required to be members of EAA.
EAA EXPERIMENTER
EAA membership and EAA EX-
PERIMENTER magazine is available for
$28.00 per year (Sport Aviation not in-
cluded). CUrrent EAA members may
receive EAA EXPERIMENTER for $18.00
per year.
FOREIGN
MEMBERSHIPS
Please submit your remittance with a
check or draft drawn on a United States
bank payable in United States dollars.
Make checks pa yab/e to EAA or the
division in which membership is
desired. Address all/etters to EAA or the
particular division at the following
address:
EAA A VIA TlON CENTER
P.O. BOX 3086
OSHKOSH, WI 54903-3086
PHONE (414) 426-4800
FAX (414) 426-4828
OFFICE HOURS:
8:15-5:00 MON.-FRI.
1-800-322-2412
974 pages of practical ,proven
construction technique s
for homebuilders
BY: TONY BINGELIS
EXCELLENT REFERENCE SOURCE-
MAKE GREAT GIFTS FOR THE
NOVICE OR EXPERIENCED
BUILDER - DON'T BUILD
WITHOUT THEM!
Information every builder needs, with all the right answersat one's finger-
tips. Prepared by Tony Bingeli s speci fically for EM and SPORT AVIATION,
these publications are profusely illustrated with photos, cutaway drawings
and easy to understand descriptionsthat clearly resolve the most compli-
cated problem. Invaluable material for anyonedesigning, building,restoring
or maintaining sport ai rcraft. Order your copies today.
SPORTPLANE BUiLDER ••. •• . S 19,95
IAircraft Construction Methods - 320 pagesl SPECIAL
FIREWALL FORWARD.......$19.95
OFFER
IEngine Installation Methods - 304 pagesl
... order all threefor just
SPORTPLANE CONSTRUCTION
TECHNIQUES ..... .. .. . ....$20.95 $52.97
IA Builder's Handbook - 350 pagesl Add S6.95 postage and handling .
Send check or money order - WI residents add WI residents add 5% sales tax.
5% sales tax. Add S2.40 postage and handling
for each oublicat ion ordered .
Order immediately by calling EAA's Toll Free Number 1.a00.843-3612
or call (414)426-4800
Major t:n!dR cards accepted.
EAA AVIATION FOUNDATION
EM Aviation Center Oshkosh, WI 54903-3086
POLY-FIBER COVERING
THE BEST GETS BETTER WITH NEW HIGH
STRENGTH LOW ELONGATION FABRIC STYLES
OUTSTANDING QUALITIES
Long Life Flexibte Coatings and Finishes Developed Espe-
cially for Aircraft Fabric. Will Not Support Combustion •
Proven Durability on Thousands of Aircraft World Wide Since
1965. Easy Repairability. Lightest Coating System Approved
Under an FAA STC and a PMA • Most Economical Covering
Materials Considering Many Years of Trouble Free Service.
FAA STC Approved for Over 690 Aircraft Models.
VIDEO TAPE AVAILABLE
FABRIC COVERING WITH RAY STITS. EDUCATIONAL.
INSTRUCTIVE. TECHNICAL. Sponsored by EAA Aviation
Foundation. See This Tape First and Avoid Expensive Mis-
takes. VHS or Beta, $39.95 Prepaid. Also Direct from EAA
(1-800-843-3612) and Poly-Fiber Distributors.
WRITE, PHONE OR FAX FOR FREE. New Fifth Edition Poly-
Fiber Manual With Updated Information. New Fabric Samples
With Test Reports. Catalog and Distributor List
STITS POLY-FIBEH .
AIHCHAFT COATINGS \.
P.o. Box 3084-V, Riversi de, CA 92519-3084
Phone (714) 684-4 280. Fax (714) 684-0518
p.O. box 468
madison, north carolina 27025
(919) 427-0216
AWWA
MEMBER
MEMBER
IANI( PAINTlNb AND REPAIIING
SANDtl"'STlNG. TANK LINERS AND COATINGS
PREVENTIVE TANK MAINTENANCE INSPECIION SUVICE
lADDER SAfETY EOUIPMENI
RESERvOIR LINERS AND ROOfS
DISMANTlING "'NO MOiliNG IANKS
NEW. USED AND RECONDITIONED TANKS
Fly high with a
quality Classic interior
Complete interior assemblies for do-it-yourself installation.
Custom quality at economical pri ces.
• Cushion upholstery sets
• Wall panel sets
• Headliners
• Carpet sets
• Baggage compartment sets
• Firewall covers
• Seat slings
• Recover envelopes and dopes
Free catalog of complete product line.
Fabric Selection Guide showing actual sample colors and
styles of materials: $3.00.
INC.
259 Lower Morrisville Rd., Dept. VA
Fallsington , PA 19054 (215) 295-4115
VINTAGE AIRPLANE 31
,INC.
Aviation Underwriting Agency
P.o. Box 35289 • Greensboro, NC 27425
BeCOUle A Metnber Of The BAA
Antique/Classic Insurance PrograUl!
BENEFITS INCLUDE:
Call Today!
• Lower Uability & Hull Premiums
• Fleet DiscoLUlts
• No Age penalty
800-727-3823
• No Hand Propping Exclusions
NotAnEAA
• No Component Parts Endorsements
,...., Antique/Classic Member?
• A+ Company with In-House Claims c ~
~ ~ ~ ~ Call To Join!
service -·r
l
_e·-,I"- 1-800-322-2412
• Option to Repair Your Own Aircraft
~ ~ l ~ ~ V 8 See Us In Booth 166
APPROVED
"OllT OF THE CLEAR BLllE OF.
THEWESTERN
SKY, IT'S.
•
Hundreds of thousands of pilots and aviation
enthusiasts grew up knowing that famous line
meant it was time for SKY KING! Every week, Sky
King, Penny and "Songbird" fought for truth and
justice. Now, a nearly-forgotten friend from the
"Golden Age" of television is back via your VCR ...
SKY KING FLIES AGAIN!
EAA, in cooperation with Flying Crown Enter-
prises, can now offer you more than 30 half-hours
of this unique television series. These shows, saved
from a tragic fire and safely hidden away in vaults,
have been unseen for more than 20 years! But now,
you can own a piece of television-and aviation-
history.
Action, drama, suspense and high-flying
adventure are all part of every Sky King episode.
Kirby Grant stars in the title role along with his
beautiful airplane "Songbird." Early episodes feature
a Cessna "Bamboo Bomber"; later programs
include a Cessna 310.
Each volume includes four uncut Sky King
episodes, complete with a word from Sky King's
sponsor, Nabisco®. Just like you remember him, Sky
ORDER
King flies again. Share the experience with your
children and grandchildren. Who knows, Sky King
may inspire another generation of aviation
enthusiasts! NOW!
Collect all eight volumes! Watch for more as they are discovered!
TO ORDER SKY KING
(or for a free EAA Video Catalog)
Volumes One - Eight
$24.95* each
Call 1-800-843-3612
or write
•™
EAA Video Sales
P.O. Box 3065
Order all eight volumes for one low price $179.95*
• plus S3 shipping per video (Wisconsin residents please add 5% sales tax.)
Oshkosh,VVI54903-3065
Ask about the EAA Video Club and how you can save an additional 15 % on every video purchase.